GardenBanter.co.uk

GardenBanter.co.uk (https://www.gardenbanter.co.uk/)
-   Australia (https://www.gardenbanter.co.uk/australia/)
-   -   best value water tanks?? (https://www.gardenbanter.co.uk/australia/178745-best-value-water-tanks.html)

lentildude 21-09-2008 02:16 AM

best value water tanks??
 
Hi, I live in the lowerbluemountains SYD, (10 mins Penrith) and really
want to splurge on a large watertank 9000 - 20000litres. Really
confused what to get, I want the best value tank that will last at
least 20 yrs. Anyone know any bargains out there?? There are a few
sellers on EBAY but worried buying sight unseen. If I connect it to
the growing shed and not the house do I still get a govt rebate? Any
tips appreciated.


George

David Hare-Scott[_2_] 21-09-2008 02:46 AM

best value water tanks??
 

"lentildude" wrote in message
...
Hi, I live in the lowerbluemountains SYD, (10 mins Penrith) and really
want to splurge on a large watertank 9000 - 20000litres. Really
confused what to get, I want the best value tank that will last at
least 20 yrs. Anyone know any bargains out there?? There are a few
sellers on EBAY but worried buying sight unseen. If I connect it to
the growing shed and not the house do I still get a govt rebate? Any
tips appreciated.


George


In my view the polymer ones are best. The polymer is UV stablized and they
have been in use for long enough to be sure that they will actually last.
Also they come in various colours and don't need painting. Concrete will
crack (especially on clay soil) and are very heavy, and galvanised iron will
rust (especially near the sea or in a polluted area). I have three polymer
ones from Bushman and I am happy with them.

As these things are rather large you need to include delivery when comparing
prices. The price per kilolitre decreases with tank size.

Something you need to work out is how in advance is how to re-arrange your
roof plumbing to capture the maximum amount of water, this is not so easy if
it was built to discharge at 3 or 4 different places. The simple solution
is to block the ends or downpipes where you don't want the water. This is
not ideal as some of the guttering is likely to fall the wrong way this can
shorten its life and accumulate muck as pools will form at the low points
where the water can no longer escape. Also if all your roof water comes
down to a single pipe the guttering is very likely to overflow in heavy rain
as the pipe will be inadequate. This will waste water and may damage your
house. If you are not experienced in this you may need a plumber.

David




len gardener 21-09-2008 09:25 PM

best value water tanks??
 
g'day george,

around the 22 to 25k litre size are agood size you could go to around
the 32k size if you have capacity to do so that is space.

i find dealing with the long time in business rural tank makers is
always better their product has stood the test of time and their
prices aren't directly driven by the gov rebate like those johnny come
lately city makers. they will also site the tank(s) where you want
it/them so long as you have access.

the supplier should also be able to sell you a pump as part of the
deal, i would suggest a 4 tap pump that will be able to service the
whole house if need be, they cost around the $600 mark, we also now
ahve a preferenc to air bladder type pressure pumps, now got no faith
in these electronic controlled pressure devices.

and if you need ot buy that cheap as floating ball cock type diverter.



On Sat, 20 Sep 2008 18:16:12 -0700 (PDT), lentildude
wrote:

snipped
With peace and brightest of blessings,

len & bev

--
"Be Content With What You Have And
May You Find Serenity and Tranquillity In
A World That You May Not Understand."

http://www.lensgarden.com.au/

len gardener 21-09-2008 09:25 PM

best value water tanks??
 
forgot to say yes polymer tanks

On Sat, 20 Sep 2008 18:16:12 -0700 (PDT), lentildude
wrote:

Hi, I live in the lowerbluemountains SYD, (10 mins Penrith) and really
want to splurge on a large watertank 9000 - 20000litres. Really
confused what to get, I want the best value tank that will last at
least 20 yrs. Anyone know any bargains out there?? There are a few
sellers on EBAY but worried buying sight unseen. If I connect it to
the growing shed and not the house do I still get a govt rebate? Any
tips appreciated.


George

With peace and brightest of blessings,

len & bev

--
"Be Content With What You Have And
May You Find Serenity and Tranquillity In
A World That You May Not Understand."

http://www.lensgarden.com.au/

none 21-09-2008 10:51 PM

best value water tanks??
 
Check out how long each sort is guaranteed for. That is interesting
reading.

lentildude wrote:
Hi, I live in the lowerbluemountains SYD, (10 mins Penrith) and really
want to splurge on a large watertank 9000 - 20000litres. Really
confused what to get, I want the best value tank that will last at
least 20 yrs. Anyone know any bargains out there?? There are a few
sellers on EBAY but worried buying sight unseen. If I connect it to
the growing shed and not the house do I still get a govt rebate? Any
tips appreciated.


George


len gardener 22-09-2008 09:08 PM

best value water tanks??
 
g'day jules,

yes look for the warranty most offer 25 years BUT! no good having a 25
year warranty if it is a johnny come lately tank maker in the city who
most likley won't be around in 10 years let alone 25 years.

that is why i suggest seek out the rural makers (they deliver their
tanks over a wide range eg.,. bundaberg poly tanks they deliver from a
line that runs out from rockhampton to emerald and down qld then to
northern nsw, and they charge no delivery or siting fees.

i live in brisbane and they delivered to us same price as anywhere,
just they work for a full load.

