GardenBanter.co.uk

GardenBanter.co.uk (https://www.gardenbanter.co.uk/)
-   Gardening (https://www.gardenbanter.co.uk/gardening/)
-   -   Tree Has Reddish "Golf Balls" Somethings Appearing: What Are They ? (https://www.gardenbanter.co.uk/gardening/187191-tree-has-reddish-golf-balls-somethings-appearing-what-they.html)

Robert11[_2_] 14-09-2009 12:29 PM

Tree Has Reddish "Golf Balls" Somethings Appearing: What Are They ?
 
Hi,

Live outside of Boston.

Have this tree in my front yard about 20 feet tall or so.
Have no idea what it is.
Has pointed leaves, no cones.

Moved in about 4 yrs ago, and tree was like, well, just there since, and
looking pretty.

Just now, WOW !

Zillions of round, reddish color, balls have appeared all over for the first
time (at least in 4 yrs.).
About 1 to 1.5 inches in diameter.

Surface is not smooth, has many protrusions going outward.
Almost like a small golf ball, with the dimples going outward rather than
inward.

Any idea what this is, and what is happening ?

Thanks,
Bob



brooklyn1 14-09-2009 01:48 PM

Tree Has Reddish "Golf Balls" Somethings Appearing: What Are They ?
 
"Robert11" wrote:

Live outside of Boston.

Have this tree in my front yard about 20 feet tall or so.
Have no idea what it is.
Has pointed leaves, no cones.

Moved in about 4 yrs ago, and tree was like, well, just there since, and
looking pretty.

Just now, WOW !

Zillions of round, reddish color, balls have appeared all over for the first
time (at least in 4 yrs.).
About 1 to 1.5 inches in diameter.

Surface is not smooth, has many protrusions going outward.
Almost like a small golf ball, with the dimples going outward rather than
inward.

Any idea what this is, and what is happening ?



Would help a lot to know what type of tree and a photo would help
immeasurably... sounds like it could be "galls", but could also be the
tree's natural fruit/seed, however odd to fruit this time of year in
the northeast

John McGaw 14-09-2009 01:51 PM

Tree Has Reddish "Golf Balls" Somethings Appearing: What AreThey ?
 
Robert11 wrote:
Hi,

Live outside of Boston.

Have this tree in my front yard about 20 feet tall or so.
Have no idea what it is.
Has pointed leaves, no cones.

Moved in about 4 yrs ago, and tree was like, well, just there since, and
looking pretty.

Just now, WOW !

Zillions of round, reddish color, balls have appeared all over for the first
time (at least in 4 yrs.).
About 1 to 1.5 inches in diameter.

Surface is not smooth, has many protrusions going outward.
Almost like a small golf ball, with the dimples going outward rather than
inward.

Any idea what this is, and what is happening ?

Thanks,
Bob



The first thing that came to mind was American Sweetgum (Liquidambar
styraciflua). It has five-pointed leaves that almost resemble a star as
drawn by a child. The fruit is golf-ball sized but has spikes rather than
simple protrusions but what you are seeing might, I suppose, be early-stage
fruits before the spikes fully develop. Does it look anything like this?

http://www.nps.gov/archive/gewa/Sweetgum.jpg

In theory this tree isn't native as far north as Boston but there is no
telling what someone might have planted in a yard. There are also some
other varieties of sweetgum that might qualify but I don't have any
experience with them.

--
John McGaw
[Knoxville, TN, USA]
http://johnmcgaw.com

Dee 14-09-2009 03:06 PM

Tree Has Reddish "Golf Balls" Somethings Appearing: What Are They ?
 
"Robert11" wrote in
:

Hi,

Live outside of Boston.

Have this tree in my front yard about 20 feet tall or so.
Have no idea what it is.
Has pointed leaves, no cones.

Moved in about 4 yrs ago, and tree was like, well, just there
since, and looking pretty.

Just now, WOW !

