GardenBanter.co.uk

GardenBanter.co.uk (https://www.gardenbanter.co.uk/)
-   Gardening (https://www.gardenbanter.co.uk/gardening/)
-   -   Crows eradicated in DC, Paghat debunked (https://www.gardenbanter.co.uk/gardening/249-re-crows-eradicated-dc-paghat-debunked.html)

animaux 25-01-2003 02:28 PM

Crows eradicated in DC, Paghat debunked
 
On 25 Jan 2003 14:22:30 GMT, (IntarsiaCo) wrote:



The 103rd Christmas Bird Count clearly refutes your claim, in particular, there
are plenty of American Crows in DC. One must not believe EVERYTHING one reads,
a bit of COMMON SENSE is required to separate the wheat from the chaff.
Cheers,
Mark


Maybe, but there is no disputing that crows are susceptible to WNV.

IntarsiaCo 25-01-2003 04:03 PM

Crows eradicated in DC, Paghat debunked
 
Maybe, but there is no disputing that crows are susceptible to WNV.


My daughter worked in the patho lab at UConn and has done the assays, no
dispute here.


paghat 25-01-2003 06:47 PM

Crows eradicated in DC, Paghat debunked
 
In article ,
(IntarsiaCo) wrote:

Sometime in October 2002 Paghat claimed:
"If the West Nile encephalitis continues to eradicate crows, which are
particularly vulnerable to the virus & have already vanished entirely from
some infected east coast cities, a great many people who once complained
of these wonderful intelligent birds will be awfully sorry, remembering
their bold antics fondly."



The 103rd Christmas Bird Count clearly refutes your claim, in

particular, there
are plenty of American Crows in DC. One must not believe EVERYTHING one reads,
a bit of COMMON SENSE is required to separate the wheat from the chaff.
Cheers,
Mark


First of all, IF crows made a miraculous comeback & WNV was no longer a
problem, that'd be good news unreleated to my degree of common sense, so
amusing you'd take a quote out of context & then without credible basis
turn it into a flame rather than share something you spotted in the news.
Clearly you were chary of citing specifics since it would not otherwise
fit your desire to flame rather than share useful or creditable
information.

Would-be debunkers, meaning chaff such as yourself, should strive to read
a wee-bit more carefully to not make a fool of yourself, since the
documention of crows vanishing en masse was never for the entire city of
Washington DC but for Brookland DC area only; & this was taken as a highly
worrisome indicator of things to come, not as proof that crow extinction
is broadly inevitable, merely possible. Unlike you, I do apply common
sense, & will be happy if crows are able to weather this extreme crisis,
but for the moment the North American bird population, & crows in
particular, are at the beginning, not the end, & not even the middle of a
clear crisis.

The die-off has been milder elsewhere, including elsewhere in DC, but
Brookland is feared to be at the vanguard for something only just now
building steam. Because crow populations can remain in their own isolated
communities, the impact has to be assessed neighborhood by neighborhood, &
the Brookland population had been longest infected. Now if the Brookland
crows DO make a come-back, that would be great news -- I've not seen any
updated report so don't know if new populations have moved in to fill the
niches vacated by the Brookland die-off. Whether or not that happens would
not be related to my degree of common sense, would not say a lot about the
WNV threat to crows, but it would be good news if such news existed.

Audubon crow counts aren't scientific & there is nothing to stop YOU from
calling in & reporting your latest flying pink elephant sighting; plus, in
the past, many annual counts were from people who automatically including
everything EXCEPT pigeons & crows, but now crows are more on everyone's
mind. But even the unreliable Audobon "back yard count" have indicated
(less extremely than some scientific field research) that there is a mild
decline in crow population along the eastern seaboard & midwest, but not
yet for the west coast which was last to be infected or is not yet widely
infected at all; the west coast could be five years behind the curve, &
west coast occurrences are just a foreshadowing. When more people
participate in the annual count, the more birds get counted -- it's to too
great an extent just a back yard count after all, & this year Audobon got
more news-coverage in the week leading up to the counting period than
usual, so an unusually high number of people phoned in, & as always, if
you're such an amateur you can't even tell a raven from a crow from a
starling, there is no way for your count to be discounted. But the point
for statistics is this: Even if the Audobon count were assumed to have a
high degree of accuracy, it remains, if a given neighborhood has 50 people
who phone in an average of 20 birds apiece in one year, & in the next year
500 people phone in an average of ten birds appiece, the total may look
vastly higher but the ratio would be half, & indicative of a horrific
decline.

Even so, whad did the AUDUBON society ITSELF conclude? The obvious: John
Bianchi speaking Dec 2002 for the society nationally: "This year, West
Nile Virus seems to have had a larger impact on U.S. bird populations than
in years past." Bianchi also pointed out that it was cruciel for the
regional organizers to undertake the count EXACTLY as it had been taken in
past years, or no comparisons to previous year counts would reveal
anything whatsoever about WVN impacts. Sadly it was not undertaken as in
past years, but the largest number of people who had never counted before
participated & skewed all results. Also the education packets for people
who sign on for the count far enough in advance did not meet demand, so
there wasn't even the usual inadequate degree of preparation. The Society
is certainly not attempting on any level to use the winter bird count as
indicating WNV is anything short of an extravagant threat to crows, jays,
ravens, hawks, owls, & eagles -- these are the most suscpetible
populations, & crows are still #1 -- over three times as many crows have
fallen prey to WNV than all other birds combined (& that's the science
conducted by Bunning, not regional club surmises).

So COMMON SENSE suggests you personally should not place so much weight on
the VERY LITTLE YOU KNOW about it, with even that teency bit either
misprepresented or misremembered by yourself. If you can give a CITATION
that indicates crows are making the fabulous comeback in Brookland, great,
I'll read that report happily & hope for similarly great news nationwide.
It wouldn't change anything I reported previously, but it would be new
information worth attending. Alas, you have no information worth
attending, do ya.

