Is Potassium not assimilated by plants ?
 

Then, it is merely a catalyst being in higher and higher concentration,
depending on water changes !?

Could anyone discuss this subject ?
The only K I add comes from TMG and little KH2PO4.
Nitrates come from Ca(NO3)2 and Mg(NO3)2...
P and N are stable from week to week but K is raising.

Thanks in advance !

Philippe

Is Potassium not assimilated by plants ?
 

U¿ytkownik "Philippe Lemaire (remove oldies)"
napisa³ w wiadomo¶ci
...
Then, it is merely a catalyst being in higher and higher concentration,
depending on water changes !?

Could anyone discuss this subject ?
The only K I add comes from TMG and little KH2PO4.
Nitrates come from Ca(NO3)2 and Mg(NO3)2...
P and N are stable from week to week but K is raising.

Thanks in advance !

Philippe


I think you nedd to add K in fresh water to reach 15 ppm K.
And if you will be add olnly to fresh warter to change you will be have
parmanent level of K.
Natyraly you can increase or decrease level of K.
I thing more is not nedd.

Is Potassium not assimilated by plants ?
 

Philippe Lemaire (remove oldies) wrote:
Then, it is merely a catalyst being in higher and higher concentration,
depending on water changes !?

Could anyone discuss this subject ?
The only K I add comes from TMG and little KH2PO4.
Nitrates come from Ca(NO3)2 and Mg(NO3)2...
P and N are stable from week to week but K is raising.

Thanks in advance !

Philippe


K is most certainly assimilated by plants. Perhaps your tapwater is
relatively high in K and the additional K from the TMG is too high of a
dose.

--
Elaine T __
http://eethomp.com/fish.html '__
rec.aquaria.* FAQ http://faq.thekrib.com

Is Potassium not assimilated by plants ?
 

Uzytkownik "Elaine T" napisal w wiadomosci
m...
Philippe Lemaire (remove oldies) wrote:
Then, it is merely a catalyst being in higher and higher concentration,
depending on water changes !?

Could anyone discuss this subject ?
The only K I add comes from TMG and little KH2PO4.
Nitrates come from Ca(NO3)2 and Mg(NO3)2...
P and N are stable from week to week but K is raising.

Thanks in advance !

Philippe


K is most certainly assimilated by plants. Perhaps your tapwater is
relatively high in K and the additional K from the TMG is too high of a
dose.

I dont think so.
The level of K is too low in tmg and cannot be accumulated using tmg in
recomendet dose.
Do you monitor your level of K ?

Is Potassium not assimilated by plants ?
 

Elaine T wrote:
Philippe Lemaire (remove oldies) wrote:
Then, it is merely a catalyst being in higher and higher concentration,
depending on water changes !?

Could anyone discuss this subject ?
The only K I add comes from TMG and little KH2PO4.
Nitrates come from Ca(NO3)2 and Mg(NO3)2...
P and N are stable from week to week but K is raising.

Thanks in advance !

Philippe


K is most certainly assimilated by plants. Perhaps your tapwater is
relatively high in K and the additional K from the TMG is too high of a
dose.

Thanks to both !

My tap water should be 0.64 mg/l
I add with KH2PO4 about 3 mg/l per week
I change 1/7 of the water every week

My current concentration is about 55 mg/l
If K+ is assimilated by plants, is it the first ion to leave
when leaves decompose ?

Thanks again !

Philippe

Is Potassium not assimilated by plants ?
 

Andrzej Konarski wrote:
Uzytkownik "Elaine T" napisal w wiadomosci
m...
Philippe Lemaire (remove oldies) wrote:
Then, it is merely a catalyst being in higher and higher concentration,
depending on water changes !?

Could anyone discuss this subject ?
The only K I add comes from TMG and little KH2PO4.
Nitrates come from Ca(NO3)2 and Mg(NO3)2...
P and N are stable from week to week but K is raising.

Thanks in advance !

Philippe


K is most certainly assimilated by plants. Perhaps your tapwater is
relatively high in K and the additional K from the TMG is too high of a
dose.

I dont think so.
The level of K is too low in tmg and cannot be accumulated using tmg in
recomendet dose.
Do you monitor your level of K ?

Now I'm at about 55 mg/l of Potassium...
See other answer for more details !

Thanks !

Philippe

Is Potassium not assimilated by plants ?
 

U¿ytkownik "Philippe Lemaire (remove oldies)"
napisa³ w wiadomo¶ci
...
Elaine T wrote:
Philippe Lemaire (remove oldies) wrote:
Then, it is merely a catalyst being in higher and higher concentration,
depending on water changes !?

Could anyone discuss this subject ?
The only K I add comes from TMG and little KH2PO4.
Nitrates come from Ca(NO3)2 and Mg(NO3)2...
P and N are stable from week to week but K is raising.

