GardenBanter.co.uk

GardenBanter.co.uk (https://www.gardenbanter.co.uk/)
-   Ponds (https://www.gardenbanter.co.uk/ponds/)
-   -   White Grubs... (https://www.gardenbanter.co.uk/ponds/17118-white-grubs.html)

ajames54™ 21-04-2003 08:08 PM

White Grubs...
 
I need to find a fish safe treatment for White Grubs ...
they have trashed my neighbors yard and are working on mine.

My neighbor is an excellent fellow and has told me he will not
spray if I can find a fish safe way to get rid of them.

Please don't say "Get a Skunk" we've been trying that and they
only do a half assed job.


Robin Hall 21-04-2003 09:08 PM

White Grubs...
 
On Mon, 21 Apr 2003 15:01:28 -0400, ajames54™
wrote:
you can use nematodes, these are a biological parisite that eat grubs
I have had moderate to excellent success with them and I am in very
infested area, ps use lots of water on your lawn if restrictions are
not in place they don't like being damp all the time.

I need to find a fish safe treatment for White Grubs ...
they have trashed my neighbors yard and are working on mine.

My neighbor is an excellent fellow and has told me he will not
spray if I can find a fish safe way to get rid of them.

Please don't say "Get a Skunk" we've been trying that and they
only do a half assed job.



MLF 21-04-2003 09:44 PM

White Grubs...
 

"ajames54T" wrote:
I need to find a fish safe treatment for White Grubs ...
Please don't say "Get a Skunk" we've been trying that and they
only do a half assed job.


Get two skunks.

(I couldn't resist.)

Michael Fermanis
New Orleans, Louisiana USA (Remove the RICE to reply)
================================================== ===========



[email protected] 21-04-2003 10:32 PM

White Grubs...
 
milky spore. completely biological. they say application will work for about 20
years. Ingrid

ajames54™ wrote:
I need to find a fish safe treatment for White Grubs ...
they have trashed my neighbors yard and are working on mine.

My neighbor is an excellent fellow and has told me he will not
spray if I can find a fish safe way to get rid of them.

Please don't say "Get a Skunk" we've been trying that and they
only do a half assed job.



Tom L. La Bron 21-04-2003 11:44 PM

White Grubs...
 
Armadillos do a great job on grubs.

Tom L.L.
----------------------------------
"MLF" wrote in message
...

"ajames54T" wrote:
I need to find a fish safe treatment for White

Grubs ...
Please don't say "Get a Skunk" we've been

trying that and they
only do a half assed job.


Get two skunks.

(I couldn't resist.)

Michael Fermanis


New Orleans, Louisiana USA (Remove the

RICE to reply)

==================================================
===========





Jerrispond 22-04-2003 12:56 AM

White Grubs...
 
Armadillos do a great job on grubs.

Man...someone talked about chipmonks tearing up a liner....I shudder to think
of a lawn or liner.....Jerri

http://www.fringeweb.com/Ponds/JerrisPond

John Rutz 22-04-2003 02:20 AM

White Grubs...
 


Jerrispond wrote:
Armadillos do a great job on grubs.



Man...someone talked about chipmonks tearing up a liner....I shudder to think
of a lawn or liner.....Jerri

http://www.fringeweb.com/Ponds/JerrisPond



--
cleaning the garden the other dzy we found a lot of those whit e grubs
Koi luvvv em




John Rutz
Z5 New Mexico
If it can't be fixed with bailing wire or duct tape
its not worth fixing

see my pond at:

http://www.fuerjefe.com


Priscilla McCullough 22-04-2003 11:32 AM

White Grubs...
 
Ahhhhhh, what is a Grub? Sounds gross!!
Priss
wrote in message
...
milky spore. completely biological. they say application will work for

about 20
years. Ingrid

ajames54T wrote:
I need to find a fish safe treatment for White Grubs ...
they have trashed my neighbors yard and are working on mine.

My neighbor is an excellent fellow and has told me he will not
spray if I can find a fish safe way to get rid of them.

Please don't say "Get a Skunk" we've been trying that and they
only do a half assed job.





