GardenBanter.co.uk

GardenBanter.co.uk (https://www.gardenbanter.co.uk/)
-   Freshwater Aquaria Plants (https://www.gardenbanter.co.uk/freshwater-aquaria-plants/)
-   -   Adding Potassium - any thoughts (https://www.gardenbanter.co.uk/freshwater-aquaria-plants/20147-adding-potassium-any-thoughts.html)

Martin 02-05-2003 11:45 PM

Adding Potassium - any thoughts
 
I need to add Nitrate and probably Potassium to my tank in order to get the
plants to grow and algae to die off (hopefully). My Nitrates are 0 (when I
add Flora Grow or other substance it increases slightly, when I perform a
water change it increases a lot) not long after (in days) its back to 0 and
there seems to be far more hair algae (some brush is appearing as well)
covering all my plants. I inject CO2 as well. Its bloody frustrating.

So apart from the 3% potassium that the flora grow will put in (which is
expensive as well) - I have purchased some Sulphate of Potash......for
garden usage. It says on the packet that it has 49-50% K2O - but it doesn't
state other chemicals. It's very white and very fine grained and looks like
cocaine (as if I would spot it even if it were put in front of me - lol).
Anyway if I catch the fish using straws and floating around the living room,
then I know something has gone horribly wrong - lol lol.

My question is - is this stuff suitable for an aquarium when sufficiently
diluted and where can I find the maths for diluting it properly. I live in
the UK and the product is http://www.gemgardening.co.uk/prodlist.asp?val=veg
however, has anyone else used this at all. I would hate to kill off all the
fish in an experiment to get rid of algae. I have read, on the Krib that
about 3/4 teaspoon for my 250L (66G) tank should be enough per week. But I
would like to make up a solution so that it can be added easily.

Does anyone know what I can buy for the KNO3 please....In the UK.....

Thanks in advance

Martin




redled 03-05-2003 12:56 AM

Adding Potassium - any thoughts
 
"Martin" wrote in
:

I need to add Nitrate and probably Potassium to my tank in order to
get the plants to grow and algae to die off (hopefully). My Nitrates
are 0 (when I add Flora Grow or other substance it increases slightly,
when I perform a water change it increases a lot) not long after (in
days) its back to 0 and there seems to be far more hair algae (some
brush is appearing as well) covering all my plants. I inject CO2 as
well. Its bloody frustrating.

So apart from the 3% potassium that the flora grow will put in (which
is expensive as well) - I have purchased some Sulphate of
Potash......for garden usage. It says on the packet that it has 49-50%
K2O - but it doesn't state other chemicals. It's very white and very
fine grained and looks like cocaine (as if I would spot it even if it
were put in front of me - lol). Anyway if I catch the fish using
straws and floating around the living room, then I know something has
gone horribly wrong - lol lol.

My question is - is this stuff suitable for an aquarium when
sufficiently diluted and where can I find the maths for diluting it
properly. I live in the UK and the product is
http://www.gemgardening.co.uk/prodlist.asp?val=veg however, has anyone
else used this at all. I would hate to kill off all the fish in an
experiment to get rid of algae. I have read, on the Krib that about
3/4 teaspoon for my 250L (66G) tank should be enough per week. But I
would like to make up a solution so that it can be added easily.

Does anyone know what I can buy for the KNO3 please....In the UK.....

Thanks in advance

Martin





I don't know about that stuff you have, but if you need anything like
that, try to find a hydroponics store near you. I found everything to
make a couple year's worth of PMDD for about $10.

Madpiano 03-05-2003 01:44 AM

Adding Potassium - any thoughts
 
Hydroponics don't exist in the UK.

Sorry I can't help you with your white powder (maybe you can sell it on some
backstreet and do a runner ? ;-))

KentMarine have just released a whole load of FW Fertilizers. I have just
ordered the Potassium from them. As soon as it arrives, I let you know what
else (apart from Potassium) it contains.

