I originally posted about my problem on r.a.f.m. but after doing several
hours of research this morning I now think it might be related to my potting
soil substrate so I'm posting this here. A really short summary: I set up
a new 60L (15 gallon) planted aquarium with potting soil substrate (about
1") and quart on top (about 1"). I added a couple amano shrimp and they did
fine for a week and then both of them starting dying at exactly the same
time. They started lying on their backs and swimming very eradically, and
they turned white. I immediately took them out and put them in my
neighbor's tank, who has been helping me set up my tank like his (using
potting soil substrate). The shrimps recovered in his tank and I left my
tank fishless for one month. I then added an ancistrus. The next day, just
before going to bed I checked on him. He had been doing fine for over 24
hours (I checked at least once an hour) but when I checked he was on his
back. I touched him with the net and he swam eradically (just like the
shrimp). Twice he swam up to the top and actually poked his head out of the
water, and then swam more and went on his back. I took him out, intending
to transfer him to my friend's tank like I had done to save the shrimps but
he was already dead.

I am now suspecting the potting soil. My water is a brownish color, which I
originally thought was algae but now I think it's due to the potting soil or
both. I read that the potting soil can contain fertilizers and other things
that can consume oxygen and/or give off marsh gases. The tank does smell,
but it smells more like potting soil than rotten eggs (sulfur). When the
ancistrus died my wife said she thought maybe there wasn't enough oxygen
since he poked his head out of the water. I didn't think much about it
until I read today that potting soil can consume oxygen. I'm really at a
loss as to what is wrong with my tank and what to do about it. It was
recommended to me in r.a.f.m.that I should tear down the tank, clean it with
bleach, and start over. It was also recommended not to use potting soil. I
know some people do well with potting soil, such as my neighbor who has a
great tank for over a year now, and others hate it. But would potting soil
cause the behavior that I described? The day the ancistrus died I added
back one of the shrimps that I had placed in my neighbor's tank and while
the ancistrus was dying the shrimp was doing just fine! I put the shrimp in
my neighbor's tank because I didn't want to take a chance on him dying.

I find the whole thing really bizarre and if you have any advice please let
me know. There are lots of choices for substrate and there is no clear
obvious choice, so this is a tough decision for me as well when I rebuild
the tank. Many of the suggestions I see such as vermiculite and flourite
don't seem to be available here in France.

Thanks,
Michael

You need to test for ammonia, nitrites and nitrates. I'm guessing the
"fertilizer" is releasing too much of one of these and that's killing
your shrimp.

--
Victor M. Martinez

http://www.che.utexas.edu/~martiv

"Michael" wrote in
:

I originally posted about my problem on r.a.f.m. but after doing
several hours of research this morning I now think it might be related
to my potting soil substrate so I'm posting this here. A really short
summary: I set up a new 60L (15 gallon) planted aquarium with potting
soil substrate (about 1") and quart on top (about 1").

I read Walstad's book and got pretty excited about potting soil for my
first planted tank.

Here are some things that the book didn't mention:

1. Soil works great for those folks who never move, remove, replant or add
plants, for as long as the tank lasts. That describes you, right?

2. Soil works great for those folks who don't have fish that rearrange
things. Your're not ever likely to have a pl*co, cichlid or loach, are you?

3. Some soil is just plain poison. Seems 5-10-20 years ago, someone
stripped the paint/changed the oil/sprayed insecticide/buried toxins/dumped
a car and engine block/emptied the amphetimine factory onto that piece of
dirt, and you just dropped all that right it into your tank. There's not a
lot of virgin earth around.

My first and only try at a soil tank killed all the fish. There are
probably hundreds of folks out there who have successful soil tanks, but I
suspect the list of failures is larger than the list of successes.

I find the whole thing really bizarre and if you have any advice please let
me know. There are lots of choices for substrate and there is no clear
obvious choice, so this is a tough decision for me as well when I rebuild
the tank. Many of the suggestions I see such as vermiculite and flourite
don't seem to be available here in France.

Thanks,
Michael

You can put in much less soil. Pre soak it first for 2-3 weeks also
will help.

There are a number of laterite brand names in France. Dupla etc all
make these amdenments to gravel, 2-3mm is a good size. These work well
w/o soil. You can(I would) add a bit of soil/mulm/peat to the bottom
layer with this gravel+ laterite mix. Just not as a much, maybe a
couple of handfuls per 80 liter tank.

'A bit more(2X) for a non CO2 planted tank.


Regards,
Tom Barr

Dave Millman dav.e.at.tac.tics.co.m wrote in message 4...
I read Walstad's book and got pretty excited about potting soil for my
first planted tank.

Actually, Walstad recommends using soil from your backyard over
potting soil. And she lists quite a few things to be careful about for
potting soil.

Here are some things that the book didn't mention:

1. Soil works great for those folks who never move, remove, replant or add
plants, for as long as the tank lasts. That describes you, right?

I think this is unfair. If you follow her instructions, and cover the
soil with gravel, you'll be OK. It may take a little while for
whatever soil you disturbed to settle back down through the gravel,
but the same could be said of many other substrates.

2. Soil works great for those folks who don't have fish that rearrange
things. Your're not ever likely to have a pl*co, cichlid or loach, are you?

Again, this is true for many other substrates. And my clown loaches
have refrained from "rearranging" things as long as I keep bribing
them with asparagus.

3. Some soil is just plain poison. Seems 5-10-20 years ago, someone
stripped the paint/changed the oil/sprayed insecticide/buried toxins/dumped
a car and engine block/emptied the amphetimine factory onto that piece of
dirt, and you just dropped all that right it into your tank. There's not a
lot of virgin earth around.

I'm sure this is true in some places, but most backyard dirt isn't
chock full of toxins.

My first and only try at a soil tank killed all the fish. There are
probably hundreds of folks out there who have successful soil tanks, but I
suspect the list of failures is larger than the list of successes.

I have heard of dozens of successes (including my own), and very few
failures. Granted, most of the successes were using regular soil
rather than potting soil. In my case, I dug under our backyard sandbox
and thus retrieved soil that had rather little organic material in it.
I felt much safer about that and the unlikely possibility of toxins
than using potting soil and knowing that there were probably weird
fertilizers added.

- Jim

Mic!,,we have same problem before,i lost some zebra danio in my first attempt!!i have a sand substrate planted tank that i migrate into potting soil covered with sand,,all you need is (patience),let the potting soil settle for a couple of weeks put some carbon in your filter,daily 15% water change until the water becomes crystal clear,then you can go back to your normal water changes schedule,mine takes only 5 days and i have crystal clear water,you have to let the plant established in there new substrate to battle ammonia spike before adding your fish,just be sure that your potting soil have no fertilizer,and don't forget to sterilize it,,don't worry about anaerobic thing others saying about the substrate,rooted plants love it!!after a month all my plants are thriving,my plants in my 25 gal. low-tech tank are : cork screw,mayaca fluviatilis,amazon sword,creeping jenny,green cabomba,anachris,wisteria and cyperus helferi. fishes: pink & normal zebra danio,WCMM,SAE,pearl danio and 1 goldy for scavenging., P.S. i never used any testkit and chemicals in my hobby.