Bonnie Espenshade 22-04-2003 01:20 PM

White Grubs...
 
Priscilla McCullough wrote:
Ahhhhhh, what is a Grub? Sounds gross!!
Priss
wrote in message
...

milky spore. completely biological. they say application will work for


about 20

years. Ingrid

ajames54T wrote:

I need to find a fish safe treatment for White Grubs ...
they have trashed my neighbors yard and are working on mine.

My neighbor is an excellent fellow and has told me he will not
spray if I can find a fish safe way to get rid of them.

Please don't say "Get a Skunk" we've been trying that and they
only do a half assed job.





A white grub is a larva (I don't remember of what) about 1"
long and 1/4" around. The flickers love to find them in my
yard.

--
Bonnie
NJ
http://home.earthlink.net/~maebe43/



Jerrispond 22-04-2003 02:32 PM

White Grubs...
 
A white grub is a larva (I don't remember of what) about 1"
long and 1/4" around.


The size of the grub is determined by what kind of bug it will be....I have
found them while digging in my yard that were larger than a mans thumb!! Jerri

http://www.fringeweb.com/Ponds/JerrisPond

John Rutz 22-04-2003 04:56 PM

White Grubs...
 
you might know em better as cutworms

John Rutz

Priscilla McCullough wrote:
Ahhhhhh, what is a Grub? Sounds gross!!
Priss
wrote in message
...

milky spore. completely biological. they say application will work for


about 20

years. Ingrid

ajames54T wrote:

I need to find a fish safe treatment for White Grubs ...
they have trashed my neighbors yard and are working on mine.

My neighbor is an excellent fellow and has told me he will not
spray if I can find a fish safe way to get rid of them.

Please don't say "Get a Skunk" we've been trying that and they
only do a half assed job.






--





John Rutz
Z5 New Mexico
If it can't be fixed with bailing wire or duct tape
its not worth fixing

see my pond at:

http://www.fuerjefe.com


ajames54™ 22-04-2003 05:08 PM

White Grubs...
 
On Mon, 21 Apr 2003 21:21:21 GMT, wrote:

milky spore. completely biological. they say application will work for about 20
years. Ingrid

Thanks all!

Unfortunately the Milky Spore is not yet approved for use around
here... and the nematodes will be about $80 for enough to cover
our two lawns..

ah well until I can figure out just how illegal it will be to
import the milky spore (1) I'll have to drop the cash.

(1) mostly a joke but you never really know.

Steve Watson 22-04-2003 05:20 PM

White Grubs...
 
"Priscilla McCullough" wrote in message ...
Ahhhhhh, what is a Grub? Sounds gross!!
Priss


They're the larva of the June beetle (those big stupid ugly brown
things that stun themselves flying into porch lights). The grub is a
white fat "worm" up to an inch long, which is found just below the
soil surface. It eats grass roots. If you can stand to dig them up
yourself, I'm sure they make a great treat for your fish (I have a
number of garden pests that I hand-pick and feed to the fish -- *very*
satisfying feeling ;-).

In addition the biological controls already mentioned, I recommend
growing something other than grass -- a monoculture just begs to have
a pest come and eat it. Adding clover seed is good place to start
(but the general stupidity of the whole idea of the modern lawn is a
whole other hobby-horse which I won't ride here ;-).

The big thing I'm worried about this year is West Nile Virus -- not
that I'll get it (I think the health scare is overblown) but that
backyard ponds may be perceived as mosquito breeding grounds, and we
may need to do some fast talking to escape being sprayed or whatever.

-- Steve

Cleveland Ponder 22-04-2003 06:32 PM

White Grubs...
 
Where I live the grubs are usually about 3/16" to 1/4" in diameter and
3/4" to 1" long. They are the larval stage of Japanese beetles. My
only complaint with the skunks is I wish they would replace the divots
when they're done.

"Priscilla McCullough" wrote in message ...
Ahhhhhh, what is a Grub? Sounds gross!!
Priss


Cybe R. Wizard 22-04-2003 07:32 PM

White Grubs...
 