Hope you get help with your powder

Greetings
Mad



Slow Leak 03-05-2003 03:33 AM

Adding Potassium - any thoughts
 
I would not mess with individual component fertilzer as it will just
frusterate novice. It could help if you know the deficiency you are dealing
with. though. Potassium is always safe to add moderately. Really there is no
magic here. The requirements are

-2-4 watts per gallon of fluorecent T8, PC, or T5 lighting 8-10 hrs per day
in small tanks
- Alkalinity 80 ppm, Hardness of 120-80 ppm depending on area you live that
is good for south american plants
- pH controller with co2 diffuser to pH 6.7 to 6.8 (this is called high tech
in some circles)

when this is set correctly then....

-add potassium sulfate at 1/4 teaspoon week per 200 liters with 25% weekly
water changes. This will reduce nitrates and appearance of green peas soup
water. It may come and go still within first 3-5 months of setup though.
- when nitrates are zero at 1ml per 20 liters of PMDD recipe (33gm MgSO4, 14
gm KSO4, 6 gm KNO3) and discontinue adding potassium sulfate. I use an Eheim
Liquidoser and it works great because I am too busy to do this.
-Shortly after I will use 1/2 dosage of Tropica Master grow weekly.

With the liquidoser 35 usd, pH controller 200 usd, diffuser 60 usd, and
regulator 100 usd, and bubble counter 20 usd, and light timer 25 usd. I have
an almost algae free tank with only feeding and weekly water changes
required. Anything can be grown with this recipe.

I made my own micronutrients as well using Fe-EDDHA wich is difficult to
obtain with other DTPA/EDTA of Cu,MO, MN Zn. The Iron is very soluble and
available in that form.I can sell One liter bottles to anyone who cares
further experiment . It really does work great.

Slow Leak





"Madpiano" wrote in message
...
Hydroponics don't exist in the UK.

Sorry I can't help you with your white powder (maybe you can sell it on

some
backstreet and do a runner ? ;-))

KentMarine have just released a whole load of FW Fertilizers. I have just
ordered the Potassium from them. As soon as it arrives, I let you know

what
else (apart from Potassium) it contains.

Hope you get help with your powder

Greetings
Mad





Sandy 03-05-2003 11:44 AM

Adding Potassium - any thoughts
 

"Madpiano" wrote in message
...
Hydroponics don't exist in the UK.

Sorry I can't help you with your white powder (maybe you can sell it on

some
backstreet and do a runner ? ;-))

KentMarine have just released a whole load of FW Fertilizers. I have just
ordered the Potassium from them. As soon as it arrives, I let you know

what
else (apart from Potassium) it contains.

Hope you get help with your powder

Greetings
Mad


Have a look here.

http://www.1-hydroponics.co.uk/main.htm

and this Google search gives plenty more.

http://makeashorterlink.com/?R26732E64

--
Don`t Worry, Be Happy

Sandy
--

E-Mail:-
Website:-
http://www.ftscotland.co.uk
IRC:- Sandyb in #rabble uk3.arcnet.vapor.com Port:6667
#Rabble Channel Website:- http://www.ftscotland.co.uk/rabbled
ICQ : 41266150



Paul Davies 03-05-2003 04:20 PM

Adding Potassium - any thoughts
 
I bought some KNO3 from my local pharmacist, a real one, not Boots. You should also try this website
http://www.computercookbook.co.uk/chemicals.
By the way , I am trying the Chempak trace element mix. I got it by mail order from :-
http://www.longwoodgardencentre.co.u...alog/info.html

Regds
Paul




"Martin" wrote in message ...
I need to add Nitrate and probably Potassium to my tank in order to get the
plants to grow and algae to die off (hopefully). My Nitrates are 0 (when I
add Flora Grow or other substance it increases slightly, when I perform a
water change it increases a lot) not long after (in days) its back to 0 and
there seems to be far more hair algae (some brush is appearing as well)
covering all my plants. I inject CO2 as well. Its bloody frustrating.

