GardenBanter.co.uk

GardenBanter.co.uk (https://www.gardenbanter.co.uk/)
-   Freshwater Aquaria Plants (https://www.gardenbanter.co.uk/freshwater-aquaria-plants/)
-   -   About NUTRAFIN CO2 Natural Plant System (https://www.gardenbanter.co.uk/freshwater-aquaria-plants/15867-about-nutrafin-co2-natural-plant-system.html)

Francisco Caamaño 20-04-2003 06:11 AM

About NUTRAFIN CO2 Natural Plant System
 
I had a DIY CO2 and it kept giving me problems, has anybody used the
NUTRAFIN CO2 Natural Plant System ??? is it any good ????


http://www.hagen.com/canada/english/...co2system.html


Thanks ...



LeighMo 20-04-2003 06:11 AM

About NUTRAFIN CO2 Natural Plant System
 
I had a DIY CO2 and it kept giving me problems, has anybody used the
NUTRAFIN CO2 Natural Plant System ??? is it any good ????



It sounds like an expensive version of DIY to me.


Leigh

http://www.fortunecity.com/lavender/halloween/881/

Dave Millman 20-04-2003 06:11 AM

About NUTRAFIN CO2 Natural Plant System
 
"Francisco Caamaño" wrote:

I had a DIY CO2 and it kept giving me problems, has anybody used the
NUTRAFIN CO2 Natural Plant System ??? is it any good ????

http://www.hagen.com/canada/english/...co2system.html


Please note that the Nutrafin system is a manufactured system which does
exactly what your DIY system does. The two packages contain yeast and
sodium bicarbonate, and you supply your own sugar. Given that you
already know how to mix yeast and sugar, you might not be too happy to
pay their price for the little packets.

Enough people have problems with diffusing CO2 that it might be worth it
just for the bubble counter/diffuser module, if it was cheap enough!


Francisco Caamaño 20-04-2003 06:11 AM

About NUTRAFIN CO2 Natural Plant System
 
before I had as diffuser a powerhead like in this image
http://www3.sympatico.ca/c1000mg/aquarium/figure1.gif and I had good CO2
level but I had a growing white fungus at the botton where the CO2 was
coming out.... !!!! you can see this picture
http://www3.sympatico.ca/c1000mg/aqu...problem005.jpg and now I don't
have the undergravel filter how else can I make a diffuser in a cheap way
???? I also tryed the bell but it didn't give me good CO2 Level....



"LeighMo" wrote in message
...
I had a DIY CO2 and it kept giving me problems, has anybody used the
NUTRAFIN CO2 Natural Plant System ??? is it any good ????



It sounds like an expensive version of DIY to me.


Leigh

http://www.fortunecity.com/lavender/halloween/881/




Aqua 20-04-2003 06:11 AM

About NUTRAFIN CO2 Natural Plant System
 
I am using Duetto DJ-50 internal filter for diffusing CO2. Its a very small
filter with an option to inject air line. I have a picture of it in my
article

http://www.dlink.org/aqua/CO2.html

--
Thank You

Dominic
http://www.dlink.org/aqua

I just coincidently happen to see one of these things in action while
at the LFS store today. The first thing I noticed was the CO2 bubble
mover system inside the tank. It's very cool to watch....but, the
more I thought about it, the more it seems like this type of diffusion
wouldn't be any better than a 'bell' type diffuser....maybe worse?
The bubble just reaches the top and goes to the surface :(

The canister was nice tho. Maybe too small for a larger tank but
perfect for something like a 5-10..maybe 20 gallon.

My little 1L reactor is pllumbed into the bottom of the venturi of my
power filter and is giving me 20-28ppm. I can't imagine doing much
better....actually, any higher would be a concern :)





RifRaf 20-04-2003 06:11 AM

About NUTRAFIN CO2 Natural Plant System
 
I actualy considered using a DJ-50 when first trying to figure out how
I was gonna dissolve the CO2. I got impatient with myself ;) and just
wanted to get *something* going and finally stuck the end of the
airline at the end of the intake tube of the power filter.

It ended up working SO well I've just forgotten about looking more
into finding a hi-tek diffuser.

