GardenBanter.co.uk

GardenBanter.co.uk (https://www.gardenbanter.co.uk/)
-   United Kingdom (https://www.gardenbanter.co.uk/united-kingdom/)
-   -   Tree Suggestion (https://www.gardenbanter.co.uk/united-kingdom/208960-tree-suggestion.html)

tonyo31 04-01-2014 03:20 PM

Tree Suggestion
 
Hi, I need an expert to help me with a suggestion for a type of tree. I am looking for a non spreading tree that will grow to a max of 8/10ft. I reckon the most obvious choice is a Juniper but wonder if anyone knows of something that will provide some more interest?
Thanks for any help and suggestions.

echinosum 07-01-2014 12:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by tonyo31 (Post 996997)
Hi, I need an expert to help me with a suggestion for a type of tree. I am looking for a non spreading tree that will grow to a max of 8/10ft. I reckon the most obvious choice is a Juniper but wonder if anyone knows of something that will provide some more interest?
Thanks for any help and suggestions.

Most objects that grow to less than 8/10 ft are called a bush rather than a tree, and many such bushes are available. Though there are some dwarfed trees that grow very slowly, mostly conifers like you mention. But most dwarfed conifers do carry on growing, just very slowly, and at 20 yrs will be higher, possibly a lot higher, than their "height at 10 yrs" or whatever is quoted. Buy your dwarfed conifer from a reputable supplier or you might get a surprise. I bought a dwarfed Arbutus unedo, an evergreen rather than a conifer, which was called an 8-10 ft tree on its label. It reached that after about 5 years and I have been pruning it hard ever since, often by 2 feet a year. Some can be very small: I had a dwarfed spruce which never got higher than about 50cm before a drought killed it off after about 10 years. I had a dwarfed Scots pine which grew to about 1m20 in 10 years before I had to move it due to building works and it didn't survive. I have a variegated Korean pine (not the commonly seen K fir) which is due to grow to 30ft or so, but will probably take a century to get there; since it is now about 15 it is still only about 1m50...

Another option is to get a weeping form which has a pre-defined height. For example, I have a weeping Atlas cedar and a weeping flowering apple (ie one that is no use for its fruit, not even for crab apple jelly) which are both just the same height as when I bought them. I didn't understand this properly when I got the cedar, if I had I wouldn't have got one that was just 3ft tall...

Another option is called pruning, as is commonly adopted for hedges, for example, but trees of suitable species can also be controlled by the pruning method called pollarding which keeps them to a defined height by routinely heavily pruning them each year. There are also in-the-ground bonsai techniques, as you can see at Wisley, though that is very hard work.

kay 07-01-2014 04:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by echinosum (Post 997081)
Another option is to get a weeping form which has a pre-defined height. For example, I have a weeping Atlas cedar and a weeping flowering apple (ie one that is no use for its fruit, not even for crab apple jelly) which are both just the same height as when I bought them.

I have Red Jade, which is a weeping crab (quite possibly the same one), and I have managed to increase its height by about 2 ft by careful pruning, removing the lowest branches, and pruning the upper ones to an upward trending side branch.

On the other hand, over the same period it has increased its spread by about 12 ft, so not the best option for the OP, who wanted a non-spreading tree.

If he wants a non-spreader, then he could go for something columnar, like the flowering cherry Amanagowa, which will go above 210ft eventually but will take a long time to do it.

echinosum 08-01-2014 03:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by kay (Post 997097)
I have Red Jade, which is a weeping crab (quite possibly the same one), and I have managed to increase its height by about 2 ft by careful pruning, removing the lowest branches, and pruning the upper ones to an upward trending side branch.

Mine is red jade too. I prune off any sideshoots that threaten to disturb the current general shape, which only amounts to about a 5 min job each winter on it, and very little material removed, though I can understand how you can also train it as you suggest. I also successfully set a mistletoe on it, and I've been interested to see how very slowly mistletoe grows, it's been there about 6 years now and still not big enough to harvest any for Christmas. (I've got a seed to germinate on one of my pear trees in the past year, though last time I germinated 3 seeds out of about 15 placed, and only one established.)

kay 08-01-2014 08:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by echinosum (Post 997171)
Mine is red jade too. I prune off any sideshoots that threaten to disturb the current general shape, which only amounts to about a 5 min job each winter on it, and very little material removed, though I can understand how you can also train it as you suggest. I also successfully set a mistletoe on it, and I've been interested to see how very slowly mistletoe grows, it's been there about 6 years now and still not big enough to harvest any for Christmas. (I've got a seed to germinate on one of my pear trees in the past year, though last time I germinated 3 seeds out of about 15 placed, and only one established.)

Wow! I like the idea of Red Jade with mistletoe! I've tried without success to get it to grow on the apple trees, but completely forgot the Red Jade in the front garden. It's a lovely tree when in blossom in spring, and gets a lot of comments from passers-by, but the "crabs" are a complete disappointment. I don't think even the blackbird can find them.


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 06:02 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
GardenBanter