So apart from the 3% potassium that the flora grow will put in (which is
expensive as well) - I have purchased some Sulphate of Potash......for
garden usage. It says on the packet that it has 49-50% K2O - but it doesn't
state other chemicals. It's very white and very fine grained and looks like
cocaine (as if I would spot it even if it were put in front of me - lol).
Anyway if I catch the fish using straws and floating around the living room,
then I know something has gone horribly wrong - lol lol.

My question is - is this stuff suitable for an aquarium when sufficiently
diluted and where can I find the maths for diluting it properly. I live in
the UK and the product is http://www.gemgardening.co.uk/prodlist.asp?val=veg
however, has anyone else used this at all. I would hate to kill off all the
fish in an experiment to get rid of algae. I have read, on the Krib that
about 3/4 teaspoon for my 250L (66G) tank should be enough per week. But I
would like to make up a solution so that it can be added easily.

Does anyone know what I can buy for the KNO3 please....In the UK.....

Thanks in advance

Martin





Kelvyn Shaw 04-05-2003 05:44 PM

Adding Potassium - any thoughts
 
I use the four fertilisers from gemgardening

1. sulphate of potash (K2O)
2. Nitrate of soda (NaNO3, sodium nitrate)
3. Superphosphate (P2O5, phosphorus pentoxide)
4. Garden Lime (CaO, Calcium Oxide). This when mixed with water becomes
Ca(HO)2 calcium hydroxide, which then combines with CO2 in the water to form
CaCO3 Calcium carbonate which increase my KH and GH.

Ideally I would like some K2SO4 and KNO3 and also micro nutrients without
any iron. But in the UK its impossable.



Martin 05-05-2003 12:32 PM

Adding Potassium - any thoughts
 
Kelvyn,

Unless I am totally wrong - Sulphate of Potash is K20 + S, however, the S is
in the form of Sulphate so what you have is actually K2SO4....

Anyway - I have just found a lab chemical outlet in UK called AvonChem
(based in Macclesfield) - if its any good (and I will check tomorrow) then I
am buying the chemicals direct - it works out at about 5.85 per kg for each
one that I want (KNO3 and K2SO4) - that should be ample for 4 years of
dosing - lol.

I have now got all the maths that I need if anyone else wants it in digest
form let me know and I will post it. Have obtained it from other sites -
hope its all OK.

Martin

"Kelvyn Shaw" wrote in message
...
I use the four fertilisers from gemgardening

1. sulphate of potash (K2O)
2. Nitrate of soda (NaNO3, sodium nitrate)
3. Superphosphate (P2O5, phosphorus pentoxide)
4. Garden Lime (CaO, Calcium Oxide). This when mixed with water becomes
Ca(HO)2 calcium hydroxide, which then combines with CO2 in the water to

form
CaCO3 Calcium carbonate which increase my KH and GH.

Ideally I would like some K2SO4 and KNO3 and also micro nutrients without
any iron. But in the UK its impossable.





Kelvyn Shaw 06-05-2003 06:20 PM

Adding Potassium - any thoughts
 
I called Avonchem today to check if they would sell to private individuals
but they wouldnt. I am thinking about ordering from the USA.



Martin 06-05-2003 08:20 PM

Adding Potassium - any thoughts
 
Kelvyn

Avonchem will not sell to individuals as I found out today, well they will
sell to anyone as long as they are VAT registered - which seems stupid to
me! and they have a £100 minimum order.

There is also a company called Scientific and Chemical Supplies Limited -
again no sale to those not VAT registered however, if you have a local
aquarist (like I do) they are VAT registered and they should get it for you
if you give them the details. The costs of KNO3 is £31 approx for 1 Kg which
will last 4 years in a 250L tank. K2SO4 is £26 for 1 Kg.

