GardenBanter.co.uk - Oak sawdust for compost?

GardenBanter.co.uk (https://www.gardenbanter.co.uk/)

- Edible Gardening (https://www.gardenbanter.co.uk/edible-gardening/)

- - Oak sawdust for compost? (https://www.gardenbanter.co.uk/edible-gardening/40903-oak-sawdust-compost.html)

Joe	20-08-2003 05:22 AM

Oak sawdust for compost?

Is it OK to put oak sawdust on my garden this fall or spring and till it in?
I heard oak has tannic acid in it. Would that hurt it?
Thanks

Philip

20-08-2003 04:32 PM

Oak sawdust for compost?

"Joe" wrote in message
news:7yC0b.204267$Ho3.27283@sccrnsc03...
Is it OK to put oak sawdust on my garden this fall or spring and till it
in?
I heard oak has tannic acid in it. Would that hurt it?
Thanks

Adding it to a compost pile would probably be OK, I didn't have problems
when I did, I'm not sure about just using it directly on the soil, I'd think
there'd be some issues about the way it decomposes.

Philip

JCM	20-08-2003 06:42 PM

Oak sawdust for compost?

"Joe" wrote in message news:7yC0b.204267$Ho3.27283@sccrnsc03...
Is it OK to put oak sawdust on my garden this fall or spring and till it in?
I heard oak has tannic acid in it. Would that hurt it?
Thanks

I use oak sawdust in my compost pile all the time. It does lower the
pH, so you might want to monitor and use lime if you need to sweeten
the soil. But it's a great source of carbon for composting.

Noydb

21-08-2003 02:22 AM

Oak sawdust for compost?

Joe wrote:

Is it OK to put oak sawdust on my garden this fall or spring and till it
in? I heard oak has tannic acid in it. Would that hurt it?
Thanks

You left out a whole lot of information.
WHERE is this garden located?
What sort of soil do you have?
How much sawdust do you contemplate tilling in?

Is your soil managed organically (biologically hyperactive) or chemically
(semi-comatose)?

Bill
--
Zone 5b (Detroit, MI)
I do not post my address to news groups.

Glenna Rose

22-08-2003 08:42 AM

Oak sawdust for compost?

writes:
Is it OK to put oak sawdust on my garden this fall or spring and till it
in?
I heard oak has tannic acid in it. Would that hurt it?
Thanks

Unfortunately, my garden was mostly covered with sawdust this year instead
of horse manure. I will *never* do it again! This was by accident . . .
it was hauled soaking wet and the person loading it thought it was well
rotted horse manure (and it was hauled and unloaded in the rain also). I
should have realized even before it started to dry out since there were
few worms in it. (The horse manure I usually get is filled with
earthworms, hundreds/thousands in every large wheelbarrowful.)

It brought in new weeds which is distressing since I'd pretty much gotten
the weeds under control in the past four years with just the manure. (It
had been out in a pasture for years, hence the weeds.) It also "sheds" the
water and water does not soak in thoroughly where it initially is dropped
(either by soaker, drip or sprinkler). It, of course, did *not* decompose
over the summer months as the horse manure does.

Because it came late this year, the garden was all rototilled before it
was hauled which aggravated the situation and contributed greatly to the
problems.

Would I let it happen again? Not no, but 7734 no! I'd rather have relied
on whatever was left from past years than let this have happened.

My obviously unbiased sarcasm here answer would be, don't do it! What
went on my garden would have been Douglas Fir which is likely benign which
oak may or may not be. It might work very well in other situations and
unlikely would have worked better had it been tilled in as you plan to do.

As always, your experience could well be entirely different, for many
reasons. Please keep us posted as to the results; I hope your story is a
happy one.

Glenna

J. Lane

26-08-2003 09:32 AM

Oak sawdust for compost?

NEVER add staight uncomposted sawdust of any kind into your garden. The
process of decomosition takes valuable nitrogen out of your soil. I have
rabbits that use pine shavings as litter and keep a separate compost pile
for their leavings. The pile will compost all winter( started in spring) and
by next spring will be added to the garden.Some sawdusts may take two years
for decomosition to take place. Oak, being a hard wood and full of tanic
acid, may take longer.
--
Jayel
"Joe" wrote in message
news:7yC0b.204267$Ho3.27283@sccrnsc03...
Is it OK to put oak sawdust on my garden this fall or spring and till it
in?
I heard oak has tannic acid in it. Would that hurt it?
Thanks

All times are GMT +1. The time now is 09:58 AM.