GardenBanter.co.uk

GardenBanter.co.uk (https://www.gardenbanter.co.uk/)
-   Freshwater Aquaria Plants (https://www.gardenbanter.co.uk/freshwater-aquaria-plants/)
-   -   CO2 bubbles collecting in Nutrafin diffuser (https://www.gardenbanter.co.uk/freshwater-aquaria-plants/29566-co2-bubbles-collecting-nutrafin-diffuser.html)

Ron Nelson 04-06-2003 10:20 AM

CO2 bubbles collecting in Nutrafin diffuser
 
If one wanted to get a better idea as to the contents of the stabilizer,
couldn't you measure out the same amounts of it and of baking soda and put
them in two identical sized containers of water that have been tested for KH
before, then check the KH after adding? At least then you might have a
better idea wouldn't you?

Ron

"Tzeentch" wrote in message
...
Some people speculated that it's probably baking soda (Sodium

Bicarbonate),
probaly since it can be used as a pretty good buffer. That's just
speculation though and I haven't seen anybody being positive on whatever

is
in that packet.

"Ronaldo Jeremiah" wrote in message
om...

I've got one of these two. I think it's great, and I'm totally
satisfied with it. As other have noted, the bubbles will begin to
travel properly on their own after a while.

My question is this: What is the stabilizer? I know that the
activator is yeast, and I suspect that the stabilizer works by somehow
regulating the pH in the yeast/sugar/water mix, but even if I am right
about that I don't know what it is. If I knew what it was, I could
probably buy it much cheaper in bulk, since a three-pack of activator
and stabilizer is about $8! I know the yeast should cost next to
nothing.

Anyone know what the stabilizer is, or want to take an educated guess?

-RJ






Tzeentch 04-06-2003 07:44 PM

CO2 bubbles collecting in Nutrafin diffuser
 
Incredible that they get away selling that stuff at that price.

Anyway, as I said earlier, I wanna keep the diffuser and build a DIY CO2
system for the rest. With CO2 check valves (if I can find those around
here, no luck yet), 2 yeast generator bottle, a gas separator and silicone
or better tubing.

BTW, anybody tried to use non-refined brown sugar like cane sugar in the mix
instead of what the instructions says: "Add white table sugar (no other
substitute)"?

"Zach987987987" wrote in message
...
simple baking soda,
I have the system as well but it was so hard to find refill packages of

the
powder I went to just the old yeast and sugar with a little baking soda to
regualte the reaction, just mix it as the instructions said with their mix

and
your off




Jak Crow 05-06-2003 08:20 AM

CO2 bubbles collecting in Nutrafin diffuser
 
On Wed, 4 Jun 2003 01:42:45 -0600, "Ron Nelson" wrote:

If one wanted to get a better idea as to the contents of the stabilizer,
couldn't you measure out the same amounts of it and of baking soda and put
them in two identical sized containers of water that have been tested for KH
before, then check the KH after adding? At least then you might have a
better idea wouldn't you?


Of course, someone could just taste it and see. :)

Ronaldo Jeremiah 05-06-2003 09:17 AM

CO2 bubbles collecting in Nutrafin diffuser
 
Andrey Tarasevich wrote in message ...
Hello

I notice that instead of going all the way up CO2 bubbles are collecting in my
new Hagen Nutrafin diffuser forming larger bubbles that just sit there all the
time. I tried forcing them out of there but eventually they reappear. Meanwhile,
I saw a working setup in my LFS and it didn't have any bubbles stuck in it. I
also read somewhere on Google that this is normal for freshly installed
diffusers and eventually this issue will go away. Did anyone experience this
problem with their Nutrafin diffusers? Will the diffuser eventually clear up?
And if it will, what's the physics of this process? I.e. what exactly is going
to change so that the diffuser will no longer trap and hold CO2 bubbles?


I've got one of these two. I think it's great, and I'm totally
satisfied with it. As other have noted, the bubbles will begin to
travel properly on their own after a while.

