Red-tipped photinia question

[Brian Anderson]

I had two of these side-by-side in my back yard, both about 15
feet tall. A couple years ago one turned brown and died, and
I replaced it with a baby, which is now about 4 feet tall.

Today the little one looks great, but two branches died from
the base up on the big one. I cut those branches off, and
some new red growth appeared. Not a lot, but some. But the
plant in general looks bad. The leaves, while still green,
are drooping as though the tree hasn't been getting enough
water (which is obviously not the case).

Does this sound familiar to anyone?

Thanks.

[escapee]

On Fri, 26 Mar 2004 09:29:00 -0600, Brian Anderson >
opined:

>I had two of these side-by-side in my back yard, both about 15
>feet tall. A couple years ago one turned brown and died, and
> I replaced it with a baby, which is now about 4 feet tall.
>
>Today the little one looks great, but two branches died from
>the base up on the big one. I cut those branches off, and
>some new red growth appeared. Not a lot, but some. But the
>plant in general looks bad. The leaves, while still green,
>are drooping as though the tree hasn't been getting enough
>water (which is obviously not the case).
>
>Does this sound familiar to anyone?
>
>Thanks.

Yes, there is a problem in the soil which is causing leaf spot, leaf drop, and
other annoyances with Photinia fraserii. I would not recommend using that
plant, it is not a good plant to use with all the problems it has.

[N. Woolley]

Photinia is a non-native invasive species just as bad as Kudzu. Thank
heavens the red-tipped variety gets disease. The Chinese variety doesn't
and is a huge problem in areas that are trying to maintain native habitat.

Ligustrum and Nandina are also in the same category.

Find something else to plant.... Evergreen Sumac or Texas Mountain
Laurel maybe?? The Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center is having their
spring plant sale soon.

-Nancy

[N. Woolley]

Photinia is a non-native invasive species just as bad as Kudzu. Thank
heavens the red-tipped variety gets disease. The Chinese variety doesn't
and is a huge problem in areas that are trying to maintain native habitat.

Ligustrum and Nandina are also in the same category.

Find something else to plant.... Evergreen Sumac or Texas Mountain
Laurel maybe?? The Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center is having their
spring plant sale soon.

-Nancy

[N. Woolley]

Photinia is a non-native invasive species just as bad as Kudzu. Thank
heavens the red-tipped variety gets disease. The Chinese variety doesn't
and is a huge problem in areas that are trying to maintain native habitat.

Ligustrum and Nandina are also in the same category.

Find something else to plant.... Evergreen Sumac or Texas Mountain
Laurel maybe?? The Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center is having their
spring plant sale soon.

-Nancy

[N. Woolley]

Photinia is a non-native invasive species just as bad as Kudzu. Thank
heavens the red-tipped variety gets disease. The Chinese variety doesn't
and is a huge problem in areas that are trying to maintain native habitat.

Ligustrum and Nandina are also in the same category.

Find something else to plant.... Evergreen Sumac or Texas Mountain
Laurel maybe?? The Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center is having their
spring plant sale soon.

-Nancy

[N. Woolley]

Photinia is a non-native invasive species just as bad as Kudzu. Thank
heavens the red-tipped variety gets disease. The Chinese variety doesn't
and is a huge problem in areas that are trying to maintain native habitat.

Ligustrum and Nandina are also in the same category.

Find something else to plant.... Evergreen Sumac or Texas Mountain
Laurel maybe?? The Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center is having their
spring plant sale soon.

-Nancy

[jac]

I've planted Kudzu and am looking forward to the full coverage it provides.I'm
putting up some lines(cables) for it to spread and make an shade arbor over a
large area by the pool. I'm well aware of it's proclivity for growth... other
than that, what's the problem with Kudzu?
jac


"N. Woolley" wrote:

> Photinia is a non-native invasive species just as bad as Kudzu. Thank
> heavens the red-tipped variety gets disease. The Chinese variety doesn't
> and is a huge problem in areas that are trying to maintain native habitat.
>
> Ligustrum and Nandina are also in the same category.
>
> Find something else to plant.... Evergreen Sumac or Texas Mountain
> Laurel maybe?? The Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center is having their
> spring plant sale soon.
>
> -Nancy

[jac]

I've planted Kudzu and am looking forward to the full coverage it provides.I'm
putting up some lines(cables) for it to spread and make an shade arbor over a
large area by the pool. I'm well aware of it's proclivity for growth... other
than that, what's the problem with Kudzu?
jac


"N. Woolley" wrote:

> Photinia is a non-native invasive species just as bad as Kudzu. Thank
> heavens the red-tipped variety gets disease. The Chinese variety doesn't
> and is a huge problem in areas that are trying to maintain native habitat.
>
> Ligustrum and Nandina are also in the same category.
>
> Find something else to plant.... Evergreen Sumac or Texas Mountain
> Laurel maybe?? The Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center is having their
> spring plant sale soon.
>
> -Nancy

[jac]

I've planted Kudzu and am looking forward to the full coverage it provides.I'm
putting up some lines(cables) for it to spread and make an shade arbor over a
large area by the pool. I'm well aware of it's proclivity for growth... other
than that, what's the problem with Kudzu?
jac


"N. Woolley" wrote:

> Photinia is a non-native invasive species just as bad as Kudzu. Thank
> heavens the red-tipped variety gets disease. The Chinese variety doesn't
> and is a huge problem in areas that are trying to maintain native habitat.
>
> Ligustrum and Nandina are also in the same category.
>
> Find something else to plant.... Evergreen Sumac or Texas Mountain
> Laurel maybe?? The Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center is having their
> spring plant sale soon.
>
> -Nancy

[jac]

I've planted Kudzu and am looking forward to the full coverage it provides.I'm
putting up some lines(cables) for it to spread and make an shade arbor over a
large area by the pool. I'm well aware of it's proclivity for growth... other
than that, what's the problem with Kudzu?
jac


"N. Woolley" wrote:

> Photinia is a non-native invasive species just as bad as Kudzu. Thank
> heavens the red-tipped variety gets disease. The Chinese variety doesn't
> and is a huge problem in areas that are trying to maintain native habitat.
>
> Ligustrum and Nandina are also in the same category.
>
> Find something else to plant.... Evergreen Sumac or Texas Mountain
> Laurel maybe?? The Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center is having their
> spring plant sale soon.
>
> -Nancy

[Chuck]

They are very prone to catching disease.


"Brian Anderson" > wrote in message
...
> I had two of these side-by-side in my back yard, both about 15
> feet tall. A couple years ago one turned brown and died, and
> I replaced it with a baby, which is now about 4 feet tall.
>
> Today the little one looks great, but two branches died from
> the base up on the big one. I cut those branches off, and
> some new red growth appeared. Not a lot, but some. But the
> plant in general looks bad. The leaves, while still green,
> are drooping as though the tree hasn't been getting enough
> water (which is obviously not the case).
>
> Does this sound familiar to anyone?
>
> Thanks.
>

[Chuck]

You're insane and must be stopped!
Do not do it! Kudzu destroys the local eco-system you idiot.


"jac" > wrote in message ...
> I've planted Kudzu and am looking forward to the full coverage it
provides.I'm
> putting up some lines(cables) for it to spread and make an shade arbor
over a
> large area by the pool. I'm well aware of it's proclivity for growth...
other
> than that, what's the problem with Kudzu?
> jac
>
>
> "N. Woolley" wrote:
>
> > Photinia is a non-native invasive species just as bad as Kudzu. Thank
> > heavens the red-tipped variety gets disease. The Chinese variety doesn't
> > and is a huge problem in areas that are trying to maintain native
habitat.
> >
> > Ligustrum and Nandina are also in the same category.
> >
> > Find something else to plant.... Evergreen Sumac or Texas Mountain
> > Laurel maybe?? The Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center is having their
> > spring plant sale soon.
> >
> > -Nancy
>

[jac]

Thanks, your opinion and been noted, without result.


Chuck wrote:

> You're insane and must be stopped!
> Do not do it! Kudzu destroys the local eco-system you idiot.
>
> "jac" > wrote in message ...
> > I've planted Kudzu and am looking forward to the full coverage it
> provides.I'm
> > putting up some lines(cables) for it to spread and make an shade arbor
> over a
> > large area by the pool. I'm well aware of it's proclivity for growth...
> other
> > than that, what's the problem with Kudzu?
> > jac
> >
> >
> > "N. Woolley" wrote:
> >
> > > Photinia is a non-native invasive species just as bad as Kudzu. Thank
> > > heavens the red-tipped variety gets disease. The Chinese variety doesn't
> > > and is a huge problem in areas that are trying to maintain native
> habitat.
> > >
> > > Ligustrum and Nandina are also in the same category.
> > >
> > > Find something else to plant.... Evergreen Sumac or Texas Mountain
> > > Laurel maybe?? The Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center is having their
> > > spring plant sale soon.
> > >
> > > -Nancy
> >

[Gary Brady]

> I'm well aware of it's proclivity for growth... other
>than that, what's the problem with Kudzu?

