Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Plant problems
Hello everyone,
My 20Gal long tank, with 2wpg, had something happen to it a few months ago. My plants stopped growing well. I've been too busy with school to worry too much about, but I did the obvious things as the plants slowly died off - stopped dosing fertilizer so much and cut down the light. It was bad - all of a sudden all my Java Fern died. Sunset Hyugro won't grow in the tank now. Finally, I got sick of the algae and the bare tank, so I hit up the LFS and lucked out - just had a fresh shipment! Picked up some awesome looking camboba, red tiger lotus, giant hygro, and something I forget that looks like bacopa with smaller leaves. Planted em up, went back to some fertilizer dosing, made sure my DIY CO2 reactor was running, and turned the lights back up to 10 hours. This was last friday. Most of the new plants are dying already. The camboba seems to have rotted almost the instant I planted in the gravel. The bacopa-like plants' leaves are slowly turning brown and getting ready to fall off. The red tiger lotus is ok for now, but I suspect my 2wpg won't be enough for it ultimately. So, more or less, it was a total failure. I'm wondering what on earth could be wrong. My water parameters are normal. I change 3-4 gallons on a monthly basis. And this tank, exactly as I'm running it now, was previously very, very successful. I thought that perhaps the tank had been contaminated, but this seems unlikely - I've had fish in it through all of this (australian rainbows, ottos, and bolivian rams) and they've been healthier and more beautiful than ever. Any ideas for something I'm overlooking? -- Ross Vandegrift A Pope has a Water Cannon. It is a Water Cannon. He fires Holy-Water from it. It is a Holy-Water Cannon. He Blesses it. It is a Holy Holy-Water Cannon. He Blesses the Hell out of it. It is a Wholly Holy Holy-Water Cannon. He has it pierced. It is a Holey Wholly Holy Holy-Water Cannon. He makes it official. It is a Canon Holey Wholly Holy Holy-Water Cannon. Batman and Robin arrive. He shoots them. |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Plant problems
Ross Vandegrift wrote in message
m... Hello everyone, My 20Gal long tank, with 2wpg, had something happen to it a few months ago. My plants stopped growing well. I've been too busy with school to worry too much about, but I did the obvious things as the plants slowly died off - stopped dosing fertilizer so much and cut down the light. It was bad - all of a sudden all my Java Fern died. Sunset Hyugro won't grow in the tank now. Finally, I got sick of the algae and the bare tank, so I hit up the LFS and lucked out - just had a fresh shipment! Picked up some awesome looking camboba, red tiger lotus, giant hygro, and something I forget that looks like bacopa with smaller leaves. Planted em up, went back to some fertilizer dosing, made sure my DIY CO2 reactor was running, and turned the lights back up to 10 hours. This was last friday. Most of the new plants are dying already. The camboba seems to have rotted almost the instant I planted in the gravel. The bacopa-like plants' leaves are slowly turning brown and getting ready to fall off. The red tiger lotus is ok for now, but I suspect my 2wpg won't be enough for it ultimately. So, more or less, it was a total failure. I'm wondering what on earth could be wrong. My water parameters are normal. I change 3-4 gallons on a monthly basis. And this tank, exactly as I'm running it now, was previously very, very successful. I thought that perhaps the tank had been contaminated, but this seems unlikely - I've had fish in it through all of this (australian rainbows, ottos, and bolivian rams) and they've been healthier and more beautiful than ever. Any ideas for something I'm overlooking? How old are the lights? Flourescents should be changed every 6-12 months, CF every 18-or-so months. They may still be working - in other words, turning on - without providing sufficient spectrum for photosynthesis. |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Plant problems
Ross Vandegrift wrote in