Chris

On Mon, 4 Nov 2002 20:06:04 -0500, "Aqua"
wrote:

I am using Duetto DJ-50 internal filter for diffusing CO2. Its a very small
filter with an option to inject air line. I have a picture of it in my
article

http://www.dlink.org/aqua/CO2.html




-----------== Posted via Newsfeed.Com - Uncensored Usenet News ==----------
http://www.newsfeed.com The #1 Newsgroup Service in the World!
-----= Over 100,000 Newsgroups - Unlimited Fast Downloads - 19 Servers =-----

kush 20-04-2003 06:11 AM

About NUTRAFIN CO2 Natural Plant System
 
If you can't use a powerhead, you can try snaking the end of the diffuser
line into the intake tube of your canister filter, or whatever. The CO2
will be entirely resorbed into the water by the time it comes out the
outflow tube. This method will, however, make a few filters (i.e., mine)
rattle.

kush

"You can't have everything - where would you put it?"

Francisco Caamaño wrote in message
.. .
before I had as diffuser a powerhead like in this image
http://www3.sympatico.ca/c1000mg/aquarium/figure1.gif and I had good CO2
level but I had a growing white fungus at the botton where the CO2 was
coming out.... !!!! you can see this picture
http://www3.sympatico.ca/c1000mg/aqu...problem005.jpg and now I don't
have the undergravel filter how else can I make a diffuser in a cheap way
???? I also tryed the bell but it didn't give me good CO2 Level....



"LeighMo" wrote in message
...
I had a DIY CO2 and it kept giving me problems, has anybody used the
NUTRAFIN CO2 Natural Plant System ??? is it any good ????



It sounds like an expensive version of DIY to me.


Leigh

http://www.fortunecity.com/lavender/halloween/881/






Steve Galupe 20-04-2003 06:11 AM

About NUTRAFIN CO2 Natural Plant System
 
Locally here, it's expensive. CAD$60! I got a 10lbs cylinder(w/ CO2) for
$25, needle valve for $30, and hosing and reactor for around $10. You have
an almost maintenance free CO2 system.

"Francisco Caamaño" wrote in message
.. .
I had a DIY CO2 and it kept giving me problems, has anybody used the
NUTRAFIN CO2 Natural Plant System ??? is it any good ????


http://www.hagen.com/canada/english/...co2system.html


Thanks ...





Steve Galupe 20-04-2003 06:11 AM

About NUTRAFIN CO2 Natural Plant System
 
For some reason, DIY CO2 will always do that. I used a wooden airstone that
deformed and was almost covered by the same stuff.

"Francisco Caamaño" wrote in message
.. .
before I had as diffuser a powerhead like in this image
http://www3.sympatico.ca/c1000mg/aquarium/figure1.gif and I had good CO2
level but I had a growing white fungus at the botton where the CO2 was
coming out.... !!!! you can see this picture
http://www3.sympatico.ca/c1000mg/aqu...problem005.jpg and now I don't
have the undergravel filter how else can I make a diffuser in a cheap way
???? I also tryed the bell but it didn't give me good CO2 Level....



"LeighMo" wrote in message
...
I had a DIY CO2 and it kept giving me problems, has anybody used the
NUTRAFIN CO2 Natural Plant System ??? is it any good ????



It sounds like an expensive version of DIY to me.


Leigh

http://www.fortunecity.com/lavender/halloween/881/






E. Mito 20-04-2003 06:11 AM

About NUTRAFIN CO2 Natural Plant System
 
In article , "Steve Galupe"
writes:

For some reason, DIY CO2 will always do that. I used a wooden airstone that
deformed and was almost covered by the same stuff.


Interesting thing about the white stuff (bacterial or fungal colonization, I
think?)...I noticed some of it starting to develop on a new setup I just put
together and the snails seem to like eating it...sort of weird.

Erica
http://members.aol.com/_ht_a/mitoem/mitoem/index.htm


David Marshburn 20-04-2003 06:11 AM

About NUTRAFIN CO2 Natural Plant System
 
kush wrote:
: If you can't use a powerhead, you can try snaking the end of the diffuser
: line into the intake tube of your canister filter, or whatever. The CO2
: will be entirely resorbed into the water by the time it comes out the
: outflow tube. This method will, however, make a few filters (i.e., mine)
: rattle.

Any idea if the same sort of scheme would work for an over-the-back power
filter? I sort of doubt it, but am not experienced with CO2 systems.
Maybe introducing the CO2 under the filter media would work?

cheers,
-david

Florian 20-04-2003 06:11 AM

About NUTRAFIN CO2 Natural Plant System
 
David Marshburn writes:

kush wrote:
: If you can't use a powerhead, you can try snaking the end of the
: diffuser line into the intake tube of your canister filter, or
: whatever. The CO2 will be entirely resorbed into the water by the
: time it comes out the outflow tube. This method will, however,
: make a few filters (i.e., mine) rattle.

