Thread: More berries
View Single Post
  #13   Report Post  
Old 06-11-2003, 11:03 PM
Cereoid-UR12-
 
Posts: n/a
Default More berries

The same way you are a schmendrick by default, Rinkytink.

It shows the true extent of your lack of enlightenment on the subject. It
does appear that you never do your own homework.

In Spjut, R.W. (1994) A SYSTEMATIC TREATMENT OF FRUIT TYPES. Memoires of the
N. Y. Bot. Gard. 70: 93, the fruit of a banana would be considered to be a
Pepo! The use of the term is not restricted to the Cucurbitaceae. The more
specific term that has been given is a Musidium.


P van Rijckevorsel wrote in message
...
Cereoid-UR12- schreef
And yet you insist the pulpy (not fleshy) fruit of a banana is a berry

when in fact it is not.

+ + +
A banana is berry by default, it is not worthwhile to come up with a
different term. Since plantains are eaten more or less as vegetables these
support the thesis!
+ + +

The classical definition of a drupe is that it is a one seeded berry.


+ + +
By "classical" you mean the ancient Romans? Or maybe the Greeks?
+ + +

Having a woody stone endocarp surrounding the seed has nothing at all to

do with the definition.

+ + +
That is only because you are using the "classical definition". If you were
to look at contemporary definitions you would find otherwise
+ + +

If the fruit has two seeds, it automatically becomes a berry by default.


+ + +
Nope. It is less and less surprising you are confused about bananas.
+ + +

So what about those plants that have fleshy fruit with 1 to 3 seeds in

them?

+ + +
Depends on the presence of an endocarp. Easy, isn't it?
PvR