m: Hello everyone, My 20Gal long tank, with 2wpg, had something happen to it a few months ago. My plants stopped growing well. IT sounds like you havea 20W bulb on there. Standard flourescent bulbs last 6-12 months before output drops significantly. This is the most obvious thing to check. but I did the obvious things as the plants slowly died off - stopped dosing fertilizer so much and cut down the light. Cutting down light is never a cure for anything, unless you have too much light. Even if your bulb were new, this is not your problem. Turn it back on 12 hours per day. The symptom of too much nutrients is algae. You do not have that symptom, so too much ferts is not the problem. I change 3-4 gallons on a monthly basis. And this tank, exactly as I'm running it now, was previously very, very successful. This is a classic case: Originally your tap water had sufficient nutrients for some plants, so they did well. Since you change so little water, you replaced very little, and eventually something ran out (probably Potassium, or if your tap water is soft, Calcium or Magnesium, although I don't know what you dose.) Replace your bulb, change 25% or more water per week, watch your plants jump to attention. I thought that perhaps the tank had been contaminated, but this seems unlikely Yes, very unlikely. |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Plant problems
On Wed, 19 Nov 2003 21:19:30 GMT, "Dunter Powries"
wrote: Ross Vandegrift wrote in message om... Hello everyone, My 20Gal long tank, with 2wpg, had something happen to it a few months ago. My plants stopped growing well. I've been too busy with school to worry too much about, but I did the obvious things as the plants slowly died off - stopped dosing fertilizer so much and cut down the light. It was bad - all of a sudden all my Java Fern died. Sunset Hyugro won't grow in the tank now. Finally, I got sick of the algae and the bare tank, so I hit up the LFS and lucked out - just had a fresh shipment! Picked up some awesome looking camboba, red tiger lotus, giant hygro, and something I forget that looks like bacopa with smaller leaves. Planted em up, went back to some fertilizer dosing, made sure my DIY CO2 reactor was running, and turned the lights back up to 10 hours. This was last friday. Most of the new plants are dying already. The camboba seems to have rotted almost the instant I planted in the gravel. The bacopa-like plants' leaves are slowly turning brown and getting ready to fall off. The red tiger lotus is ok for now, but I suspect my 2wpg won't be enough for it ultimately. So, more or less, it was a total failure. I'm wondering what on earth could be wrong. My water parameters are normal. I change 3-4 gallons on a monthly basis. And this tank, exactly as I'm running it now, was previously very, very successful. I thought that perhaps the tank had been contaminated, but this seems unlikely - I've had fish in it through all of this (australian rainbows, ottos, and bolivian rams) and they've been healthier and more beautiful than ever. Any ideas for something I'm overlooking? How old are the lights? Flourescents should be changed every 6-12 months, CF every 18-or-so months. They may still be working - in other words, turning on - without providing sufficient spectrum for photosynthesis. I have had plant problems in the beginning, last year December. My first tank, 75 gallons, would look nice with its new plants, but I would eventually lose them or I got black hair algae so bad, I just replaced the plants. That was then, now, 12 months later, I have 5 tanks ranging from 75 to 10 and my final solution, low light plants, and lots of them are doing fine. I have not changed my lights. I don't like the bright lights. I decided to buy low light plants (1.5-2 wpg) and rely on "survival of the fittest." All of my tanks are doing well, in fact one of the lessons I learned to defeat major algae problems, was to keep the hours of lighting down from 16 to 12 hours a day. Two of my larger tanks I can switch off part of the lights, so I reduce the watts when I see algae starting again. I see plant selection as the solution. Pick plants that like lower light. By the way, I change about 20 percent of my water weekly. I have dense fish populations and assume the nutrient levels are high so I feel I am diluting the nutrient levels. I am not an expert, just experienced with problems and learning as I go. I enjoy what others share and take those ideas into consideration. However, I am often surprised when something works for others that seems to be different from my sucesses. |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Plant problems
On 2003-11-20, Dave Millman wrote:
My 20Gal long tank, with 2wpg, had something happen to it a few months ago. My plants stopped growing well. IT sounds like you havea 20W bulb on there. Standard flourescent bulbs last 6-12 months before output drops significantly. This is the most obvious thing to check. It's a twin 20W flourescent bulb. Is this really the case? I've read it around the groups plenty of times, but I never really believed it. I'd put these bulbs at around two years old. I think I have some spares - I'll swap them in and see how things go. but I did the obvious things as the plants slowly died off - stopped dosing fertilizer so much and cut down the light. Cutting down light is never a cure for anything, unless you have too much light. Even if your bulb were new, this is not your problem. Turn it back on 12 hours per day. The symptom of too much nutrients is algae. You do not have that symptom, so too much ferts is not the problem. Well, I did when all my plants died and left the nutrients sitting in the tank ::-) I cut down the light mostly to reduce work on myself when I hadn't had a chance to replant everything. As soon as the new plants went into the tank, I cranked it back up to 12 hours a day. I change 3-4 gallons on a monthly basis. And this tank, exactly as I'm running it now, was previously very, very successful. This is a classic case: Originally your tap water had sufficient nutrients for some plants, so they did well. Since you change so little water, you replaced very little, and eventually something ran out (probably Potassium, or if your tap water is soft, Calcium or Magnesium, although I don't know what you dose.) I'll give it a shot, sounds pretty reasonable. My water is very high GH, medium-high kH. My fertilizer regimen: I dose Kent Freshwater Plant Supplement (Iron, Potash, Copper, Manganese, Molybdenum, Zinc) and Flourish Trace (some of the above plus, Boron, Cobalt, Rubidium, Tin, Vanadium). I don't put in as much as the bottle recommends since that's always tended to create algae problems - I dose Kent twice a week, Flourish once. Anyhow, thanks for the suggestions everyone! -- Ross Vandegrift A Pope has a Water Cannon. It is a Water Cannon. He fires Holy-Water from it. It is a Holy-Water Cannon. He Blesses it. It is a Holy Holy-Water Cannon. He Blesses the Hell out of it. It is a Wholly Holy Holy-Water Cannon. He has it pierced. It is a Holey Wholly Holy Holy-Water Cannon. He makes it official. It is a Canon Holey Wholly Holy Holy-Water Cannon. Batman and Robin arrive. He shoots them. |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Plant problems
On 2003-11-20, Dave Millman wrote:
My 20Gal long tank, with 2wpg, had something happen to it a few months ago. My plants stopped growing well. IT sounds like you havea 20W bulb on there. Standard flourescent bulbs last 6-12 months before output drops significantly. This is the most obvious thing to check. It's a twin 20W flourescent bulb. Is this really the case? I've read it around the groups plenty of times, but I never really believed it. I'd put these bulbs at around two years old. I think I have some spares - I'll swap them in and see how things go. but I did the obvious things as the plants slowly died off - stopped dosing fertilizer so much and cut down the light. Cutting down light is never a cure for anything, unless you have too much light. Even if your bulb were new, this is not your problem. Turn it back on 12 hours per day. The symptom of too much nutrients is algae. You do not have that symptom, so too much ferts is not the problem. Well, I did when all my plants died and left the nutrients sitting in the tank ::-) I cut down the light mostly to reduce work on myself when I hadn't had a chance to replant everything. As soon as the new plants went into the tank, I cranked it back up to 12 hours a day. I change 3-4 gallons on a monthly basis. And this tank, exactly as I'm running it now, was previously very, very successful. This is a classic case: Originally your tap water had sufficient nutrients for some plants, so they did well. Since you change so little water, you replaced very little, and eventually something ran out (probably Potassium, or if your tap water is soft, Calcium or Magnesium, although I don't know what you dose.) I'll give it a shot, sounds pretty reasonable. My water is very high GH, medium-high kH. My fertilizer regimen: I dose Kent Freshwater Plant Supplement (Iron, Potash, Copper, Manganese, Molybdenum, Zinc) and Flourish Trace (some of the above plus, Boron, Cobalt, Rubidium, Tin, Vanadium). I don't put in as much as the bottle recommends since that's always tended to create algae problems - I dose Kent twice a week, Flourish once. Anyhow, thanks for the suggestions everyone! -- Ross Vandegrift A Pope has a Water Cannon. It is a Water Cannon. He fires Holy-Water from it. It is a Holy-Water Cannon. He Blesses it. It is a Holy Holy-Water Cannon. He Blesses the Hell out of it. It is a Wholly Holy Holy-Water Cannon. He has it pierced. It is a Holey Wholly Holy Holy-Water Cannon. He makes it official. It is a Canon Holey Wholly Holy Holy-Water Cannon. Batman and Robin arrive. He shoots them. |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Plant problems
On 2003-11-20, Dave Millman wrote:
My 20Gal long tank, with 2wpg, had something happen to it a few months ago. My plants stopped growing well. IT sounds like you havea 20W bulb on there. Standard flourescent bulbs last 6-12 months before output drops significantly. This is the most obvious thing to check. It's a twin 20W flourescent bulb. Is this really the case? I've read it around the groups plenty of times, but I never really believed it. I'd put these bulbs at around two years old. I think I have some spares - I'll swap them in and see how things go. but I did the obvious things as the plants slowly died off - stopped dosing fertilizer so much and cut down the light. Cutting down light is never a cure for anything, unless you have too much light. Even if your bulb were new, this is not your problem. Turn it back on 12 hours per day. The symptom of too much nutrients is algae. You do not have that symptom, so too much ferts is not the problem. Well, I did when all my plants died and left the nutrients sitting in the tank ::-) I cut down the light mostly to reduce work on myself when I hadn't had a chance to replant everything. As soon as the new plants went into the tank, I cranked it back up to 12 hours a day. I change 3-4 gallons on a monthly basis. And this tank, exactly as I'm running it now, was previously very, very successful. This is a classic case: Originally your tap water had sufficient nutrients for some plants, so they did well. Since you change so little water, you replaced very little, and eventually something ran out (probably Potassium, or if your tap water is soft, Calcium or Magnesium, although I don't know what you dose.) I'll give it a shot, sounds pretty reasonable. My water is very high GH, medium-high kH. My fertilizer regimen: I dose Kent Freshwater Plant Supplement (Iron, Potash, Copper, Manganese, Molybdenum, Zinc) and Flourish Trace (some of the above plus, Boron, Cobalt, Rubidium, Tin, Vanadium). I don't put in as much as the bottle recommends since that's always tended to create algae problems - I dose Kent twice a week, Flourish once. Anyhow, thanks for the suggestions everyone! -- Ross Vandegrift A Pope has a Water Cannon. It is a Water Cannon. He fires Holy-Water from it. It is a Holy-Water Cannon. He Blesses it. It is a Holy Holy-Water Cannon. He Blesses the Hell out of it. It is a Wholly Holy Holy-Water Cannon. He has it pierced. It is a Holey Wholly Holy Holy-Water Cannon. He makes it official. It is a Canon Holey Wholly Holy Holy-Water Cannon. Batman and Robin arrive. He shoots them. |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Plant problems
Ross Vandegrift wrote in message
m... On 2003-11-20, Dave Millman wrote: My 20Gal long tank, with 2wpg, had something happen to it a few months ago. My plants stopped growing well. IT sounds like you havea 20W bulb on there. Standard flourescent bulbs last 6-12 months before output drops significantly. This is the most obvious thing to check. It's a twin 20W flourescent bulb. Is this really the case? I've read it around the groups plenty of times, but I never really believed it. I'd put these bulbs at around two years old. I think I have some spares - I'll swap them in and see how things go. Two 20w bulbs over a 20g *long* should count as better than 2wpg because of the shallowness of the tank. Interestingly (IMO, anyway), of all the big and small tanks I've had, my 20g long is the only one I've had persistent problems with, both with the twin 20w's and a single cf over it. I've lost track of how many times over the years I've broken it down and started over. Just coincidence, I'm sure. |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Plant problems
On 2003-11-20, Dunter Powries wrote:
Interestingly (IMO, anyway), of all the big and small tanks I've had, my 20g long is the only one I've had persistent problems with, both with the twin 20w's and a single cf over it. I've lost track of how many times over the years I've broken it down and started over. Just coincidence, I'm sure. Thanks for the encouragement ::-) -- Ross Vandegrift A Pope has a Water Cannon. It is a Water Cannon. He fires Holy-Water from it. It is a Holy-Water Cannon. He Blesses it. It is a Holy Holy-Water Cannon. He Blesses the Hell out of it. It is a Wholly Holy Holy-Water Cannon. He has it pierced. It is a Holey Wholly Holy Holy-Water Cannon. He makes it official. It is a Canon Holey Wholly Holy Holy-Water Cannon. Batman and Robin arrive. He shoots them. |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Plant problems / recommendations | Freshwater Aquaria Plants | |||
Problems retransplanting a split tropical plant | United Kingdom | |||
Mosquito Magnet Pro problems - anyone else having problems? | Gardening | |||
Tank--plant, goldfish problems | Freshwater Aquaria Plants | |||
Avocado Plant problems | Texas |