back from the dead?
 

I have a rose, Fragrant Cloud, the canes got torn off the poor thing,
I thought it was dead... then about a month or so later there are
leaves growing out of the root stock I left in the ground, and the
beginings of a bud. could this still be the wonderful rose I love? or
is it possible that it is another rose?


"education is the progressive discovery of our own ignorance" --Will Durant
"people who read the tabloids deserve to be lied to " Jerry Seinfeld
"if we don't have a sense of humor, we can't have a sense of perspective --Wayne Thiboux

back from the dead?
 

"Dennis" wrote:
I have a rose, Fragrant Cloud, the canes got torn off the poor thing,
I thought it was dead... then about a month or so later there are
leaves growing out of the root stock I left in the ground, and the
beginings of a bud. could this still be the wonderful rose I love? or
is it possible that it is another rose?

Well, if it was a Fragrant Cloud grafted onto a rootstock, you
probably have the rootstock...unless the new growth is from the
tissue grown from the scion. If there's a flower bud...well, wait
and see. The usual rootstock is not likely to bloom this late in
the season, whereas Fragrant Cloud is.

Mark.

back from the dead?
 

"Dennis" wrote in message
...
I have a rose, Fragrant Cloud, the canes got torn off the
poor thing,
I thought it was dead... then about a month or so later
there are
leaves growing out of the root stock I left in the ground,
and the
beginings of a bud. could this still be the wonderful rose
I love? or
is it possible that it is another rose?

If the new growth is coming from the bud
union, it should be your rose. If it's coming
from the root stock (*below* the bud union),
it's a different rose, typically either one
that won't bloom, or blooms once per year.

I have a Dr. Huey I got from a reverted rose
(before I knew much about roses). I really
like it but I wouldn't want a yard full of them.
Dr. Huey is a common root stock, at least around
my part of the world.

Gail
near San Antonio TX Zone 8

back from the dead?
 

Patrick Scheible startled small woodland creatures
when they said:

Dennis writes:

I have a rose, Fragrant Cloud, the canes got torn off the poor thing,
I thought it was dead... then about a month or so later there are
leaves growing out of the root stock I left in the ground, and the
beginings of a bud. could this still be the wonderful rose I love? or
is it possible that it is another rose?

It could be either way. Wait and see when it blooms.

-- Patrick

still waiting, seems this flower is taking it's time... :-)
----

"education is the progressive discovery of our own ignorance" --Will Durant
"people who read the tabloids deserve to be lied to " Jerry Seinfeld
"If we don't have a sense of humor, we can't have a sense of perspective --Wayne Thiboux
To Reply: Scrape off the end bits...

back from the dead?
 

Patrick Scheible startled small woodland creatures
when they said:

Dennis writes:

I have a rose, Fragrant Cloud, the canes got torn off the poor thing,
I thought it was dead... then about a month or so later there are
leaves growing out of the root stock I left in the ground, and the
beginings of a bud. could this still be the wonderful rose I love? or
is it possible that it is another rose?

It could be either way. Wait and see when it blooms.

-- Patrick

still waiting, seems this flower is taking it's time... :-)
----

"education is the progressive discovery of our own ignorance" --Will Durant
"people who read the tabloids deserve to be lied to " Jerry Seinfeld
"If we don't have a sense of humor, we can't have a sense of perspective --Wayne Thiboux
To Reply: Scrape off the end bits...

back from the dead?
 

"Dennis" wrote
still waiting, seems this flower is taking it's time...
:-)

Is there actually a bud?

Gail

back from the dead?
 

"Dennis" wrote
still waiting, seems this flower is taking it's time...
:-)

Is there actually a bud?

Gail

back from the dead?
 

"Gail Futoran" startled small
woodland creatures when they said:

"Dennis" wrote
still waiting, seems this flower is taking it's time...
:-)

Is there actually a bud?

Gail

ahh yes there was... then some critter (human or otherwise) picked it.
am waiting to see if it does actually make another Bud...

----

"education is the progressive discovery of our own ignorance" --Will Durant
"people who read the tabloids deserve to be lied to " Jerry Seinfeld
"If we don't have a sense of humor, we can't have a sense of perspective --Wayne Thiboux
To Reply: Scrape off the end bits...