Hhere is just one opinion vastly better drawn that yours, from Raymond
Adams, MAS research committee chair for the study of avian mortality due
to West Nile Virus. It's significance Adams' opinion is based on a deep &
growing body of knowledge & ongoing research nationwide, & typical of
ANYone well grounded in this recent problem, Adams' degree of concern is
fairly great because of what he likens "heavy mortality" among these
birds, to whit to woo:

"My concern for American Crows and other North American bird species
arises from the high incidence of mortality of individual birds infected
by the virus in this country. The American Crow, Blue Jay, some owls and
hawks are especially prone to this disease. West Nile Virus outbreaks with
heavy mortality of birds are largely unknown within the original
geographic range of the virus. In North America, large outbreaks in birds
associated with heavy mortality (epizootics) occurred in 1999 and 2002. In
recent weeks, nature centers, animal control offices and offices of the
Michigan Department of Natural Resources have been inundated with
telephone calls regarding dead and dying birds. In my 33 years at the
Kalamazoo Nature Center, our facility has never received this many reports
of dead and dying birds during the summer. By 23 August 2002 the hotline
had logged 6576 calls regarding dead or dying birds. Of these, 3132 were
from just 3 counties. Help is needed on several fronts. Anyone seeing dead
or dying crows should report the observation to the Michigan hot line for
the West Nile Virus by accessing
http://www.nwhc.usgs.gov/research/we...west_nile.html "

To date no DEFINITIVE answer about the future fate of crows & raptors is
possible & my sounding an alarm is only what all health, wildlife, & bird
organizatiosn are doing with sound indicators for what is very possibly
going to occur over the next five years: more mass die-offs of crows
foremost among birds. The Washington Post article that suggested crows are
going to go the way of the Passenger Pigeon, with the Brookland die-off
underscoring the worst-case scenario, is not yet a given. It is a worry.
That you're not worried about it is largely because you're not bright
enough to follow the issue, or really don't care.

On the final fate of the crows & the science is still beginning to gather
data, & it remains that in too many regions there is no sound science
being conducted at all, so that to too great an extant people are still
reliant on amateur bird counts, or thoroughly uncontrolled world wide web
reports such as anyone can leave at www.birdsource.org/gbbc. This is
regarded by the Audobon Society itself as the "Surveillance Stage" & not
of scientific value. The Surveillance nevertheless has a high priority for
the very reason that it is regarded as an emerging crisis of the highest
order, & SOME preliminary indicators are needed to heighten scientific
interest -- in such a light, the GBBC project is regarded
"better'n'nothing" rather than really something.

Many wildlife & health organizations are collecting dead birds from the
public to establish causes of death, & more data is published each month
(though not on the web for easy access). Up to now it remains that for
bird populations as a whole, the single largest cause of death (by far!)
is pesticides, so non-organic gardeners & agriculturalists remain birds'
worst enemies. But for crows per se, & for a growing percentage of
raptors, & especially in the longest-infected areas including specific
areas of NYC & Washington DC, the chief cause of death is already WNV.
And that vaunted "common sense" suggests it will get worse; only profound
ignorance concludes it isn't even a problem.

-paghat the ratgirl

--
"Of what are you afraid, my child?" inquired the kindly teacher.
"Oh, sir! The flowers, they are wild," replied the timid creature.
-from Peter Newell's "Wild Flowers"
See the Garden of Paghat the Ratgirl: http://www.paghat.com/

paghat 25-01-2003 07:59 PM

Crows eradicated in DC, Paghat debunked
 
In article ,
(IntarsiaCo) wrote:

And that vaunted "common sense" suggests it will get worse; only profound
ignorance concludes it isn't even a problem.


Over 1100 areas have reported in, there are crows everywhere, you figure

it out
for yourself. There is no crow crisis.


You have gone below even my low estimation of your ability to reason!

I'm done with you now dearie.


If you're done, time to take your baked head out of the oven.

-paggers

--
"Of what are you afraid, my child?" inquired the kindly teacher.
"Oh, sir! The flowers, they are wild," replied the timid creature.
-from Peter Newell's "Wild Flowers"
See the Garden of Paghat the Ratgirl:
http://www.paghat.com/

IntarsiaCo 25-01-2003 08:03 PM

Crows eradicated in DC, Paghat debunked
 
And that vaunted "common sense" suggests it will get worse; only profound
ignorance concludes it isn't even a problem.


Over 1100 areas have reported in, there are crows everywhere, you figure it out
for yourself. There is no crow crisis.
I'm done with you now dearie.

GrampysGurl 25-01-2003 10:12 PM

Crows eradicated in DC, Paghat debunked
 

And that vaunted "common sense" suggests it will get worse; only profound
ignorance concludes it isn't even a problem.


Over 1100 areas have reported in, there are crows everywhere, you figure it
out
for yourself. There is no crow crisis.
I'm done with you now dearie.






Just because in your mind they are every where doesn't mean they aren't in
danger and decreasing in numbers. You may want to subscribe to the Audubon
Society, The NWF, The Nature Conservatory and the Environmental Defense Fund
(all have online notifications) and get yourself informed first. :o) Ignorance
kills me.
Colleen
Zone 5 Connecticut
Colleen

Betsy 25-01-2003 10:30 PM

Crows eradicated in DC, Paghat debunked
 
I don't know what the fight's about--but I'm here to tell you that I've
noticed a LOT less crows here in Baltimore Maryland. We used to have them
in such abundance it looked like the Hitchcock movie. They'd caw so loudly
you'd have to cover your ears. I can't remember the last time I noticed a
flock (?) of crows!

"GrampysGurl" wrote in message
...

And that vaunted "common sense" suggests it will get worse; only

profound
ignorance concludes it isn't even a problem.


Over 1100 areas have reported in, there are crows everywhere, you figure

it
out
for yourself. There is no crow crisis.
I'm done with you now dearie.






Just because in your mind they are every where doesn't mean they aren't in
danger and decreasing in numbers. You may want to subscribe to the Audubon
Society, The NWF, The Nature Conservatory and the Environmental Defense

Fund
(all have online notifications) and get yourself informed first. :o)

Ignorance
kills me.
Colleen
Zone 5 Connecticut
Colleen




GrampysGurl 25-01-2003 10:45 PM

Crows eradicated in DC, Paghat debunked
 

I don't know what the fight's about--but I'm here to tell you that I've
noticed a LOT less crows here in Baltimore Maryland. We used to have them
in such abundance it looked like the Hitchcock movie. They'd caw so loudly
you'd have to cover your ears. I can't remember the last time I noticed a
flock (?) of crows!

Knowing the rate we are losing crows to WNV here in Connecticut, there is NO
WAY it isn't adversely effecting the crow population; it's only going to get
much worse before it gets better if it ever does. It is amazing what our
wildlife goes through world wide and ignorance is the cause of more deaths then
anything. I could spout off a few other organizations but I highly doubt many
of us are gardening in the oceans lol.
Colleen
Zone 5 Connecticut

I wanna walk and not run, I wanna skip and not fall.
I wanna look at the horizon, and not see a building standing tall.
I wanna be the only one, for miles and miles; except for maybe you and your
simple smiles. -Dixie Chicks




Ann 26-01-2003 12:06 AM

Crows eradicated in DC, Paghat debunked
 
"Betsy" -0 expounded:

I don't know what the fight's about--but I'm here to tell you that I've
noticed a LOT less crows here in Baltimore Maryland. We used to have them
in such abundance it looked like the Hitchcock movie. They'd caw so loudly
you'd have to cover your ears. I can't remember the last time I noticed a
flock (?) of crows!


Actually, there are far fewer crows around here, even. I've only seen
one this past month, and that was the first one I'd seen in many
months. And blue jays, too, they've just finally appeared after a
long absence. WNV obviously killed a few around here, too.