They are pricey but I later found a company that sold me the chemicals over
the phone using a credit card - just try one or two from a search engine and
Im sure one of them will. The main problem is getting them to deal in small
amounts - S&C Supplies Ltd will do that but only to companies that have a
proper turnover.

They are obviously trying to prevent selling to stupid people that want to
make the odd bomb or two. I mean that literally. I would be cautious about
the USA - I would assume that's the sort of traffic customs are looking for
even though it is legitimate.

Martin

"Kelvyn Shaw" wrote in message
...
I called Avonchem today to check if they would sell to private individuals
but they wouldnt. I am thinking about ordering from the USA.





Paul Davies 06-05-2003 09:44 PM

Adding Potassium - any thoughts
 
The sulphate of potash you already have is OK. It is potassium sulphate (K2SO4). The reference to K2O is only the way it's analysed.
I've previously posted convenient sources for KNO3, but you'll also need the K2SO4, as the nitrate doesn't give you enough potassium. http://www.csd.net/~cgadd/aqua/75g.htm is a good link for the calculations.
You'll probably also need Epsom Salts (MgSO4.7H2O)for the magnesium.
All trace element mixes I'm aware of in the UK contain chelated iron. Not quite sure why you wouldn't want iron.

Paul



"Martin" wrote in message ...
Kelvyn

Avonchem will not sell to individuals as I found out today, well they will
sell to anyone as long as they are VAT registered - which seems stupid to
me! and they have a £100 minimum order.

There is also a company called Scientific and Chemical Supplies Limited -
again no sale to those not VAT registered however, if you have a local
aquarist (like I do) they are VAT registered and they should get it for you
if you give them the details. The costs of KNO3 is £31 approx for 1 Kg which
will last 4 years in a 250L tank. K2SO4 is £26 for 1 Kg.

They are pricey but I later found a company that sold me the chemicals over
the phone using a credit card - just try one or two from a search engine and
Im sure one of them will. The main problem is getting them to deal in small
amounts - S&C Supplies Ltd will do that but only to companies that have a
proper turnover.

They are obviously trying to prevent selling to stupid people that want to
make the odd bomb or two. I mean that literally. I would be cautious about
the USA - I would assume that's the sort of traffic customs are looking for
even though it is legitimate.

Martin

"Kelvyn Shaw" wrote in message
...
I called Avonchem today to check if they would sell to private individuals
but they wouldnt. I am thinking about ordering from the USA.






Martin 06-05-2003 11:20 PM

Adding Potassium - any thoughts
 
Paul,
I was under the impression that, as I have 100% flourite as the substrate,
then this already has all the iron and trace elements that I may need - it
is fractured clay. I believe the chemistry is OK for trace elements.

Martin

PS. I am actually getting laboratory grade KNO3 and K2SO4 now as I don't
(100%) trust the gardening stuff not to have some nasty trace elements in it
(like pesticides) (it won't go to waste though).



LeighMo 07-05-2003 03:44 AM

Adding Potassium - any thoughts
 
I was under the impression that, as I have 100% flourite as the substrate,
then this already has all the iron and trace elements that I may need


Flourite only provides iron. Which is what laterite provides. The other
traces must be added, whether you use Flourite or laterite. Plus, some plants
don't have much in the way of roots, and draw nutrients through their leaves.
Flourite only feeds the roots.


Leigh

http://www.fortunecity.com/lavender/halloween/881/

LeighMo 07-05-2003 09:56 PM

Adding Potassium - any thoughts
 
The reason i want trace elements without Iron in them is because i have 100%
flourite gravel.


You still need to add iron.

Flourite only provides iron to plants that are root-feeders. Many aquarium
plants don't have strong root systems and absorb most of their nutrients
throught their leaves.

In addition, some plants need more iron than just Flourite can provide. I
routinely give my swords, crypts, and lotuses root tabs containing iron and
other traces. Even in my 100% Flourite tank.





