View Single Post
  #9   Report Post  
Old 26-04-2003, 01:23 PM
P van Rijckevorsel
 
Posts: n/a
Default Tropical Hardwoods

David Hershey schreef

It was not a sense of humor but a fact that anyone can coin a commom

name for a plant, even by accident.

+ + +
Coining a name is one thing (often fueled by a sense of humor), but that
does not make it a common name
+ + +

There are millions of plant common
names and often dozens or hundreds for a single species. If a common
name is used, even on websites or in conversation, then it becomes a
common name by default.

+ + +
Not by a long way. If you have a cat and you call him "whiskers" and your
daughters take to referring to other cats as "wiskers", this does not make
"whiskers" a 'common name' for cats.
+ + +

I said that even if iapacho originated as a typo, it would still be a

valid common name because it is in use. Do you know for a fact that
iapacho arose due to a typo, or does it represent an alternate
spelling or a native term?

+ + +
It is definitely a typo
+ + +

http://www.ou.edu/cas/botany-micro/ben/ben109.html


+ + +
Nice site, supporting what I say. It warns against attempting to
artificially introduce common names
+ + +

What science has to do with your vague criticisms of a webpage is that

scientists are supposed to be specific. [snip]
David R. Hershey


+ + +
Depends on circumstance. There is a technical name for "being specific" at
length on topics you have no power to change just for the sake of filling up
space: it is called "gossip". It is not supposed to be a scientific
endeavour.
PvR