GardenBanter.co.uk

GardenBanter.co.uk (https://www.gardenbanter.co.uk/)
-   Gardening (https://www.gardenbanter.co.uk/gardening/)
-   -   daffodill bulbs (https://www.gardenbanter.co.uk/gardening/173287-daffodill-bulbs.html)

[email protected] 21-04-2008 12:09 AM

daffodill bulbs
 
I'm no gardener but have had the unfortunate task of tending my
father's grave. I planted some daff bulbs last autumn and had a
beautiful display but the flowers are now dying off. I shall soon be
re-planting with summer plants. Should I save the daff bulbs for next
year, or shoud they be discarded and buy new ones again in the autumn?

David E. Ross 21-04-2008 01:32 AM

daffodill bulbs
 
On 4/20/2008 4:45 PM, Charlie wrote:
On Sun, 20 Apr 2008 16:09:09 -0700 (PDT),
wrote:

I'm no gardener but have had the unfortunate task of tending my
father's grave. I planted some daff bulbs last autumn and had a
beautiful display but the flowers are now dying off. I shall soon be
re-planting with summer plants. Should I save the daff bulbs for next
year, or shoud they be discarded and buy new ones again in the autumn?


Just leave 'em be. They will be back, year after year.

I'm sorry for your loss, whenever it was.

Care
Charlie


Daffodills are quite hardy. They will survive most winters, even with
snow and freezing weather. Just plant summer annuals over them without
digging them up.

The one problem you might have is if the cemetary maintenance crew mows
over your father's grave. Cutting the daffodill foliage before it turns
yellow and dies will weaken the bulbs. If this happens, you might as
well dig up the bulbs and trash them.

--
David E. Ross
Climate: California Mediterranean
Sunset Zone: 21 -- interior Santa Monica Mountains with some ocean
influence (USDA 10a, very close to Sunset Zone 19)
Gardening pages at http://www.rossde.com/garden/

Pete C[_2_] 21-04-2008 03:21 AM

daffodill bulbs
 
David E. Ross wrote:
On 4/20/2008 4:45 PM, Charlie wrote:
On Sun, 20 Apr 2008 16:09:09 -0700 (PDT),
wrote:

I'm no gardener but have had the unfortunate task of tending my
father's grave. I planted some daff bulbs last autumn and had a
beautiful display but the flowers are now dying off. I shall soon be
re-planting with summer plants. Should I save the daff bulbs for
next year, or shoud they be discarded and buy new ones again in the
autumn?


Just leave 'em be. They will be back, year after year.

I'm sorry for your loss, whenever it was.

Care
Charlie


Daffodills are quite hardy. They will survive most winters, even with
snow and freezing weather. Just plant summer annuals over them
without digging them up.

The one problem you might have is if the cemetary maintenance crew
mows over your father's grave. Cutting the daffodill foliage before
it turns yellow and dies will weaken the bulbs. If this happens, you
might as well dig up the bulbs and trash them.


I thought you could dig them up, with tops, store in a paper bag in the dark
until tops die off, and replant next year? Or am I getting confused? :)
--
Pete C
London UK



Bob Hobden 21-04-2008 10:13 AM

daffodill bulbs
 

Grouchy.Oldgit wrote
I'm no gardener but have had the unfortunate task of tending my
father's grave. I planted some daff bulbs last autumn and had a
beautiful display but the flowers are now dying off. I shall soon be
re-planting with summer plants. Should I save the daff bulbs for next
year, or shoud they be discarded and buy new ones again in the autumn?


I planted some on my Mums grave near the S. coast years ago and they come up
year on year, I also planted some "Glory of the Snow" and after the first
clump got stolen they grew well but the over enthusiastic early strimming of
the grave by the workmen saw to them. They could see and miss the Daff
leaves but not those of the little bulbs.
No point in planting summer stuff due to the strimming.
--
Regards
Bob Hobden




The Old OakTree 21-04-2008 10:56 AM

daffodill bulbs
 
I'm no gardener but have had the unfortunate task of tending
my
father's grave. I planted some daff bulbs last autumn and had
a
beautiful display but the flowers are now dying off. I shall
soon be
re-planting with summer plants. Should I save the daff bulbs
for next
year, or shoud they be discarded and buy new ones again in
the autumn?


If you don't dig them up, make sure to cut off the flower heads
once they start to wither. This encourages them to put their
strength into the bulb. If you leave the flowers they put their
strength into setting seed.



John McGaw 21-04-2008 03:37 PM

daffodill bulbs
 
Pete C wrote:
David E. Ross wrote:
On 4/20/2008 4:45 PM, Charlie wrote:
On Sun, 20 Apr 2008 16:09:09 -0700 (PDT),
wrote:

I'm no gardener but have had the unfortunate task of tending my
father's grave. I planted some daff bulbs last autumn and had a
beautiful display but the flowers are now dying off. I shall soon be
re-planting with summer plants. Should I save the daff bulbs for
next year, or shoud they be discarded and buy new ones again in the
autumn?
Just leave 'em be. They will be back, year after year.