My question is this: What is the stabilizer? I know that the
activator is yeast, and I suspect that the stabilizer works by somehow
regulating the pH in the yeast/sugar/water mix, but even if I am right
about that I don't know what it is. If I knew what it was, I could
probably buy it much cheaper in bulk, since a three-pack of activator
and stabilizer is about $8! I know the yeast should cost next to
nothing.

Anyone know what the stabilizer is, or want to take an educated guess?

-RJ

Zach987987987 05-06-2003 09:17 AM

CO2 bubbles collecting in Nutrafin diffuser
 
simple baking soda,
I have the system as well but it was so hard to find refill packages of the
powder I went to just the old yeast and sugar with a little baking soda to
regualte the reaction, just mix it as the instructions said with their mix and
your off
My question is this: What is the stabilizer? I know that the
activator is yeast, and I suspect that the stabilizer works by somehow
regulating the pH in the yeast/sugar/water mix, but even if I am right
about that I don't know what it is. If I knew what it was, I could
probably buy it much cheaper in bulk, since a three-pack of activator
and stabilizer is about $8! I know the yeast should cost next to
nothing.

Anyone know what the stabilizer is, or want to take an educated guess?

-RJ










Tzeentch 05-06-2003 09:17 AM

CO2 bubbles collecting in Nutrafin diffuser
 
Some people speculated that it's probably baking soda (Sodium Bicarbonate),
probaly since it can be used as a pretty good buffer. That's just
speculation though and I haven't seen anybody being positive on whatever is
in that packet.

"Ronaldo Jeremiah" wrote in message
om...

I've got one of these two. I think it's great, and I'm totally
satisfied with it. As other have noted, the bubbles will begin to
travel properly on their own after a while.

My question is this: What is the stabilizer? I know that the
activator is yeast, and I suspect that the stabilizer works by somehow
regulating the pH in the yeast/sugar/water mix, but even if I am right
about that I don't know what it is. If I knew what it was, I could
probably buy it much cheaper in bulk, since a three-pack of activator
and stabilizer is about $8! I know the yeast should cost next to
nothing.

Anyone know what the stabilizer is, or want to take an educated guess?

-RJ




Ron Nelson 05-06-2003 09:17 AM

CO2 bubbles collecting in Nutrafin diffuser
 
If one wanted to get a better idea as to the contents of the stabilizer,
couldn't you measure out the same amounts of it and of baking soda and put
them in two identical sized containers of water that have been tested for KH
before, then check the KH after adding? At least then you might have a
better idea wouldn't you?

Ron

"Tzeentch" wrote in message
...
Some people speculated that it's probably baking soda (Sodium

Bicarbonate),
probaly since it can be used as a pretty good buffer. That's just
speculation though and I haven't seen anybody being positive on whatever

is
in that packet.

"Ronaldo Jeremiah" wrote in message
om...

I've got one of these two. I think it's great, and I'm totally
satisfied with it. As other have noted, the bubbles will begin to
travel properly on their own after a while.

My question is this: What is the stabilizer? I know that the
activator is yeast, and I suspect that the stabilizer works by somehow
regulating the pH in the yeast/sugar/water mix, but even if I am right
about that I don't know what it is. If I knew what it was, I could
probably buy it much cheaper in bulk, since a three-pack of activator
and stabilizer is about $8! I know the yeast should cost next to
nothing.

Anyone know what the stabilizer is, or want to take an educated guess?

-RJ






Tzeentch 05-06-2003 09:17 AM

CO2 bubbles collecting in Nutrafin diffuser
 
Incredible that they get away selling that stuff at that price.

Anyway, as I said earlier, I wanna keep the diffuser and build a DIY CO2
system for the rest. With CO2 check valves (if I can find those around
here, no luck yet), 2 yeast generator bottle, a gas separator and silicone
or better tubing.

BTW, anybody tried to use non-refined brown sugar like cane sugar in the mix
instead of what the instructions says: "Add white table sugar (no other
substitute)"?