Jac, I'm no expert on Kudzu, but in wetter climates, such as East Texas and
Louisiana, its rampant growth takes over everything in its path. Wisteria is
also considered a plague worse than locusts in those areas, but it's easily
controlled and makes a nice plant around Austin. In Louisiana, wisteria could
literally strangle a pine tree, while Kudzu would cover the tree and deprive it
of sunlight.
Gary Brady
Austin, TX

[GeneS]

I "tried" to grow some & it all died - no kidding.


"jac" > wrote in message ...
> I've planted Kudzu and am looking forward to the full coverage it
provides.I'm
> putting up some lines(cables) for it to spread and make an shade arbor
over a
> large area by the pool. I'm well aware of it's proclivity for growth...
other
> than that, what's the problem with Kudzu?
> jac
>
>
> "N. Woolley" wrote:
>
> > Photinia is a non-native invasive species just as bad as Kudzu. Thank
> > heavens the red-tipped variety gets disease. The Chinese variety doesn't
> > and is a huge problem in areas that are trying to maintain native
habitat.
> >
> > Ligustrum and Nandina are also in the same category.
> >
> > Find something else to plant.... Evergreen Sumac or Texas Mountain
> > Laurel maybe?? The Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center is having their
> > spring plant sale soon.
> >
> > -Nancy
>

[escapee]

The problem is not the plant, it's the people who plant it. It's a horrible
thing to introduce that to this area.


On Sat, 27 Mar 2004 15:36:49 GMT, jac > opined:

>I've planted Kudzu and am looking forward to the full coverage it provides.I'm
>putting up some lines(cables) for it to spread and make an shade arbor over a
>large area by the pool. I'm well aware of it's proclivity for growth... other
>than that, what's the problem with Kudzu?
>jac
>
>
>"N. Woolley" wrote:
>
>> Photinia is a non-native invasive species just as bad as Kudzu. Thank
>> heavens the red-tipped variety gets disease. The Chinese variety doesn't
>> and is a huge problem in areas that are trying to maintain native habitat.
>>
>> Ligustrum and Nandina are also in the same category.
>>
>> Find something else to plant.... Evergreen Sumac or Texas Mountain
>> Laurel maybe?? The Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center is having their
>> spring plant sale soon.
>>
>> -Nancy

[Katra]

Ever driven thru Kentucky or Tennesee???
Miles and miles of Kudzu...

That's the one thing that has stopped me from planting it! Horribly
invasive. You are likely to live to regret having planted it.

Want full coverage with little water use? Do what I did and plant the
local wild muscadine grape! At least it's a local plant and good for
xeriscaping, and the chickens like the grapes if I don't want to make
jelly or wine out of them. ;-)

I finally have my green privacy fences and it only took 3 years. Those
vines get huge fast, especially if you DO water them.

Honeysuckle is also good, as is oriental jasmine, or even english ivy.
Ivy is good for shaded areas and in fact, seems to do better for me in
the shade. Won't stand up to dog trampling tho' ;-( As much as I adore
my BC, I'm almost beginning to regret adopting her. <sigh> Almost. She
is such a wonderful pet that I forgive her the plant destruction.

K.


In article >,
escapee > wrote:

> The problem is not the plant, it's the people who plant it. It's a horrible
> thing to introduce that to this area.
>
>
> On Sat, 27 Mar 2004 15:36:49 GMT, jac > opined:
>
> >I've planted Kudzu and am looking forward to the full coverage it
> >provides.I'm
> >putting up some lines(cables) for it to spread and make an shade arbor over
> >a
> >large area by the pool. I'm well aware of it's proclivity for growth...
> >other
> >than that, what's the problem with Kudzu?
> >jac
> >
> >
> >"N. Woolley" wrote:
> >
> >> Photinia is a non-native invasive species just as bad as Kudzu. Thank
> >> heavens the red-tipped variety gets disease. The Chinese variety doesn't
> >> and is a huge problem in areas that are trying to maintain native habitat.
> >>
> >> Ligustrum and Nandina are also in the same category.
> >>
> >> Find something else to plant.... Evergreen Sumac or Texas Mountain
> >> Laurel maybe?? The Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center is having their
> >> spring plant sale soon.
> >>
> >> -Nancy
>

--
Sprout the Mung Bean to reply...

"There are many intelligent species in the universe, and they are all owned by cats! -- Asimov

>,,<Cat's Haven Hobby Farm>,,<Katraatcenturyteldotnet>,,<
http://cgi6.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewSellersOtherItems&include=0&userid=katra