I'm sorry for your loss, whenever it was.

Care
Charlie

Daffodills are quite hardy. They will survive most winters, even with
snow and freezing weather. Just plant summer annuals over them
without digging them up.

The one problem you might have is if the cemetary maintenance crew
mows over your father's grave. Cutting the daffodill foliage before
it turns yellow and dies will weaken the bulbs. If this happens, you
might as well dig up the bulbs and trash them.


I thought you could dig them up, with tops, store in a paper bag in the dark
until tops die off, and replant next year? Or am I getting confused? :)


Probably you are confused. It is necessary for the plants to remain in a
normal growing state with roots and foliage intact so that they can support
bulb growth which is what makes the new plants and flowers the next Spring.
As soon as the plant has finished this process the foliage dies back and
all that remains is the bulb (or bulbs) under the ground. Typically one can
plant annuals around the remaining daffodil foliage to make it less obvious
but even if the bulb is to be dug and re-planted in the Autumn it is
necessary for the plant to go through its "recharging" routine to produce
healthy bulbs. I normally clip the spent flower stem right after the flower
fades to make the plants look less ragged but I would never remove any
undiseased leaves.

--
John McGaw
[Knoxville, TN, USA]
http://johnmcgaw.com

Pete C[_2_] 21-04-2008 03:43 PM

daffodill bulbs
 
John McGaw wrote:
Pete C wrote:
David E. Ross wrote:
On 4/20/2008 4:45 PM, Charlie wrote:
On Sun, 20 Apr 2008 16:09:09 -0700 (PDT),
wrote:

I'm no gardener but have had the unfortunate task of tending my
father's grave. I planted some daff bulbs last autumn and had a
beautiful display but the flowers are now dying off. I shall soon
be re-planting with summer plants. Should I save the daff bulbs
for next year, or shoud they be discarded and buy new ones again
in the autumn?
Just leave 'em be. They will be back, year after year.

I'm sorry for your loss, whenever it was.

Care
Charlie
Daffodills are quite hardy. They will survive most winters, even
with snow and freezing weather. Just plant summer annuals over them
without digging them up.

The one problem you might have is if the cemetary maintenance crew
mows over your father's grave. Cutting the daffodill foliage before
it turns yellow and dies will weaken the bulbs. If this happens,
you might as well dig up the bulbs and trash them.


I thought you could dig them up, with tops, store in a paper bag in
the dark until tops die off, and replant next year? Or am I getting
confused? :)


Probably you are confused. It is necessary for the plants to remain
in a normal growing state with roots and foliage intact so that they
can support bulb growth which is what makes the new plants and
flowers the next Spring. As soon as the plant has finished this
process the foliage dies back and all that remains is the bulb (or
bulbs) under the ground. Typically one can plant annuals around the
remaining daffodil foliage to make it less obvious but even if the
bulb is to be dug and re-planted in the Autumn it is necessary for
the plant to go through its "recharging" routine to produce healthy
bulbs. I normally clip the spent flower stem right after the flower
fades to make the plants look less ragged but I would never remove
any undiseased leaves.


Thank you John :)
--
Pete C
London UK



Sacha[_3_] 21-04-2008 10:48 PM

daffodill bulbs
 
On 21/4/08 00:09, in article
,
" wrote:

I'm no gardener but have had the unfortunate task of tending my
father's grave. I planted some daff bulbs last autumn and had a
beautiful display but the flowers are now dying off. I shall soon be
re-planting with summer plants. Should I save the daff bulbs for next
year, or shoud they be discarded and buy new ones again in the autumn?



Providing nobody mows over the grave and cuts off the leaves, let the bulbs
remain in place. You can remove the faded flowers but whatever you do,
leave the leaves in place as these will nourish the bulb for next year's
flowering. Daffodils flower again and again every year and they increase
naturally, creating offsets little bulbs that eventually turn into big grown
up bulbs that produce more flowers. Think Wordsworth. There are summer
bedding plants you can use, of course but there are also some summer
flowering bulbs which can also remain in place.

--
Sacha
http://www.hillhousenursery.co.uk
South Devon
'We do not inherit the earth from our ancestors, we borrow it from our
children.'



Sheldon[_1_] 21-04-2008 10:51 PM

daffodill bulbs
 
On Apr 20, 7:09�pm, wrote:
I'm no gardener but have had the unfortunate task of tending my
father's grave. I planted some daff bulbs last autumn and had a
beautiful display but the flowers are now dying off. I shall soon be
re-planting with summer plants. Should I save the daff bulbs for next
year, or shoud they be discarded and buy new ones again in the autumn?