On Mon, 22 Sep 2008 07:51:59 +1000, none ""jules\"@(none)" wrote:

Check out how long each sort is guaranteed for. That is interesting
reading.

lentildude wrote:
Hi, I live in the lowerbluemountains SYD, (10 mins Penrith) and really
want to splurge on a large watertank 9000 - 20000litres. Really
confused what to get, I want the best value tank that will last at
least 20 yrs. Anyone know any bargains out there?? There are a few
sellers on EBAY but worried buying sight unseen. If I connect it to
the growing shed and not the house do I still get a govt rebate? Any
tips appreciated.


George

With peace and brightest of blessings,

len & bev

--
"Be Content With What You Have And
May You Find Serenity and Tranquillity In
A World That You May Not Understand."

http://www.lensgarden.com.au/

terryc 23-09-2008 03:22 AM

best value water tanks??
 
On Sun, 21 Sep 2008 11:46:02 +1000, David Hare-Scott wrote:

In my view the polymer ones are best. The polymer is UV stablized and
they have been in use for long enough to be sure that they will actually
last. Also they come in various colours and don't need painting. Concrete
will crack (especially on clay soil) and are very heavy, and galvanised
iron will rust (especially near the sea or in a polluted area). I have
three polymer ones from Bushman and I am happy with them.


Just to add 2c to the discussion.
If you are in a place bordering bushland, you might want to
reconsider poly tanks if you are relying on them to assist in fire
fighting, but if that is a serious consideration, then you'll have a
diesel powered pump in a brick enclosure and roof sprinklers as well I
guess.

I'm also thinking about repairing them. The old gal (new = colorbond)
could be easily repaired with a piece of tin and sticky goo. they seem to
rust out in the bottom if never cleaned out. I guess you'll need to be
able to fibreglass to properly repair a poly tank (anyone done it).

Generally get the biggest tank you can and make sure the ground under it
is VERY stable and compacted.

After you work out how to get the tank into place, you also need to
investigae all the costs. If you are going for the rebates,then you have
to hire professinals (plumber and electrician(?) AFAIK to sign off.


Something you need to work out is how in advance is how to re-arrange
your roof plumbing to capture the maximum amount of water, this is not
so easy if it was built to discharge at 3 or 4 different places. The
simple solution is to block the ends or downpipes where you don't want
the water.


Start from the top.
Work out how to keep leaves out of the gutter, but make sure you can
clean/flush the gutter as they are not the only crap that gets their (all
filters have small bits fall through, plus flower parts, bugs,
etc).

Then have a leaf diverter below the outlet and work out where the leaf
diverter is going throw the leaves and a bit of moisture.

The "sydney standard" says I should have 3x100mm down pipes. Like everyone
else, I have 2x90mm, but my front downpipes are long horizontal runs down
each side of the house. Different yes, but I'd loose most of my
water if I didn't. Until SWMBO agrees to replace the front lawn
with a mega tank, then it stays that way.

Long horizontal runs are leaf catchers, which is why I mentioned the two
steps above.

I also have a first flush diverter (put T vertical just before the
downpipes(2 on each tank) enter the tanks(2).


John Savage 25-09-2008 07:01 AM

best value water tanks??
 
lentildude writes:
Hi, I live in the lowerbluemountains SYD, (10 mins Penrith) and really
want to splurge on a large watertank 9000 - 20000litres. Really
confused what to get, I want the best value tank that will last at
least 20 yrs. Anyone know any bargains out there?? There are a few
sellers on EBAY but worried buying sight unseen. If I connect it to
the growing shed and not the house do I still get a govt rebate? Any
tips appreciated.


The poly tank does seem reliable and robust and is easy to transport
and move if you decide it's original placement is not quite right. I'm
not sure whether they have been around long enough to be confident that
they'll last as long as the gal tanks or the precast concrete ones in
the sun (e.g., 75 years, whatever). Certainly, most say they are
UV-stabilised but whether some withstand direct sun better than others
who knows?

Instead of 'having all your eggs in one basket' you can have multiple
tanks, but you'll probably find that the rebate is available only on
the first, so install the biggest capacity tank first. Identical
capacities come in different shapes, and naturally you'd buy tanks that
sit no higher than your roof gutters (unless you intend some clever
pumping during rain). It is feasible to bury the lower portion of a
tank to allow use of a taller one, but there is always the chance that
it will float up in the hole if the tank is empty when the hole fills
during a storm.

It's instructive to examine brochures from a number of poly tank
manufacturers. If you are getting a tall tank, you'd want to make
sure that its wall thickness increases towards the base of the tank.