Thanks in advance !

Philippe


K is most certainly assimilated by plants. Perhaps your tapwater is
relatively high in K and the additional K from the TMG is too high of a
dose.

Thanks to both !

My tap water should be 0.64 mg/l
I add with KH2PO4 about 3 mg/l per week

Add kh2po4 only to fresh water to reach 1-1,5 ppm in water to change .
if you need more PO4 add some fish and do not add kh2po4 daily because K is
cumulating as you write.

I change 1/7 of the water every week

My current concentration is about 55 mg/l
If K+ is assimilated by plants, is it the first ion to leave
when leaves decompose ?

Thanks again !

Philippe

Is Potassium not assimilated by plants ?
 

Andrzej Konarski wrote:
U¿ytkownik "Philippe Lemaire (remove oldies)"
napisa³ w wiadomo¶ci
...
Elaine T wrote:

K is most certainly assimilated by plants. Perhaps your tapwater is
relatively high in K and the additional K from the TMG is too high of a
dose.

Thanks to both !

My tap water should be 0.64 mg/l
I add with KH2PO4 about 3 mg/l per week

Add kh2po4 only to fresh water to reach 1-1,5 ppm in water to change .
if you need more PO4 add some fish and do not add kh2po4 daily because K is
cumulating as you write.


Thanks !

So no K enters in plants structure !?

Philippe

Is Potassium not assimilated by plants ?
 

Philippe Lemaire (remove oldies) wrote:
Andrzej Konarski wrote:

U¿ytkownik "Philippe Lemaire (remove oldies)"
napisa³ w wiadomo¶ci
...

Elaine T wrote:


K is most certainly assimilated by plants. Perhaps your tapwater is
relatively high in K and the additional K from the TMG is too high of a
dose.

Thanks to both !

My tap water should be 0.64 mg/l
I add with KH2PO4 about 3 mg/l per week

Add kh2po4 only to fresh water to reach 1-1,5 ppm in water to change .
if you need more PO4 add some fish and do not add kh2po4 daily because K is
cumulating as you write.



Thanks !

So no K enters in plants structure !?

Philippe


Again, potassium (K) IS assimilated by plants. It enters the stucture
of the plants, if that's how you want to say it. Are you sure of your
test results? Perhaps something else is accumulating in the water and
making your K test inaccurate.

--
Elaine T __
http://eethomp.com/fish.html '__
rec.aquaria.* FAQ http://faq.thekrib.com

Is Potassium not assimilated by plants ?
 

Elaine T wrote:
Philippe Lemaire (remove oldies) wrote:

Thanks !

So no K enters in plants structure !?

Philippe


Again, potassium (K) IS assimilated by plants. It enters the stucture
of the plants, if that's how you want to say it. Are you sure of your
test results? Perhaps something else is accumulating in the water and
making your K test inaccurate.

Thanks again !

Is there some description of the standard plant composition ?
When leaves die, does K first return to water ?

Philippe

Is Potassium not assimilated by plants ?
 

Potassium is not integrated into the plant strucure to any great
extent. Potassium is predominantly involved in ion channels. It
regulates potential across the cell membrane, providing energy for
cellular processes, maintaining osmotic pressure, etc. Take away
potassium and the cell's biological processes shut down. FWIW plants
actually have quite a high potassium demand, second only to nitrogen.
Andrew

Is Potassium not assimilated by plants ?
 

Andrew wrote:
Potassium is not integrated into the plant strucure to any great
extent. Potassium is predominantly involved in ion channels. It
regulates potential across the cell membrane, providing energy for
cellular processes, maintaining osmotic pressure, etc. Take away
potassium and the cell's biological processes shut down. FWIW plants
actually have quite a high potassium demand, second only to nitrogen.
Andrew

So it acts like a catalyst ?
Is it the same for Ca and Mg ?
And Fe ??

Philippe

Is Potassium not assimilated by plants ?
 

Andrew wrote:
Potassium is not integrated into the plant strucure to any great
extent. Potassium is predominantly involved in ion channels. It
regulates potential across the cell membrane, providing energy for
cellular processes, maintaining osmotic pressure, etc. Take away
potassium and the cell's biological processes shut down. FWIW plants
actually have quite a high potassium demand, second only to nitrogen.
Andrew

Define integrated. Remove a plant stalk, and you remove quite a bit of
potassium from the closed tank system. While potassium is mostly
cytosolic and not bound to protein, it is still intracellular (remember,
high Na+ outside, high K+ inside). That means it is sequestered from
the tank water and there is net uptake as plants grow. I believe that
is Philippe's essential question, since he is confused about the
accumulating potassium in his aquarium.