Daffodils are very hardy and resiliant... unless you're going to enter
a daff contest for best of show there's no need to do anything and
they will continue to thrive and produce more and more year after
year... even if you mow them before the flowers fade once established
they will do just fine. You need to concern yourself more with
critters ravaging daffs, deer and rabbits won't eat them but squirrels
and chipmonks love them... still most will live on.


Eggs Zachtly 21-04-2008 11:07 PM

daffodill bulbs
 
John McGaw said:

Pete C wrote:
David E. Ross wrote:
On 4/20/2008 4:45 PM, Charlie wrote:
On Sun, 20 Apr 2008 16:09:09 -0700 (PDT),
wrote:

I'm no gardener but have had the unfortunate task of tending my
father's grave. I planted some daff bulbs last autumn and had a
beautiful display but the flowers are now dying off. I shall soon be
re-planting with summer plants. Should I save the daff bulbs for
next year, or shoud they be discarded and buy new ones again in the
autumn?
Just leave 'em be. They will be back, year after year.

I'm sorry for your loss, whenever it was.

Care
Charlie
Daffodills are quite hardy. They will survive most winters, even with
snow and freezing weather. Just plant summer annuals over them
without digging them up.

The one problem you might have is if the cemetary maintenance crew
mows over your father's grave. Cutting the daffodill foliage before
it turns yellow and dies will weaken the bulbs. If this happens, you
might as well dig up the bulbs and trash them.


I thought you could dig them up, with tops, store in a paper bag in the dark
until tops die off, and replant next year? Or am I getting confused? :)


Probably you are confused.


No, that would be you. =) They will do fine, and even thrive, when done as
Pete C questioned. We dug up thousands last spring, after they finished
blooming. Laid them all out under an overhang to finish yellowing/drying,
cut the foilage off, and stored them in bulb crates under a bench at work.
I brought home several hundred last fall, and /every one/ of them is still
in full bloom (3 weeks now). The rest, re-planted at work, are also
thriving.

It is necessary for the plants to remain in a
normal growing state with roots and foliage intact so that they can support
bulb growth which is what makes the new plants and flowers the next Spring.



The roots, at that time, are playing a very minor role. The food is all
being sent back down to the bulb for storage. It's being made in the
leaves, not the roots.

As soon as the plant has finished this process the foliage dies back and
all that remains is the bulb (or bulbs) under the ground. Typically one can
plant annuals around the remaining daffodil foliage to make it less obvious
but even if the bulb is to be dug and re-planted in the Autumn it is
necessary for the plant to go through its "recharging" routine to produce
healthy bulbs. I normally clip the spent flower stem right after the flower
fades to make the plants look less ragged but I would never remove any
undiseased leaves.


And, they wouldn't be removed if dug up, intact. They'll still produce
food, and you don't have the ragged, yellowed foilage in the bed.

Yup, you can plant around them. You can also dig them up, just fine.

--

Eggs

Most books now say our sun is a star. But it still knows how to change back
into a sun in the daytime.

David E. Ross 22-04-2008 01:39 AM

daffodill bulbs
 
On 4/21/2008 3:07 PM, Eggs Zachtly wrote:
John McGaw said:

Pete C wrote:
David E. Ross wrote:
On 4/20/2008 4:45 PM, Charlie wrote:
On Sun, 20 Apr 2008 16:09:09 -0700 (PDT),
wrote:

I'm no gardener but have had the unfortunate task of tending my
father's grave. I planted some daff bulbs last autumn and had a
beautiful display but the flowers are now dying off. I shall soon be
re-planting with summer plants. Should I save the daff bulbs for
next year, or shoud they be discarded and buy new ones again in the
autumn?
Just leave 'em be. They will be back, year after year.

I'm sorry for your loss, whenever it was.

Care
Charlie
Daffodills are quite hardy. They will survive most winters, even with
snow and freezing weather. Just plant summer annuals over them
without digging them up.

The one problem you might have is if the cemetary maintenance crew
mows over your father's grave. Cutting the daffodill foliage before
it turns yellow and dies will weaken the bulbs. If this happens, you
might as well dig up the bulbs and trash them.
I thought you could dig them up, with tops, store in a paper bag in the dark
until tops die off, and replant next year? Or am I getting confused? :)

Probably you are confused.


No, that would be you. =) They will do fine, and even thrive, when done as
Pete C questioned. We dug up thousands last spring, after they finished
blooming. Laid them all out under an overhang to finish yellowing/drying,
cut the foilage off, and stored them in bulb crates under a bench at work.
I brought home several hundred last fall, and /every one/ of them is still
in full bloom (3 weeks now). The rest, re-planted at work, are also
thriving.

It is necessary for the plants to remain in a
normal growing state with roots and foliage intact so that they can support
bulb growth which is what makes the new plants and flowers the next Spring.