--
Ann, Gardening in zone 6a
Just south of Boston, MA
********************************

David Modine 26-01-2003 12:52 AM

Crows eradicated in DC, Paghat debunked
 

"Betsy" -0 wrote in message
...
I don't know what the fight's about--but I'm here to tell you that I've
noticed a LOT less crows here in Baltimore Maryland. We used to have them
in such abundance it looked like the Hitchcock movie. They'd caw so

loudly
you'd have to cover your ears. I can't remember the last time I noticed a
flock (?) of crows!


I never thought about it much until reading this thread, but here in
Mont.Co. MD, NE of DC and SW of Baltimore, there does seem to be a lot less
of them.
Of coarse I don't have any documentation to prove it.
David, zone 7, Olney MD



madgard 26-01-2003 04:59 AM

Crows eradicated in DC, Paghat debunked
 
Xref: news7 rec.gardens:206768


"Betsy" -0 wrote in message
...
I don't know what the fight's about--but I'm here to tell you that I've
noticed a LOT less crows here in Baltimore Maryland. We used to have them
in such abundance it looked like the Hitchcock movie. They'd caw so

loudly
you'd have to cover your ears. I can't remember the last time I noticed a
flock (?) of crows!



That would be a "Murder of Crows"........is the correct descriptive word for
a large number of them....................if you ever saw them in hot
pursuit of an owl, you'd understand the symbolism.
madgardener, who for the moment has crows, blackbirds and possibly ravens,
but not quite sure on the latter and who also knows we've had reports last
summer of WNV.......




Frogleg 26-01-2003 12:49 PM

Crows eradicated in DC, Paghat debunked
 
On 25 Jan 2003 14:22:30 GMT, (IntarsiaCo) wrote:

Sometime in October 2002 Paghat claimed:
"If the West Nile encephalitis continues to eradicate crows, which are
particularly vulnerable to the virus & have already vanished entirely from
some infected east coast cities, a great many people who once complained
of these wonderful intelligent birds will be awfully sorry, remembering
their bold antics fondly."

The 103rd Christmas Bird Count clearly refutes your claim, in particular, there
are plenty of American Crows in DC. One must not believe EVERYTHING one reads,
a bit of COMMON SENSE is required to separate the wheat from the chaff.


Perhaps this dispute can be traced to the term "eradicate" which means
both to eliminate entirely AND to kill in large numbers. With brief
Googling, I see no alerts that crows have been entirely eliminated,
but several showing they are unusually susceptible to WNV and many
have died from it. Also a happy note that while any new virus may
claim many victims, immunity begins to build and the high mortality
numbers drop off.

IntarsiaCo 26-01-2003 01:36 PM

Crows eradicated in DC, Paghat debunked
 
With brief
Googling, I see no alerts that crows have been entirely eliminated,
but several showing they are unusually susceptible to WNV and many
have died from it. Also a happy note that while any new virus may
claim many victims


See:
http://www.newsday.com/news/local/wi...4jan24,0,54408
43.story?coll=ny-ap-regional-wire

Tom Jaszewski 26-01-2003 03:06 PM

Crows eradicated in DC, Paghat debunked
 
On 26 Jan 2003 13:36:23 GMT, (IntarsiaCo) wrote:

With brief
Googling, I see no alerts that crows have been entirely eliminated,
but several showing they are unusually susceptible to WNV and many
have died from it. Also a happy note that while any new virus may
claim many victims


See:
http://www.newsday.com/news/local/wi...4jan24,0,54408
43.story?coll=ny-ap-regional-wire




http://www.newsday.com/news/local/wi...,5440843.story



Regards,

tomj

"Non-violence leads to the highest ethics, which is the goal of all evolution.
Until we stop harming all other living beings, we are still savages."

- Thomas Edison

paghat 26-01-2003 06:20 PM

Crows eradicated in DC, Paghat debunked
 
In article ,
(Frogleg) wrote:

On 25 Jan 2003 14:22:30 GMT,
(IntarsiaCo) wrote:

Sometime in October 2002 Paghat claimed:
"If the West Nile encephalitis continues to eradicate crows, which are
particularly vulnerable to the virus & have already vanished entirely from
some infected east coast cities, a great many people who once complained
of these wonderful intelligent birds will be awfully sorry, remembering
their bold antics fondly."

The 103rd Christmas Bird Count clearly refutes your claim, in

particular, there
are plenty of American Crows in DC. One must not believe EVERYTHING one

reads,
a bit of COMMON SENSE is required to separate the wheat from the chaff.


Perhaps this dispute can be traced to the term "eradicate" which means
both to eliminate entirely AND to kill in large numbers. With brief
Googling, I see no alerts that crows have been entirely eliminated,
but several showing they are unusually susceptible to WNV and many
have died from it


The tone of the "dispute" was set by InterasiaCo's trollish desire for my
attention, or it wouldn't've been necessary to start a thread with my name
in it. Last year I noted the threat to crows (questioned by no one with a
measurable IQ) is slowly spreading westward, & cited the worst case yet
reported in the east as a harbinger of worse to come, namely the
eradication of crows in Brookland, Washington, DC, ascribed to West Nile
Virus. Our trolly weirdo thought that crow sitings anywhere in the USA
"debunked" not the Washington Post & NPR piece I quoted a few months back,
but that it debunked me personally, when of course it debunked nothing at
all, not even by misrepresenting what I'd reported -- though even the
out-of-context quote begins with the word "If" & the troll wasn't very
clever at such misrepresentation. Any ACTUAL report on the complete safety
of crows would have been cited specifically as good news, not alluded to
vaguely as a magical debunking principle.

At first it seemed InterasiaCo was actually just insane, brooding in
misery ever since I corrected his complete misunderstanding on the subject
months back, until he "broke" & flew off the handle months later. But it
slowly dawned on me that trolling really was the point, & since the goal
was to troll me personally by starting a thread under my name, & since I
responded, it can be counted a success trolling.

We would otherwise be asked to believe InterasiaCo is such a loony that it
really IS possible to believe such crazy-ass things as 1) Paghat is one &
the same with all news-services & health organizations; 2) a siting of any
crow anywhere in the USA proves that West Nile Virus never eradicated
crows anywhere, therefore 3) the WNV threat to crows & raptors is a hoax
perpetuated by hundreds of health organizations, wildlife organizations,
scientists, all orchestrated by Paghat, because 4) West Nile Virus does
not kill crows; & no doubt that 5) the earth is flat & battery acid makes
for a sparkling refreshing drink.

Realizing trolling really was the one & only purpose, it becomes less
surprising that the only "evidence" the troll provided as evidence for an
alternate viewpoint on WVN even existing -- is a link to a much-despised
& pointless "crow shooting contest" the goal of which was to disrupt a
famous crow roost then just discard the thousands of dead birds
(illegally) in the nearest dumpster. Well, I guess it is more creative &
less unhealthy for InterasiaCo to behave as a crazy-ass troll rather than
to just be crazy, as those would seem to be the only two possibilities.