Any idea if the same sort of scheme would work for an over-the-back
power filter? I sort of doubt it, but am not experienced with CO2
systems. Maybe introducing the CO2 under the filter media would
work?


I experimented with this last week. I drilled a 3/8" hole in the side
of a spare intake tube for my AquaClear 150, tapered the end of an
airline from my DIY CO2 yeast culture, and worked it in.

It seemed quite effective; I got a pH drop from ~8.2 to ~7.0 in the 7
gallon tank (~6 gal water volume), compared to the ~7.6 pH I get just
letting the CO2 gently bubble out of an airstone. The CO2 bubbles
hitting the impeller made bubbly noises, of course. Also, there was a
fair bit of suction, so be careful if using a soft-walled
(collapsible) bottle for your yeast culture.
--
odoratusque est Dominus odorem suavitatis

RifRaf 20-04-2003 06:11 AM

About NUTRAFIN CO2 Natural Plant System
 

I'm also using an AQ150 with the tube tappered off feeding the bottom
of the tube.
I normally measure about 25'ish ppm....granted, this is a 5 gal tank

I keep the filter turned down to its lowest flow rating (to reduce
surface agitation and eddies) so there's absolutely NO suction
happening. I don't think it even happens at higher levels....don't
even see *how* this could be happeing to others.
I didn't drill a hole in the tube. I just have the bubbles entering
the slits in the bottom of the tube so there's really NO WAY enuf
suction can be built-up this way....and it works perfectly.

Chris

On 05 Nov 2002 01:10:03 -0600, Florian wrote:

David Marshburn writes:

kush wrote:
: If you can't use a powerhead, you can try snaking the end of the
: diffuser line into the intake tube of your canister filter, or
: whatever. The CO2 will be entirely resorbed into the water by the
: time it comes out the outflow tube. This method will, however,
: make a few filters (i.e., mine) rattle.

Any idea if the same sort of scheme would work for an over-the-back
power filter? I sort of doubt it, but am not experienced with CO2
systems. Maybe introducing the CO2 under the filter media would
work?


I experimented with this last week. I drilled a 3/8" hole in the side
of a spare intake tube for my AquaClear 150, tapered the end of an
airline from my DIY CO2 yeast culture, and worked it in.

It seemed quite effective; I got a pH drop from ~8.2 to ~7.0 in the 7
gallon tank (~6 gal water volume), compared to the ~7.6 pH I get just
letting the CO2 gently bubble out of an airstone. The CO2 bubbles
hitting the impeller made bubbly noises, of course. Also, there was a
fair bit of suction, so be careful if using a soft-walled
(collapsible) bottle for your yeast culture.




-----------== Posted via Newsfeed.Com - Uncensored Usenet News ==----------
http://www.newsfeed.com The #1 Newsgroup Service in the World!
-----= Over 100,000 Newsgroups - Unlimited Fast Downloads - 19 Servers =-----

kush 20-04-2003 06:11 AM

About NUTRAFIN CO2 Natural Plant System
 
I won't use an airstone just for that reason. I THINK the substance itself
is benign, but it affects the bubble size, eventually cancelling out the
benefit of using the stone over just having an uncapped line. Someone
recently suggested using the disposables. I just introduce the CO2 in ways
that don't require a stone, diffusion chamber and powerhead injection.

kush

"You can't have everything - where would you put it?"

E. Mito wrote in message
...
In article , "Steve Galupe"
writes:

For some reason, DIY CO2 will always do that. I used a wooden airstone

that
deformed and was almost covered by the same stuff.


Interesting thing about the white stuff (bacterial or fungal colonization,

I
think?)...I noticed some of it starting to develop on a new setup I just

put
together and the snails seem to like eating it...sort of weird.

Erica
http://members.aol.com/_ht_a/mitoem/mitoem/index.htm




Dave 20-04-2003 06:11 AM

About NUTRAFIN CO2 Natural Plant System
 
I use a Duetto DJ-50 internal filter in my heavily-planted 29gal tank:

http://www.animalnetwork.com/fish2/a...ct/default.asp

I attached the CO2 line to the hose barb. I wasn't getting quite the CO2
dissolution that I wanted, so I rigged up a plastic cup to redirect some of
the output back to the input. Basically just cut a notch out of a
large plastic cup, inverted the cup and pushed it over filter. Works
great now.

