View Single Post
  #2   Report Post  
Old 16-11-2010, 10:56 AM
echinosum echinosum is offline
Registered User
 
First recorded activity by GardenBanter: Feb 2006
Location: Chalfont St Giles
Posts: 1,340
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Julian200 View Post
Hi, I have a Red Falstaff apple tree I planted last year, it produced two apples this year, a few weeks ago I noticed a soft patch in the truck about two foot from the ground, is this a disease and should I cut the trunk off below this.
It does look like a canker. You can in principle cut out the bad material, treat the cut surface with suitable chemicals, and then get regrowth around the wound. Web search will provide details.

But I had a young apple tree where the canker went around 90% of the trunk about 2 foot off the ground, and the restriction of supply of sap to the upper part of the tree was so severe that there was hardly any growth, even though the canker was not active any more. If the good flesh was going to regrow back around the wound, it was clearly going to take a very long time, and there were several more cankers formed on the trunk as well. I discussed cutting off the upper part of the tree to let it regrow below the canker with a leading nurseryman. He said it would work, but in general he wasn't very enthusiastic, mainly because he was concerned I would get a very odd shaped tree. But I did it anyway, and the tree is now growing strongly and giving me apples, and isn't such an odd shape apart from a slight wiggle in the trunk at the lopping site. Several buds formed, but once a clear strongest branch was established I cut the rest off to have a single-trunked tree. But I think I did had to wait about 3 years before it gave me anything after that lopping. Yours is so young that planting a new one might be quicker. In fact the nursery might give you a new one for getting such a bad canker so quickly, if you ask nicely - mine was 4 or 5 when I lopped it.

I planted a substitute tree in case it didn't work. So now I have an extra tree.

Make sure that if you do cut it off, that you cut it off well above the graft, otherwise you'll be growing rootstock, not Red Falstaff.