The roots, at that time, are playing a very minor role. The food is all
being sent back down to the bulb for storage. It's being made in the
leaves, not the roots.

As soon as the plant has finished this process the foliage dies back and
all that remains is the bulb (or bulbs) under the ground. Typically one can
plant annuals around the remaining daffodil foliage to make it less obvious
but even if the bulb is to be dug and re-planted in the Autumn it is
necessary for the plant to go through its "recharging" routine to produce
healthy bulbs. I normally clip the spent flower stem right after the flower
fades to make the plants look less ragged but I would never remove any
undiseased leaves.


And, they wouldn't be removed if dug up, intact. They'll still produce
food, and you don't have the ragged, yellowed foilage in the bed.

Yup, you can plant around them. You can also dig them up, just fine.


Perhaps in England (where the original poster apparently lives), roots
might not be important in allowing nutrients to migrate into the bulb.

In my climate, the relative humidity tends to be much lower (21% at
noon). Without roots supplying moisture, the leaves would prematurely
wilt and shrivel before they could complete their task. Also, leaving
the bulbs in the ground through the summer keeps them cool; summer
temperatures here often exceed 90F and even 100F.

--
David E. Ross
Climate: California Mediterranean
Sunset Zone: 21 -- interior Santa Monica Mountains with some ocean
influence (USDA 10a, very close to Sunset Zone 19)
Gardening pages at http://www.rossde.com/garden/

John McGaw 22-04-2008 10:06 PM

daffodill bulbs
 
Eggs Zachtly wrote:
snip...
The roots, at that time, are playing a very minor role. The food is all
being sent back down to the bulb for storage. It's being made in the
leaves, not the roots.

snip...

Guess we'll just have to disagree. It is amazing that you would claim that
the plant's roots are "minor" given that this is the only way they absorb
water and nutrients. Sure, photosynthesis is happening in the leaves but
without water and soil nutrients nothing useful is going to be happening
since it doesn't operate on atmospheric C02 alone. I will remain with the
position that for best results the plants should stay exactly where they
are until the foliage dies back. It is a minor drawback since daffodils
don't hold onto their foliage all that long and can be easily screened from
view.

Granted, the plants are amazingly tough and might well survive the
treatment you describe but if it was the way to produce best-quality bulbs
I'd expect the big growers to be doing it that way to save time. The Dutch
growers would be able to put their new crop in the warehouses in April and
spend the rest of the year sunning themselves in Majorca.


--
John McGaw
[Knoxville, TN, USA]
http://johnmcgaw.com

Eggs Zachtly 22-04-2008 11:44 PM

daffodill bulbs
 
John McGaw said:

Eggs Zachtly wrote:
snip...
The roots, at that time, are playing a very minor role. The food is all
being sent back down to the bulb for storage. It's being made in the
leaves, not the roots.

snip...

Guess we'll just have to disagree.


No problem. I leave my bulbs at home in the ground, year round, cutting
yellowing foilage as it appears. A bit time-consuming (there are seveal
thousand bulbs), but the beds stay looking fairly fresh. My point was, it
*is* fine to dig the bulbs up, lay them in a cool place to finish, and then
remove the foilage. Planted that fall, they'll produce fine the following
spring.

It is amazing that you would claim that
the plant's roots are "minor" given that this is the only way they absorb
water and nutrients. Sure, photosynthesis is happening in the leaves but
without water and soil nutrients nothing useful is going to be happening
since it doesn't operate on atmospheric C02 alone.


When bulb foilage begins to yellow, the roots are /not/ taking in water. If
they're not taking in water, they're also *not* taking up nutrients. When
the bulb finishes flowering, the roots are done, and begin to die off, same
as the foilage. All food production is taking place above ground, and that
food is being sent to the bulb for dormancy survival, and the following
season's growth.


I will remain with the
position that for best results the plants should stay exactly where they
are until the foliage dies back. It is a minor drawback since daffodils
don't hold onto their foliage all that long and can be easily screened from
view.


Again, there's nothing wrong with that method. Pete C's question was of
digging them up (fine), storing them "in a paper bag in the dark until tops
die off" (BAD idea). Lose the paper bag, and it will work, with no
ill-effects.


Granted, the plants are amazingly tough and might well survive the
treatment you describe but if it was the way to produce best-quality bulbs
I'd expect the big growers to be doing it that way to save time. The Dutch
growers would be able to put their new crop in the warehouses in April and
spend the rest of the year sunning themselves in Majorca.


Having never visited a "big grower", much less one in Holland, I can't
comment on their production methods. Were you to ask one of them about the
inner-workings of a bulb, and just what happens during it's life-cycle, I
bet they'd tell you the same thing I stated above. ;)
--

Eggs

Do Amish people get one phone call when arrested?