Zillions of round, reddish color, balls have appeared all over for
the first time (at least in 4 yrs.).
About 1 to 1.5 inches in diameter.

Surface is not smooth, has many protrusions going outward.
Almost like a small golf ball, with the dimples going outward
rather than inward.

Any idea what this is, and what is happening ?

Thanks,
Bob


First thing that comes to mind is Cornus kousa.

Dee

T2B 14-09-2009 04:26 PM

Tree Has Reddish "Golf Balls" Somethings Appearing: What Are They?
 
On Sep 14, 10:06*am, Dee wrote:
"Robert11" wrote :





Hi,


Live outside of Boston.


Have this tree in my front yard about 20 feet tall or so.
Have no idea what it is.
Has pointed leaves, no cones.


Moved in about 4 yrs ago, and tree was like, well, just there
since, and looking pretty.


Just now, WOW !


Zillions of round, reddish color, balls have appeared all over for
the first time (at least in 4 yrs.).
About 1 to 1.5 inches in diameter.


Surface is not smooth, has many protrusions going outward.
Almost like a small golf ball, with the dimples going outward
rather than inward.


Any idea what this is, and what is happening ?


Thanks,
Bob


First thing that comes to mind is Cornus kousa.

Dee- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -


http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Fi...ousa_fruit.jpg

I second your nomination. All in favor ???

Phisherman[_3_] 14-09-2009 05:59 PM

Tree Has Reddish "Golf Balls" Somethings Appearing: What Are They ?
 
On Mon, 14 Sep 2009 08:26:57 -0700 (PDT), T2B
wrote:

On Sep 14, 10:06*am, Dee wrote:
"Robert11" wrote :





Hi,


Live outside of Boston.


Have this tree in my front yard about 20 feet tall or so.
Have no idea what it is.
Has pointed leaves, no cones.


Moved in about 4 yrs ago, and tree was like, well, just there
since, and looking pretty.


Just now, WOW !


Zillions of round, reddish color, balls have appeared all over for
the first time (at least in 4 yrs.).
About 1 to 1.5 inches in diameter.


Surface is not smooth, has many protrusions going outward.
Almost like a small golf ball, with the dimples going outward
rather than inward.


Any idea what this is, and what is happening ?


Thanks,
Bob


First thing that comes to mind is Cornus kousa.

Dee- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -


http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Fi...ousa_fruit.jpg

I second your nomination. All in favor ???



Looks like Dogwood fruit, each about the size of a pea, not 1-1.5" in
diameter.

beccabunga 14-09-2009 09:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Robert11[_2_] (Post 864396)
Hi,

Live outside of Boston.

Have this tree in my front yard about 20 feet tall or so.
Have no idea what it is.
Has pointed leaves, no cones.

Moved in about 4 yrs ago, and tree was like, well, just there since, and
looking pretty.

Just now, WOW !

Zillions of round, reddish color, balls have appeared all over for the first
time (at least in 4 yrs.).
About 1 to 1.5 inches in diameter.

Surface is not smooth, has many protrusions going outward.
Almost like a small golf ball, with the dimples going outward rather than
inward.

Any idea what this is, and what is happening ?

Thanks,
Bob


Try Arbutus unedo [The strawberry tree].

Dee 14-09-2009 09:12 PM

Tree Has Reddish "Golf Balls" Somethings Appearing: What Are They ?
 
Phisherman wrote in
:

On Mon, 14 Sep 2009 08:26:57 -0700 (PDT), T2B
wrote:

On Sep 14, 10:06*am, Dee wrote:
"Robert11" wrote
:





Hi,

Live outside of Boston.

Have this tree in my front yard about 20 feet tall or so.
Have no idea what it is.
Has pointed leaves, no cones.

Moved in about 4 yrs ago, and tree was like, well, just there
since, and looking pretty.

Just now, WOW !

Zillions of round, reddish color, balls have appeared all over
for the first time (at least in 4 yrs.).
About 1 to 1.5 inches in diameter.

