Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Only one small drainage hole in a planter: "obstruct" with stonesetc., or no?
I've bought some quite large terracotta planters in which to plant some patio shrubs to form a hedging screen, but have found that each planter comes with only one small hole in its bottom, and in this hole there is a rubber plug. I feel that I must, without doubt, remove the plug, to allow drainage in case excess rain-water falls on the planter. But, given that there is only one small hole, about the size of a 50 pence coin, should I just fill the planter with compost, so the compost sits on the hole, and moisture has immediate and unobstructed exit? Or should I place stones or bits of broken crockery over the hole first? It seems to me that placing solid items over the hole will obstruct drainage.. I'm concerned about what to do because there's only one hole and it's so small. David. |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Only one small drainage hole in a planter: "obstruct" with stonesetc., or no?
On 04/05/2016 14:07, Chris Hogg wrote:
On Wed, 4 May 2016 05:35:41 -0700 (PDT), David wrote: I've bought some quite large terracotta planters in which to plant some patio shrubs to form a hedging screen, but have found that each planter comes with only one small hole in its bottom, and in this hole there is a rubber plug. I feel that I must, without doubt, remove the plug, to allow drainage in case excess rain-water falls on the planter. But, given that there is only one small hole, about the size of a 50 pence coin, should I just fill the planter with compost, so the compost sits on the hole, and moisture has immediate and unobstructed exit? Or should I place stones or bits of broken crockery over the hole first? It seems to me that placing solid items over the hole will obstruct drainage. I'm concerned about what to do because there's only one hole and it's so small. David. Them that use terracotta pots regularly nearly always have a quantity of broken pot bits, and they use these to line the base of new terracotta pots to improve the drainage. Because these bits are not flat (e.g. they're the sides of plant pots so they're slightly curved), they do not lie flat in the bottom of the pot and so allow water to percolate easily. In your case, if you haven't got any of the above, then pebbles or broken up polystyrene packing or 'squiggles' make a good alternative. But if you use anything made of 'plastic', do separate it out and bin it when eventually the time comes to put the pot contents on the compost heap, otherwise your compost will be laced with bits of said 'plastic' that will look horrible as it blows around the garden. If you are going to use the "squiggles" then suck them and see, just make sure that they are not the ones made from corn starch. |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Only one small drainage hole in a planter: "obstruct" with stones etc., or no?
On Wed, 4 May 2016 05:35:41 -0700 (PDT), David
wrote: But, given that there is only one small hole, about the size of a 50 pence coin, I would say that's a fair size hole, I use a square of garden fleece , a very small roll would supply you for years, lets the water drain away, (I hear older gardeners used to use an old net curtain, fleece is just easier and cheaper) |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Only one small drainage hole in a planter: "obstruct" with stonesetc., or no?
On 05/05/16 08:30, divingbrit wrote:
On Wed, 4 May 2016 05:35:41 -0700 (PDT), David wrote: But, given that there is only one small hole, about the size of a 50 pence coin, I would say that's a fair size hole, I use a square of garden fleece , a very small roll would supply you for years, lets the water drain away, (I hear older gardeners used to use an old net curtain, fleece is just easier and cheaper) +1 (although I use weedproof membrane) Also stops ants getting in the pots! -- Jeff |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Only one small drainage hole in a planter: "obstruct" with stonesetc., or no?
On 05/05/2016 20:15, Chris French wrote:
Chris Hogg Wrote in message: On Wed, 4 May 2016 05:35:41 -0700 (PDT), David wrote: I've bought some quite large terracotta planters in which to plant some patio shrubs to form a hedging screen, but have found that each planter comes with only one small hole in its bottom, and in this hole there is a rubber plug. I feel that I must, without doubt, remove the plug, to allow drainage in case excess rain-water falls on the planter. But, given that there is only one small hole, about the size of a 50 pence coin, should I just fill the planter with compost, so the compost sits on the hole, and moisture has immediate and unobstructed exit? Or should I place stones or bits of broken crockery over the hole first? It seems to me that placing solid items over the hole will obstruct drainage. I'm concerned about what to do because there's only one hole and it's so small. David. Them that use terracotta pots regularly nearly always have a quantity of broken pot bits, and they use these to line the base of new terracotta pots to improve the drainage. ISTR something a few years back, maybe on GW. They looked at this and the conclusion was that it made no difference to how well the pot drained. I do stick a bit of weed membrane over the hole to keep compost in. This debate of crock or don't crock really goes back to when many people used either garden soil or soil based composts in their tubs/ urns/ large pots. This was much slower draining and had the habit of going "solid". Now our composts are chiefly Peat based or other soil less compost make up which has very different properties so using a membrane will suffice. The advantage of soil based compost if you are planting a tall plant/tree in pots then the extra weight helps to stop them blowing over. Have a look at the citrus and olives being imported from Italy, feels as if they are growing in concrete. David@a sunny side of Swansea Bay. |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Only one small drainage hole in a planter: "obstruct" with stones etc., or no?