Bill[_13_] 23-04-2008 12:00 AM

daffodill bulbs
 
In article ,
Eggs Zachtly wrote:

John McGaw said:

Eggs Zachtly wrote:
snip...
The roots, at that time, are playing a very minor role. The food is all
being sent back down to the bulb for storage. It's being made in the
leaves, not the roots.

snip...

Guess we'll just have to disagree.


No problem. I leave my bulbs at home in the ground, year round, cutting
yellowing foilage as it appears. A bit time-consuming (there are seveal
thousand bulbs), but the beds stay looking fairly fresh. My point was, it
*is* fine to dig the bulbs up, lay them in a cool place to finish, and then
remove the foilage. Planted that fall, they'll produce fine the following
spring.

It is amazing that you would claim that
the plant's roots are "minor" given that this is the only way they absorb
water and nutrients. Sure, photosynthesis is happening in the leaves but
without water and soil nutrients nothing useful is going to be happening
since it doesn't operate on atmospheric C02 alone.


When bulb foilage begins to yellow, the roots are /not/ taking in water. If
they're not taking in water, they're also *not* taking up nutrients. When
the bulb finishes flowering, the roots are done, and begin to die off, same
as the foilage. All food production is taking place above ground, and that
food is being sent to the bulb for dormancy survival, and the following
season's growth.


I will remain with the
position that for best results the plants should stay exactly where they
are until the foliage dies back. It is a minor drawback since daffodils
don't hold onto their foliage all that long and can be easily screened from
view.


Again, there's nothing wrong with that method. Pete C's question was of
digging them up (fine), storing them "in a paper bag in the dark until tops
die off" (BAD idea). Lose the paper bag, and it will work, with no
ill-effects.


Granted, the plants are amazingly tough and might well survive the
treatment you describe but if it was the way to produce best-quality bulbs
I'd expect the big growers to be doing it that way to save time. The Dutch
growers would be able to put their new crop in the warehouses in April and
spend the rest of the year sunning themselves in Majorca.


Having never visited a "big grower", much less one in Holland, I can't
comment on their production methods. Were you to ask one of them about the
inner-workings of a bulb, and just what happens during it's life-cycle, I
bet they'd tell you the same thing I stated above. ;)


Guess you guys know daffodils are toxic, Some bulbs mixed with young
onions would not be easy to discern not good. Sort of a text for
murder she wrote.

Standard Major Disclaimer.

So Charlie and Billy when shall we party?

Bill

--
Garden in shade zone 5 S Jersey USA

Billy[_4_] 23-04-2008 01:22 AM

daffodill bulbs
 
In article
,
Bill wrote:

In article ,
Eggs Zachtly wrote:

John McGaw said:

Eggs Zachtly wrote:
snip...
The roots, at that time, are playing a very minor role. The food is all
being sent back down to the bulb for storage. It's being made in the
leaves, not the roots.
snip...

Guess we'll just have to disagree.


No problem. I leave my bulbs at home in the ground, year round, cutting
yellowing foilage as it appears. A bit time-consuming (there are seveal
thousand bulbs), but the beds stay looking fairly fresh. My point was, it
*is* fine to dig the bulbs up, lay them in a cool place to finish, and then
remove the foilage. Planted that fall, they'll produce fine the following
spring.

It is amazing that you would claim that
the plant's roots are "minor" given that this is the only way they absorb
water and nutrients. Sure, photosynthesis is happening in the leaves but
without water and soil nutrients nothing useful is going to be happening
since it doesn't operate on atmospheric C02 alone.


When bulb foilage begins to yellow, the roots are /not/ taking in water. If
they're not taking in water, they're also *not* taking up nutrients. When
the bulb finishes flowering, the roots are done, and begin to die off, same
as the foilage. All food production is taking place above ground, and that
food is being sent to the bulb for dormancy survival, and the following
season's growth.


I will remain with the
position that for best results the plants should stay exactly where they
are until the foliage dies back. It is a minor drawback since daffodils
don't hold onto their foliage all that long and can be easily screened
from
view.


Again, there's nothing wrong with that method. Pete C's question was of
digging them up (fine), storing them "in a paper bag in the dark until tops
die off" (BAD idea). Lose the paper bag, and it will work, with no
ill-effects.


Granted, the plants are amazingly tough and might well survive the
treatment you describe but if it was the way to produce best-quality
bulbs
I'd expect the big growers to be doing it that way to save time. The
Dutch
growers would be able to put their new crop in the warehouses in April
and
spend the rest of the year sunning themselves in Majorca.


Having never visited a "big grower", much less one in Holland, I can't
comment on their production methods. Were you to ask one of them about the
inner-workings of a bulb, and just what happens during it's life-cycle, I
bet they'd tell you the same thing I stated above. ;)


Guess you guys know daffodils are toxic, Some bulbs mixed with young
onions would not be easy to discern not good. Sort of a text for
murder she wrote.