Surface is not smooth, has many protrusions going outward.
Almost like a small golf ball, with the dimples going outward
rather than inward.

Any idea what this is, and what is happening ?

Thanks,
Bob

First thing that comes to mind is Cornus kousa.

Dee- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -


http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Fi...ousa_fruit.jpg

I second your nomination. All in favor ???



Looks like Dogwood fruit, each about the size of a pea, not 1-1.5"
in diameter.


According to Wikipedia, the fruit is 2-3 cm in diameter though can be
up to 4 cm.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cornus_kousa

Dee


enigma 14-09-2009 10:00 PM

Tree Has Reddish "Golf Balls" Somethings Appearing: What Are They ?
 
Dee wrote in
om:

Phisherman wrote in
:
Looks like Dogwood fruit, each about the size of a pea, not
1-1.5" in diameter.


According to Wikipedia, the fruit is 2-3 cm in diameter though
can be up to 4 cm.


the description of the fruit sounds like dogwood (& those are
edible, BTW), but would you describe the leaves as "pointy"?
lee

PhoenixWench 15-09-2009 02:02 AM

Tree Has Reddish "Golf Balls" Somethings Appearing: What AreThey ?
 
beccabunga wrote:
'Robert11[_2_ Wrote:
;864396']Hi,

Live outside of Boston.

Have this tree in my front yard about 20 feet tall or so.
Have no idea what it is.
Has pointed leaves, no cones.

Moved in about 4 yrs ago, and tree was like, well, just there since,
and
looking pretty.

Just now, WOW !

Zillions of round, reddish color, balls have appeared all over for the
first
time (at least in 4 yrs.).
About 1 to 1.5 inches in diameter.

Surface is not smooth, has many protrusions going outward.
Almost like a small golf ball, with the dimples going outward rather
than
inward.

Any idea what this is, and what is happening ?

Thanks,
Bob



Try Arbutus unedo [The strawberry tree].




Unlikely - the tree is growing in Boston - Arbutus unedo is zone 8 - 10
I'm voting with the others for Cornus kousa. I used to see them all over
the place on Long Island which has similar growing conditions. Too cold
for them where I live now pout

--
Sylvia

jeff 15-09-2009 03:20 AM

Tree Has Reddish "Golf Balls" Somethings Appearing: What AreThey ?
 
T2B wrote:
On Sep 14, 10:06 am, Dee wrote:
"Robert11" wrote :





Hi,
Live outside of Boston.
Have this tree in my front yard about 20 feet tall or so.
Have no idea what it is.
Has pointed leaves, no cones.
Moved in about 4 yrs ago, and tree was like, well, just there
since, and looking pretty.
Just now, WOW !
Zillions of round, reddish color, balls have appeared all over for
the first time (at least in 4 yrs.).
About 1 to 1.5 inches in diameter.
Surface is not smooth, has many protrusions going outward.
Almost like a small golf ball, with the dimples going outward
rather than inward.
Any idea what this is, and what is happening ?
Thanks,
Bob

First thing that comes to mind is Cornus kousa.

Dee- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -


http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Fi...ousa_fruit.jpg


I saw something very much like this a day ago. Growing in poor soil
on a slope leading into a lake in 7a (N Georgia). Sprawling, perhaps
wider than tall. The fruit looked to be no bigger than am inch at most.

Jeff

I second your nomination. All in favor ???


Dee 15-09-2009 04:04 PM

Tree Has Reddish "Golf Balls" Somethings Appearing: What Are They ?
 
enigma wrote in news:Xns9C86AD00DD0EBenigmaevilnet@
199.125.85.9:

Dee wrote in
om:

Phisherman wrote in
:
Looks like Dogwood fruit, each about the size of a pea, not
1-1.5" in diameter.


