GardenBanter.co.uk - View Single Post

Tom Gardner[_2_] · 03-06-2012, 01:11 PM posted to uk.rec.gardening

wrote in :

In article 2,
Tom Gardner wrote:
echinosum wrote in
:

Actually parasol is one of the safer ones as it is relatively hard to
mistake a parasol for something else, provided you have seen a few
parasols and someone who knows has confirmed it to you. They are quite
distinctive once you have seen a few and know that is what they are. So
it is the parasol you should have eaten with confidence, provided you
had good reason to be confident, not the mushroom which is much easier
to mistake for something else.

I've eaten parasols and shaggy parasols. Both were
delicious, but the /second/ time I ate shaggy parasols
my digestive tract rebelled violently. Possible difference:
the second ones were growing under a laurel.

Vanishingly unlikely to be the cause.

Oh, I'm unconvinced as well!

Did you have any alcohol with the latter :-)

Not that I can remember, but it was 10 years ago.

I don't recall reading about any antabuse effects
with shaggy parasols, but as you say...

I have had that effect with what I was absolutely certain was not
the antabuse species, so I suspect that there may be a shaggy one
that includes a small amount of the same toxin. Whether it is
that the normal one can occasionally do so, there is another
so-far unseparated (sub-)species, or my speculation is wrong,
God alone knows. Anyway, mere short-term gutrot isn't something
worth worrying about.

I only worry about it in the short term