David wrote:
I've bought some quite large terracotta planters in which to plant some patio shrubs to form a hedging screen, but have found that each planter comes with only one small hole in its bottom, and in this hole there is a rubber plug. I feel that I must, without doubt, remove the plug, to allow drainage in case excess rain-water falls on the planter. But, given that there is only one small hole, about the size of a 50 pence coin, should I just fill the planter with compost, so the compost sits on the hole, and moisture has immediate and unobstructed exit? Or should I place stones or bits of broken crockery over the hole first? It seems to me that placing solid items over the hole will obstruct drainage. I'm concerned about what to do because there's only one hole and it's so small. David. It doesn't matter how small the hole is, and I think 50p size is quite large, the pot will never become waterlogged for any length of time as water always finds the lowest point, which will be through the drain hole.. Cover it with anything that won't degrade, a piece of plastic with a hole in it, or any kind of nylon mesh. |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Only one small drainage hole in a planter: "obstruct" with stonesetc., or no?
Many thanks, people, for all the generous help.
Very much appreciated. David. |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Only one small drainage hole in a planter: "obstruct" with stones etc., or no?
On Wed, 4 May 2016 05:35:41 -0700 (PDT), David
wrote: Or should I place stones or bits of broken crockery over the hole first? It seems to me that placing solid items over the hole will obstruct drainage. I've tried several systems, including (a) doing nothing (b) adding large stones, kindly left by builders in case I needed them (c) adding terracotta pot fragments (d) adding terracotta fragments plus grit. With all these methods, silt from the JI compost I use would eventually wash through and block the hole, it just took varying lengths of time. So now I use option d AND I put all my pots on pot stands. It helps when the window cleaner comes anyway. Them feety things are hopeless, I was forever knocking pots over when I tried them. It's a good idea to use mesh or fleece, though: I'm definitely going to give that a try. Can't believe I never thought of it. But I'll still use a pot stand just in case. -- Bob Moore http://bobmoore.mvps.org/ |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Only one small drainage hole in a planter: "obstruct" with stones etc., or no?
On Fri, 03 Jun 2016 17:10:49 +0100, Bob Moore wrote:
It's a good idea to use mesh or fleece, though: I'm definitely going to give that a try. Can't believe I never thought of it. But I'll still use a pot stand just in case. http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article ... perts.html Personally I don't put crocks at the bottom of my pots, sometimes fine netting to keep out bugs, and I do use lots of broken up 'polystyrene' to reduce the amount of compost needed, as a large plant looks better in a big pot, but does not need always a large pot of compost! |
#11
|
|||
|
|||
Only one small drainage hole in a planter: "obstruct" with stonesetc., or no?
On Wednesday, May 4, 2016 at 1:35:42 PM UTC+1, David wrote:
I've bought some quite large terracotta planters in which to plant some patio shrubs to form a hedging screen, but have found that each planter comes with only one small hole in its bottom, and in this hole there is a rubber plug. I feel that I must, without doubt, remove the plug, to allow drainage in case excess rain-water falls on the planter. But, given that there is only one small hole, about the size of a 50 pence coin, should I just fill the planter with compost, so the compost sits on the hole, and moisture has immediate and unobstructed exit? Or should I place stones or bits of broken crockery over the hole first? It seems to me that placing solid items over the hole will obstruct drainage. I'm concerned about what to do because there's only one hole and it's so small. David. I use polystyrene packaging, it keeps slugs out. |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Tis better to be Gills "Chew Toy" than one of Roy "Tristain" Hauer's "SOCKS" | Ponds | |||
How do you plug the drainage hole in clay pot? | Gardening | |||
Drill drain hole in concrete planter? | Gardening | |||
Bamboo makeshift planter - size of drainage holes? | Bamboo | |||
[IBC] Drainage and other unfortunate mysteries (was : Bonsai Today article on drainage) | Bonsai |