Tree Roots (was planting mulberry)
In article , Babberney wrote:
On Mon, 12 May 2003 22:11:45 GMT, Spam Collector wrote: In article , kn125 wrote: I have a tree growing very close to my house, a neighbour identified it as a mulberry and said he wouldnt recommend replanting the tree (it now about 4-5 feet tall and the roots have gone 2-3 ft deep). He said it attracts lots of bugs. I have some space in my backyard and was thinking of replanting this tree there. Has anybody had bad/good experiences with mulberries? Also is it native to this area? Thanks. -kn If you value your home's foundation you shouldn't have any trees growing 'very close' to your house. Even if the roots aren't large enough to cause damage by themselves, trees suck a lot of water from the soil and can cause uneven settling especially if your house is built on some of the expansive soils in the area, Frank Actually, this is one of those unbeatable myths, largely started by engineers in England where clay soils are apparently common (search for "subsidence" if you want to see a ton of stuff about it). In fact, shaded clay is less likely to lose water to evaporation than sunny spots, so trees moderate this effect rather than causing it. Probably true in terms of surface evaporation, but tree roots pull a lot of water from deeper in the soil. I can show you miles of roads out in the Southeastern part of the county where the sides of the roads sink during periods of drought where a tree is growing on the fenceline and are fine where there are no trees. Maybe coincidence, but I'm not the only person in the area that has noticed the correlation. Shoddy road construction is probably a contributing factor, but I don't think its the only factor. We tree guys are continually trying to counter the arguments of construction guys because theya re used to saying "the tree did it" and getting away with it. They have years of advance propaganda, which has led to the "common sense" notion that these things must be true. Another biggie is the "tree heaves sidewalk" angle. Tree roots don't push outward, they flow into spaces. They are no doubt contributory--they fill a space, water comes in and freezes, space expands, root fills it, etc. So you're saying a root that starts out about the size of a hair can only grow to be several inches thick if space is created around it? I have a gate post set in concrete 2' deep that has been moved several inches over and up. Is it just a coincidence that a tree sprouted less than a foot away and grew rapidly before it started shifting? Or was it from water freezing under it when the frost line here in Austin is probably something less than an inch deep? As trees grow from a seed or sucker to something 50-100' tall doesn't the soil that used to be where the large roots are have to have moved somewhere? But studies have found just as many heaved sidewalks where there are no trees around to blame. Next time you see this, look at the concrete. Do you see reinforcements (rebar)? My guess is, you don't. Bad sidewalks crumble, the installer gets a call, hmm, must be the tree, cuase we do only the best work. I'm not saying all heaved sidewalks or foundation problems are tree- related, most of them probably aren't. But I disagree with saying none of them are. Frank As for mulberry trees, I like the small ones in my back yard for the berries/birds, but I won't ever let them get out of my control. they are prone to poor structure, they sprout profusely, and they are fairly short-lived. If you are looking at a spot that is wide open a spacious, you might go for it, but if this is going to be the one tree your yard can hold, I'd pick something else. Keith Babberney ISA Certified Arborist For more info about the International Society of Arboriculture, please visit http://www2.champaign.isa-arbor.com/. For consumer info about tree care, visit http://www2.champaign.isa-arbor.com/.../consumer.html |
All times are GMT +1. The time now is 11:09 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
GardenBanter