"Zach987987987" wrote in message
...
simple baking soda,
I have the system as well but it was so hard to find refill packages of

the
powder I went to just the old yeast and sugar with a little baking soda to
regualte the reaction, just mix it as the instructions said with their mix

and
your off




Jak Crow 05-06-2003 09:17 AM

CO2 bubbles collecting in Nutrafin diffuser
 
On Wed, 4 Jun 2003 01:42:45 -0600, "Ron Nelson" wrote:

If one wanted to get a better idea as to the contents of the stabilizer,
couldn't you measure out the same amounts of it and of baking soda and put
them in two identical sized containers of water that have been tested for KH
before, then check the KH after adding? At least then you might have a
better idea wouldn't you?


Of course, someone could just taste it and see. :)

Ron Nelson 05-06-2003 10:56 AM

CO2 bubbles collecting in Nutrafin diffuser
 
Call me a chicken but I try to avoid submitting myself to unknown
chemicals... :-)

Ron

"Jak Crow" wrote in message
...
On Wed, 4 Jun 2003 01:42:45 -0600, "Ron Nelson" wrote:

If one wanted to get a better idea as to the contents of the stabilizer,
couldn't you measure out the same amounts of it and of baking soda and

put
them in two identical sized containers of water that have been tested for

KH
before, then check the KH after adding? At least then you might have a
better idea wouldn't you?


Of course, someone could just taste it and see. :)




Duncan A. McRae 05-06-2003 03:44 PM

CO2 bubbles collecting in Nutrafin diffuser
 
Just as a matter of interest, what did you do during your college years...?
;)

"Ron Nelson" wrote in message
...
Call me a chicken but I try to avoid submitting myself to unknown
chemicals... :-)





Ron Nelson 05-06-2003 06:08 PM

CO2 bubbles collecting in Nutrafin diffuser
 
"Duncan A. McRae" wrote in message
. rogers.com...
Just as a matter of interest, what did you do during your college

years...?
;)


I don't really remember college, but I researched every single one of those
chemicals before I tried them. :-)

Ron



Graham Broadbridge 13-06-2003 02:21 PM

CO2 bubbles collecting in Nutrafin diffuser
 
The stabilizer is baking soda


"Ronaldo Jeremiah" wrote in message
om...
Andrey Tarasevich wrote in message

...
Hello

I notice that instead of going all the way up CO2 bubbles are collecting

in my
new Hagen Nutrafin diffuser forming larger bubbles that just sit there

all the
time. I tried forcing them out of there but eventually they reappear.

Meanwhile,
I saw a working setup in my LFS and it didn't have any bubbles stuck in

it. I
also read somewhere on Google that this is normal for freshly installed
diffusers and eventually this issue will go away. Did anyone experience

this
problem with their Nutrafin diffusers? Will the diffuser eventually

clear up?
And if it will, what's the physics of this process? I.e. what exactly is

going
to change so that the diffuser will no longer trap and hold CO2 bubbles?


I've got one of these two. I think it's great, and I'm totally
satisfied with it. As other have noted, the bubbles will begin to
travel properly on their own after a while.

My question is this: What is the stabilizer? I know that the
activator is yeast, and I suspect that the stabilizer works by somehow
regulating the pH in the yeast/sugar/water mix, but even if I am right
about that I don't know what it is. If I knew what it was, I could
probably buy it much cheaper in bulk, since a three-pack of activator
and stabilizer is about $8! I know the yeast should cost next to
nothing.

Anyone know what the stabilizer is, or want to take an educated guess?

-RJ




Graham Broadbridge 13-06-2003 02:21 PM

CO2 bubbles collecting in Nutrafin diffuser
 
ROFL!!

I don't really remember college, but I researched every single one of

those
chemicals before I tried them. :-)

Ron





Phil Dietz 13-06-2003 08:08 PM

CO2 bubbles collecting in Nutrafin diffuser
 
My diffuser had a cracked rung, so make sure your's isn't similar.
Hagen replaced mine for free.

Also make sure your unwanted snail population isn't causing the bubble
to jam.

And also make sure that the blue-green algea accumulated on the rungs
is kept in order. If it gets too plentiful it'll make the bubbles
stick...


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 04:11 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
GardenBanter