If you have a high house and want to raise the tank onto a stand, then
the stand is likely to cost more than the tank! But a high tank means
that you are not held hostage to a pressure pump for gardening, and a
reliable 240 supply during hosing down during bushfire weather. The
poly tanks are happy to sit on a bed of builder's sand (the stuff that
has clay in it, and sets like cement with time). Make sure that the
edges can't get eroded over the years, and protect the tank from
accidental scraping from passing tractors, etc.

Pressure pumps, while giving the convenience of mains pressure, have
a sinister side: while you are at work they can completely empty your
tank, and if you are really unlucky, dump it all onto your bathroom
floor. An advantage of placing the pressure pump where you will hear
it in operation is so that in the middle of the night you can ask
yourself, "Why is that pump going?!" and in short time discover that
someone has left a garden tap turned on.

There have been cases during drought of someone returning home to find
that their precious store of rainwater has been spirited away by a tanker
truck during their absence.
--
John Savage (my news address is not valid for email)

bassett 25-09-2008 10:32 AM

best value water tanks??
 

"John Savage" wrote in message
...
lentildude writes:
Hi, I live in the lowerbluemountains SYD, (10 mins Penrith) and really
want to splurge on a large watertank 9000 - 20000litres. Really
confused what to get, I want the best value tank that will last at
least 20 yrs. Anyone know any bargains out there?? There are a few
sellers on EBAY but worried buying sight unseen. If I connect it to
the growing shed and not the house do I still get a govt rebate? Any
tips appreciated.


The poly tank does seem reliable and robust and is easy to transport
and move if you decide it's original placement is not quite right. I'm
not sure whether they have been around long enough to be confident that
they'll last as long as the gal tanks or the precast concrete ones in
the sun (e.g., 75 years, whatever). Certainly, most say they are
UV-stabilised but whether some withstand direct sun better than others
who knows?

Instead of 'having all your eggs in one basket' you can have multiple
tanks, but you'll probably find that the rebate is available only on
the first, so install the biggest capacity tank first. Identical
capacities come in different shapes, and naturally you'd buy tanks that
sit no higher than your roof gutters (unless you intend some clever
pumping during rain). It is feasible to bury the lower portion of a
tank to allow use of a taller one, but there is always the chance that
it will float up in the hole if the tank is empty when the hole fills
during a storm.

It's instructive to examine brochures from a number of poly tank
manufacturers. If you are getting a tall tank, you'd want to make
sure that its wall thickness increases towards the base of the tank.

If you have a high house and want to raise the tank onto a stand, then
the stand is likely to cost more than the tank! But a high tank means
that you are not held hostage to a pressure pump for gardening, and a
reliable 240 supply during hosing down during bushfire weather. The
poly tanks are happy to sit on a bed of builder's sand (the stuff that
has clay in it, and sets like cement with time). Make sure that the
edges can't get eroded over the years, and protect the tank from
accidental scraping from passing tractors, etc.

Pressure pumps, while giving the convenience of mains pressure, have
a sinister side: while you are at work they can completely empty your
tank, and if you are really unlucky, dump it all onto your bathroom
floor. An advantage of placing the pressure pump where you will hear
it in operation is so that in the middle of the night you can ask
yourself, "Why is that pump going?!" and in short time discover that
someone has left a garden tap turned on.

There have been cases during drought of someone returning home to find
that their precious store of rainwater has been spirited away by a tanker
truck during their absence.
--
John Savage (my news address is not valid for email)


Anyone who buys a gal-tank these days has rocks in there heads. A gal tank
might last 10 years, and it might not. if it remains full it will last if
it's half empty it won't. The thing will start to pin-hole within 5 or 6
years, regardless of wether it has a plastic liner or not.
As for concrete tanks, Sure there OK, IF you can afford a large crane to
install the thing and if you can get the thing into the back yard in the
first place.
Poly tanks are the way to go. As for being thicker at the base, that's a
load of bullshit, and the guy that suggested that has no bloody idea.
How do I know all this. I've been on tank water for the last 25 years, and
all by tanks are now Poly. Our local company are offering a 10.000 litre
tank [Duraplus] plus a pressure pump, delivered and placed for $1700.
Beat that.

In fact if you build a new home in the country, your required to install a
10.000 litre tank for your local Fire brigade , No tank , no completion
certificate onyour home from the council.


bassett



FarmI 25-09-2008 10:46 PM

best value water tanks??
 
"bassett" wrote in message
"John Savage" wrote in message
lentildude writes:


Hi, I live in the lowerbluemountains SYD, (10 mins Penrith) and really
want to splurge on a large watertank 9000 - 20000litres. (snip)


The poly tank does seem reliable and robust and is easy to transport
and move if you decide it's original placement is not quite right. (snip)


It's instructive to examine brochures from a number of poly tank
manufacturers. If you are getting a tall tank, you'd want to make
sure that its wall thickness increases towards the base of the tank.

(snip)

(snip) As for being thicker at the base, that's a load of bullshit, and
the guy that suggested that has no bloody idea.
How do I know all this. I've been on tank water for the last 25 years, and
all by tanks are now Poly.


What rot.