Also a happy note that while any new virus may
claim many victims, immunity begins to build and the high mortality
numbers drop off.


This is certainly the hope for the crow population long-term, that any
crows & raptors surviving the pending or in-progress bird holocaust will
be the seed of a future population not susceptible to the disease. There
are presently only indicators & hypotheses. Worst case scenario,
extinction; best-case, adaptive immunity. In Africa the virus does not
kill many birds, & that's the hopeful indicator of what is possible.

-paghat the ratgirl

--
"Of what are you afraid, my child?" inquired the kindly teacher.
"Oh, sir! The flowers, they are wild," replied the timid creature.
-from Peter Newell's "Wild Flowers"
See the Garden of Paghat the Ratgirl:
http://www.paghat.com/

paghat 26-01-2003 06:45 PM

Crows eradicated in DC, Paghat debunked
 
In article , "Frank Logullo"
wrote:

I did have a dead crow in the back yard early in the epidemic. The
state wanted these deaths called in to check for disease but the wild life
agent was lazy and said he was busy and then a day later said he would only
pick up if crow was refrigerated - it was July. At any rate he said you
cannot catch virus from dead bird.
Frank


Sorry for your encounter with a typical lazyass couldn't-care-less badguy.

Though there is no possibility of dead birds per se infecting anyone with
WNV, parasites on the bird just might be able to transfer the disease. It
is believed the disease reaching certain hawk populations because of a
tendency to scavenge dead birds & having infected bloodsucking parasites
transfer to a new host. Humans get it from mosquitos & mosquitos can
transfer it from any number of mammals or birds to humans. So though I
don't think it has been studied, it's at least a credible hypothesis that
contact with infected parasites could provide a mild threat to humans.
There are several other zoonotic diseases for which parasites are
intermediate carriers.

In some regions, most dead crows that get analyzed did have the virus as
cause of death, but for birds more broadly, analysis of thousands of
corpses shows the primary cause of death generally to be pesticides.

-paghat

--
"Of what are you afraid, my child?" inquired the kindly teacher.
"Oh, sir! The flowers, they are wild," replied the timid creature.
-from Peter Newell's "Wild Flowers"
See the Garden of Paghat the Ratgirl: http://www.paghat.com/

Frank Logullo 26-01-2003 06:47 PM

Crows eradicated in DC, Paghat debunked
 

In my experience the disease has done nothing to diminish the presence of
these pests in my neighborhood.
FYI, I did have a dead crow in the back yard early in the epidemic. The
state wanted these deaths called in to check for disease but the wild life
agent was lazy and said he was busy and then a day later said he would only
pick up if crow was refrigerated - it was July. At any rate he said you
cannot catch virus from dead bird.
Frank



Lar 27-01-2003 01:33 AM

Crows eradicated in DC, Paghat debunked
 
In article paghat-2601031145330001
@soggy72.drizzle.com,
says...
:) In some regions, most dead crows that get analyzed did have the virus as
:) cause of death, but for birds more broadly, analysis of thousands of
:) corpses shows the primary cause of death generally to be pesticides.
:)
:)
:)
There is a governmental graph floating around out there
that came out I believe 2000, maybe 1999 that had a
break down of bird mortality for N America and lists
death by many natural occurring pathogens (Avian
botulism, avian cholera, Salmonellosis and now WNV would
also be in that group) far out numbered the other
causes. Second was lead poisoning/heavy metal poisoning
from hunting-fishing and pollutants (industry-farming)
and then pesticide/pesticide pollutants followed by
hunting/impact trauma (communication towers, hunting,
windows of homes, electrocution). The data was from
several agencies in U.S, Canada, Mexico and I believe it
was over 600,000 carcasses.
--
A mouse trap, placed on top of your alarm clock
will prevent you from rolling over and going back
to sleep.


Lar. (to e-mail, get rid of the BUGS!!



IntarsiaCo 27-01-2003 01:18 PM

Crows eradicated in DC, Paghat debunked
 
cited the worst case yet
reported in the east as a harbinger of worse to come,


Listen lady (or is it Chicken Little, "the crows are falling, the crows are
falling"), while I will yield to you on your knowledge of trailer parks in
Oregon, you really should suck it up and admit that your illogical and
unquestioning belief in the two references that you cite- the eradication of
crows in the DC area is patently false.

Oh, you really should check your posts, it's Intarsiaco, but you can call me
Mark, debunker of Paghat, user of a process called logic.


Suja 27-01-2003 04:38 PM

Crows eradicated in DC, Paghat debunked
 

madgard wrote:


That would be a "Murder of Crows"........is the correct descriptive word for
a large number of them....................if you ever saw them in hot
pursuit of an owl, you'd understand the symbolism.



I had no idea that it's called a "Murder of Crows". I do know what that
means, since I've seen so many in hot pursuit of young hawks and such -
it even happened last Wednesday.

Suja


paghat 27-01-2003 07:03 PM

Crows eradicated in DC, Paghat debunked
 
In article ,
(IntarsiaCo) wrote:

cited the worst case yet
reported in the east as a harbinger of worse to come,


Listen lady (or is it Chicken Little, "the crows are falling, the crows are
falling"), while I will yield to you on your knowledge of trailer parks in
Oregon, you really should suck it up and admit that your illogical and
unquestioning belief in the two references that you cite- the eradication of
crows in the DC area is patently false.


In summer of 2002, the DC Health Department had 65 to 110 people PER DAY
turning over dead crows from Northeast Washington DC, virtually all of
them from Ward 3 and Ward 5. Hundreds of the corpses were given over to
Cornell University, which did the bloodwork to establish conclusively that
the sudden mass die-off was caused by West Nile Virus, which the crow
population had lived with for several years before this, thus indicating
an accumulative effect in a long-infected population. Last year when I
posted this incontrovertible occurrence, I asked what all the scientists
are asking, is this a foreshadowing of the future for crows across
America. For reasons known only to you, you lost your cookies & behaved
irrationally over this. You are still behaving irrationally. Since the
problem is at its height in summer & early autumn, new assessments won't
really be possible until summer 2003. I would like the DC phenomenon to
NOT be recurring in other regions, but to date there is no reason to
suppose anything unique about the DC population except the length of time
infected.

Your attempt to infer these findings are mine, & to debunk me personally,
show nothing except that you are a complete loon. Those are the facts that
NO ONE with a capacity to reason can deny, because that's what happened.
Period. The situation may change with time, but what occurred in DC in
summer of 2002 is history & nothing short of time travel will change it.

To be more precise, nothing short of time travel will change it, you dumb ****.

