View Single Post
  #4   Report Post  
Old 09-10-2011, 09:42 PM posted to rec.gardens
David Hare-Scott[_2_] David Hare-Scott[_2_] is offline
external usenet poster
 
First recorded activity by GardenBanter: Sep 2008
Posts: 3,036
Default a level product design questionnaire

Kaiser fuel wrote:
'David Hare-Scott[_2_ Wrote:
;939096']Kaiser fuel wrote:-
This is just a quick questionnaire about a solar powered watering
system i am hoping to make. please just write your answers in posts.
thank you for your time.

1. Would you consider purchasing a solar powered watering system for
the garden?

Yes No+-

No. I notice that you are not at all interested in my reason why.
Odd.
-

2. What size is your garden?
-
4m2 5m2-10m2 11m2-15m2 15m2+--

Much bigger
-

3. How often do you water the garden?

Everyday Every other day Twice a week

Once a week Never-

When it is necessary, which is not some particular time interval.
-

4. Would you like the system to be modular (you can add on extra
parts when you need to)?

Yes No-

Watering systems are already extensible, why would you not have that
feature?
-

5. How much would you be willing to pay for the product?

£20-30 £31-40 £41-50 £50+
-

$0 since I have no idea what the capabilities of the system are.
-
6. Would you like it to blend in with the garden or stand out?

Blend in Stand out-

In what part of the world are watering systems a fashion statement?
Are you
harbouring a fetish for black polypipe? A warning: polypipe doesn't
carry
water when it is kinky.
-

7. Would you like the system to water automatically at certain times
of the day?

Yes No-

No, that presupposes the garden needs watering.
-

8. How old are you?
-
20 21-30 31-40 41-60 61-70 70+--

Too old to have much patience with such a silly survey.

You haven't mentioned any reason why one might want a solar powered
watering
system. Consider where water comes from. For city dwellers in
developed
countries (most readers here) it comes out of a tap at enough
pressure to be
delivered through a passive watering system. So that means a high
proportion (my guess 90%) of readers have no need for your product.

For others water comes from a well, dam, tank, or a natural body of
water.
Such people probably have pumping and delivery systems to get the
water to
the garden but they might be interested in using solar energy to
power the
pump. Why would they do that? Well, it _might_ be cheaper or more
sustainable, or be available where there is no electricity. Would
your

system suit any of them? From your description there is no way of
knowing.
So who are you going to get interested in this? I don't know.


David


From these results I can deduce that the majority of the people
surveyed were miserable gits who enjoy taking time to crush the
dreams of aspiring product designers. This will influence my product
greatly and it was very useful to future product development of the
product. *NOT*


I understand you feel bad being told your baby is ugly - get used to it - if
you are going to expect agreement with your pre-conceived ideas you are
going to get that a lot. If you are immune to learning something from a
person who actually waters large gardens in a demanding environment and has
built watering systems then this product doesn't have any future to develop.

For example Q3 shows you don't understand at least one basic concept of
watering. Why would that information not influence you?

The smart thing would be to engage with those who criticise and revise your
thinking accordingly not complain because their feedback doesn't match your
dream. You can take your bat and ball and go home or remove the blinkers
and try again. You decide.

David