According to Wikipedia, the fruit is 2-3 cm in diameter though
can be up to 4 cm.


the description of the fruit sounds like dogwood (& those are
edible, BTW), but would you describe the leaves as "pointy"?
lee


I wouldn't, no. But I could see how someone who didn't know much about
plants might do so. A simple leaf with a point on the end might be
described as pointy :-) But I guess if the OP doesn't post back with
a response or a photo we may never know for sure.

Dee

Zeppo 16-09-2009 02:53 PM

Tree Has Reddish "Golf Balls" Somethings Appearing: What Are They ?
 


"Dee" wrote in message
om...
Phisherman wrote in
:

On Mon, 14 Sep 2009 08:26:57 -0700 (PDT), T2B
wrote:

On Sep 14, 10:06 am, Dee wrote:
"Robert11" wrote
:





Hi,

Live outside of Boston.

Have this tree in my front yard about 20 feet tall or so.
Have no idea what it is.
Has pointed leaves, no cones.

Moved in about 4 yrs ago, and tree was like, well, just there
since, and looking pretty.

Just now, WOW !

Zillions of round, reddish color, balls have appeared all over
for the first time (at least in 4 yrs.).
About 1 to 1.5 inches in diameter.

Surface is not smooth, has many protrusions going outward.
Almost like a small golf ball, with the dimples going outward
rather than inward.

Any idea what this is, and what is happening ?

Thanks,
Bob

First thing that comes to mind is Cornus kousa.

Dee- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -

http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Fi...ousa_fruit.jpg

I second your nomination. All in favor ???



Looks like Dogwood fruit, each about the size of a pea, not 1-1.5"
in diameter.


According to Wikipedia, the fruit is 2-3 cm in diameter though can be
up to 4 cm.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cornus_kousa

Dee


Or maybe 'Litchi Chinensis'?

http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Fi...sis_fruits.JPG

Jon



brooklyn1 16-09-2009 05:28 PM

Tree Has Reddish "Golf Balls" Somethings Appearing: What Are They ?
 
On Wed, 16 Sep 2009 09:53:33 -0400, "Zeppo" wrote:



"Dee" wrote in message
. com...
Phisherman wrote in
:

On Mon, 14 Sep 2009 08:26:57 -0700 (PDT), T2B
wrote:

On Sep 14, 10:06 am, Dee wrote:
"Robert11" wrote
:





Hi,

Live outside of Boston.

Have this tree in my front yard about 20 feet tall or so.
Have no idea what it is.
Has pointed leaves, no cones.

Moved in about 4 yrs ago, and tree was like, well, just there
since, and looking pretty.

Just now, WOW !

Zillions of round, reddish color, balls have appeared all over
for the first time (at least in 4 yrs.).
About 1 to 1.5 inches in diameter.

Surface is not smooth, has many protrusions going outward.
Almost like a small golf ball, with the dimples going outward
rather than inward.

Any idea what this is, and what is happening ?

Thanks,
Bob

First thing that comes to mind is Cornus kousa.

Dee- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -

http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Fi...ousa_fruit.jpg

I second your nomination. All in favor ???


Looks like Dogwood fruit, each about the size of a pea, not 1-1.5"
in diameter.


According to Wikipedia, the fruit is 2-3 cm in diameter though can be
up to 4 cm.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cornus_kousa

Dee


Or maybe 'Litchi Chinensis'?

http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Fi...sis_fruits.JPG

Jon


Litchi is sub tropical, I seriously doubt it will grow in the Boston
area.

http://www.lycheesonline.com/lycheedescription.cfm

Until the OP posts a photo of the tree and growths described all
anyone can offer is wild speculation. There are galls that also match
the description and are likely to occur on trees that grow in the
Boston growing zone.
http://stockindexonline.com/index.ph...=keywordsearch


dwight 19-09-2009 02:58 PM

Tree Has Reddish "Golf Balls" Somethings Appearing: What Are They ?
 

"Dee" wrote in message
om...
enigma wrote in news:Xns9C86AD00DD0EBenigmaevilnet@
199.125.85.9:

Dee wrote in
om:

Phisherman wrote in
:
Looks like Dogwood fruit, each about the size of a pea, not
1-1.5" in diameter.