As for which nutrients leave a dead plant first, my best guess
(for the reasons stated above) is K, followed by N and P. As a general
rule, it is preferable to remove dead plant matter from an aquarium
rather than leave it to rot.

--
Elaine T __
http://eethomp.com/fish.html '__
rec.aquaria.* FAQ http://faq.thekrib.com

Is Potassium not assimilated by plants ?
 

Elaine T wrote:
Andrew wrote:
Potassium is not integrated into the plant strucure to any great
extent. Potassium is predominantly involved in ion channels. It
regulates potential across the cell membrane, providing energy for
cellular processes, maintaining osmotic pressure, etc. Take away
potassium and the cell's biological processes shut down. FWIW plants
actually have quite a high potassium demand, second only to nitrogen.
Andrew

Define integrated. Remove a plant stalk, and you remove quite a bit of
potassium from the closed tank system. While potassium is mostly
cytosolic and not bound to protein, it is still intracellular (remember,
high Na+ outside, high K+ inside). That means it is sequestered from
the tank water and there is net uptake as plants grow. I believe that
is Philippe's essential question, since he is confused about the
accumulating potassium in his aquarium.

As for which nutrients leave a dead plant first, my best guess
(for the reasons stated above) is K, followed by N and P. As a general
rule, it is preferable to remove dead plant matter from an aquarium
rather than leave it to rot.

Your answer is mostly interseting although some words as cytosolic is not
used every day ;-)

My main problem is to add Nitrates to keep the level at 30 ppm...
As therfore I add too much Ca or Mg. K comes mainly from TMG and KH2PO4.
If I increase waterchanges, I shall add still more nitrates :-(

I will try to remove floating leaves ASAP !

Philippe

Is Potassium not assimilated by plants ?
 

Philippe Lemaire (remove oldies) wrote:
Elaine T wrote:

Andrew wrote:

Potassium is not integrated into the plant strucure to any great
extent. Potassium is predominantly involved in ion channels. It
regulates potential across the cell membrane, providing energy for
cellular processes, maintaining osmotic pressure, etc. Take away
potassium and the cell's biological processes shut down. FWIW plants
actually have quite a high potassium demand, second only to nitrogen.
Andrew


Define integrated. Remove a plant stalk, and you remove quite a bit of
potassium from the closed tank system. While potassium is mostly
cytosolic and not bound to protein, it is still intracellular (remember,
high Na+ outside, high K+ inside). That means it is sequestered from
the tank water and there is net uptake as plants grow. I believe that
is Philippe's essential question, since he is confused about the
accumulating potassium in his aquarium.

As for which nutrients leave a dead plant first, my best guess
(for the reasons stated above) is K, followed by N and P. As a general
rule, it is preferable to remove dead plant matter from an aquarium
rather than leave it to rot.


Your answer is mostly interseting although some words as cytosolic is not
used every day ;-)

"Cytosolic" means dissolved in the fluid on the inside of a cell. I was
trying to respond to both you and Andrew at the same time.

My main problem is to add Nitrates to keep the level at 30 ppm...
As therfore I add too much Ca or Mg. K comes mainly from TMG and KH2PO4.
If I increase waterchanges, I shall add still more nitrates :-(

Why are you keeping nitrates at 30 ppm? That's part of your problem!
Everything I've read suggests that 5-10 ppm nitates is preferable.
Here's an article on recommended dosing levels.
http://www.sfbaaps.com/articles/barr_02.html I don't even have problems
with nitrates below 5 ppm as long as I'm dosing every couple of days.

--
Elaine T __
http://eethomp.com/fish.html '__
rec.aquaria.* FAQ http://faq.thekrib.com

Is Potassium not assimilated by plants ?
 

Elaine T wrote:
Philippe Lemaire (remove oldies) wrote:
Your answer is mostly interseting although some words as cytosolic is not
used every day ;-)

"Cytosolic" means dissolved in the fluid on the inside of a cell. I was
trying to respond to both you and Andrew at the same time.

My main problem is to add Nitrates to keep the level at 30 ppm...
As therfore I add too much Ca or Mg. K comes mainly from TMG and KH2PO4.
If I increase waterchanges, I shall add still more nitrates :-(

Why are you keeping nitrates at 30 ppm? That's part of your problem!
Everything I've read suggests that 5-10 ppm nitates is preferable.
Here's an article on recommended dosing levels.
http://www.sfbaaps.com/articles/barr_02.html I don't even have problems
with nitrates below 5 ppm as long as I'm dosing every couple of days.

My GBA are quite calm since I moved from 15 to 30 ppm nitrates.
Presently, I already put some nitrates everyday not have higher instantaneous values.

Thanks for the help !

Are Ca and Mg cytosolic too ?

Philippe

Is Potassium not assimilated by plants ?
 