Standard Major Disclaimer.

So Charlie and Billy when shall we party?

Bill


You're not bring the onion dip are ya? Other than that, just let me get
the cork out'en the bottle.
--

Billy

http://au.youtube.com/watch?v=7WBB0s...eature=related

David E. Ross 23-04-2008 03:23 AM

daffodil bulbs
 
On 4/22/2008 3:44 PM, Eggs Zachtly wrote:
John McGaw said:

Eggs Zachtly wrote:
snip...
The roots, at that time, are playing a very minor role. The food is all
being sent back down to the bulb for storage. It's being made in the
leaves, not the roots.

snip...

Guess we'll just have to disagree.


No problem. I leave my bulbs at home in the ground, year round, cutting
yellowing foilage as it appears. A bit time-consuming (there are seveal
thousand bulbs), but the beds stay looking fairly fresh. My point was, it
*is* fine to dig the bulbs up, lay them in a cool place to finish, and then
remove the foilage. Planted that fall, they'll produce fine the following
spring.

It is amazing that you would claim that
the plant's roots are "minor" given that this is the only way they absorb
water and nutrients. Sure, photosynthesis is happening in the leaves but
without water and soil nutrients nothing useful is going to be happening
since it doesn't operate on atmospheric C02 alone.


When bulb foilage begins to yellow, the roots are /not/ taking in water. If
they're not taking in water, they're also *not* taking up nutrients. When
the bulb finishes flowering, the roots are done, and begin to die off, same
as the foilage. All food production is taking place above ground, and that
food is being sent to the bulb for dormancy survival, and the following
season's growth.


I will remain with the
position that for best results the plants should stay exactly where they
are until the foliage dies back. It is a minor drawback since daffodils
don't hold onto their foliage all that long and can be easily screened from
view.


Again, there's nothing wrong with that method. Pete C's question was of
digging them up (fine), storing them "in a paper bag in the dark until tops
die off" (BAD idea). Lose the paper bag, and it will work, with no
ill-effects.

Granted, the plants are amazingly tough and might well survive the
treatment you describe but if it was the way to produce best-quality bulbs
I'd expect the big growers to be doing it that way to save time. The Dutch
growers would be able to put their new crop in the warehouses in April and
spend the rest of the year sunning themselves in Majorca.


Having never visited a "big grower", much less one in Holland, I can't
comment on their production methods. Were you to ask one of them about the
inner-workings of a bulb, and just what happens during it's life-cycle, I
bet they'd tell you the same thing I stated above. ;)


In my garden, the narcissus foliage (both daffodils and their relatives)
remains green and vigorous for well more than a month after the flowers
have withered and faded. The leaves are still working, manufacturing
nutrients to rebuild the bulb. For this, they still need moisture as
well as nitrogen, phosphorus, potassium, and other plant nutrients from
the soil -- through the roots.

Only after the leaves start to yellow are the roots no longer important.
Digging the bulbs before then might leave bulbs that flower the next
year. But repeating this again in that next year might prevent the
bulbs from flowering a third year.

Sometimes, I do dig and divide the bulbs in my garden. I do this when
the foliage is not yellow but brown and dried. I immediately (same day)
replant the bulbs that I'm keeping. I have no interruption of blooming
with this practice.

--
David E. Ross
Climate: California Mediterranean
Sunset Zone: 21 -- interior Santa Monica Mountains with some ocean
influence (USDA 10a, very close to Sunset Zone 19)
Gardening pages at http://www.rossde.com/garden/

Eggs Zachtly 23-04-2008 10:16 AM

daffodil bulbs
 
David E. Ross said:

On 4/22/2008 3:44 PM, Eggs Zachtly wrote:
John McGaw said:

Eggs Zachtly wrote:
snip...
The roots, at that time, are playing a very minor role. The food is all
being sent back down to the bulb for storage. It's being made in the
leaves, not the roots.
snip...

Guess we'll just have to disagree.


No problem. I leave my bulbs at home in the ground, year round, cutting
yellowing foilage as it appears. A bit time-consuming (there are seveal
thousand bulbs), but the beds stay looking fairly fresh. My point was, it
*is* fine to dig the bulbs up, lay them in a cool place to finish, and then
remove the foilage. Planted that fall, they'll produce fine the following
spring.

It is amazing that you would claim that
the plant's roots are "minor" given that this is the only way they absorb
water and nutrients. Sure, photosynthesis is happening in the leaves but
without water and soil nutrients nothing useful is going to be happening
since it doesn't operate on atmospheric C02 alone.


When bulb foilage begins to yellow, the roots are /not/ taking in water. If
they're not taking in water, they're also *not* taking up nutrients. When
the bulb finishes flowering, the roots are done, and begin to die off, same
as the foilage. All food production is taking place above ground, and that
food is being sent to the bulb for dormancy survival, and the following
season's growth.