In , "Francisco Caamaño"
empowered us with this mighty blow against the
Patriarchy:

before I had as diffuser a powerhead like in this image
http://www3.sympatico.ca/c1000mg/aquarium/figure1.gif and I had good CO2
level but I had a growing white fungus at the botton where the CO2 was
coming out.... !!!! you can see this picture
http://www3.sympatico.ca/c1000mg/aqu...problem005.jpg and now I don't
have the undergravel filter how else can I make a diffuser in a cheap way
???? I also tryed the bell but it didn't give me good CO2 Level....



"LeighMo" wrote in message
...
I had a DIY CO2 and it kept giving me problems, has anybody used the
NUTRAFIN CO2 Natural Plant System ??? is it any good ????



It sounds like an expensive version of DIY to me.


Leigh

http://www.fortunecity.com/lavender/halloween/881/





Rich Conley 20-04-2003 06:11 AM

About NUTRAFIN CO2 Natural Plant System
 
where did you get a CO2 tank....been thinkning of setting up CO2...but dont
want to deal with changing it every week...and possible issues with yeast
releasing alchohol in my tank....

Steve Galupe wrote:

Locally here, it's expensive. CAD$60! I got a 10lbs cylinder(w/ CO2) for
$25, needle valve for $30, and hosing and reactor for around $10. You have
an almost maintenance free CO2 system.

"Francisco Caamaño" wrote in message
.. .
I had a DIY CO2 and it kept giving me problems, has anybody used the
NUTRAFIN CO2 Natural Plant System ??? is it any good ????


http://www.hagen.com/canada/english/...co2system.html


Thanks ...




Dave 20-04-2003 06:11 AM

About NUTRAFIN CO2 Natural Plant System
 
In , Rich Conley
empowered us with this mighty blow against the
Patriarchy:

where did you get a CO2 tank....been thinkning of setting up CO2...but
dont want to deal with changing it every week...


Aw, I only change mine every two weeks. ;-)

and possible issues
with yeast releasing alchohol in my tank....


The only way that could happen is if the mix got into the tank, and you'd
need to either kick over the container or have some strong suction at the
other end of the line to pull in the mix. Yeah, people have reported these
kinds of things happening, but they're pretty rare and very easy to avoid.

But anyway ;-) ....

http://www.wcf.com/co2iron/

Aqua 20-04-2003 06:11 AM

About NUTRAFIN CO2 Natural Plant System
 
Recently I setup a CO2 tank. Here is the info
http://www.dlink.org/aqua/CO2.html

--
Thank You

Dominic
http://www.dlink.org/aqua

"Rich Conley" wrote in message
...
where did you get a CO2 tank....been thinkning of setting up CO2...but

dont
want to deal with changing it every week...and possible issues with yeast
releasing alchohol in my tank....

Steve Galupe wrote:

Locally here, it's expensive. CAD$60! I got a 10lbs cylinder(w/ CO2)

for
$25, needle valve for $30, and hosing and reactor for around $10. You

have
an almost maintenance free CO2 system.

"Francisco Caamaño" wrote in message
.. .
I had a DIY CO2 and it kept giving me problems, has anybody used the
NUTRAFIN CO2 Natural Plant System ??? is it any good ????


http://www.hagen.com/canada/english/...co2system.html


Thanks ...






Rich Conley 20-04-2003 06:11 AM

About NUTRAFIN CO2 Natural Plant System
 
Could use use a cylinder from a Paintball gun? I know most of the lower end
ones use CO2....some of the big guys use nitrogen...or compressed air....bt
most just use CO2.....what do you think?

Aqua wrote:

Recently I setup a CO2 tank. Here is the info
http://www.dlink.org/aqua/CO2.html

--
Thank You

Dominic
http://www.dlink.org/aqua

"Rich Conley" wrote in message
...
where did you get a CO2 tank....been thinkning of setting up CO2...but

dont
want to deal with changing it every week...and possible issues with yeast
releasing alchohol in my tank....

Steve Galupe wrote:

Locally here, it's expensive. CAD$60! I got a 10lbs cylinder(w/ CO2)

for
$25, needle valve for $30, and hosing and reactor for around $10. You

have
an almost maintenance free CO2 system.

"Francisco Caamaño" wrote in message
.. .
I had a DIY CO2 and it kept giving me problems, has anybody used the
NUTRAFIN CO2 Natural Plant System ??? is it any good ????


http://www.hagen.com/canada/english/...co2system.html


Thanks ...





