Debate Over Plants Having Feelings
 

I need help.
I am having a debate over wether plants have feelings or not.
I say no they do not others say they do.
I have said that plants need a nervous system and a brain also I have
said that plants are responsive to stimuli and chemical reactions.

but this does not help so I need some biology and botanist experts
with some sciencfic proof.

Cordialy
Bill Vereen

Debate Over Plants Having Feelings
 

In article .com, wrote:
I need help.
I am having a debate over wether plants have feelings or not.
I say no they do not others say they do.
I have said that plants need a nervous system and a brain also I have
said that plants are responsive to stimuli and chemical reactions.

but this does not help so I need some biology and botanist experts
with some sciencfic proof.

There is no way to *prove* a negative. If plants *do* have feelings,
it may be possible one day to prove it; but there is no way to prove
they don't. (Of course, greenies will say they do, hence the concept
of "Happy plants". ;-)

Cheers, Phred.

--
LID

Debate Over Plants Having Feelings
 

On Oct 31, 3:09 pm, (Phred) wrote:
In article .com, wrote:
I need help.
I am having a debate over wether plants have feelings or not.
I say no they do not others say they do.
I have said that plants need a nervous system and a brain also I have
said that plants are responsive to stimuli and chemical reactions.

but this does not help so I need some biology and botanist experts
with some sciencfic proof.

There is no way to *prove* a negative. If plants *do* have feelings,
it may be possible one day to prove it; but there is no way to prove
they don't. (Of course, greenies will say they do, hence the concept
of "Happy plants". ;-)

Cheers, Phred.

--


Dear Phred
Thankyou for your input and your partly right but if I can have an
expert Biologist or Botanist give me their views and some research
studies to back it up then this would be of great help.

thankyou

Bill Vereen

Debate Over Plants Having Feelings
 

schreef
Dear Phred
Thankyou for your input and your partly right but if I can have an
expert Biologist or Botanist give me their views and some research
studies to back it up then this would be of great help.

***
Well, I'd say Phred qualifies as an expert.
PvR

Debate Over Plants Having Feelings
 

On Oct 31, 8:07 pm, "P. van Rijckevorsel" wrote:
schreef

Dear Phred
Thankyou for your input and your partly right but if I can have an
expert Biologist or Botanist give me their views and some research
studies to back it up then this would be of great help.

***
Well, I'd say Phred qualifies as an expert.
PvR

Im not saying Phred is not an expert but his answer did not provide
any substantial scientific evidence one way or another which is what i
need

Debate Over Plants Having Feelings
 

On Wed, 31 Oct 2007 08:14:41 -0000, wrote:

I need help.
I am having a debate over wether plants have feelings or not.
I say no they do not others say they do.
I have said that plants need a nervous system and a brain also I have
said that plants are responsive to stimuli and chemical reactions.

but this does not help so I need some biology and botanist experts
with some sciencfic proof.

Cordialy
Bill Vereen


http://answers.yahoo.com/question/in...6213525AAZt1Kv

http://www.guardian.co.uk/internatio...190520,00.html

http://malaysia.answers.yahoo.com/qu...2173244AAfWGYJ

http://skepdic.com/plants.html


Make of them what you will.