I will remain with the
position that for best results the plants should stay exactly where they
are until the foliage dies back. It is a minor drawback since daffodils
don't hold onto their foliage all that long and can be easily screened from
view.


Again, there's nothing wrong with that method. Pete C's question was of
digging them up (fine), storing them "in a paper bag in the dark until tops
die off" (BAD idea). Lose the paper bag, and it will work, with no
ill-effects.

Granted, the plants are amazingly tough and might well survive the
treatment you describe but if it was the way to produce best-quality bulbs
I'd expect the big growers to be doing it that way to save time. The Dutch
growers would be able to put their new crop in the warehouses in April and
spend the rest of the year sunning themselves in Majorca.


Having never visited a "big grower", much less one in Holland, I can't
comment on their production methods. Were you to ask one of them about the
inner-workings of a bulb, and just what happens during it's life-cycle, I
bet they'd tell you the same thing I stated above. ;)


In my garden, the narcissus foliage (both daffodils and their relatives)
remains green and vigorous for well more than a month after the flowers
have withered and faded. The leaves are still working, manufacturing
nutrients to rebuild the bulb. For this, they still need moisture as
well as nitrogen, phosphorus, potassium, and other plant nutrients from
the soil -- through the roots.

Only after the leaves start to yellow are the roots no longer important.


That's exactly what I said.

[rest snipped]

--

Eggs

-For every action, there is an equal and opposite government program.

Sacha[_3_] 23-04-2008 10:53 AM

daffodil bulbs
 
On 23/4/08 10:16, in article , "Eggs
Zachtly" wrote:

snip

That's exactly what I said.

[rest snipped]


Perhaps you could snip a bit more next time? Repeating such a lot just to
add one line is a bit of a waste of space.
--
Sacha
http://www.hillhousenursery.co.uk
South Devon
'We do not inherit the earth from our ancestors, we borrow it from our
children.'



Bill[_13_] 23-04-2008 11:15 PM

daffodill bulbs
 
In article , Charlie wrote:

On Tue, 22 Apr 2008 19:00:22 -0400, Bill wrote:


So Charlie and Billy when shall we party?

Bill



Oh yeah......a garden party? Who brings the wine, who brings the
botanicals, who brings what????


Charlie

"People came from miles around, everyone was there
Yoko brought her walrus, there was magic in the air
'n' over in the corner, much to my surprise
Mr. Hughes hid in Dylan's shoes wearing his disguise"

"But it's all right now, I learned my lesson well.
You see, ya can't please everyone, so ya got to please yourself"

~~Ricky


Grew up with Nelson's.

Bill

--
Garden in shade zone 5 S Jersey USA

Bill[_13_] 24-04-2008 12:06 AM

daffodill bulbs
 
In article ,
wrote:

Grew up with Nelson's.

Bill


HUH? You mean as in same period or as in sharing
Nehi's and Moon Pies?


Nah more like Rickey and David as human .

The past video seems to have a sort of power over words , Shame the
content could not keep up unless we had access to amend . Hope this is
a try.

Libraries , Libraries and examples of folks making sense.

Bill Tired....

--
Garden in shade zone 5 S Jersey USA

[email protected] 24-04-2008 03:46 AM

daffodill bulbs
 
On Apr 20, 7:09*pm, wrote:
I'm no gardener but have had the unfortunate task of tending my
father's grave. I planted some daff bulbs last autumn and had a
beautiful display but the flowers are now dying off. I shall soon be
re-planting with summer plants. Should I save the daff bulbs for next
year, or shoud they be discarded and buy new ones again in the autumn?


Seems to me that after you plant daffodills, it's quite difficult to
kill them if you try.

Billy[_4_] 24-04-2008 07:21 AM

daffodill bulbs
 
In article , Charlie wrote:

On Tue, 22 Apr 2008 19:00:22 -0400, Bill wrote:


So Charlie and Billy when shall we party?

Bill



Oh yeah......a garden party? Who brings the wine, who brings the
botanicals, who brings what????


Charlie

"People came from miles around, everyone was there
Yoko brought her walrus, there was magic in the air
'n' over in the corner, much to my surprise
Mr. Hughes hid in Dylan's shoes wearing his disguise"

"But it's all right now, I learned my lesson well.
You see, ya can't please everyone, so ya got to please yourself"

~~Ricky


Hope you got down on "Earth Day". Down on your knees works for me to:-(
--

Billy

http://au.youtube.com/watch?v=7WBB0s...eature=related

Billy[_4_] 24-04-2008 07:23 AM

daffodill bulbs
 
In article
,
Bill wrote:

In article , Charlie wrote:

On Tue, 22 Apr 2008 19:00:22 -0400, Bill wrote:


So Charlie and Billy when shall we party?