On Tue, 22 Apr 2003 10:54:55 -0500, ajames54™ wrote:

On Mon, 21 Apr 2003 21:21:21 GMT, wrote:

milky spore. completely biological. they say application will work
for about 20 years. Ingrid

Thanks all!

Unfortunately the Milky Spore is not yet approved for use around
here... and the nematodes will be about $80 for enough to cover our
two lawns..

ah well until I can figure out just how illegal it will be to import
the milky spore (1) I'll have to drop the cash.

(1) mostly a joke but you never really know.


Don't know about Milky Spore, but most things that'll kill the grubs
will do in earthworms, too.
Just FYI.

Cybe R. Wizard

--
Unofficial "Wizard of Odds," A.H.P.
Original PORG "Water Wizard," R.P.
"Wize(ned) Wizard," A.P.F-P-Y.
Barely Tolerated Wizard, A.J.L & A.A.L

Neil Law 22-04-2003 07:32 PM

White Grubs...
 
On 22 Apr 2003 10:21:59 -0700, (Cleveland Ponder) wrote:

Where I live the grubs are usually about 3/16" to 1/4" in diameter and
3/4" to 1" long. They are the larval stage of Japanese beetles. My
only complaint with the skunks is I wish they would replace the divots
when they're done.

Divots? One year they tore up my whole front yard. Only recourse was to tear up
what was left and reseed everything. Things were that badly shredded.

MLF 22-04-2003 10:32 PM

White Grubs...
 

My only complaint with the skunks is I wish they would replace
the divots when they're done.

Divots? One year they tore up my whole front yard. Only recourse was to

tear up
what was left and reseed everything. Things were that badly shredded.



I had the perfect answer to grubs when I lived in Connecticut. Moles. Dozens
of them. Hundreds of them. Hordes of them, everywhere, tunneling day and
night. The whole lawn looked like a washboard. The cats dragged in a half
dozen every day (not that it seemed to make a dent in the population any),
but no grubs.

All in all, I just as soon have grubs.


Michael Fermanis
New Orleans, Louisiana USA (Remove the RICE to reply)
================================================== ===========




[email protected] 22-04-2003 11:56 PM

White Grubs...
 
nope. natural biological that just kills beetle grubs.
http://homeharvest.com/milkspore.html

"Cybe R. Wizard" wrote:
Don't know about Milky Spore, but most things that'll kill the grubs
will do in earthworms, too.
Just FYI.


Gregory Young 24-04-2003 12:20 AM

White Grubs...
 
The milky spore is expensive.
It only works for grubs of Japanese beetles.
Have you taken your grubs down to local your co-operative extension/nursery
to confirm they are Japanese beetle larvae, before committing to specific
therapy?
Greg


"ajames54T" wrote in message
...
On Mon, 21 Apr 2003 21:21:21 GMT,
wrote:

milky spore. completely biological. they say application will work for

about 20
years. Ingrid

Thanks all!

Unfortunately the Milky Spore is not yet approved for use around
here... and the nematodes will be about $80 for enough to cover
our two lawns..

ah well until I can figure out just how illegal it will be to
import the milky spore (1) I'll have to drop the cash.

(1) mostly a joke but you never really know.




[email protected] 24-04-2003 03:56 AM

White Grubs...
 
http://homeharvest.com/milkspore.html

Milky Spore - Bacillus popillae
" Two kinds of bacteria are known to cause milky disease in grubs. They attack only
members of the white grub family. Milky Spore disease affects some-- 47 different
varieties of beetle grubs in the U.S. including June Beetle or May Fly grubs, but the
Japanese beetle grub is probably the most extensively affected.---- Milky disease
bacteria do not infect nor harm other insects, earthworms, birds, warm-blooded
animals, humans, or plants."

effective 15-20 years. 10oz Covers 2,500 SF $28+
about the cost of 1 nice rose, cheap at the price.
Ingrid

Gregory Young 25-04-2003 05:20 AM

White Grubs...
 