Tanks with thicker plastic at the bottom and lower part of the walls is
preferred by experienced rural dwellers as many farmers have found that poly
tanks that aren't thicker on the bottom and lower walls split.



faeychild 25-09-2008 10:52 PM

best value water tanks??
 
lentildude wrote:

Hi, I live in the lowerbluemountains SYD, (10 mins Penrith) and really
want to splurge on a large watertank 9000 - 20000litres. Really
confused what to get, I want the best value tank that will last at
least 20 yrs. Anyone know any bargains out there?? There are a few
sellers on EBAY but worried buying sight unseen. If I connect it to
the growing shed and not the house do I still get a govt rebate? Any
tips appreciated.


George

Has anyone heard the conspiracy rumour that one the Government has a
sufficiently large list of tank owners, via the rebate, they can start to tax
the rain water the runs off your roof. They

It may be wisest to cop the full cost and keep quiet
--
faeychild

David Hare-Scott[_2_] 26-09-2008 01:54 AM

best value water tanks??
 

"John Savage" wrote in message
...

If you have a high house and want to raise the tank onto a stand, then
the stand is likely to cost more than the tank! But a high tank means
that you are not held hostage to a pressure pump for gardening, and a
reliable 240 supply during hosing down during bushfire weather. The
poly tanks are happy to sit on a bed of builder's sand (the stuff that
has clay in it, and sets like cement with time). Make sure that the
edges can't get eroded over the years, and protect the tank from
accidental scraping from passing tractors, etc.


I high tank that gives gravity flow is also limited in volume by the
distance from the roof to the stand.

Pressure pumps, while giving the convenience of mains pressure, have


Mains pressure will be a big expensive pump. Cheaper ones with less than
mains pressure are OK for the garden.

a sinister side: while you are at work they can completely empty your
tank, and if you are really unlucky, dump it all onto your bathroom
floor. An advantage of placing the pressure pump where you will hear
it in operation is so that in the middle of the night you can ask
yourself, "Why is that pump going?!" and in short time discover that
someone has left a garden tap turned on.


This is true. You must make sure your plumbing is good, especially polypipe
joints are not as reliable as metal. As well as wasting water and soaking
somewhere you don't want soaked a leak or tap left on may burn out the pump
motor if it runs dry. My garden tank is turned off at the valve and the
motor switched off when not in use for this reason.

David



bassett 26-09-2008 09:36 AM

best value water tanks??
 

"FarmI" ask@itshall be given wrote in message
...
"bassett" wrote in message



(snip) As for being thicker at the base, that's a load of bullshit, and
the guy that suggested that has no bloody idea.
How do I know all this. I've been on tank water for the last 25 years,
and all by tanks are now Poly.


What rot.

Tanks with thicker plastic at the bottom and lower part of the walls is
preferred by experienced rural dwellers as many farmers have found that
poly tanks that aren't thicker on the bottom and lower walls split.


Name a brand of tank that has a thicker wall at the base, As for splitting
that's only likely if you attempt to move the thing while partly full, and
most of the reputable brands have a 25 year guarantee



bassett 26-09-2008 09:43 AM

best value water tanks??
 

"David Hare-Scott" wrote in message
...

..

Pressure pumps, while giving the convenience of mains pressure, have


Mains pressure will be a big expensive pump. Cheaper ones with less than
mains pressure are OK for the garden.

a sinister side: while you are at work they can completely empty your
tank, and if you are really unlucky, dump it all onto your bathroom
floor. An advantage of placing the pressure pump where you will hear
it in operation is so that in the middle of the night you can ask
yourself, "Why is that pump going?!" and in short time discover that
someone has left a garden tap turned on.


This is true. You must make sure your plumbing is good, especially
polypipe joints are not as reliable as metal. As well as wasting water
and soaking somewhere you don't want soaked a leak or tap left on may burn
out the pump motor if it runs dry. My garden tank is turned off at the
valve and the motor switched off when not in use for this reason.

David

What a load of paranoid rubbish, how do you think it works for people with
only a tank water supply and a pressure pump.
And a modern pressure pump is worth something like $120 , or there free
when you buy some tanks.
They don't need to be big or expensive.

So tell us , how long have you had a tank water supply. Your playing games
with a **** arsed little tank and a garden hose. You have no bloody idea.
All my solar water fittings are poly type and I,ve never had a problem.
with water pressure blow outs.

bassett



terryc 26-09-2008 05:09 PM

best value water tanks??
 
On Thu, 25 Sep 2008 06:01:02 +0000, John Savage wrote:


If you have a high house and want to raise the tank onto a stand, then the
stand is likely to cost more than the tank!


Why not just sit it on the ground and buy a taller tank? Pressure is a
factor of the "head" (height of water above the tap), assuming you've
used at least 1/2" pipe and not a long run.

But a high tank means that you
are not held hostage to a pressure pump for gardening, and a reliable
240 supply during hosing down during bushfire weather.


Reliable mains and bushfires do not go together.


David Hare-Scott[_2_] 27-09-2008 01:40 AM

best value water tanks??
 

"bassett" wrote in message
...