According to Wikipedia, the fruit is 2-3 cm in diameter though
can be up to 4 cm.


the description of the fruit sounds like dogwood (& those are
edible, BTW), but would you describe the leaves as "pointy"?
lee


I wouldn't, no. But I could see how someone who didn't know much about
plants might do so. A simple leaf with a point on the end might be
described as pointy :-) But I guess if the OP doesn't post back with
a response or a photo we may never know for sure.

Dee


Reading this thread, I thought I'd snap some photos of my own pointy-leaved
tree with red golf balls:
http://www.tfrog.com/digitals/daily/daily.htm

The golf balls do not appear annually, which may be why it comes as a
surprise to the OP, and mine are between 1/2" to an 1". They also mostly
appear only on the side of the tree exposed to sunlight.

dwight



T2B 19-09-2009 04:41 PM

Tree Has Reddish "Golf Balls" Somethings Appearing: What Are They?
 
On Sep 19, 9:58*am, "dwight" wrote:
"Dee" wrote in message

om...





enigma wrote in news:Xns9C86AD00DD0EBenigmaevilnet@
199.125.85.9:


Dee wrote in
.com:


Phisherman wrote in
:
Looks like Dogwood fruit, each about the size of a pea, not
1-1.5" in diameter.


According to Wikipedia, the fruit is 2-3 cm in diameter though
can be up to 4 cm.


*the description of the fruit sounds like dogwood (& those are
edible, BTW), but would you describe the leaves as "pointy"?
lee


I wouldn't, no. *But I could see how someone who didn't know much about
plants might do so. *A simple leaf with a point on the end might be
described as pointy *:-) *But I guess if the OP doesn't post back with
a response or a photo we may never know for sure.


Dee


Reading this thread, I thought I'd snap some photos of my own pointy-leaved
tree with red golf balls:http://www.tfrog.com/digitals/daily/daily.htm

The golf balls do not appear annually, which may be why it comes as a
surprise to the OP, and mine are between 1/2" to an 1". They also mostly
appear only on the side of the tree exposed to sunlight.

dwight- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -


Nice photos Dwight. Cornus kousa.

enigma 19-09-2009 06:21 PM

Tree Has Reddish "Golf Balls" Somethings Appearing: What Are They ?
 
"dwight" wrote in
:


Reading this thread, I thought I'd snap some photos of my own
pointy-leaved tree with red golf balls:
http://www.tfrog.com/digitals/daily/daily.htm

The golf balls do not appear annually, which may be why it comes
as a surprise to the OP, and mine are between 1/2" to an 1".
They also mostly appear only on the side of the tree exposed to
sunlight.


dogwood (cornus kousa). those fruits are edible. the outer 'shells'
are a bit crunchy which contrasts with the custardy insides.
we had a bumper crop last year, but the fruits are quite sparse this
year. they tend to bear heavily on alternate years, but this spring
was cold and very wet here, so there was a shortage of bugs to
pollinate as well.
the trees appreciate sun, & fruit better if they get a lot of sun.
the one next to my driveway always has more fruit than the ones in
the semishade in the backyard.
i have to fight both the chickens & the dogs to get any of the
fruit... i discovered my cattledog will climb trees to get cornus
kousa fruit last year.
lee

Dee 20-09-2009 02:25 PM

Tree Has Reddish "Golf Balls" Somethings Appearing: What Are They ?
 
"dwight" wrote in
:


"Dee" wrote in message
om...
enigma wrote in
news:Xns9C86AD00DD0EBenigmaevilnet@ 199.125.85.9:

Dee wrote in
om:

Phisherman wrote in
:
Looks like Dogwood fruit, each about the size of a pea, not
1-1.5" in diameter.