Da' Fishboy 20-04-2003 06:12 AM

About NUTRAFIN CO2 Natural Plant System
 
The fuzzy looking growth that you see is mostly likely a yeast culture. The
"spray" from the yeast culture releases a small amount of yeast spores in to
the CO2. You can see these particals dance into the water during a
release of built up CO2 gases.

I have used both aquaclear method and a hose into the intake of a power
head. I use a penguin 660R powerhead with sponge filter attached. I can
place this under the water surface and it does a great job of diffusing the
CO2 w/o to much annoying rattle. The aquaclear solution just about drove me
batty. lol

My two cents,


Earl
"Francisco Caamaño" wrote in message
.. .
I had a DIY CO2 and it kept giving me problems, has anybody used the
NUTRAFIN CO2 Natural Plant System ??? is it any good ????


http://www.hagen.com/canada/english/...co2system.html


Thanks ...





redled 20-04-2003 06:12 AM

About NUTRAFIN CO2 Natural Plant System
 
In both my 10 and 55 gallon tanks I just use the upturned cup method and it
works very well. If you can figure out the right amount of surface area, you
can make it so that the CO2 level remains very constant, and there's no danger
of over injecting because any time you put in more than the cup can hold it
just bubbles out. Also, surface area of the cup, not volume, is important, so
it is easy to make a small, inconspicuous system for your tank if you use
something that's shallow at the top of your tank, like part of a tupperware
container. I put mine under the outflow of my overhang filters. I think that
the greater water flow here makes the system more efficient. Oh yeah, the
main reason why I use this method is it makes no noise.

In article , "Da' Fishboy"
wrote:
The fuzzy looking growth that you see is mostly likely a yeast culture. The
"spray" from the yeast culture releases a small amount of yeast spores in to
the CO2. You can see these particals dance into the water during a
release of built up CO2 gases.

I have used both aquaclear method and a hose into the intake of a power
head. I use a penguin 660R powerhead with sponge filter attached. I can
place this under the water surface and it does a great job of diffusing the
CO2 w/o to much annoying rattle. The aquaclear solution just about drove me
batty. lol

My two cents,


Earl
"Francisco Caamaño" wrote in message
. ..
I had a DIY CO2 and it kept giving me problems, has anybody used the
NUTRAFIN CO2 Natural Plant System ??? is it any good ????


http://www.hagen.com/canada/english/...co2system.html


Thanks ...





__
"Insert witty comment here."
-John

Haywire 20-04-2003 06:14 AM

About NUTRAFIN CO2 Natural Plant System
 
OK,

it's been a few days, I peaked at 7 bubbles in the "diffuser" after that my
CO2 bubbles are by-passing the "diffuser". Going to remove the plastic
diffuser and clean it, might be something near invisible blocking the outlet
for the plastic hose.

"Haywire" wrote in message
able.rogers.com...
Just set the unit up,

instructions say that it should start making CO2 in about 2hrs, It's been
that, pressure is quite low, but it's there it's moved down the line about
1/2 an inch. I'll keep you all posted in the next few days to see it

makes
a difference. Kit also came with fertiliser which I won't use till next
week.



"Francisco Caamaño" wrote in message
.. .
I had a DIY CO2 and it kept giving me problems, has anybody used the
NUTRAFIN CO2 Natural Plant System ??? is it any good ????


http://www.hagen.com/canada/english/...co2system.html


Thanks ...







KerryA 20-04-2003 06:14 AM

About NUTRAFIN CO2 Natural Plant System
 
Anyone had one of these for a while?

How long does the yeast/nutriant kit last? Anyone use the setup with a DIY
yeast setup yet??



Haywire 20-04-2003 06:14 AM

About NUTRAFIN CO2 Natural Plant System
 
packaging says 2 weeks I'm getting close to it, I haven't noticed anything
dramatic yet, may have some growth on the brazilian micro swords which is a
good thing :)

I don't plan on buying the yeast packs as the DIY recipes are really easy.

"KerryA" wrote in message
...
Anyone had one of these for a while?

How long does the yeast/nutriant kit last? Anyone use the setup with a DIY
yeast setup yet??





Bruce Butz 20-04-2003 06:14 AM

About NUTRAFIN CO2 Natural Plant System
 
I just set one up tonight.LFS guy says if the
little spout at the end of the tube is not angled
just right the bubbles will bypass the diffuser.
I will let you know how mine does.

