I need a reality check. Anybody know about Sluggo Snail and Slug Bait?

Epinions.com says,"new iron phosphate compounds, sold under several
brand names such as Sluggo and Escar-go. These are non-toxic and
unattractive to mammals and birds, but when slugs ingest the pellets,
they stop eating and die. Iron phosphate bait can be sprinkled around
your favorite plants without worry."

Greenfeet.com. says, "Sluggo will give protetion to lawns, gardens,
commercial landscape areas, greenhouses, outdoor ornamentals, container
nursery plants, vegetable gardens, field crops, fruit trees and berries.
The bait can be scattered on the lawn or on the soil around vegetables,
flowers, fruit trees, or bushes to be protected.

1 lb per 1000 square feet or 1 teaspoon per square yard. Apply more
heavily if infestation is severe. Reapply Sluggo as bait is consumed.
Scatter Sluggo on the soil around or near plants to be protected. May be
applied over the top of plants. Aerial applications allowed. Sluggo
remains effective after a sprinkle, irrigation or rain.
Active Ingredient: Iron Phosphate . . . .1%".

It looks too good to be true. The two reviews above are from Monsanto
"front groups", right?

I've lived in this "there's a sucker born every minute" country long
enough that it must be "caveat emptor" time again.

What is the skinny?

- Bill
Cloribus gustibus non disputatum (mostly)

On Mar 27, 5:00 pm, William Rose wrote:
I need a reality check. Anybody know about Sluggo Snail and Slug Bait?

Epinions.com says,"new iron phosphate compounds, sold under several
brand names such as Sluggo and Escar-go. These are non-toxic and
unattractive to mammals and birds, but when slugs ingest the pellets,
they stop eating and die. Iron phosphate bait can be sprinkled around
your favorite plants without worry."

Greenfeet.com. says, "Sluggo will give protetion to lawns, gardens,
commercial landscape areas, greenhouses, outdoor ornamentals, container
nursery plants, vegetable gardens, field crops, fruit trees and berries.
The bait can be scattered on the lawn or on the soil around vegetables,
flowers, fruit trees, or bushes to be protected.

1 lb per 1000 square feet or 1 teaspoon per square yard. Apply more
heavily if infestation is severe. Reapply Sluggo as bait is consumed.
Scatter Sluggo on the soil around or near plants to be protected. May be
applied over the top of plants. Aerial applications allowed. Sluggo
remains effective after a sprinkle, irrigation or rain.
Active Ingredient: Iron Phosphate . . . .1%".

It looks too good to be true. The two reviews above are from Monsanto
"front groups", right?

I've lived in this "there's a sucker born every minute" country long
enough that it must be "caveat emptor" time again.

What is the skinny?

- Bill
Cloribus gustibus non disputatum (mostly)

sluggo works well. I have used it for years and I used to have a lot
of slugs.
I lost crops several times to them. Encouraging birds has also
helped.
They spend hours a day in there (I put out water for them).
They clean up cabbage worms too, so if your infestation is mild a pan
of water
may be a solution to various insect problems.

Next year I am getting chickens, so hopefully this box is my last one.
Six
chickens take one day to eradicate them from a 500 sqft garden. I
wish
someone could rent chickens to home gardeners.

In article
,
William Rose wrote:

I need a reality check. Anybody know about Sluggo Snail and Slug Bait?

Epinions.com says,"new iron phosphate compounds, sold under several
brand names such as Sluggo and Escar-go. These are non-toxic and
unattractive to mammals and birds, but when slugs ingest the pellets,
they stop eating and die. Iron phosphate bait can be sprinkled around
your favorite plants without worry."

Greenfeet.com. says, "Sluggo will give protetion to lawns, gardens,
commercial landscape areas, greenhouses, outdoor ornamentals, container
nursery plants, vegetable gardens, field crops, fruit trees and berries.
The bait can be scattered on the lawn or on the soil around vegetables,
flowers, fruit trees, or bushes to be protected.

1 lb per 1000 square feet or 1 teaspoon per square yard. Apply more
heavily if infestation is severe. Reapply Sluggo as bait is consumed.
Scatter Sluggo on the soil around or near plants to be protected. May be
applied over the top of plants. Aerial applications allowed. Sluggo
remains effective after a sprinkle, irrigation or rain.
Active Ingredient: Iron Phosphate . . . .1%".

It looks too good to be true. The two reviews above are from Monsanto
"front groups", right?

I've lived in this "there's a sucker born every minute" country long
enough that it must be "caveat emptor" time again.

What is the skinny?

- Bill
Cloribus gustibus non disputatum (mostly)

Thanks "simy1" for the heads up, but I also have mice and "CATS(5)". I
have a bird feeder and a suspended water source for birds but, because I
like them (except for jays) I don't want them on the ground.

I respect your effort to find a more natural approach to snail and slug
control than chemicals. My ultimate goal is probably geese but I need to
work this out with my schaferhund and her side kick, the McNabb. (Two of
the cleverest hounds that Beelzebub ever conceived.) (This is in no way
an endorsement of organized, or otherwise, religion.)

My natural instinct is to try the flat piece of wood on the ground
approach, but if the low labor intensive Borgia approach works, who am I
to quibble?

Do I hear a dissenting opinion?

Thanks in advance,

- Bill

Cloribus gustibus non disputatum (mostly)

On Tue, 27 Mar 2007 23:17:46 -0700, William Rose wrote:

My natural instinct is to try the flat piece of wood on the ground
approach, but if the low labor intensive Borgia approach works, who am I
to quibble?


Pardon me, but what is the 'flat piece of wood on the ground' tek?

stonerfish

On Mon, 09 Apr 2007 03:28:36 GMT, jellybean stonerfish wrote:

On Tue, 27 Mar 2007 23:17:46 -0700, William Rose wrote:

My natural instinct is to try the flat piece of wood on the ground
approach, but if the low labor intensive Borgia approach works, who am I
to quibble?

Pardon me, but what is the 'flat piece of wood on the ground' tek?

stonerfish

Hi stonerfish,the slug's hide under the wood at night.In the morning you
lift the wood and take care of the slug's.
I use a pair of scissors.
--
Regards From
Wane Smooth

Help feed the Hungry,goto
http://www.thehungersite.com
It's Free!

On May 11, 5:34 am, Wane Smooth wrote:
On Mon, 09 Apr 2007 03:28:36 GMT, jellybean stonerfish wrote:
On Tue, 27 Mar 2007 23:17:46 -0700, William Rose wrote:

My natural instinct is to try the flat piece of wood on the ground
approach, but if the low labor intensive Borgia approach works, who am I
to quibble?

Pardon me, but what is the 'flat piece of wood on the ground' tek?

stonerfish

Hi stonerfish,the slug's hide under the wood at night.In the morning you
lift the wood and take care of the slug's.
I use a pair of scissors.
--
Regards From
Wane Smooth

Help feed the Hungry,gotohttp://www.thehungersite.com
It's Free!

I keep a spray bottle with 1part ammonia and 2parts water around,
whenever I see one of those slimballs one shot from the spray bottle
and their dead!!!!! This works well in the morning after a good rain
and they are still out on a cement driveway. You don't get them all
but I see less damange every year.
Hope that helps
Cheers
Monty