Thread: BT or DE ?
View Single Post
  #2   Report Post  
Old 24-04-2015, 06:02 PM posted to rec.gardens.edible
Terry Coombs Terry Coombs is offline
external usenet poster
 
First recorded activity by GardenBanter: Sep 2012
Posts: 678
Default BT or DE ?

Derald wrote:
"Terry Coombs" wrote:

Something is nibbling on my bok choy , and I've seen grasshoppers .
Not certain that they're to blame , but ... which will work better
for grasshoppers ? Other pests that I've seen on these plants before
are like a very small beetle-type bug , hopefully one of these will
help with those too . Chemicals are problematic , I'm trying to
avoid any chem based insecticides because of our bees .


I'm kind of doubtful whether your pests are grasshoppers because,
of they were, you'd not have reported something "nibbling" the bok
choy.... ;-) One thing grasshoppers do not do is nibble! Bt is a
genus-specific pathogen that is totally ineffective on grasshoppers.
DE may be minimally effective, if applied directly to the animals,
and less so when broadcast. In either case, its residual effect is
detrimental to the innocuous and/or "beneficial" insects.
Grasshoppers are difficult to control because of the great distances
adults travel. Poisoned bait has the most immediate effect and a
biological agent ("nolo", a locust-specific pathogen), the
longest-term (AWA cumulative) effect but under a rather narrow set of
conditions. The timing of application-within a day or so of
emergence-greatly affects the efficacy of either.
FWIW: Grasshoppers have been my most chronic and difficult to
control garden "pest". I have grasshoppers in all stages of
development year 'round, except for the coldest days. Two successive
annual applications of "nolo" over a large area (acres) "seem" (purely
anecdotally) to have been of benefit but my perception is likely
twisted by memories of the cash outlay (BMW Syndrome). Bait or
so-called "trap" crops are effective when actually interplanted _in
the garden_. Last season I "discovered" pokeweed to be a superior
protector of eggplant and this season I have picked out some
seedlings for transplantation. Perhaps this year, I will beat the
birds to enough poke seeds to be able to learn to germinate them.


Hmm , I've got 30 marigolds in 4" pots that need homes ... I've been
trying to decide where they should go . For sure some will go in alongside
the bok choy . Also want to put some around the roses , scatter the rest
around the garden . I shoulda planted twice that number ...
I've pretty much quit using insecticides of any kind , and have seen an
upsurge of insect activity - some good , some bad . I've also seen a lot
more lizards around the last couple of years ...
--
Snag