wrote in message
...
http://homeharvest.com/milkspore.html

Milky Spore - Bacillus popillae
" Two kinds of bacteria are known to cause milky disease in grubs. They

attack only
members of the white grub family. Milky Spore disease affects some-- 47

different
varieties of beetle grubs in the U.S. including June Beetle or May Fly

grubs, but the
Japanese beetle grub is probably the most extensively affected.---- Milky

disease
bacteria do not infect nor harm other insects, earthworms, birds,

warm-blooded
animals, humans, or plants."

effective 15-20 years. 10oz Covers 2,500 SF $28+
about the cost of 1 nice rose, cheap at the price.
Ingrid


That is an interesting reference, from a retailer/reseller of the product.
Their web site states "milky spore disease affects 47 diff varieties of
beetle grubs..." .. note here the word disease vs. the bacteria they are
selling, because the following site:
http://www.milkyspore.com/milkyspore.htm
which is from St Gabriel's labs, who actually manufacture the product state:
"It (Milky Spore) targets and discriminately works to attack the white grubs
of Japanese Beetles..
No mention 47 other varieties here!

By golly discrepant information again!
Who should we believe.. the product reseller or manufacturer??? I think I'll
go with the latter.

As to the expense, if all you need is to cover 2500 sq ft, then it's not too
bad. Many have turfs much larger, and it is pricey.

Also if you go to the manufacturer's site I listed, you will see applying it
will take time. You need to map out your yard, and be sure to follow their
instructions as to when to apply (to avoid inactivation).

You can't use a broadcast spreader. If you use a drop spreader you can't use
the powder.. you need a special mix, at a higher cost.

As I said in my initial post, MS will work for Japanese beetle grubs, and if
you are sure you have an infestation of them, then go for it!

BUT:

I still would recommend before you spend any $$ on MS that you have the
grubs checked as I described in my initial post.

Good luck, (let me know what you find out about your grubs!)
Greg






[email protected] 26-04-2003 04:20 PM

White Grubs...
 
some .edu sites say only japanese beetles, others say other kind of grubs.
here is a .edu site talks about milky spore and OTHER ways of killing grubs using
insecticides. cant use both at the same time.
http://www.hort.uconn.edu/ipm/homegr...s/37lpests.htm


By golly discrepant information again!


Gregory Young 26-04-2003 05:56 PM

White Grubs...
 
Nice reference.
Given my druthers, I'd pick a bio. agent (like MS) over a chemical agent, as
long as the grubs were responsive to it, even if it cost more, as it's more
environmentally sound.


wrote in message
...
some .edu sites say only japanese beetles, others say other kind of grubs.
here is a .edu site talks about milky spore and OTHER ways of killing

grubs using
insecticides. cant use both at the same time.
http://www.hort.uconn.edu/ipm/homegr...s/37lpests.htm


By golly discrepant information again!




kari 27-04-2003 03:32 PM

White Grubs...
 
What you do at this point is borrow a dog if you don't want one full
time. Especially a lab type of dog. They'll dig all the mole hills up,
making the little vermin leave. Yea, you have massive ditches where you
had moles, BUT you have the sick satisfaction that they left in fear and
the dog is REALLY happy! :)



I had the perfect answer to grubs when I lived in Connecticut. Moles. Dozens
of them. Hundreds of them. Hordes of them, everywhere, tunneling day and
night. The whole lawn looked like a washboard. The cats dragged in a half
dozen every day (not that it seemed to make a dent in the population any),
but no grubs.

All in all, I just as soon have grubs.


Michael Fermanis
New Orleans, Louisiana USA (Remove the RICE to reply)
================================================== ===========





ajames54™ 28-04-2003 01:44 PM

White Grubs...
 
On Sat, 26 Apr 2003 16:49:18 GMT, "Gregory Young"
wrote:

Gregory...
Any idea if Milky spore is available in the buffalo area?
(I caught the buffalo.edu address).

The Nematode solution (I'm told) will only work if the soil temp
is constantly above 15C...

I did a count on Saturday .. I dug up approx 1 square foot of
soil and counted 8 grubs sigh


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 02:22 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
GardenBanter