According to Wikipedia, the fruit is 2-3 cm in diameter though
can be up to 4 cm.

the description of the fruit sounds like dogwood (& those are
edible, BTW), but would you describe the leaves as "pointy"?
lee


I wouldn't, no. But I could see how someone who didn't know much
about plants might do so. A simple leaf with a point on the end
might be described as pointy :-) But I guess if the OP doesn't
post back with a response or a photo we may never know for sure.

Dee


Reading this thread, I thought I'd snap some photos of my own
pointy-leaved tree with red golf balls:
http://www.tfrog.com/digitals/daily/daily.htm

The golf balls do not appear annually, which may be why it comes
as a surprise to the OP, and mine are between 1/2" to an 1". They
also mostly appear only on the side of the tree exposed to
sunlight.

dwight


Thanks for posting your photos, dwight. I enjoyed perusing through
them.

Dee


lannerman 20-09-2009 10:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dee (Post 864888)
"dwight" wrote in
:


"Dee" wrote in message
om...
enigma
wrote in
news:Xns9C86AD00DD0EBenigmaevilnet@ 199.125.85.9:

Dee wrote in
om:

Phisherman
wrote in
:
Looks like Dogwood fruit, each about the size of a pea, not
1-1.5" in diameter.

According to Wikipedia, the fruit is 2-3 cm in diameter though
can be up to 4 cm.

the description of the fruit sounds like dogwood (& those are
edible, BTW), but would you describe the leaves as "pointy"?
lee


I wouldn't, no. But I could see how someone who didn't know much
about plants might do so. A simple leaf with a point on the end
might be described as pointy :-) But I guess if the OP doesn't
post back with a response or a photo we may never know for sure.

Dee


Reading this thread, I thought I'd snap some photos of my own
pointy-leaved tree with red golf balls:
http://www.tfrog.com/digitals/daily/daily.htm

The golf balls do not appear annually, which may be why it comes
as a surprise to the OP, and mine are between 1/2" to an 1". They
also mostly appear only on the side of the tree exposed to
sunlight.

dwight


Thanks for posting your photos, dwight. I enjoyed perusing through
them.

Dee

Hi Folks, Most intrigued by your discussion, from where I am in Cornwall UK. I would also opt for Cornus but the variety I would go for is capitata.
Regards Lanerman.

T2B 21-09-2009 06:12 AM

Tree Has Reddish "Golf Balls" Somethings Appearing: What Are They?
 
On Sep 20, 5:04*pm, lannerman
wrote:
Dee;864888 Wrote:





"dwight" wrote in
:
-


"Dee" wrote in message
. com...-
enigma wrote in
news:Xns9C86AD00DD0EBenigmaevilnet@ 199.125.85.9:
-
Dee wrote in
. com:


Phisherman wrote in
:
Looks like Dogwood fruit, each about the size of a pea, not
1-1.5" in diameter.


According to Wikipedia, the fruit is 2-3 cm in diameter though
can be up to 4 cm.


the description of the fruit sounds like dogwood (& those are
edible, BTW), but would you describe the leaves as "pointy"?
lee-


I wouldn't, no. *But I could see how someone who didn't know much
about plants might do so. *A simple leaf with a point on the end
might be described as pointy *:-) *But I guess if the OP doesn't
post back with a response or a photo we may never know for sure.


Dee-


Reading this thread, I thought I'd snap some photos of my own
pointy-leaved tree with red golf balls:
http://tinyurl.com/nhhxu8


The golf balls do not appear annually, which may be why it comes
as a surprise to the OP, and mine are between 1/2" to an 1". They
also mostly appear only on the side of the tree exposed to
sunlight.


dwight-


Thanks for posting your photos, dwight. *I enjoyed perusing through
them.


Dee


Hi Folks, Most intrigued by your discussion, from where I am in
Cornwall UK. I would also opt for Cornus but the variety I would go for
is capitata.
Regards Lanerman.

--
lannerman- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -


Yes, it could be Cornus capitata since one of its common names is
"Himalaya strawberry-tree."


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 10:08 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
GardenBanter