I assume the "stabilizer" is baking soda?
It does not say what type of yeast is in the
"activator" I bet it is champaign yeast if it is supposed to last 28
days.

Has anyone tried to use the diffuser with a regular 2L DIY bottle?

Bruce


http://community.webtv.net/BruBz/BrucesBeatlePage


Philip Ash 20-04-2003 06:14 AM

About NUTRAFIN CO2 Natural Plant System
 
I just got one of these today.
Isaw one working on the LFS plant tank, and was impressed by the efficiency
of the diffuser.
I can see no reason why it shouldnt work with a 2L bottle.
Probably worth investing the 15 gbp it cost to get the decent diffuser and a
'safer' introduction to CO2.
I too will use my own recipe once the sachets are used up.
Mine hasnt even started producing yet, (its only been setup 30mins lol) but
i tried blowing a bubble into my diffuser and it just seemed to stick there.
Maybe it isnt level etc yet, i will play once i start production.
We should keep exhanging info about these seeing as there are several of us
just starting out, and they are a new product and all.


Phil.




"Bruce Butz" wrote in message
...
I just set one up tonight.LFS guy says if the
little spout at the end of the tube is not angled
just right the bubbles will bypass the diffuser.
I will let you know how mine does.

I assume the "stabilizer" is baking soda?
It does not say what type of yeast is in the
"activator" I bet it is champaign yeast if it is supposed to last 28
days.

Has anyone tried to use the diffuser with a regular 2L DIY bottle?

Bruce


http://community.webtv.net/BruBz/BrucesBeatlePage




Bruce Butz 20-04-2003 06:14 AM

About NUTRAFIN CO2 Natural Plant System
 
Phil: My first load was a dud,24 hours no bubbles.So I started over.This
time with half as much "stabilizer" (baking soda) as I have very hard
water. This time I got bubbles after three
hours.It's been five days and I am getting steady bubbles at the rate of
one every five seconds.
I also like the bubble counter/diffuser a lot.
After years of messing around with injecting into the filter
intake(noisy) Using cut off one ltr.
bottles with holes in them (ugly and inefficient)
I would recommend the diffuser by it's self
to others who use DIY Co2.
You can buy the diffuser by its self from Big Als.
I think it is $11.
Kind of looks cool too.

Bruce


http://community.webtv.net/BruBz/BrucesBeatlePage


Philip Ash 20-04-2003 06:14 AM

About NUTRAFIN CO2 Natural Plant System
 
"Bruce Butz" wrote in message
...
Phil: My first load was a dud,24 hours no bubbles.So I started over.This
time with half as much "stabilizer" (baking soda) as I have very hard
water. This time I got bubbles after three
hours.It's been five days and I am getting steady bubbles at the rate of
one every five seconds.
I also like the bubble counter/diffuser a lot.
After years of messing around with injecting into the filter
intake(noisy) Using cut off one ltr.
bottles with holes in them (ugly and inefficient)
I would recommend the diffuser by it's self
to others who use DIY Co2.
You can buy the diffuser by its self from Big Als.
I think it is $11.


Ditto. My first batch, nada. I remade a batch with half stabilser and within
2 hours nice regular bubbles.
I cleaned the diffuser under hot water , no detergent, and it flows nicely
now.
My bubbles dont seem to be getting any smaller as they reach the top though,
(as i observed at the LFS).
But they are in contact with the water for a decent amount of time. I might
still be pushing air out from the tube? It hasnt been runnig too long yet :)
This is the last stage of a real effort to keep some plants going properly.
I had some beard/hair algae before, which i have eliminated as well as i
can.
I have upgraded the lighting, switched to RO (i have high nitrates and
phosphates in my tap supply) and now added some CO2.
I just hope the algae doesnt come back ! I only kept two of my old plants
(Echnidorus Ozelot) and bought 20 new ones.
I also added some ProAqua plant food and halved the stocking density of
fish. Lets hope they thrive now.
I have certainly seen some growth even within the last few days.( I only
added plants on Wednesday)
And that was without CO2.

Plants have always been my weak point. Now fish, they are easy ! lol

Phil.





Cichlidiot 20-04-2003 06:14 AM

About NUTRAFIN CO2 Natural Plant System
 
I got one of these on a whim the other week because I could more likely
convince my roommates to allow it than DIY. I also only wanted moderate
CO2 injection since it's for a rift lake tank. It seemed to me at first
like it wasn't producing, but then I noticed the issue. The water pressure
was just too much for the CO2 to push all the water out of the tubing. I
took a 6mL feeding syringe which was just the right size for the tubing
and used it to push all the water out. Then I pinched the line closed as
much as possible before putting it back on the canister. Within minutes, I
had bubbling going.