This is true. You must make sure your plumbing is good, especially
polypipe joints are not as reliable as metal. As well as wasting water
and soaking somewhere you don't want soaked a leak or tap left on may
burn out the pump motor if it runs dry. My garden tank is turned off at
the valve and the motor switched off when not in use for this reason.

David

What a load of paranoid rubbish, how do you think it works for people
with only a tank water supply and a pressure pump.


The same way it does for for my 45 kl house system which is on all the time.
But the plumbing there is high pressure polymer or copper and has been
pressure tested and it is protected by the house structure. I know people
who have had exactly the problem that I described with garden and stock
systems, this is not something that I imagined. I don't know of a case
where the motor burnt out personally but my plumber advised me that it can
happen.

And a modern pressure pump is worth something like $120 , or there free
when you buy some tanks.
They don't need to be big or expensive.


For the garden no they don't need to be big or high pressure and my 10kl
system isn't. But the cheapos don't give mains pressure. I didn't say the
previous poster needed a big pump I did say a little one doesn't give mains
pressure.

So tell us , how long have you had a tank water supply.


Since I built the house.

Your playing games
with a **** arsed little tank and a garden hose.


Why go to the gym when you can get all your exercise jumping to conclusions?
Why the intemperate language? You do seem to have rather an emotional
investment in your limited experience.

You have no bloody idea.
All my solar water fittings are poly type and I,ve never had a problem.
with water pressure blow outs.


Good for you but I don't think that proves very much in this context. Have
you had a horse decide to play with your plastic fittings? They have big
teeth that can disconect a waterer that is not well shielded. I doubt the
previous poster will have this problem, I am just pointing out there are
risks outside a domestic system. Perhaps carelessly driving a stake through
a buried pipe is a more likely example.

Poly fittings are simply not as reliable as metal or the crimped sort on
high pressure tube, especially the push fit types (as opposed to nut and
olive) that are mainly used on 12, 19 and 25 mm poly pipe which are common
sizes for garden use. Some push joiners will blow out just on a low
pressure pump without outside interference unless they are also clamped.

Add together the lower reliabilty of the (most common) fittings and that
there are other hazards found out doors and there is a real risk of pumping
a tank dry due to a leak.

David




David Hare-Scott[_2_] 27-09-2008 01:46 AM

best value water tanks??
 

"bassett" wrote in message
...

"FarmI" ask@itshall be given wrote in message
...
"bassett" wrote in message



(snip) As for being thicker at the base, that's a load of bullshit, and
the guy that suggested that has no bloody idea.
How do I know all this. I've been on tank water for the last 25 years,
and all by tanks are now Poly.


What rot.

Tanks with thicker plastic at the bottom and lower part of the walls is
preferred by experienced rural dwellers as many farmers have found that
poly tanks that aren't thicker on the bottom and lower walls split.


Name a brand of tank that has a thicker wall at the base,


Bushman

David



FarmI 27-09-2008 08:03 AM

best value water tanks??
 

"bassett" wrote in message
...

"FarmI" ask@itshall be given wrote in message
...
"bassett" wrote in message



(snip) As for being thicker at the base, that's a load of bullshit, and
the guy that suggested that has no bloody idea.
How do I know all this. I've been on tank water for the last 25 years,
and all by tanks are now Poly.


What rot.

Tanks with thicker plastic at the bottom and lower part of the walls is
preferred by experienced rural dwellers as many farmers have found that
poly tanks that aren't thicker on the bottom and lower walls split.


Name a brand of tank that has a thicker wall at the base,


Never heard of google? I just did a quick search and Clark Tanks, Toowoomba
Plastics polytanks, Rainwater Tank Company, Action Tanks and Lifestyle tanks
were some of the ones that popped up whihc all claim that the thicker lower
walls is adds strength. and of course such a claim amkes sense given that
is where the maximum pressure would be.

And David mentioned Bushmans. I didn't see those tanks in my hunt, but it
was only a very quick and dirty google.

As for splitting
that's only likely if you attempt to move the thing while partly full, and
most of the reputable brands have a 25 year guarantee


As a number of people have already pointed out, a 25 year guarantee means
little as numerous people have found out over the years for all sorts of
reasons and for all sorts of products. And there can be multiple failures
for tanks and moving a half full tank may not be one of them.



FarmI 27-09-2008 08:22 AM

best value water tanks??
 
"bassett" wrote in message
"David Hare-Scott" wrote in message


Pressure pumps, while giving the convenience of mains pressure, have


Mains pressure will be a big expensive pump. Cheaper ones with less than
mains pressure are OK for the garden.

a sinister side: while you are at work they can completely empty your
tank, and if you are really unlucky, dump it all onto your bathroom
floor. An advantage of placing the pressure pump where you will hear
it in operation is so that in the middle of the night you can ask
yourself, "Why is that pump going?!" and in short time discover that
someone has left a garden tap turned on.


This is true. You must make sure your plumbing is good, especially
polypipe joints are not as reliable as metal. As well as wasting water
and soaking somewhere you don't want soaked a leak or tap left on may
burn out the pump motor if it runs dry. My garden tank is turned off at
the valve and the motor switched off when not in use for this reason.


