Semantics, semantics. Words mean things and can have an effect just by
their use. We probably need to be aware of the unspoken baggage that words
bring with them when we use them. For example, the three words you listed
bring with them (to me) the implication that the subject makes at least a
part of his living doing this. "Professional" is an adjective which
emphasizes this for another word such as "professional nurseryman".
Is this the image you get? And if so, is it the image you wish to convey?
Do you wish to restrict the discussion to only those who gain a large part
of their income from the practice of bonsai? The word (that doesn't carry
the economic implication) I lean toward for people I respect is "talent",
as in "he has a talent with pines". The radio and television people use it
in a "professional" sense when they refer to "on-air talent", no training
necessary but needs a certain flair.
My local club is sponsoring the '06 state convention and we have been
discussing workshop and demonstration leaders. Some of those discussed
would fall under ALL of the titles listed, some have formal training in
Japan, some are "self-taught" (which means that they have made their
mistakes by themselves) and some have "backed into" the bonsai community
from somewhere else (landscape designer, nurseryman, etc.). But the one
thing they all have in common is the respect that the general bonsai
community pays to them. They are all "talents".
Now I'll go away again. Have fun - jay
Jay Beckenbach - Melrose, FL - Zone 8b/9a -
-----Original Message-----
From: Alejandro Bedini G. ]
I know the professional people who doing bonsai in a high
level(workshop, teach, demo, congress, lecture)
dont like Call or use the word MASTER.
What do you think is the correct name to use?
A) Teacher
B) Artist
C) professional
D) ????
---------- CLIP ----------
************************************************** ******************************
++++Sponsored, in part, by Boon Manakitivipart++++
************************************************** ******************************
-- The IBC HOME PAGE & FAQ: http://www.internetbonsaiclub.org/ --
+++++ Questions? Help? e-mail +++++