One thing I have noticed that deviates from the LFS setup of this system I
saw is that my bubbles get stuck mid-way up the diffuser. I'm not
complaining much. This allows more contact time between the CO2 and water.
I think the reason is that I don't have the diffuser perfectly straight on
the side of the glass. It is slightly tilting down on the side away from
the CO2 tubing.

I do have to say even though I'm only getting moderate CO2 injection (I
have just one unit on a 40 gal, about 2-3 bubbles per minute) I am seeing
the results. Within a couple days of putting it in, all 10-20ppm of
nitrates from the tap water were sucked away (main reason I put plants in
a rift lake tank). The crypts stopped melting and started to pearl and put
up new leaves and runners. The java ferns are putting out plantlets and
new leaves like crazy. Now a couple weeks later, my algae problem is under
wraps. There's still a thin layer of green algae on the rocks and tank
sides, but nothing near the algae mess there was at first (which was
another reason I decided to follow my whim and try this system.. at $30,
it couldn't hurt to try it to see if the algae would be controlled).

I hope to have some updated pictures on this tank's website to show the
system at work, but I need to get some film for my SLR, so it'll be a week
at least. If you want to see how the tank looked when it was freshly set
up, the URL is http://www.shwaine.com/fish_40g.html. There's been
considerable growth in the crypts (the tallest ones are just about as tall
as the rock pile now) since adding the CO2, although I may pull the
aponogeton bulbs. They just aren't happy even with the CO2 it seems.

Bruce Butz wrote:
Phil: My first load was a dud,24 hours no bubbles.So I started over.This
time with half as much "stabilizer" (baking soda) as I have very hard
water. This time I got bubbles after three
hours.It's been five days and I am getting steady bubbles at the rate of
one every five seconds.
I also like the bubble counter/diffuser a lot.
After years of messing around with injecting into the filter
intake(noisy) Using cut off one ltr.
bottles with holes in them (ugly and inefficient)
I would recommend the diffuser by it's self
to others who use DIY Co2.
You can buy the diffuser by its self from Big Als.
I think it is $11.
Kind of looks cool too.


Bruce



http://community.webtv.net/BruBz/BrucesBeatlePage



Phil Dietz 20-04-2003 06:14 AM

About NUTRAFIN CO2 Natural Plant System
 
"Philip Ash" wrote in message ...
My bubbles dont seem to be getting any smaller as they reach the top though,
(as i observed at the LFS).



Mine didn't either, until I fiddled with it.

I pushed the bubble stair-case down an inch and at a slightest of
angle.

Now the bubbles reduce in half...then in half again before exiting.
(Enter as a bean and leave as half-BBs).

The bubbles move much slower as well. I have 4 or 5 bubbles in the
device at the same time.

Haywire 20-04-2003 06:14 AM

About NUTRAFIN CO2 Natural Plant System
 
Murphy's law strikes

yeast is done, 2 weeks +1 day, just as I start double shifts this week,
sigh, maybe tomorrow morning I can find some spare time to clean the reactor
instead of posting.

"Phil Dietz" wrote in message
om...
"Philip Ash" wrote in message

...
My bubbles dont seem to be getting any smaller as they reach the top

though,
(as i observed at the LFS).



Mine didn't either, until I fiddled with it.

I pushed the bubble stair-case down an inch and at a slightest of
angle.

Now the bubbles reduce in half...then in half again before exiting.
(Enter as a bean and leave as half-BBs).

The bubbles move much slower as well. I have 4 or 5 bubbles in the
device at the same time.




Rick 20-04-2003 06:14 AM

About NUTRAFIN CO2 Natural Plant System
 

"Cichlidiot" wrote in message
...
I got one of these on a whim the other week because I could more likely
convince my roommates to allow it than DIY. I also only wanted moderate
CO2 injection since it's for a rift lake tank. It seemed to me at first
like it wasn't producing, but then I noticed the issue. The water pressure
was just too much for the CO2 to push all the water out of the tubing. I
took a 6mL feeding syringe which was just the right size for the tubing
and used it to push all the water out. Then I pinched the line closed as
much as possible before putting it back on the canister. Within minutes, I
had bubbling going.

