18-08-2003, 08:13 AM
|
|
|
What's The Latest On Roundup Herbicide?
In article , (Bill Oliver) wrote:
In article ,
Psalm 110 wrote:
"Dave Gower" "Nature-Hating Republican Liar"
wrote in message
...
"Bill Oliver" wrote
... Smashing
in someone's skull with a hammer is not a test of iron toxicity.
In fact, studies which look at real criteria repeatedly have found that
it is safe when used properly.
I think this is an succinct and definitive rebuttal to the hysterical
dogmatism of Paghat and other unthinking haters of big business.
Nature-Hating Republican Liar:
Ah, yes. If you can't argue the science, argue the person.
Yes yes, you keep telling us how you trust first and formost the same
researcher who "proved" tobacco was harmless and who Monsanto hired away
from Philip Morris to work for yet another company that cooks the stats &
lies outright to journal editors, as Monsanto was recently SO caught doing
through JAMA for meaningful example. And my point still stands: Your
trusting criminals to tell you the truth is as insane as trusting a known
child molestor to babysit your children. Character does matter. It being
shown time and again that stats paid for or concocted by Monsanto were
intentionally fabricated does matter. To you honesty doesn't matter as
long as the resulting science appears in even the most marginal way to be
on Monsanto's side. But you know what, honesty does matter. And Monsanto
researchers have very little of that required trait. If their mouths are
moving, they're lying.
The science has been sufficiently argued & will be argued again by others
I've no doubt. You held your own a bit, but were not finally convincing to
anyone who has read about Monsanto. That you couldn't convince by citing
cooked statistics is why you're now resorting to more & more ad hominum
attack since your poorly selected choice of which science scores best was
so unconvincing. Melchizedek posted useful information everyone can judge
for themselves -- so you "argue" with the same non-argument you tried on
me. It would be more honest, if no less ridiculous, if you'd just keep
reposting the cooked statistics instead of repeating the ad hominums.
-paggers
--
"Of what are you afraid, my child?" inquired the kindly teacher.
"Oh, sir! The flowers, they are wild," replied the timid creature.
-from Peter Newell's "Wild Flowers"
See the Garden of Paghat the Ratgirl: http://www.paghat.com/
|