You've certainly NEVER provided one iota of information that would place
even slight doubt on the research from Cornell Univeristy (which they
updated in Otober 2002 resulting in fresh wire service articles at that
time, including those I cited last year from Washington Post & on NPR)
about the mass die-off in Brookland. If you COULD debunk this it would
have very little to do with me -- rather, you'd be outwitting scientists
at Cornell University, at the National Zoo, the Animal Disease Prevention
Division of DC's Department of Health, & the space/time continuum. Reason
alone indicates you cannot do this; your nutty posts show conclusively you
haven't. You certainly never even come close by mere insane pronouncements
about how amateur phone-in citings elsewhere in the nation debunk
neighborhood-specific information out of Cornell. Your one & only citation
proved nothing but that your craziness is boundless, when you finally
shared a "source" for your outbursts, vis, the crow-hating gun-nuts in
upstate New York despised by everyone but you. In your putrescent mind the
horrible acts of gun-nuts in upstate New York has some direct baring on
what happened in Brookland last year, & cancels out that bit of history.

It appears that you had a mini-psychotic break & acted it out by posting
my name as a thread title to get attention. Your twisted emotional state
had no more logic, source, or information beyond that of your simply
acting out inappropriately. You had a weird response to well-sourced facts
given in evidence last October, when you first made a fool of yourself
denying reality, & you have brooded on it like an insane dork ever since,
finally erupting anew in your ignorant, baseless, & laughable manner.

Oh, you really should check your posts, it's Intarsiaco, but you can call me
Mark, debunker of Paghat, user of a process called logic.


Now now, InnerAnalCo. Remember, you provided clear examples of your idea
of "logic," vis, a few crow-hating gun-nuts slaughtering crows in upstate
New York & some random call-in sightings of crows throughout middle
america, to you, directly impacts & changes conditions in northeast DC.

So even you must know full well that logic is beyond your capacity,
irrationality being your only hallmark. All you have to keep you going is
your anger at sundry people, at me at the moment, apparently also at
crows, probably displaced anger over things from your life, which your
out-of-left-field interest in trailer parks may give us a clue
regarding. Since you're the same guy alleging that a chintzy pegboard
chair with small plastic rollers affixed to the legs is a superior
replacement for an actual wheelchair, it wouldn't be too surprising if
this was designed to fit into your equally crappy trailer house. Yes, that
much is logical. Disabled individuals who sadly can't afford a real house
being likewise stuck with one of your disgustingly inadadequate
wheelchairs -- what a nightmare image.

The closest you've come to "logic" is your manner of exemplifying how
fools behave foolishly. You have revealed repeatedly your incapacity to
grasp simple elements of reality, without which logic will remain always
beyond your reach, & you will end up as in the present instance descending
into increasing lunacy, including revelations of your delight in the
attempted destruction of a famous well-studied rookery by a few insane
assholes with shotguns, who exmplify your ideal for the treatment of
crows. Any other animals you hate beyond reason? Besides sweet ratties
that is.

If the day ever comes that you have something substantial to offer on this
or any topic, it won't have to posture as debunkery. Actual information
is actual information & requires no needy shouts for Paghat's attention.
Laughable though I find you, I seriously am sorry your ego was so
flattened you needed to pretend your bunk could debunk anyone, whether me
or Cornell University.

-paghat the ratgirl

--
"Of what are you afraid, my child?" inquired the kindly teacher.
"Oh, sir! The flowers, they are wild," replied the timid creature.
-from Peter Newell's "Wild Flowers"
See the Garden of Paghat the Ratgirl:
http://www.paghat.com/

IntarsiaCo 27-01-2003 09:02 PM

Crows eradicated in DC, Paghat debunked
 
Now now dearie, didn't your momma and poppa teach you that it is not polite to
call people names, normal humans give that up sometime around puberty.
You really need to find some purpose in life besides self edification and
pomposity. There is still time for you to earn your spot on the planet, even
someone with your minimal talent can be taught to be productive.
The bottom line dreary, crows were not extirpated in DC, nor NY, nor CT, nor
MA, nor DE, nor NJ, nor MD, nor VA, nor NC, from personal observation.
I feel sorry for you, please go back to taking your meds, they will help. It
sure is fun toying with you, probably unfair given your severe limitations.
Oh, that chair is used quite successfully in early intervention programs, it is
not a wheelchair. But then again, what do you know?



paghat 27-01-2003 10:55 PM

Crows eradicated in DC, Paghat debunked
 
In article ,
(IntarsiaCo) wrote:

Now now dearie, didn't your momma and poppa teach you that it is not polite to
call people names, normal humans give that up sometime around puberty.
You really need to find some purpose in life besides self edification and
pomposity. There is still time for you to earn your spot on the planet, even
someone with your minimal talent can be taught to be productive.
The bottom line dreary, crows were not extirpated in DC, nor NY, nor CT, nor
MA, nor DE, nor NJ, nor MD, nor VA, nor NC, from personal observation.
I feel sorry for you, please go back to taking your meds, they will help. It
sure is fun toying with you, probably unfair given your severe limitations.
Oh, that chair is used quite successfully in early intervention

programs, it is
not a wheelchair. But then again, what do you know?


Thanks for the spam. You left out your actual company slogan "Fail your
way to success!" Too bad that is all you have instead of scientific
support for your bold claims of medical value to your lowgrade products.
If making money by hornswoggling high prices for your failures is your
idea of failing your way to success, well gawwwwwd damn, is that your
admission of criminality?

And since you are reliant on people a great many of whom actually ARE "on
meds" to make your livelihood, we find here that your estimation of people
with medical needs is so low that insulting your betters with the "Take
your meds!" cliche is your formost recourse when you find as usual you
cannot grasp the rudiments of science or reason.

It's bad enough you make harmlessly stupid claims against science, but you
also make baseless medical claims in order to sell worthless junk to
people with actual needs. Unforgiveable.

Your intellectual leap to "Take your meds! Take your meds!" is something
NO ONE who was HONESTLY qualified to sell "therapy" to the disabled would
ever resort to -- I might call you a retardo but probably not if I were
raising a retarded child, & I might take delight in noting you're crazy
gimp who needs his meds dosage upped -- but probably not if I were someone
whose profession had much to do with delivering therapy to people in
physical or mental crisis. Too bad you can't even PRETEND to have respect
for those you are reliant on for an income.

So pardon me if I doubt there is even a slight basis to your false boast
of providing ANYthing of ANY therapeutic value to ANYone. You sell
snakeoil, & the vaguely chair-shaped easy-to-dash-together
pegboard-box-with-bolted-on-casters is just the most obvious of your
scoundrally flimflam "health" & "therapy" offerings for which you provide
no evidence of proven value..