What a load of paranoid rubbish, how do you think it works for people
with only a tank water supply and a pressure pump.


I live, and have lived, with tank water supply and pressure pumps for about
4 decades. I thought that what David said made sense.

And a modern pressure pump is worth something like $120 , or there free
when you buy some tanks.
They don't need to be big or expensive.

So tell us , how long have you had a tank water supply. Your playing
games with a **** arsed little tank and a garden hose. You have no bloody
idea.


Based on my 4 decades of living with water tanks and owning 2 farms which
are both on tank water, I'd say there was nothing wrong with his advice or
comments.

All my solar water fittings are poly type and I,ve never had a problem.
with water pressure blow outs.


Lucky you. We've had lots of incidences of water loss and for various
reasons.

I've just counted how many water tanks we have on our 2 farms. We have 7.
All but one are concrete.

We have 2 tanks on the other farm (both concrete) - they gravity feed the
house and garden there. When the header tank runs low we use a fire
fighting pump to move water from the tank on the house up to the header tank
on the hill.

At this farm we have 3 concrete water tanks solely for house water. In
addition, for the garden and very occassional stock use, I have one concrete
tank and the plastic tank. These are supplied with water from a dam and a
bore.

We have 3 pressure pumps and a fire fighting pump. We've never had a
problem with the fire fighting pump but have had to replace all three
pressure pumps. We've lost 2 full tanks of house water (that I can recall)
and lost so many tanks of gardening water that I wouldn't be able to give
even a rough guesstimate of the number. Reasons include: cow eating poly
pipe, cow eating tank fitting, stock trough failure due to cow eating
fitting, stock trough failure due to stock trough fitting failure, pump
failure, multiple and differing human failures.

Shit happens.



Jeßus[_4_] 27-09-2008 11:31 PM

best value water tanks??
 
FarmI wrote:
snip
We have 2 tanks on the other farm (both concrete) - they gravity feed the
house and garden there. When the header tank runs low we use a fire
fighting pump to move water from the tank on the house up to the header tank
on the hill.

At this farm we have 3 concrete water tanks solely for house water. In
addition, for the garden and very occassional stock use, I have one concrete
tank and the plastic tank. These are supplied with water from a dam and a
bore.

We have 3 pressure pumps and a fire fighting pump. We've never had a
problem with the fire fighting pump but have had to replace all three
pressure pumps. We've lost 2 full tanks of house water (that I can recall)
and lost so many tanks of gardening water that I wouldn't be able to give
even a rough guesstimate of the number. Reasons include: cow eating poly
pipe, cow eating tank fitting, stock trough failure due to cow eating
fitting, stock trough failure due to stock trough fitting failure, pump
failure, multiple and differing human failures.

Shit happens.


Interesting thread, despite the arguing :)

Dare I ask about pros and cons of the various brands of pressure pumps
commonly available?

Are they all more-or-less the same or do some stand out as better (price
ranges being similar). More importantly - any to stay away from?

Cheers

tuppy 28-09-2008 02:02 AM

best value water tanks??
 
Thanks everyone for all the posts, looks like plastic is the way to
go, but I was asking about best value - Im on a budget of about $2000.
Want to get the biggest tanks I can get delivered for that. No pump, I
live on a slope so will gravity feed driplines.

Dynaplas seem to have a store on ebay!
delivery syd is only $95

looking at this
http://cgi.ebay.com.au/4350L-RAIN-WA...2.m153.l1 262
They seem to be joining 3 tanks via polypipe to make up 4350l of
storage. Splitting storage into 3 tanks must be easier to
install and handle but wondering if there is a disadvantage.

sellers store http://stores.ebay.com.au/yourippa-Truck-4wd-car-van

thanks
George

FarmI 28-09-2008 04:45 AM

best value water tanks??
 
"tuppy" wrote in message
...
Thanks everyone for all the posts, looks like plastic is the way to
go, but I was asking about best value - Im on a budget of about $2000.
Want to get the biggest tanks I can get delivered for that. No pump, I
live on a slope so will gravity feed driplines.

Dynaplas seem to have a store on ebay!
delivery syd is only $95

looking at this
http://cgi.ebay.com.au/4350L-RAIN-WA...2.m153.l1 262
They seem to be joining 3 tanks via polypipe to make up 4350l of
storage. Splitting storage into 3 tanks must be easier to
install and handle but wondering if there is a disadvantage.


I must admit that I wouldn't be keen on the polypipe connections. The
upside is that they are visually reasonably good looking.

I must also be getting old and tight because for the amount you have
allowed, we got a 9,000 ltr concrete tank not so many years ago.

I have been planning to make up at least one of what the Poms would call
"water butts" from used 220 ltr olive containers and chemical containers
like these:
http://cracker.com.au/canterbury-ban...755/advert.htm

I even have the olive barrels which IIRC correctly cost me $20 each, and the
taps which have a gasket on either side and a screww that tightens up and
forms a seal on each side of the barrel wall. All I have to do is drill a
hole. Just haven't got around to finding my "round tuit" tool.