Leigh

http://www.fortunecity.com/lavender/halloween/881/

Rich Conley 08-05-2003 07:08 PM

Adding Potassium - any thoughts
 
I think he still wants to dose iron, but wants to dose it less than the trace
would do.

LeighMo wrote:

The reason i want trace elements without Iron in them is because i have 100%
flourite gravel.


You still need to add iron.

Flourite only provides iron to plants that are root-feeders. Many aquarium
plants don't have strong root systems and absorb most of their nutrients
throught their leaves.

In addition, some plants need more iron than just Flourite can provide. I
routinely give my swords, crypts, and lotuses root tabs containing iron and
other traces. Even in my 100% Flourite tank.

Leigh

http://www.fortunecity.com/lavender/halloween/881/



Martin 08-05-2003 09:32 PM

Adding Potassium - any thoughts
 
Right got my chemicals...

KNO3 and K2SO4 to start with - am going to dose with KNO3 first to see what
the effects are...This will put more K in the tank than I guess I have at
the moment. If successful then in goes the K2SO4 to make up the difference
in K.

I will be aiming for about 12ppm Nitrate. The nitrate level I want will give
me 8 ppm of K in the tank.

I will also be aiming for about 20ppm K. So when I dose with K2SO4 I will be
adding a further 12ppm of K which leaves me with 15ppm of introduced SO4.

So, what's the effect that SO4 has on the plants or fish?

This is as much fun as I had last night at the local Curry house.
Martin


"Martin" wrote in message
...
Paul,
I was under the impression that, as I have 100% flourite as the substrate,
then this already has all the iron and trace elements that I may need - it
is fractured clay. I believe the chemistry is OK for trace elements.

Martin

PS. I am actually getting laboratory grade KNO3 and K2SO4 now as I don't
(100%) trust the gardening stuff not to have some nasty trace elements in

it
(like pesticides) (it won't go to waste though).





Kelvyn Shaw 08-05-2003 09:56 PM

Adding Potassium - any thoughts
 
Sulphur is a macro nutrient and will be provided by SO4.
I found a table the relative nutient usage but i dont know how correct it
is.


appox G/Ltr % of total Ratio to Fe
N 1.41 6.41% 3.06
K 13.80 62.53% 29.84
S 5.19 23.50% 11.21
Mg 0.95 4.32% 2.06
Fe 0.46 2.10% 1.00
Mn 0.13 0.60% 0.29
Zn 0.03 0.12% 0.06
Cu 0.01 0.03% 0.01
Mo 0.00 0.01% 0.01
B 0.08 0.38% 0.18
Co 0.00 0.00% 0.00
And two important quanities
NO3 6.26 -- 13.54
SO4 15.56 -- 33.63



Martin 09-05-2003 07:32 PM

Adding Potassium - any thoughts
 
Kelvyn - Thanks for that, did you get my email regarding that chemical
company? I thought it was better to send it via email instead of posting it
up here!

Have you contacted them?

"Kelvyn Shaw" wrote in message
...
Sulphur is a macro nutrient and will be provided by SO4.
I found a table the relative nutient usage but i dont know how correct it
is.


appox G/Ltr % of total Ratio to Fe
N 1.41 6.41% 3.06
K 13.80 62.53% 29.84
S 5.19 23.50% 11.21
Mg 0.95 4.32% 2.06
Fe 0.46 2.10% 1.00
Mn 0.13 0.60% 0.29
Zn 0.03 0.12% 0.06
Cu 0.01 0.03% 0.01
Mo 0.00 0.01% 0.01
B 0.08 0.38% 0.18
Co 0.00 0.00% 0.00
And two important quanities
NO3 6.26 -- 13.54
SO4 15.56 -- 33.63





Kelvyn Shaw 10-05-2003 10:56 PM

Adding Potassium - any thoughts
 
I got the email, thanks for that, but have not contacted them yet.



