View Single Post
  #14   Report Post  
Old 30-08-2006, 05:04 AM posted to alt.home.repair,rec.gardens
Al Bundy Al Bundy is offline
external usenet poster
 
First recorded activity by GardenBanter: Aug 2006
Posts: 11
Default Aerate vs. Dethatch vs. Overseed

blueman wrote in
:

I have a relatively small lawn (maybe 5 thousand square feet spread
across a couple of patches) that has developed seemingly more brown
than green spots, including a bit of a mat of dead grass.

I know I need to do something to condition the soil and re-seed this
fall.

I am considering aerating, dethatching, and then overseeding. I am
confused about which of these tasks requires a power machine (and
hence rental) vs. the ability to do by hand.

If the marginal benefit is not too great, I would prefer not to have
to rent 3 separate machines.

- My understanding is that aeration requires a power machine to do it
right, so presumably I need to rent an aerator.

- Do I need a dethatcher or could I do just as good a job with a
special
dethatching rake?

- Do I need an overseeder machine or can I do almost as good a job
with a
standard Scott's broadcast spreader?

- If I rent an overseeder, do I still need an aerator or will the
overseeder do a reasonably good job of opening up the soil?

- Finally, is this the right order of operations:
Aerate
Dethatch
Fertilize/lime
Seed/overseed
Water
Water
Water...

Thanks



Have you considered the possibility of disease or bugs?

Brown areas can be caused by this. For instance, grubs will chow on the
roots and create brown spots. You can usually grab the brown turf and
pull up a patch because they have destroyed the roots. Or if you go cut
down at the edge of the brown and pull up the edge you will actually see
the grubs. A prime indicator of grubs is skunks that dig in your yard.
People want to shoot the skunks not realizing they are doing them a
favor by digging a relatively small hole to eat their delicasy food,
grubs.

Disease is another story. Gotta ID it.

Bottom line whether it's bad mowing or someone spraying Triox on your
lawn at night, you gotta ID the root cause and not just throw stuff at
it like a jackpot.