FarmI 28-09-2008 04:49 AM

best value water tanks??
 
"Jeßus" wrote in message

Dare I ask about pros and cons of the various brands of pressure pumps
commonly available?

Are they all more-or-less the same or do some stand out as better (price
ranges being similar). More importantly - any to stay away from?


Can't really help you too much there. Onga and Davey seem to be the most
common round here and we've (so far) had no problems from the Onga pumps we
have.



SG1 28-09-2008 05:48 AM

best value water tanks??
 

"tuppy" wrote in message
...
Thanks everyone for all the posts, looks like plastic is the way to
go, but I was asking about best value - Im on a budget of about $2000.
Want to get the biggest tanks I can get delivered for that. No pump, I
live on a slope so will gravity feed driplines.

Dynaplas seem to have a store on ebay!
delivery syd is only $95

looking at this
http://cgi.ebay.com.au/4350L-RAIN-WA...2.m153.l1 262
They seem to be joining 3 tanks via polypipe to make up 4350l of
storage. Splitting storage into 3 tanks must be easier to
install and handle but wondering if there is a disadvantage.

sellers store http://stores.ebay.com.au/yourippa-Truck-4wd-car-van

thanks
George


Bunnings have a 5000 litre job for $880. 2 of them and a bit of change.



-- Posted on news://freenews.netfront.net - Complaints to --

terryc 29-09-2008 12:06 AM

best value water tanks??
 
On Sat, 27 Sep 2008 18:02:09 -0700, tuppy wrote:


They seem to be joining 3 tanks via polypipe to make up 4350l of storage.
Splitting storage into 3 tanks must be easier to install and handle but
wondering if there is a disadvantage.


The best storage is the largest, tallest, circular tank you can install in
he space. Anything else is inefficent use of land space or an attempt to
maximise storage in weird spaces (side walkways, etc.



terryc 29-09-2008 12:07 AM

best value water tanks??
 
On Sun, 28 Sep 2008 17:16:09 +1000, wrote:


George, First up and yes, !!harsh!!, using Goggle Gropers as Usenet access
is not smart, at all.


"Goggle gropers" is usenet



Jeßus[_4_] 29-09-2008 04:06 AM

best value water tanks??
 
FarmI wrote:
"Jeßus" wrote in message

Dare I ask about pros and cons of the various brands of pressure pumps
commonly available?

Are they all more-or-less the same or do some stand out as better (price
ranges being similar). More importantly - any to stay away from?


Can't really help you too much there. Onga and Davey seem to be the most
common round here and we've (so far) had no problems from the Onga pumps we
have.


No worries at all and thanks, it was mainly pure curiosity for the time
being.

I have a 5000 gal tank here, couldn't even tell you the brand of pump
offhand (was already set up when I bought the property).

But I am thinking about a much larger tank later down the track - I have
a permanent creek down the back of the property - water quality appears
excellent (although I haven't had it tested). Its the same water that
they use for the town water anyway.
Beyond the creek is all uphill to about 50m, so I'm thinking gravity
feed would work extremely well.

Chookie 29-09-2008 08:45 AM

best value water tanks??
 
In article ,
"FarmI" ask@itshall be given wrote:

We have 3 pressure pumps and a fire fighting pump. We've never had a
problem with the fire fighting pump but have had to replace all three
pressure pumps. We've lost 2 full tanks of house water (that I can recall)
and lost so many tanks of gardening water that I wouldn't be able to give
even a rough guesstimate of the number. Reasons include: cow eating poly
pipe, cow eating tank fitting, stock trough failure due to cow eating
fitting, stock trough failure due to stock trough fitting failure, pump
failure, multiple and differing human failures.

Shit happens.


I certainly hope it did, with little bits of poly fittings in. Or do cows not
survive eating plastic bits?

--
Chookie -- Sydney, Australia
(Replace "foulspambegone" with "optushome" to reply)

http://chookiesbackyard.blogspot.com/

John Savage 29-09-2008 09:27 AM

best value water tanks??
 
I wrote:
If you have a high house and want to raise the tank onto a stand, then
the stand is likely to cost more than the tank! But a high tank means
that you are not held hostage to a pressure pump for gardening, and a
reliable 240 supply during hosing down during bushfire weather. The
poly tanks are happy to sit on a bed of builder's sand (the stuff that
has clay in it, and sets like cement with time). Make sure that the
edges can't get eroded over the years, and protect the tank from
accidental scraping from passing tractors, etc.


On reflection I think I used "decomposed granite", not builder's sand.

There have been cases during drought of someone returning home to find
that their precious store of rainwater has been spirited away by a tanker
truck during their absence.


Not the whole tank went missing, just its contents. :-)
--
John Savage (my news address is not valid for email)

FarmI 29-09-2008 01:02 PM

best value water tanks??
 
