GardenBanter.co.uk

GardenBanter.co.uk (https://www.gardenbanter.co.uk/)
-   Gardening (https://www.gardenbanter.co.uk/gardening/)
-   -   will Round Up kill dormant southern grasses (https://www.gardenbanter.co.uk/gardening/109693-will-round-up-kill-dormant-southern-grasses.html)

James Bond 08-12-2005 03:23 PM

will Round Up kill dormant southern grasses
 
Hello, I am wondering if Round Up or other similar non selective herbicides
will kill St. Augustine and/or Centipede grasses when they are in dormance
during the winter. To extend the question, how do these herbicides work
exactly? If they are only absoarbed via the leaves, then it seems that
maybe the dormant grass leaves would not absoarb the herbicide. Any
insight into this is appreciated. Thank you.

JB

Wolf Kirchmeir 08-12-2005 03:50 PM

will Round Up kill dormant southern grasses
 
James Bond wrote:
Hello, I am wondering if Round Up or other similar non selective herbicides
will kill St. Augustine and/or Centipede grasses when they are in dormance
during the winter. To extend the question, how do these herbicides work
exactly? If they are only absoarbed via the leaves, then it seems that
maybe the dormant grass leaves would not absoarb the herbicide. Any
insight into this is appreciated. Thank you.

JB


Roundup type herbicides are actually variations on the natural growth
hormones, and work by tricking the plants into overextending themselves.
AFAIK, they are taken up through roots as well as leaves. Being
hormones, they don't last long when the plants die, which is the reason
you can replant or reseed with no ill effects about two weeks after the
weeds have died.

So the question is whether a dormant plant will take up the hormone,
start to grow and die. I suspect not, but that's not a good enough
answer for you. I'm sure another poster will tell you what you want to know.

Vox Humana 08-12-2005 04:22 PM

will Round Up kill dormant southern grasses
 

"James Bond" wrote in message
...
Hello, I am wondering if Round Up or other similar non selective

herbicides
will kill St. Augustine and/or Centipede grasses when they are in dormance
during the winter. To extend the question, how do these herbicides work
exactly? If they are only absoarbed via the leaves, then it seems that
maybe the dormant grass leaves would not absoarb the herbicide. Any
insight into this is appreciated. Thank you.


Doesn't the label say to apply to growing foliage?



Stephen Henning 08-12-2005 05:56 PM

will Round Up kill dormant southern grasses
 
Wolf Kirchmeir wrote:

Roundup type herbicides are actually variations on the natural growth
hormones, and work by tricking the plants into overextending themselves.
AFAIK, they are taken up through roots as well as leaves. Being
hormones, they don't last long when the plants die, which is the reason
you can replant or reseed with no ill effects about two weeks after the
weeds have died.


No, you are confusing glyphosate (Roundup) with 2,4-D (weed killer) and
2,4,5-T (brush killer)

2,4-D is a growth hormone that stimulates the plant to grow so much it
kills the plant. It works best on broad leafed herbaceous material
except won't work on grasses. That is the reason it is commonly sold as
"weed killer" for lawns.

2,4,5-T is also a growth hormone but is much stronger than 2,4-D. It
kills perennial woody materials but not grasses. That is the reason it
is commonly called "brush killer". Unfortunately, dioxin is a common
impurity in cheaper grades of 2,4,5-T.

glyphosate (Roundup) only enters through green tissue (leaves and green
stems) and must be transported by the plant to the roots where it kills
the roots. It is best applied on mature green plants that are
transporting sugars to the roots. It will not affect very young plants
or plants that are dormant. It gets neutralized up by the clays in
soils and will not affect roots directly. It is broad spectrum and will
kill most any plant. It works equally well on all herbaceous materials,
grasses and woody perennials.

--
Pardon my spam deterrent; send email to
Cheers, Steve Henning in Reading, PA USA
http://home.earthlink.net/~rhodyman

Dwayne 08-12-2005 06:16 PM

will Round Up kill dormant southern grasses
 
When we lived in Arkansas, the Gardner came on TV and answered questions.
His response for crab grass removal, was to go out in the early spring and
look at the yard. As soon as you started seeing grass getting green again,
spray it with round up. He said that the crab grass was the first to green
up and as long as you sprayed it early, you wouldn't bother your other grass
that you want to leave.

Dwayne


"James Bond" wrote in message
...
Hello, I am wondering if Round Up or other similar non selective
herbicides
will kill St. Augustine and/or Centipede grasses when they are in dormance
during the winter. To extend the question, how do these herbicides work
exactly? If they are only absoarbed via the leaves, then it seems that
maybe the dormant grass leaves would not absoarb the herbicide. Any
insight into this is appreciated. Thank you.

JB




Wolf Kirchmeir 08-12-2005 08:52 PM

will Round Up kill dormant southern grasses
 
Stephen Henning wrote:
Wolf Kirchmeir wrote:


Roundup type herbicides are actually variations on the natural growth
hormones, and work by tricking the plants into overextending themselves.
AFAIK, they are taken up through roots as well as leaves. Being
hormones, they don't last long when the plants die, which is the reason
you can replant or reseed with no ill effects about two weeks after the
weeds have died.



No, you are confusing glyphosate (Roundup) with 2,4-D (weed killer) and
2,4,5-T (brush killer)

2,4-D is a growth hormone that stimulates the plant to grow so much it
kills the plant. It works best on broad leafed herbaceous material
except won't work on grasses. That is the reason it is commonly sold as
"weed killer" for lawns.

2,4,5-T is also a growth hormone but is much stronger than 2,4-D. It
kills perennial woody materials but not grasses. That is the reason it
is commonly called "brush killer". Unfortunately, dioxin is a common
impurity in cheaper grades of 2,4,5-T.

glyphosate (Roundup) only enters through green tissue (leaves and green
stems) and must be transported by the plant to the roots where it kills
the roots. It is best applied on mature green plants that are
transporting sugars to the roots. It will not affect very young plants
or plants that are dormant. It gets neutralized up by the clays in
soils and will not affect roots directly. It is broad spectrum and will
kill most any plant. It works equally well on all herbaceous materials,
grasses and woody perennials.



thanks for the info.


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 04:21 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
GardenBanter