Look at this piece of shit folks:
http://www.therapyshapes.com/CHAIR.3.jpg
Imagine trying to get around a home, school, or office in THAT one!
Some trivial values might be found for such a cheezy-looking device if one
looked hard enough (or needed a hook to hang your hammer), & didn't expect
much else. But instead it gets sold under the banner of "therapy" &
alleged to be successful for "early intervention." Just a hoodwinker
claiming medical values where none are present.

So what ARE your medical qualifications, InnerAnalCo? Finishing the
Matchbook School of Carpentry won't fill the bill. I view you as a
flimflam man taking advantage of the disabled, especially those who cannot
afford quality healthcare equipment, who would likely be that same trailer
court crowd you previously demeaned. So you arrive with your snakeoil to
profit on others' desperation. "Take your meds!" squawked the flimflam
man. "Take your meds!" -- typical of someone who would misrepresent their
boxy pegboard chair as "therapy" capable of "intervention." Invervention
of what? Your victims' pocketbooks? You'd reduce a disabled kid to a
"cripple-in-a-box" thereafter needing even further "assistance" of still
other bogus products merely to move half an inch in any direction.

So you call trapping someone inside a pegboard box "therapy" in your
sorryass advertisements & "intervention" in your snakeoil salesman's
dream. Where exactly did you get your medical degrees & physical
therapist's training? At which teaching & research institutes did your
pegboard chair undergo testing for these imaginary "therapy" &
"intervention" uses? In what scientific publications are the peer-reviewed
outcomes to be found, showing the basis for your claims of "intervention"
& "therapy" for ugly pegboard boxes bolted to coasters? These'd be cute if
you made them for your pet spider monkey double-amputee in order to get on
Animal Planet, but not to claim therapeutic virtues.

Give me the citations. I would love to be wrong on this one, because being
right means I also have to know you victimize the disabled, & that's
tragic. You couldn't prove Cornell wrong about crows with your whinging &
lying, but perhaps you can lay to rest my strong belief that you are a
vampire victimizing the disabled, & doing so with even less authority than
you possess while you're pretending to debunk Cornell WNV research. If
your pegboard chair has been proven to possess even moderate therapeutic
value of any kind, then there ARE published peer-reviewed studies that
show this. Just tell me where to find them & I will read them & report
back exactly what they say. I'll accept even the tiniest statistically
significance proving any value whatsoever of any kind, & admit thereafter
it at least gives you legal backing for your exaggerations, but it HAS to
be peer reviewed science or it's nothing but your groundless salespitch.

If your pegboard-box-on-coasters has the therapeutic value you allege,
then the independent studies proving it will be easy to cite. If it's a
groundless assertion for a worthless product, there'll be nothing to cite.
Peer-reviewed scientific journals only, please, not testimonials from
third-rate bone-manipulators to whom you give deep discounts to induce
them to help you sell crapola. Give me the scientific citations that prove
your pegboard boxes' efficacy as "therapy & intervention" -- because so
far it looks to me like this is a patently worthless piece of equipment
that has only your snakeoil sales pitches to support it. Actually USEFUL
up-to-date wheelchairs are expensive & an almost-affordable alternative
might be sad to settle for, but it could be argued that low-grade
alternatives for the impoverished do serve a purpose in a country where
quality healthcare is often pay-as-you-go, & for some it has to be
low-quality alternatives or nothing at all. But to put on top of that
stopgap situation unfounded medical claims of therapy & intervention,
whew, that's downright evil.

Because you make medical & healthcare claims, I believe that qualifies you
as a medical fraud & profiteer standing completely outside trained &
accredited health professions. So it is quite natural for you, in a
name-calling mood, to assume anyone you are mad at is appropriately
alluded to in a medical context as worthless. That's what you think of
your own "customers" (or victims) for the Magical Pegboard Box Cure, so it
comes easy for you to tell your betters to go take their meds -- at least
you keep yourself in clear context, but too bad for your customers you
can't even drum up a little pretended respect & not use their situations
to name-call your betters.

You've shown yourself incapable of comprehending simple science, & willing
to dissimilate when science won't support you. So you damned sure ain't no
therapist doing intervention with your magic pegboard box. I see you as a
flimflam man sucking vampirishly at gullible individuals within the
disabled community, always hoping to sell yet another worthless boxy chair
made of pegboard & mounted on four crappy little coasters that'd have
trouble even getting over a spot of gum, while in your spare time you
praise gun-nuts out to destroy rookeries & weasil your way around a
Cornell study in Brookland by making sweeping claims about North Carolina
& anywhere else -- without even knowing one thing about North Carolina
either, you're such a complete fraud. Maybe next you'll throw something
out there about Antarctica & see if that one floats, lacking as you do
capacity even for the marginally sensible.

And I have no doubt whatsoever that your expertise in "therapy &
intervention" is no greater than your expertise on crows in North Carolina
(or anywhere else) that you toss out blithely with no basis of knowledge.
Prove me wrong by citing the peer-reviewed studies supporting this wild
claim of yours that a pegboard box on little coasters has therapeutic
value. Show me the evidence it was independently tested & proven to have
any value whatsoever. I have fairly quick access to the University of
Washington Health Sciences Library so don't go fabricating in your usual
manner, I can & will check any citation you can provide.

And this is something the disabled community should really be informed of
-- you using the conditions of people in need of medical assistance to
name-call your betters is bad enough for someone professionally reliant on
just such people for an income. It shows your complete lack of interest in
anything but the pocketbooks of those people. It's something your
victim-base should know more about.

"Fail your way to success" indeed. Absolutely pathetic. You therapy claims
appear to be permanently in failure mode.

-paghat the ratgirl

--
"Of what are you afraid, my child?" inquired the kindly teacher.
"Oh, sir! The flowers, they are wild," replied the timid creature.
-from Peter Newell's "Wild Flowers"
See the Garden of Paghat the Ratgirl: http://www.paghat.com/

NewsUser 27-01-2003 11:04 PM

Crows eradicated in DC, Paghat debunked
 

"paghat" wrote in message
...
Though there is no possibility of dead birds per se infecting anyone with
WNV, parasites on the bird just might be able to transfer the disease. It
is believed the disease reaching certain hawk populations because of a
tendency to scavenge dead birds & having infected bloodsucking parasites
transfer to a new host. Humans get it from mosquitos & mosquitos can
transfer it from any number of mammals or birds to humans. So though I
don't think it has been studied, it's at least a credible hypothesis that
contact with infected parasites could provide a mild threat to humans.
There are several other zoonotic diseases for which parasites are
intermediate carriers.



Please provide the source of the info about parasites (other than mosquitos)
transmitting WNV in hawk populations. I believe there are 36 species of
mosquito in the US known to carry WNV but have not yet seen mention of other
parasites.
Thanks.

karen



Lar 28-01-2003 12:47 AM

Crows eradicated in DC, Paghat debunked
 
In article ,
ess says...
:) Please provide the source of the info about parasites (other than mosquitos)
:) transmitting WNV in hawk populations. I believe there are 36 species of
:) mosquito in the US known to carry WNV but have not yet seen mention of other
:) parasites.
:)
These two articles don't state that it is another
parasite, but it does make say hmmmmmm...I would think
close net lifestyle of crows would make it very possible
for lice or bird flea or even larger insects like
conenose bugs that will inhabit bird nests of ratures to
be a possibility as another vector.