Kelvyn Shaw 10-05-2003 11:44 PM

Adding Potassium - any thoughts
 
The reason i want trace elements without Iron in them is because i have 100%
flourite gravel. So i dont need to add as much iron if any, but cutting down
on iron would also mean limiting trace elements unless i can get trace
element without iron.
I have found out that www.animal-house.co.uk/ has started selling Kent
marines aquabotanic range of pmdd www.kentmarine.com/html/botanica.html
which has trace element-iron mixture.



Kelvyn Shaw 17-07-2003 08:43 PM

Adding Potassium - any thoughts
 
I use the four fertilisers from gemgardening

1. sulphate of potash (K2O)
2. Nitrate of soda (NaNO3, sodium nitrate)
3. Superphosphate (P2O5, phosphorus pentoxide)
4. Garden Lime (CaO, Calcium Oxide). This when mixed with water becomes
Ca(HO)2 calcium hydroxide, which then combines with CO2 in the water to form
CaCO3 Calcium carbonate which increase my KH and GH.

Ideally I would like some K2SO4 and KNO3 and also micro nutrients without
any iron. But in the UK its impossable.



Martin 17-07-2003 08:43 PM

Adding Potassium - any thoughts
 
Kelvyn,

Unless I am totally wrong - Sulphate of Potash is K20 + S, however, the S is
in the form of Sulphate so what you have is actually K2SO4....

Anyway - I have just found a lab chemical outlet in UK called AvonChem
(based in Macclesfield) - if its any good (and I will check tomorrow) then I
am buying the chemicals direct - it works out at about 5.85 per kg for each
one that I want (KNO3 and K2SO4) - that should be ample for 4 years of
dosing - lol.

I have now got all the maths that I need if anyone else wants it in digest
form let me know and I will post it. Have obtained it from other sites -
hope its all OK.

Martin

"Kelvyn Shaw" wrote in message
...
I use the four fertilisers from gemgardening

1. sulphate of potash (K2O)
2. Nitrate of soda (NaNO3, sodium nitrate)
3. Superphosphate (P2O5, phosphorus pentoxide)
4. Garden Lime (CaO, Calcium Oxide). This when mixed with water becomes
Ca(HO)2 calcium hydroxide, which then combines with CO2 in the water to

form
CaCO3 Calcium carbonate which increase my KH and GH.

Ideally I would like some K2SO4 and KNO3 and also micro nutrients without
any iron. But in the UK its impossable.





Kelvyn Shaw 17-07-2003 08:44 PM

Adding Potassium - any thoughts
 
I called Avonchem today to check if they would sell to private individuals
but they wouldnt. I am thinking about ordering from the USA.



Martin 17-07-2003 08:44 PM

Adding Potassium - any thoughts
 
Kelvyn

Avonchem will not sell to individuals as I found out today, well they will
sell to anyone as long as they are VAT registered - which seems stupid to
me! and they have a £100 minimum order.

There is also a company called Scientific and Chemical Supplies Limited -
again no sale to those not VAT registered however, if you have a local
aquarist (like I do) they are VAT registered and they should get it for you
if you give them the details. The costs of KNO3 is £31 approx for 1 Kg which
will last 4 years in a 250L tank. K2SO4 is £26 for 1 Kg.

They are pricey but I later found a company that sold me the chemicals over
the phone using a credit card - just try one or two from a search engine and
Im sure one of them will. The main problem is getting them to deal in small
amounts - S&C Supplies Ltd will do that but only to companies that have a
proper turnover.

They are obviously trying to prevent selling to stupid people that want to
make the odd bomb or two. I mean that literally. I would be cautious about
the USA - I would assume that's the sort of traffic customs are looking for
even though it is legitimate.

Martin

"Kelvyn Shaw" wrote in message
...
I called Avonchem today to check if they would sell to private individuals
but they wouldnt. I am thinking about ordering from the USA.





