15 Jun 2004 15:56:21 GMT wrote:


However, evolution does not work to long-term species survival, but
comparative advantage between offspring.
If in the past a certian behaviour or characteristic has benefited the
species to go into being a specialist, then the species may become very
specialist indeed, and sensitive to the loss of whatever they specialise
in.

Evolution cannot look ahead, and wonder what happens if the Goobly tree
becomes extinct due to Dutch Goobly disease, and there are no
Gooblyberries to eat.

Same thing I told P van Rijckevorsel. The factor of "Environment" is missing in Darwin Evolution theory
which as a factor is probably more important than the other 4 factors of differential reproductive success,
geographical isolation, etc etc.

We do not expect Darwin Evolution to be hovering over ever species and moving its members along on the road
of greatest success.

But if a force of Environment is such that it moves a large number of species every year from becoming more
Specialist and losing its Generalist tendencies
(eg prunus tomentosa losing its ability of viable seeds unless passed through the gut of a bird).

Then, well, Darwin Evolution has a huge gap missing in that the Environment is shaping the future of species
more than the 4 factors espoused in Darwin Evolution.

And it is exactly a factor of Environment that the theory of Superdeterminism would say is more important
than the other 4 factors given by Darwin Evolution.

So why should any member of any species be seen as success or survival when the entire species is hurly
gurly burly roller coastering into extinction.

If Darwin Evolution is deaf dumb and silent about whether a species is becoming too specialist rather than
generalist, whilst Environment is dictating what species is made to be more specialist, well, obviously
there are huge holes and flaws and gaps in Darwin Evolution.

Archimedes Plutonium
www.archimedesplutonium.com
www.iw.net/~a_plutonium
whole entire Universe is just one big atom where dots
of the electron-dot-cloud are galaxies