From an article by a rapture rehabilitator
http://www.cah.com/library/wnvrapt.html

It's possible the virus has mutated, becoming more
likely to cause illness and death. Perhaps raptors in
the East and South were protected by exposure to another
virus closely related to West Nile. Or perhaps another
species of mosquito, or another insect entirely that
prefers to feed on raptors, has picked up the virus.
There has also been speculation that raptors are
not being infected by mosquitoes, but by exposure to the
flesh and blood of infected prey. That would seem
consistent with recent findings that the virus can be
transmitted between humans in donated organs and blood.
Redig said the experimental work has not been done
to prove it, but Gibson is convinced that mosquitoes are
not vital to the cycle of West Nile infection.
She says a crippled bald eagle she uses as a
foster parent to orphaned eagles became West Nile- -
positive after feeding infected younger birds. The large
flight room where they were kept was netted against
mosquitoes.
And when some of the 30 orphaned common terns she
was caring for began dying, she sent their organs off
for West Nile testing. All were negative at first.
But on Wednesday, her phone rang with word that the
single tern brain sent to the lab has tested positive
for West Nile.
"Damn!" Gibson says. "We gave the terns West
Nile." The terns, endangered in Wisconsin, had been kept
on a porch double-netted against mosquitoes. But Gibson
had been hand-feeding them, and she's convinced, despite
her infection control efforts, that she transmitted the
virus from the ailing raptors to the previously healthy
young terns.

From a press release from the US Geological Survey

http://www.cfe.cornell.edu/erap/WNV/WNV-LArchive/10-26-
00.html

Scientists from the U.S. Geological Survey said
today that the West Nile Virus can be transmitted from
bird-to-bird in a confined laboratory setting. It had
been thought that the virus was only transmitted through
mosquito bites.

Scientists from the USGS National Wildlife Health Center
in Madison, Wisc., placed infected birds in the same
biocontainment (BL3) aviary as healthy birds. The
infected birds died five to eight days later. Most of
the healthy birds, the researchers found, also became
ill from the virus and died five to eight days after the
first infected bird died. ........
........"Now we're not sure how it moved: by mouth, by
preening, did the birds shed the virus in their feces?
We're not sure," he said. "But by keeping the infected
and healthy birds together in close contact, we really
maximized the potential that this bird-to-bird
transmission could take place. Now we know it did and we
want to figure out how."






--
A mouse trap, placed on top of your alarm clock
will prevent you from rolling over and going back
to sleep.


Lar. (to e-mail, get rid of the BUGS!!



NewsUser 28-01-2003 01:17 AM

Crows eradicated in DC, Paghat debunked
 
Thanks for the link, Lar. This is speculation, then, rather than research. I
was aware of other multiple hazards. I'm trying to keep up with all the info
on WNV because I keep several birds outside in summer. Have to take steps to
protect them.

karen

"Lar" wrote in message
. ..
In article ,
ess says...
:) Please provide the source of the info about parasites (other than

mosquitos)
:) transmitting WNV in hawk populations. I believe there are 36 species

of
:) mosquito in the US known to carry WNV but have not yet seen mention of

other
:) parasites.
:)
These two articles don't state that it is another
parasite, but it does make say hmmmmmm...I would think
close net lifestyle of crows would make it very possible
for lice or bird flea or even larger insects like
conenose bugs that will inhabit bird nests of ratures to
be a possibility as another vector.

From an article by a rapture rehabilitator
http://www.cah.com/library/wnvrapt.html





IntarsiaCo 28-01-2003 01:14 PM

Crows eradicated in DC, Paghat debunked
 
Let's see, yesterday we helped to adapt a standing wheelchair for a young lady
with CP so that she can attend college and teach a class on inclusion, devised
and manufactured a device for a 3.5 year old without fingers on one hand to
grasp a hockey stick so that he can play just like his older brother, repaired
a young boys new power chair, initiated design on a walker for a set of
conjoined twins ( we have already supplied/modified a stander, bather and
stroller for them) consulted with the head PT at a major rehab hospital on
seating a large man in a chair that is limited in size due to architectural
constraints, advised a local dealer on how to adapt a 20 inch Jay 2 back into a
22 inch wide chair. We will be reimbursed for one of these tasks. People have
come to us for over 20 years because they trust us to do the right thing. I'm
secure in my skin, what's your function in life, playing with vermin?
Back to the issue ratgirl (why would someone nickname themselves after vermin,
low self esteem perhaps), crows are not exterminated in Brookdale, Eastern
birders know that Brookdale has been a crow roost for at least 50 years, there
are plenty of crows left. You should put your paws on the ground and take a
look see for yourself rather than relying on what you can suck up off the net.
Sure is fun toying with you dearie, seems momma and poppa were quite deficient
in socializing you (I assume they did a better job with the potty training),
good grief lady, even dogs are pack socialized by 8 weeks But then again, your
responses are quite predictable and I'm bored with you now. You require anger
management therapy, please do seek some help. If you can't afford it, I'm sure
that there are local agencies that would be willing to assist.
Ta ta Jessica, I have to get some work done.

paghat 28-01-2003 06:47 PM

Crows eradicated in DC, Paghat debunked
 
In article ,
(IntarsiaCo) wrote:

Let's see, yesterday we helped to adapt a standing wheelchair for a young lady
with CP so that she can attend college and teach a class on inclusion, devised
and manufactured a device for a 3.5 year old without fingers on one hand to
grasp a hockey stick so that he can play just like his older brother, repaired
a young boys new power chair, initiated design on a walker for a set of
conjoined twins ( we have already supplied/modified a stander, bather and
stroller for them) consulted with the head PT at a major rehab hospital on
seating a large man in a chair that is limited in size due to architectural
constraints, advised a local dealer on how to adapt a 20 inch Jay 2 back

into a
22 inch wide chair.


[rest of the spam deleted]

Citations, buster, not lying boasts. Even a heating pad manufacturer could
provide citations for the independent laboratory findings for their
product if asked. Pretty damned revealing that you can't. If your
dangerous ugly pegboard-box-on-coasters had the "therapeutic" &
"intervention" values you so easily lie about, all you had to do was post
the studies that showed this to be true. You didn't. You couldn't. They
don't exist.

Perhaps your sales pitch works on the duped & endangered, that hardly
makes that a good thing. If your point really is that there's a sucker
born every minute, I agree some people are so easily duped by a snakeoil
salesman. So much so they'd even put a thrashing palsied child in a
sharp-edged square box with exposed bolts & other sharp bits.

