View Single Post
  #5   Report Post  
Old 24-09-2007, 07:50 PM posted to austin.gardening
[email protected] Julie@BartonSellsAustin.com is offline
external usenet poster
 
First recorded activity by GardenBanter: Sep 2007
Posts: 4
Default Live Oak - Move or Remove Help

On Sep 24, 9:48 am, Omelet wrote:
In article . com,





wrote:
On Sep 24, 12:49 am, "Dave" wrote:
wrote in message


roups.com...


Hi all, I need some advice regarding a live oak that was carelessly
planted too close to the back of our house by a previous owner. The
tree is now about 20 ft tall and blocks the view from our deck - and
we have to make some sort of decision. Can anyone help?


1. Can the tree be moved?
2. Should we just cut it down and plant another (or more) further
away from the house?
3. Can anyone recommend a good service to help with either of these
choices?


Thanks in advance, everyone!


J


In this part of the woods, I doubt if the owner planted the live oak.
Probably purposely avoided cutting same. Original part of the property.


I'd be happy with such a tree. If its blocking your view of a the panorama,
consider it a tax break. Undoubtedly, part of your property tax has a view
as taxable.


Seen on some educational TV channels moving large trees to other locations
with specialized equipment for that purpose.


Unless you have a holy mission, like viewing a nudee, don't bother cutting
the tree.


Anyone can cut down a tree. Not anyone can plant a tree that will continue
to grow.
Dave


It was most definitely (and quite obviously) planted. It's still
relatively young, too. We live in Lakeway and in a fairly new
construction home - there are two trees behind the house that were
planted by the previous owner, and this is one of them. It may not be
a live oak, but it is an oak of some sort.


As I said, we don't want to cut it down, we'd rather move it. It is
directly blocking the view of the lake, and is just plain too close to
the house and our septic. Not good for the tree or the house or the
septic.


Thanks for the thoughtful response, though, and if you have a
recommendation on a good tree service I appreciate it.


Julie


Once it gets taller, you can prune lower branches and it will no longer
block the view of the lake and the shade for your deck is valuable.

How close is it to the septic system? If you have 10 ft. of clearance,
you should be fine. Less might be ok too, that is a conservative
estimate.
--
Peace, Om

Remove _ to validate e-mails.

"Human nature seems to be to control other people until they put their foot down." -- Steve Rothstein- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -


It will probably take quite a while to grow to a height where we can
thin it out. Right now it's quite young and just "bushy." I have
thought about thinning it, just not sure how much good it will do.

The septic is about 5 feet away, the house foundation about 3. Not
well thought out.

I don't like to cut down trees, despise it, really. If we wind up
cutting down this one we'll plant two the same size in the greenbelt
behind the house!

J