Two of my 7 S.A.E.s have taken to taken to chasing each other around.They
appear to be sucking the stripes off of each other. After a bout of chase
and nip their stripes are barely discernable, but come back overnight. Am I
right in assuming this is a territorial dispute between them? What are their
reproductive habits and how does one sex them? These are about 2.75" long
( my original is now about 4.5") I am thinking about making one of the
aggressive pair go live with the guppies, but I wonder if they will eat the
fry.

--
Jeff Lowe
reply to: j a l o w e 10 @ h o t m a i l dot c o m

Sounds like normal SAE agression... they aren't the best fish to have,
they tend to end up doing that to every other fish too... eventually, you'll
find them sucking off the other fish, then that fish will be dead, and all
of the SAE's will be dining on it...

I tend to opt for lower aggression algae eaters, pl*cos and Otos...


"Jeff Lowe" wrote in message
...
Two of my 7 S.A.E.s have taken to taken to chasing each other around.They
appear to be sucking the stripes off of each other. After a bout of chase
and nip their stripes are barely discernable, but come back overnight. Am
I
right in assuming this is a territorial dispute between them? What are
their
reproductive habits and how does one sex them? These are about 2.75" long
( my original is now about 4.5") I am thinking about making one of the
aggressive pair go live with the guppies, but I wonder if they will eat
the
fry.

--
Jeff Lowe
reply to: j a l o w e 10 @ h o t m a i l dot c o m

I hate those dam things.. I have 2 that are about 4 inches long and had to
separate them into 2 tanks. They were eating the root's off my little sword
plant's runner. they nip at my plants, and boy do they crap alot.. Since
they are separte, there is no more agression, and I'm happy..

"RedForeman" wrote in message
...
Sounds like normal SAE agression... they aren't the best fish to have,
they tend to end up doing that to every other fish too... eventually,
you'll
find them sucking off the other fish, then that fish will be dead, and all
of the SAE's will be dining on it...

I tend to opt for lower aggression algae eaters, pl*cos and Otos...


"Jeff Lowe" wrote in message
...
Two of my 7 S.A.E.s have taken to taken to chasing each other
around.They
appear to be sucking the stripes off of each other. After a bout of
chase
and nip their stripes are barely discernable, but come back overnight.
Am
I
right in assuming this is a territorial dispute between them? What are
their
reproductive habits and how does one sex them? These are about 2.75"
long
( my original is now about 4.5") I am thinking about making one of the
aggressive pair go live with the guppies, but I wonder if they will eat
the
fry.

--
Jeff Lowe
reply to: j a l o w e 10 @ h o t m a i l dot c o m

Two of my 7 S.A.E.s have taken to taken to chasing each other around.They
appear to be sucking the stripes off of each other.

Are they actually sucking on each other? Have you see it? If so, are you sure
they are true SAEs, and not CAEs? SAEs don't have sucker mouths.

After a bout of chase
and nip their stripes are barely discernable, but come back overnight.

That is normal for all kinds of fish in territorial disputes. The stripes fade
when they are fighting over pecking order. This happens with my clown loaches
as well as my SAEs. The color fading is natural and not harmful. And it's not
caused by sucking.

Am I
right in assuming this is a territorial dispute between them?

Yes. If they are true SAEs, they will probably settle down once a pecking
order is established. Especially with so many fish in the school. (The only
time I've had a real problem with SAE aggression was when I had only three of
them in a 29 gallon tank. The tank was too small, and so was the school. I
put the three SAEs into my bigger tank, and once they were with the larger
school there, there was no more aggression.)

What are their
reproductive habits and how does one sex them? These are about 2.75" long
( my original is now about 4.5") I am thinking about making one of the
aggressive pair go live with the guppies, but I wonder if they will eat the
fry.

I don't know if it's possible to sex them, aside from the usual assumption that
the fatter ones are females (if they are in breeding condition). They are
egg-scatters, and yours are a bit small for breeding. I have heard that they
are easiest to breed when young, but I've also heard that they aren't sexually
mature until they are 3" or so.


Leigh

http://www.fortunecity.com/lavender/halloween/881/

"Gimpy" wrote in message
le.rogers.com...
I hate those dam things.. I have 2 that are about 4 inches long and had to
separate them into 2 tanks. They were eating the root's off my little
sword
plant's runner. they nip at my plants, and boy do they crap alot.. Since
they are separte, there is no more agression, and I'm happy..


Odd. I have SAE's, all full size, (4 inches +) in 4 different tanks, bought
at different times, and have never had any aggression issues. They
occasionally chase each other around, but there's no real heat in the
chasing. Is it possible that you have false SAE's, or flying foxes, which
*do* get aggressive? Just a thought.

billy

"Gimpy" wrote in message
le.rogers.com...
I hate those dam things.. I have 2 that are about 4 inches long and had to
separate them into 2 tanks. They were eating the root's off my little
sword
plant's runner. they nip at my plants, and boy do they crap alot.. Since
they are separte, there is no more agression, and I'm happy..


Odd. I have SAE's, all full size, (4 inches +) in 4 different tanks, bought
at different times, and have never had any aggression issues. They
occasionally chase each other around, but there's no real heat in the
chasing. Is it possible that you have false SAE's, or flying foxes, which
*do* get aggressive? Just a thought.

billy

"Gimpy" wrote in message
le.rogers.com...
I hate those dam things.. I have 2 that are about 4 inches long and had to
separate them into 2 tanks. They were eating the root's off my little
sword
plant's runner. they nip at my plants, and boy do they crap alot.. Since
they are separte, there is no more agression, and I'm happy..


Odd. I have SAE's, all full size, (4 inches +) in 4 different tanks, bought
at different times, and have never had any aggression issues. They
occasionally chase each other around, but there's no real heat in the
chasing. Is it possible that you have false SAE's, or flying foxes, which
*do* get aggressive? Just a thought.

billy

In article ,
says...




"Gimpy" wrote in message
le.rogers.com...
I hate those dam things.. I have 2 that are about 4 inches long and had to
separate them into 2 tanks. They were eating the root's off my little
sword
plant's runner. they nip at my plants, and boy do they crap alot.. Since
they are separte, there is no more agression, and I'm happy..


Odd. I have SAE's, all full size, (4 inches +) in 4 different tanks, bought
at different times, and have never had any aggression issues. They
occasionally chase each other around, but there's no real heat in the
chasing. Is it possible that you have false SAE's, or flying foxes, which
*do* get aggressive? Just a thought.

billy



I've got two 3" SAEs in a 55 and all they've done is a masterful job on
my black brush algae--the only "aggressive" behavior they've shown is
trying to school with the rainbows (who find the attempts most
disconcerting). Check and make sure the black stripe on the side runs
all the way THROUGH the tail fin. If it stops with the body, you have
the wrong fish.