"josephine" wrote in message
...
:
: hi i have been given a rose bush lasty year and now its got black
: spot can antone tell me how to get rid of it please i have tried lots
: of sprays but nothing seems to work i take of all the bad leave but it
: always returns thank you jo

I don't think you will ever get rid of it unless you spray fortnightly with
a fungicide specifically produced for that purpose. I gave up with spraying
roses and keep only the ones that survive on their own