"Chookie" wrote in message
"FarmI" ask@itshall be given wrote:

We have 3 pressure pumps and a fire fighting pump. We've never had a
problem with the fire fighting pump but have had to replace all three
pressure pumps. We've lost 2 full tanks of house water (that I can
recall)
and lost so many tanks of gardening water that I wouldn't be able to give
even a rough guesstimate of the number. Reasons include: cow eating poly
pipe, cow eating tank fitting, stock trough failure due to cow eating
fitting, stock trough failure due to stock trough fitting failure, pump
failure, multiple and differing human failures.

Shit happens.


I certainly hope it did, with little bits of poly fittings in. Or do cows
not
survive eating plastic bits?


We haven't lost one yet to poly pipe but I know of producers who have had
thier animals die from eating the stuff. The sodding things just love it
for some reason. They also like to chew bones too.



tuppy 30-09-2008 06:13 AM

best value water tanks??
 
Hi, 2 x $880 Bunnings tanks will give me 10000l for $1600 (.16/l)
probably the best Ill do at this price.

thanks for the info!

George


thanks
George


Bunnings have a 5000 litre job for $880. 2 of them and a bit of change.

-- Posted on news://freenews.netfront.net - Complaints to --- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -



SG1 30-09-2008 10:36 AM

best value water tanks??
 

"tuppy" wrote in message
...
Hi, 2 x $880 Bunnings tanks will give me 10000l for $1600 (.16/l)
probably the best Ill do at this price.

thanks for the info!

George


Not a problem may even be getting 1 for myself



thanks
George


Bunnings have a 5000 litre job for $880. 2 of them and a bit of change.

-- Posted on news://freenews.netfront.net - Complaints to
--- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -





-- Posted on news://freenews.netfront.net - Complaints to --

John Savage 30-09-2008 02:04 PM

best value water tanks??
 
terryc writes:
On Thu, 25 Sep 2008 06:01:02 +0000, John Savage wrote:
If you have a high house and want to raise the tank onto a stand, then the
stand is likely to cost more than the tank!


Why not just sit it on the ground and buy a taller tank? Pressure is a
factor of the "head" (height of water above the tap), assuming you've
used at least 1/2" pipe and not a long run.


Best to ask those who sit tanks on stands. But a tank sitting on the
ground right outside your window can block a lot of view. If yard space
is at a premium, a water tank on a high stand can still allow you to see
out, and it will not block cooling breeze from that direction. Security
would come into it, too, you may not want a tank to block your line of
sight to the garage, street, neighbours, etc., or to offer cover to some
one trying to break in. Where the stand already exists, it might have a
garden or storage shed underneath. Some farm tanks have a gravity fed
shower underneath or alongside.

Filling a high tank from a well or an underground cement tank might be
preferred as a fire safety measure, offering a supply of low-pressure
water even should the electricity fail.

But a high tank means that you
are not held hostage to a pressure pump for gardening, and a reliable
240 supply during hosing down during bushfire weather.


Reliable mains and bushfires do not go together.


Which is why I didn't mention mains.
--
John Savage (my news address is not valid for email)

John Savage 30-09-2008 02:05 PM

best value water tanks??
 
"bassett" writes:
Anyone who buys a gal-tank these days has rocks in there heads.


Maybe, maybe not. The OP didn't say exactly what he/she wanted it for
or where he intended to locate it. But he did indicate that he lived in
the mountains.

I do know that after house fires there are usually two structures left
standing: the firebrick chimney, and the gal tank, and no one has
successfully seen out the loss of a house in a firestorm by taking refuge in
their chimney!

As for concrete tanks, Sure there OK, IF you can afford a large crane to
install the thing and if you can get the thing into the back yard in the
first place.


The OP never mentioned a yard, or a back yard, AFAIR so I made no assumptions.

When I was buying a tank 4 years ago, for the size we wanted we could get a
prefab concrete tank delivered ready to site on a lowloader with crane for
about the cost of a poly tank half its capacity. The concrete tank likewise
had a long life guarantee, and a guarantee that it would not be cracked
during install. I may be wrong, but I reckon that a cement tank should keep
the water cooler, in scorching summer heat, than does a PVC tank.

But I would agree that todays steel tanks are probably a mere shadow of the
quality of those that were manufactured 50 years ago. Though they must still
offer some advantage or they wouldn't be still being sold. Fire resistance
or melting point may well be one.

I think it cost around $500 for our pressure pump; quite a robust unit and of
capacity more than required for 98% of the time but the tank was to be used
for house, laundry and 2 garden taps simultaneously at times.
--
John Savage (my news address is not valid for email)

terryc 30-09-2008 03:41 PM

best value water tanks??
 
On Tue, 30 Sep 2008 13:04:41 +0000, John Savage wrote:

Best to ask those who sit tanks on stands.


There ain't no such one thing.

In urbn settings the household tank was usually situated so the bottom was
equal to or slightly higher than the kitchen sink tap and the top allowed
a gutter feed. most tanks were also around the back of the house.

I am yet to see any modern installaions where the rainwater tank is in the
front yard.

Anything else involves pumping.


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 09:48 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
GardenBanter