Paul Davies 17-07-2003 08:44 PM

Adding Potassium - any thoughts
 
The sulphate of potash you already have is OK. It is potassium sulphate (K2SO4). The reference to K2O is only the way it's analysed.
I've previously posted convenient sources for KNO3, but you'll also need the K2SO4, as the nitrate doesn't give you enough potassium. http://www.csd.net/~cgadd/aqua/75g.htm is a good link for the calculations.
You'll probably also need Epsom Salts (MgSO4.7H2O)for the magnesium.
All trace element mixes I'm aware of in the UK contain chelated iron. Not quite sure why you wouldn't want iron.

Paul



"Martin" wrote in message ...
Kelvyn

Avonchem will not sell to individuals as I found out today, well they will
sell to anyone as long as they are VAT registered - which seems stupid to
me! and they have a £100 minimum order.

There is also a company called Scientific and Chemical Supplies Limited -
again no sale to those not VAT registered however, if you have a local
aquarist (like I do) they are VAT registered and they should get it for you
if you give them the details. The costs of KNO3 is £31 approx for 1 Kg which
will last 4 years in a 250L tank. K2SO4 is £26 for 1 Kg.

They are pricey but I later found a company that sold me the chemicals over
the phone using a credit card - just try one or two from a search engine and
Im sure one of them will. The main problem is getting them to deal in small
amounts - S&C Supplies Ltd will do that but only to companies that have a
proper turnover.

They are obviously trying to prevent selling to stupid people that want to
make the odd bomb or two. I mean that literally. I would be cautious about
the USA - I would assume that's the sort of traffic customs are looking for
even though it is legitimate.

Martin

"Kelvyn Shaw" wrote in message
...
I called Avonchem today to check if they would sell to private individuals
but they wouldnt. I am thinking about ordering from the USA.






Martin 17-07-2003 08:44 PM

Adding Potassium - any thoughts
 
Paul,
I was under the impression that, as I have 100% flourite as the substrate,
then this already has all the iron and trace elements that I may need - it
is fractured clay. I believe the chemistry is OK for trace elements.

Martin

PS. I am actually getting laboratory grade KNO3 and K2SO4 now as I don't
(100%) trust the gardening stuff not to have some nasty trace elements in it
(like pesticides) (it won't go to waste though).



LeighMo 17-07-2003 08:44 PM

Adding Potassium - any thoughts
 
I was under the impression that, as I have 100% flourite as the substrate,
then this already has all the iron and trace elements that I may need


Flourite only provides iron. Which is what laterite provides. The other
traces must be added, whether you use Flourite or laterite. Plus, some plants
don't have much in the way of roots, and draw nutrients through their leaves.
Flourite only feeds the roots.


Leigh

http://www.fortunecity.com/lavender/halloween/881/

LeighMo 17-07-2003 08:44 PM

Adding Potassium - any thoughts
 
The reason i want trace elements without Iron in them is because i have 100%
flourite gravel.


You still need to add iron.

Flourite only provides iron to plants that are root-feeders. Many aquarium
plants don't have strong root systems and absorb most of their nutrients
throught their leaves.

In addition, some plants need more iron than just Flourite can provide. I
routinely give my swords, crypts, and lotuses root tabs containing iron and
other traces. Even in my 100% Flourite tank.





Leigh

http://www.fortunecity.com/lavender/halloween/881/

Rich Conley 17-07-2003 08:45 PM

Adding Potassium - any thoughts
 
I think he still wants to dose iron, but wants to dose it less than the trace
would do.

LeighMo wrote:

The reason i want trace elements without Iron in them is because i have 100%
flourite gravel.


You still need to add iron.

Flourite only provides iron to plants that are root-feeders. Many aquarium
plants don't have strong root systems and absorb most of their nutrients
throught their leaves.