Bill



Oh yeah......a garden party? Who brings the wine, who brings the
botanicals, who brings what????


Charlie

"People came from miles around, everyone was there
Yoko brought her walrus, there was magic in the air
'n' over in the corner, much to my surprise
Mr. Hughes hid in Dylan's shoes wearing his disguise"

"But it's all right now, I learned my lesson well.
You see, ya can't please everyone, so ya got to please yourself"

~~Ricky


Grew up with Nelson's.

Bill


Oh, come on. Nobody grew up with the Nelsons. They had separate twin
beds. The Nelsons was when ignorance was bliss.
--

Billy

http://au.youtube.com/watch?v=7WBB0s...eature=related

Billy[_4_] 24-04-2008 07:24 AM

daffodill bulbs
 
In article ,
wrote:

Grew up with Nelson's.

Bill


HUH? You mean as in same period or as in sharing
Nehi's and Moon Pies?


You in North Carolina now Charlie?
--

Billy

http://au.youtube.com/watch?v=7WBB0s...eature=related

Billy[_4_] 24-04-2008 07:43 AM

daffodill bulbs
 
In article
,
Bill wrote:

In article ,
wrote:

Grew up with Nelson's.

Bill


HUH? You mean as in same period or as in sharing
Nehi's and Moon Pies?


Nah more like Rickey and David as human .

The past video seems to have a sort of power over words , Shame the
content could not keep up unless we had access to amend . Hope this is
a try.

Libraries , Libraries and examples of folks making sense.

Bill Tired....


Strange thing about getting old. You're tired more often and you sleep
less. Personally, I'm waiting for the malabsorbtion syndrome to kick in
so that I can lose some weight, and recapture my boyish figure that is
buried in here somewhere. Wait a minute, I don't have to worry about
that anymore. Shrub has my weight loss worries covered. With any bad
luck at all, I should be forty pounds lighter next year at this time, if
I make it through the winter.

Wonder if any of that "shine" they are making for gasoline is ever goin'
to make it to the "market" that will really appreciate it;-)

The body runs on acetate and it is only a tiny, teeny jump from ethanol
to acetate. Beside, it's non-fattening and I got me five milk thistle
plants to cover my liver;-) (again)

Yeah, yeah. Look out Bill, another one is zoning out . . . zzz
--

Billy

http://au.youtube.com/watch?v=7WBB0s...eature=related

Bill[_13_] 24-04-2008 04:41 PM

daffodill bulbs
 
In article , Charlie wrote:

On Wed, 23 Apr 2008 23:24:02 -0700, Billy wrote:

In article ,
wrote:

Grew up with Nelson's.

Bill

HUH? You mean as in same period or as in sharing
Nehi's and Moon Pies?


You in North Carolina now Charlie?


Nah....I think I was in Headupmybuttville when I posted. ;-)

Charlie, thinkin' havin' a Nehi and Moon Pie with Opie sounds fun.


You guys never had the pleasure of cranking up your BG with tastykakes?

http://www.tastykake.com/

I used to walk trough the woods about a mile for my school bus and
would eat my tasty cake on the way and discard the rest. I'd also have
my Fox 12 gauge with me incase a crow came by. This was a time when
dynamite was used against crow roosts. Things have changed haven't they.

Bill who feeds the birds and calls crows.

--
Garden in shade zone 5 S Jersey USA

Billy[_4_] 24-04-2008 07:13 PM

daffodill bulbs
 
In article
,
Bill wrote:

http://www.tastykake.com/


Interesting tat no where in this advertisement for a food product do
they tell you what the ingredients are. One can only guess:

enriched flour

soy oil

high fructose corn syrup

(Other corn products,
Food Additives That May Contain Corn:
Calcium lactate or stearate
Calcium stearoyl lactylate
Dextrin or Dextrose
Ethyl maltol
Fumaric or Lactic acid
Gluconolactone or Glucono delta-lactone
Glucose
Glycerine
Hydrolyzed vegetable protein
Lecithin
Linoleic acid
Malt, Maltodextrin, Maltose or Maltol
Mannitol
Polydextrose
Polysorbates
Potassium gluconate
Propylene glycol monostearate
Sodium ascorbate or other ascorbates
Sodium stearoyl fumarate
Sodium-, Magnesium-, Calcium- or Potassium-fumarate
Stearyl citrate
Tocopherol (alpha-Tocopherol, vitamin E)

Reference:
Farlow, C. Food Additives: A Shopper¹s Guide to What¹s Safe and What¹s
Not. 1993. )

salt

artificial flavor

artificial color

and enough BHA or BHT for a twenty year shelf life.
-------

Just a guess mind you;-)
--

Billy

http://au.youtube.com/watch?v=7WBB0s...eature=related


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 03:59 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
GardenBanter