View Single Post
  #23   Report Post  
Old 06-09-2006, 04:01 AM posted to rec.gardens.orchids
Al[_1_] Al[_1_] is offline
external usenet poster
 
First recorded activity by GardenBanter: Jul 2006
Posts: 97
Default CITES plants and hybrids: AOS judging & showing

The first link was *really* interesting. :-) It really underscores why
nobody ever seems to know what's going on with a particular plant and it
legal status.

The fourth link was interesting too. I don't know if there are differences
between US CITES regulations and UK CITES regulations, probably little to
none in terms of general information, but for people from the UK, that's an
important link to bookmark.

I had somebody suggest that certificate thing to me as way to provide
"proof" who needed it. He did say, it would be meaningless, but if it makes
people feel good and sell plants. Actually a certificate stating that my
plants come from Antec and their association with the USBG is the same thing
as putting that statement in writing on the receipt and signing it. If it
is a true statement, it's a true statement, if it is not then it is fraud
and it has to be proven such by a conviction. You don't get extra jail time
for committing fraud in gold leaf script on velum parchment, do you?


"Nancy G." wrote in message
oups.com...

And mo
Does anybody really read any of this crap? :-)

Yes, as a matter of fact we do.

http://www.usbg.gov/plant-collection...ietnamense.cfm

http://www.cites.org/common/com/PC/1...rtificate %22

http://pollenatrix.blogspot.com/2003...im-really.html

http://www.rbgkew.org.uk/conservatio...e%20legally%22

I actually think the certificate people have mentioned to you started
out as a marketing ploy by other sellers, a way to reassure potential
customers. Possibly wasn't deliberate but then again, if they (other
sellers) can make the buyer paranoid or doubtful as to the integrity of
other sellers or source of the product, then by reason they should be
able to sell more. I saw a blurb about the certificate, it may have
been about Phrag kovachii, later confused with Paph vietnamense, but
the effect was the same. If it will endanger my collection or send me
to prison, do I want to buy a plant without the certificate?

What the heck, for $12 anyone can buy a package of parchment paper and
using power point, print a certificate. It may increase the value and
be reflected in the price. I received or printed them for all
occasions. I had templates for all occasions, Certificates of
Completion for training, Certificates of Appreciation, etc.

Would you want to provide a certificate? Probably not, but then you
probably could if you wanted. If you do, keep it pompous and obscure
like Navy certificates. I've seen those for "plank owners", crossing
the equator, and polar bears for north of the arctic circle. "Hear
yea, Hear yea. Let all citizens, government officials, and A.O.S
judges, know by sight and sound that (insert person's name here) has
legally purchased a (plant name here) of X# divisions on (this date).
Said plant was propagated in vitro by (insert lab name here) under the
auspices of the United States Botanical Gardens with approval by
C.I.T.E.S. from impounded or imported plants, satisfying the
international agreements in effect. The plant described above was
purchased on the open market from (insert name here) . ....

You could probably make a fortune printing new certificates as the
plants grew, updating the number of divisions for your customers.
Anyway they look really good with red and gold scroll. ;-)

Of course, it would lead to the question on how you could trace a
single certificate to an individual plant anyway. It's not as if you
could take a print or tattoo a leaf. I'm just looking forward to the
day when I can afford to buy one and risk its early demise.

Nancy