In addition, some plants need more iron than just Flourite can provide. I
routinely give my swords, crypts, and lotuses root tabs containing iron and
other traces. Even in my 100% Flourite tank.

Leigh

http://www.fortunecity.com/lavender/halloween/881/



Martin 17-07-2003 08:45 PM

Adding Potassium - any thoughts
 
Right got my chemicals...

KNO3 and K2SO4 to start with - am going to dose with KNO3 first to see what
the effects are...This will put more K in the tank than I guess I have at
the moment. If successful then in goes the K2SO4 to make up the difference
in K.

I will be aiming for about 12ppm Nitrate. The nitrate level I want will give
me 8 ppm of K in the tank.

I will also be aiming for about 20ppm K. So when I dose with K2SO4 I will be
adding a further 12ppm of K which leaves me with 15ppm of introduced SO4.

So, what's the effect that SO4 has on the plants or fish?

This is as much fun as I had last night at the local Curry house.
Martin


"Martin" wrote in message
...
Paul,
I was under the impression that, as I have 100% flourite as the substrate,
then this already has all the iron and trace elements that I may need - it
is fractured clay. I believe the chemistry is OK for trace elements.

Martin

PS. I am actually getting laboratory grade KNO3 and K2SO4 now as I don't
(100%) trust the gardening stuff not to have some nasty trace elements in

it
(like pesticides) (it won't go to waste though).





Kelvyn Shaw 17-07-2003 08:45 PM

Adding Potassium - any thoughts
 
Sulphur is a macro nutrient and will be provided by SO4.
I found a table the relative nutient usage but i dont know how correct it
is.


appox G/Ltr % of total Ratio to Fe
N 1.41 6.41% 3.06
K 13.80 62.53% 29.84
S 5.19 23.50% 11.21
Mg 0.95 4.32% 2.06
Fe 0.46 2.10% 1.00
Mn 0.13 0.60% 0.29
Zn 0.03 0.12% 0.06
Cu 0.01 0.03% 0.01
Mo 0.00 0.01% 0.01
B 0.08 0.38% 0.18
Co 0.00 0.00% 0.00
And two important quanities
NO3 6.26 -- 13.54
SO4 15.56 -- 33.63



Martin 17-07-2003 08:45 PM

Adding Potassium - any thoughts
 
Kelvyn - Thanks for that, did you get my email regarding that chemical
company? I thought it was better to send it via email instead of posting it
up here!

Have you contacted them?

"Kelvyn Shaw" wrote in message
...
Sulphur is a macro nutrient and will be provided by SO4.
I found a table the relative nutient usage but i dont know how correct it
is.


appox G/Ltr % of total Ratio to Fe
N 1.41 6.41% 3.06
K 13.80 62.53% 29.84
S 5.19 23.50% 11.21
Mg 0.95 4.32% 2.06
Fe 0.46 2.10% 1.00
Mn 0.13 0.60% 0.29
Zn 0.03 0.12% 0.06
Cu 0.01 0.03% 0.01
Mo 0.00 0.01% 0.01
B 0.08 0.38% 0.18
Co 0.00 0.00% 0.00
And two important quanities
NO3 6.26 -- 13.54
SO4 15.56 -- 33.63





Kelvyn Shaw 17-07-2003 08:45 PM

Adding Potassium - any thoughts
 
I got the email, thanks for that, but have not contacted them yet.



Kelvyn Shaw 17-07-2003 08:45 PM

Adding Potassium - any thoughts
 
The reason i want trace elements without Iron in them is because i have 100%
flourite gravel. So i dont need to add as much iron if any, but cutting down
on iron would also mean limiting trace elements unless i can get trace
element without iron.
I have found out that www.animal-house.co.uk/ has started selling Kent
marines aquabotanic range of pmdd www.kentmarine.com/html/botanica.html
which has trace element-iron mixture.




All times are GMT +1. The time now is 08:23 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
GardenBanter