View Single Post
  #1   Report Post  
Old 09-10-2004, 06:01 PM
Archimedes Plutonium
 
Posts: n/a
Default Which came first, the Green Ash or the White Ash species

What prompted this question? Well recently I bought some lumber of white
ash, plus hickory plus white oak and various others. I do not believe
the data on strength of wood is accurate and am wanting to test these
woods myself. I believe oak is stronger than hickory. I believe the
strength of hickory is a sales hype. The reason I say this is because in
history trebuchets were built out of oak and not hickory even though
England had hickory species and ash species. And because the growth
pattern of oaks allows horizontal branches which means the wood has to
be tougher and stronger to grow horizontal. I also want to test spruce
for strength because a spruce bears the full force of wind so its wood
must be strong.

But the question that rose in my mind is whether GreenAsh came first in
geologic history or whether WhiteAsh and which mutated and gave rise to
the other?

I accept Darwin Evolution theory only as a algorithm or rule and not as
a theory. Let me call it the Darwin-Evolution-Rule. So according to that
Rule, which of the ashes existed first? Was it GreenAsh that mutated to
create the WhiteAsh species or vice versa?

If I had to guess I would say the WhiteAsh came first and gave rise to
the GreenAsh and I would guess that because the GreenAsh has a wider
range of habitat. Because in the Rule of its survival of the fittest it
is less likely for a species to give rise to a weaker species that
thence increases its range of habitat. Based on *likelihood*.

Question: what is in the genetics of GreenAsh that it can live
where-ever WhiteAsh lives and then some more? Is it that GreenAsh is
less picky as to pH soil conditions? Is it that GreenAsh can take wind
better than WhiteAsh? Is it that GreenAsh can survive with less water?

So I wonder if a Genome project can be run on GreenAsh and WhiteAsh and
whether the genome can date whether GreenAsh was a mutation of WhiteAsh
and has now become the dominant ash species?

I am thinking that DNA is a fossil record itself and can tell us which
species of two contending species came first.

And this DNA dating is very important for the human species itself in
that it can tell us that Stonethrowing came before bipedalism and
created bipedalism.

Archimedes Plutonium
www.iw.net/~a_plutonium
whole entire Universe is just one big atom where dots
of the electron-dot-cloud are galaxies