Andrew wrote:
Potassium is not integrated into the plant strucure to any great
extent. Potassium is predominantly involved in ion channels. It
regulates potential across the cell membrane, providing energy for
cellular processes, maintaining osmotic pressure, etc. Take away
potassium and the cell's biological processes shut down. FWIW plants
actually have quite a high potassium demand, second only to nitrogen.
Andrew

Define integrated.

By integrated into the plant structure I meant K is not usually
covalently integrated into protein, lipid or carbohydrate structures as
is the case for nutrients such as N and P. It remains in in a free
state in the intracellular matrix.

Remove a plant stalk, and you remove quite a bit of
potassium from the closed tank system. While potassium is mostly
cytosolic and not bound to protein, it is still intracellular (remember,
high Na+ outside, high K+ inside).

Of course, and if you scoop a bucket of water out of your tank you
remove quite a bit of water from a closed system but it doesn't mean
the water is integrated into the structure of the bucket.

That means it is sequestered from the tank water and there is net uptake as
plants grow.

I never said it wasn't sequestered just not iintegrated into the
"structure" of the plant. You do remove a lot of K when you prune, etc.

I believe that is Philippe's essential question, since he is confused about the
accumulating potassium in his aquarium.

Semantics regarding what makes a structurally integrated component of a
plant aside, I believe that question was answered before I posted, ie
yes, K is taken up by the plant so his rising levels of K is unlikely
to be due to the plant not using it, assuming he's not over supplying
it (Given aquatic fertilizers are high in K and Phillipe hasn't said
how much N and P are being supplied by the tank's bioload, this may be
a possibility). Philippe asked a further question regarding what K
does. This is what my post referred to.

As for which nutrients leave a dead plant first, my best guess
(for the reasons stated above) is K, followed by N and P. As a general
rule, it is preferable to remove dead plant matter from an aquarium
rather than leave it to rot.

Plant will often try to retain nutrients where possible. A lot of the
soluble components of dying leaves (eg ions, amino acids, nucleic acids
etc) are transported to the growing areas. What's left in the dead leaf
are usually the structural components which are contain more N and P
than K. When the leaf rots the locked up N and P are released while the
K most likely remains in the living plant.

Andrew

Is Potassium not assimilated by plants ?
 

Andrew wrote:
Andrew wrote:
Potassium is not integrated into the plant strucure to any great
extent. Potassium is predominantly involved in ion channels. It
regulates potential across the cell membrane, providing energy for
cellular processes, maintaining osmotic pressure, etc. Take away
potassium and the cell's biological processes shut down. FWIW plants
actually have quite a high potassium demand, second only to nitrogen.
Andrew

Define integrated.

By integrated into the plant structure I meant K is not usually
covalently integrated into protein, lipid or carbohydrate structures as
is the case for nutrients such as N and P. It remains in in a free
state in the intracellular matrix.

Remove a plant stalk, and you remove quite a bit of
potassium from the closed tank system. While potassium is mostly
cytosolic and not bound to protein, it is still intracellular (remember,
high Na+ outside, high K+ inside).

Of course, and if you scoop a bucket of water out of your tank you
remove quite a bit of water from a closed system but it doesn't mean
the water is integrated into the structure of the bucket.

That means it is sequestered from the tank water and there is net uptake as
plants grow.

I never said it wasn't sequestered just not iintegrated into the
"structure" of the plant. You do remove a lot of K when you prune, etc.

I believe that is Philippe's essential question, since he is confused about the
accumulating potassium in his aquarium.

Semantics regarding what makes a structurally integrated component of a
plant aside, I believe that question was answered before I posted, ie
yes, K is taken up by the plant so his rising levels of K is unlikely
to be due to the plant not using it, assuming he's not over supplying
it (Given aquatic fertilizers are high in K and Phillipe hasn't said
how much N and P are being supplied by the tank's bioload, this may be
a possibility). Philippe asked a further question regarding what K
does. This is what my post referred to.

As for which nutrients leave a dead plant first, my best guess
(for the reasons stated above) is K, followed by N and P. As a general
rule, it is preferable to remove dead plant matter from an aquarium
rather than leave it to rot.

Plant will often try to retain nutrients where possible. A lot of the
soluble components of dying leaves (eg ions, amino acids, nucleic acids
etc) are transported to the growing areas. What's left in the dead leaf
are usually the structural components which are contain more N and P
than K. When the leaf rots the locked up N and P are released while the
K most likely remains in the living plant.

Andrew

Thanks for this precise answer !

So, I know now that pruning remove K but not removing old decaying leaves...
Could you comment also on Ca and Mg ?

I first thought it was related on which type of leaves (new/old) were affected by
deficiencies... However, P, N and K affect old leaves making that not a good critrerion !

Philippe whose English cannot match yours