Your therapeutic claims remain unsubstantiated because, quite obviously,
wholly untrue.

Sure is fun toying with you dearie, seems momma and poppa were quite deficient


Just so long as you enjoy the spankings, great. Pretty odd that you do,
since your credibility in your unsnappy comebacks is so lacking. You
just better hope the mommas & poppas of your customers don't see your
attitude toward persons you would regard as "deficient" -- as in deficient
enough to be tricked into purchasing sharp-edged grotesquely dangerous
products for their equally "deficient" offspring.

I've seen your sort before, selling all sorts of worthless devices with
every conceivable promise of therapeutic & health values, not even one of
them substantiated by anything but the snakeoil pitch & hollow claims.
Until the independent lab & peer-review publications are sited, you remain
manifestly a liar hornswoggling people with actual needs into buying
harmful & unproven substitutes for the real thing.

--
"Of what are you afraid, my child?" inquired the kindly teacher.
"Oh, sir! The flowers, they are wild," replied the timid creature.
-from Peter Newell's "Wild Flowers"
See the Garden of Paghat the Ratgirl:
http://www.paghat.com/

paghat 28-01-2003 09:30 PM

Crows eradicated in DC, Paghat debunked
 
In article ,
(IntarsiaCo) wrote:

Until the independent lab & peer-review publications are sited


We're regulated by the FDA and CT Department of Consumer Protection know it
all.


Yeh yeh & you have your retailer liscense too, so what. Still waiting for
the SCIENTIFIC citations that provide the basis for your false &
misleading claims of therapeutic & "intervention" values -- other than
your intervention of peoples' bank accounts for misrepresented & dangerous
products.

Look dearie, they counted over 1500 crows in DC (the most of any

species) over

Even if those HAD all been in Ward 3 & 5 of Brookland -- & you've not a
clue one way or the other, do you, dumbass -- which is where the
mass-die-off occurred, & is not deniable by anyone of even moderate
intelligence -- even if 1,500 crows HAD returned to Brookland, your simple
inability to comprehend reality would NOT change the space time continuum
for the situation reported by Cornell & others in 2002. Of course you're
not intelligent enough to tell the difference.

Just as a pegboard box with coasters bolted to the wheel has NONE of the
medical values you allege for it without even slight foundation.

Christmas, you need to admit it and come to terms with that, I know it is a
difficult thing to do in your overwrought state, but I believe you can do it.
Your ego can't be so fragile that this minor admission will do it irreparable
harm, can it?.


You're breaking the irony meter, oh medical flimflam scoundral.

We're all rooting for you.


The royal we I see. I suspected you heard voices in your head.

Now you go, get better, but please do
return when your condition has stabilized and you've become civilized and
housebroken. Have they tried electroshock yet? Perhaps one of those collars
they use on dogs to property train and a loved one to push the button when you
need correction, have they tried clicker training on you yet, you know

it works
on dolphins (uh, not the fish dearie).
More fun, thanks for the free entertainment I really should be paying you for
this.


I'm sure you DO pay for most of your spankings. It's one of the most
common things you guys ask for, dog collar fantasy & all, so it's quite
proper you should be grateful for once to not have to empty your wallet, &
won't be bringing any venerial diseases home to sundry family members &
the dogs this time, so it's comparatively healthier for you to do it this
way.

I jsut feel sorry for all those endangered kids stuck in that horrible
pegboard box by parents fooled by you into believing they have
"therapeutic & intervention" value. Still waiting for those citations
kiddle. Your wiggling & wiggling is meaningless since you can't provide
the scientific studies that show your medical claims for the dangerously
sharp-edged pegboard box have even a slight basis in reality.

-paggers

--
"Of what are you afraid, my child?" inquired the kindly teacher.
"Oh, sir! The flowers, they are wild," replied the timid creature.
-from Peter Newell's "Wild Flowers"
See the Garden of Paghat the Ratgirl:
http://www.paghat.com/

IntarsiaCo 28-01-2003 09:45 PM

Crows eradicated in DC, Paghat debunked
 
Until the independent lab & peer-review publications are sited

We're regulated by the FDA and CT Department of Consumer Protection know it
all. As you seem to have some kind of skill in pressing a search button, go
check it out, you have plenty of time on your hands.
That is cited with a c, some editor you are, oh verbose one.
Look dearie, they counted over 1500 crows in DC (the most of any species) over
Christmas, you need to admit it and come to terms with that, I know it is a
difficult thing to do in your overwrought state, but I believe you can do it.
Your ego can't be so fragile that this minor admission will do it irreparable
harm, can it?. We're all rooting for you. Now you go, get better, but please do
return when your condition has stabilized and you've become civilized and
housebroken. Have they tried electroshock yet? Perhaps one of those collars
they use on dogs to property train and a loved one to push the button when you
need correction, have they tried clicker training on you yet, you know it works
on dolphins (uh, not the fish dearie).
More fun, thanks for the free entertainment I really should be paying you for
this.
Going home to let the dogs out to play and sow some seed, can't wait to see
what drivel you come up with next Jess.
Cheers dearie.

IntarsiaCo 29-01-2003 12:11 PM

Crows eradicated in DC, Paghat debunked
 
Typical drivel, really not even worth a response this time. The masses are not
rushing to your defense dearie, your failings are quite transparent, more
evidence of parental failings. Let this be a lesson to the parents out there,
you need to set a strong moral course for your children or you may end up with
a sorry soul such as Jess. Normally I would pity a person like you, but your a
nasty fruitcake with no redeeming social value.
Oh, do I read your response as acknowledging that crows are found in DC, folks,
I think we have something here, she has admitted her mistake. This is a
positive step, good girl, good girl, want a cookie?

paghat 29-01-2003 04:39 PM

Crows eradicated in DC, Paghat debunked
 
In article ,
(IntarsiaCo) wrote:

Typical drivel,


Still waiting for the citations.

-paggers

--
"Of what are you afraid, my child?" inquired the kindly teacher.
"Oh, sir! The flowers, they are wild," replied the timid creature.
-from Peter Newell's "Wild Flowers"
See the Garden of Paghat the Ratgirl:
http://www.paghat.com/

IntarsiaCo 29-01-2003 06:01 PM

Crows eradicated in DC, Paghat debunked
 
Still waiting for the citations.


I thought you were a better researcher. I'll give you a couple of hints.
Check the proceedings for the annual meetings of RESNA for the past 20+ years.
See if you can scare up a copy of Positioning for Function by Bergen et al.
Unfortunately for you dearie, not everything is on the net.
Oh, we're not a retail establishment, we fill medical prescriptions for DME
dealers, schools and hospitals. Your ignorance shines bright and your really
nothing to crow about, but then again you know that, don't you dearie? Your out
of your league you know, back down to the minors for you.


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 07:41 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
GardenBanter