One thing I have noticed that deviates from the LFS setup of this system I
saw is that my bubbles get stuck mid-way up the diffuser. I'm not
complaining much. This allows more contact time between the CO2 and water.
I think the reason is that I don't have the diffuser perfectly straight on
the side of the glass. It is slightly tilting down on the side away from
the CO2 tubing.

I do have to say even though I'm only getting moderate CO2 injection (I
have just one unit on a 40 gal, about 2-3 bubbles per minute) I am seeing
the results. Within a couple days of putting it in, all 10-20ppm of
nitrates from the tap water were sucked away (main reason I put plants in
a rift lake tank). The crypts stopped melting and started to pearl and put
up new leaves and runners. The java ferns are putting out plantlets and
new leaves like crazy. Now a couple weeks later, my algae problem is under
wraps. There's still a thin layer of green algae on the rocks and tank
sides, but nothing near the algae mess there was at first (which was
another reason I decided to follow my whim and try this system.. at $30,
it couldn't hurt to try it to see if the algae would be controlled).

I hope to have some updated pictures on this tank's website to show the
system at work, but I need to get some film for my SLR, so it'll be a week
at least. If you want to see how the tank looked when it was freshly set
up, the URL is http://www.shwaine.com/fish_40g.html. There's been
considerable growth in the crypts (the tallest ones are just about as tall
as the rock pile now) since adding the CO2, although I may pull the
aponogeton bulbs. They just aren't happy even with the CO2 it seems.

well that answers one question as I thought these systems were good for
tanks only up to 20g.

Rick



Philip Ash 20-04-2003 06:14 AM

About NUTRAFIN CO2 Natural Plant System
 
I have posted some pics of the tank in alt.binaries.aquaria


Phil.

"Phil Dietz" wrote in message
om...
"Philip Ash" wrote in message

...
My bubbles dont seem to be getting any smaller as they reach the top

though,
(as i observed at the LFS).



Mine didn't either, until I fiddled with it.

I pushed the bubble stair-case down an inch and at a slightest of
angle.

Now the bubbles reduce in half...then in half again before exiting.
(Enter as a bean and leave as half-BBs).

The bubbles move much slower as well. I have 4 or 5 bubbles in the
device at the same time.




Phil Dietz 20-04-2003 06:14 AM

About NUTRAFIN CO2 Natural Plant System
 
(Phil Dietz) wrote in message . com...

Mine didn't either, until I fiddled with it.

I pushed the bubble stair-case down an inch and at a slightest of
angle.

Now the bubbles reduce in half...then in half again before exiting.
(Enter as a bean and leave as half-BBs).

The bubbles move much slower as well. I have 4 or 5 bubbles in the
device at the same time.


Tonight I noticed 10-11 bubbles moving up at the same time...
and the bubbles moving very slow...3 or 4 secs per step...
and the bubbles shrink to specks.

It's a great buy and the whole setup looks nice.

Bruce Butz 20-04-2003 06:14 AM

About NUTRAFIN CO2 Natural Plant System
 
I like mine too.I just wish I knew what kind of yeast they use so I
could get it from a cheaper
source. I bet it is a champaign yeast,but what strain?

Bruce


http://community.webtv.net/BruBz/BrucesBeatlePage


Haywire 20-04-2003 06:15 AM

About NUTRAFIN CO2 Natural Plant System
 
well mine tan for about 3 weeks on the 1st pack of yeast, finally changed it
last night, and for sure it's Champaign yeast, smelled like it, didn't want
to taste the alcohol in the reactor to be totally sure but without the co2
in the liquid could it really be Champaign?


"Bruce Butz" wrote in message
...
There are several new posts about this system.
Mine has been running two and a half weeks now and still going strong.
Here are a few things I have learned.

1.Hang the Reactor on the tank .This shortens
the tube length and gives bubbles more often than putting the Reactor
below the tank with a long tube.

2. The "Stabilizer" is baking soda.If you have hard water don't use the
whole package.
I use half a package or about one half tsp.

3. The slower the bubbles move up the ramp the better.So experiment with
the placement
of the bubble counter/diffuser.Mine is off axis
from vertical about five degrees.
With the bottom just slightly closer to the edge
of the tank than the top.
But yours may differ.

4. If you use your own Yeast. Use champaign
yeast rather than wine or bread yeast.
It takes longer to start but will last longer.
Three packs of champaign yeast are supplied
with the unit.

Hope this helps.

Bruce


http://community.webtv.net/BruBz/BrucesBeatlePage





All times are GMT +1. The time now is 12:51 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
GardenBanter