GardenBanter.co.uk

GardenBanter.co.uk (https://www.gardenbanter.co.uk/)
-   Orchids (https://www.gardenbanter.co.uk/orchids/)
-   -   Defeating Snails... (https://www.gardenbanter.co.uk/orchids/82143-defeating-snails.html)

Diana Kulaga 21-08-2004 10:06 PM

Defeating Snails...
 
All,

'Tis the summer of the escargots! Big, fat snails hiding in the pots, on
the benches, etc, and doing their evil night work.

I've been using Garden Safe Slug and Snail Bait by Schultz, and it does work
(I've been throwing out dead snails). I chose this product because Casper
the cat goes out in the lanai and it's safe for him. But the pellets
degrade in water, and end up a soggy, moldy mess. This eventually
disappears, but it's still mold, and going into the pots.

It seems to me that I remember copper being an effective snail/slug
deterent. So, if I wrap copper wire around the edges and legs of the
benches, and around the hanging bars, will that help?

TIA

Diana



Gene Schurg 22-08-2004 02:19 AM

Diana,

I doubt this will help you but for others it may....TOADS!

I have lots of toads everywhere. They laid eggs in the small pond in the
back and now I have baby toads everywhere. I have big fat toads all over
the property. I have three or four that live in the greenhouse.

I don't have any slugs. Toads love to eat slugs.

If you can keep the cat from playing with the toads then when you see one
outside scoop it up and put it with your plants on the lanai.

Good Growing,
Gene



"Diana Kulaga" wrote in message
hlink.net...
All,

'Tis the summer of the escargots! Big, fat snails hiding in the pots, on
the benches, etc, and doing their evil night work.

I've been using Garden Safe Slug and Snail Bait by Schultz, and it does

work
(I've been throwing out dead snails). I chose this product because Casper
the cat goes out in the lanai and it's safe for him. But the pellets
degrade in water, and end up a soggy, moldy mess. This eventually
disappears, but it's still mold, and going into the pots.

It seems to me that I remember copper being an effective snail/slug
deterent. So, if I wrap copper wire around the edges and legs of the
benches, and around the hanging bars, will that help?

TIA

Diana





Weeble 22-08-2004 08:34 AM

What you need is some copper fashing a couple of inches wide. It's pretty
soft and easy to cut. They also make a copper snail barrier but I don't
know what it's called.

Shell


"Diana Kulaga" wrote in message
hlink.net...
All,

'Tis the summer of the escargots! Big, fat snails hiding in the pots, on
the benches, etc, and doing their evil night work.

I've been using Garden Safe Slug and Snail Bait by Schultz, and it does

work
(I've been throwing out dead snails). I chose this product because Casper
the cat goes out in the lanai and it's safe for him. But the pellets
degrade in water, and end up a soggy, moldy mess. This eventually
disappears, but it's still mold, and going into the pots.

It seems to me that I remember copper being an effective snail/slug
deterent. So, if I wrap copper wire around the edges and legs of the
benches, and around the hanging bars, will that help?

TIA

Diana





Susan Erickson 22-08-2004 04:40 PM

Don't forget the old beer trick. You can also make a trap that
they enter and that protects the bait from the water to some
extent.

Cut the top off a soda bottle down in the full size area. Turn
it inside out - so the open top goes into the bottle. Staple the
cut edges together and you have a plastic trap that holds the
bait out of the way of most water.

The beer trick is easier. - Just put out a saucer of beer. Cover
it or leave it uncovered. They love beer climb in it readily.

For traps you can also leave a citrus rind upside down on a
bench. They will climb up into it to spend the day. Early
morning discard should help thin the crop.

Good luck.

SuE
http://orchids.legolas.org/gallery/albums.php

Susan Erickson 22-08-2004 04:40 PM

Don't forget the old beer trick. You can also make a trap that
they enter and that protects the bait from the water to some
extent.

Cut the top off a soda bottle down in the full size area. Turn
it inside out - so the open top goes into the bottle. Staple the
cut edges together and you have a plastic trap that holds the
bait out of the way of most water.

The beer trick is easier. - Just put out a saucer of beer. Cover
it or leave it uncovered. They love beer climb in it readily.

For traps you can also leave a citrus rind upside down on a
bench. They will climb up into it to spend the day. Early
morning discard should help thin the crop.

Good luck.

SuE
http://orchids.legolas.org/gallery/albums.php

Weeble 22-08-2004 06:46 PM

I've heard grape juice works too. We were infested in the front yard and I
found Sluggo worked great. Had to apply it twice and will probably apply it
one more time but I haven't seen any snails in awhile

Shell


"Susan Erickson" wrote in message
...
Don't forget the old beer trick. You can also make a trap that
they enter and that protects the bait from the water to some
extent.

Cut the top off a soda bottle down in the full size area. Turn
it inside out - so the open top goes into the bottle. Staple the
cut edges together and you have a plastic trap that holds the
bait out of the way of most water.

The beer trick is easier. - Just put out a saucer of beer. Cover
it or leave it uncovered. They love beer climb in it readily.

For traps you can also leave a citrus rind upside down on a
bench. They will climb up into it to spend the day. Early
morning discard should help thin the crop.

Good luck.

SuE
http://orchids.legolas.org/gallery/albums.php




Diana Kulaga 22-08-2004 09:16 PM

Oh, we have little toads, Gene! I find them in the orchids all the time.
And Casper would "play" with them, for sure. Happily, he hasn't caught any.
We've got tons of geckos out there, too. Those, he does catch, although he
doesn't try to kill them. He wants to play.

Diana



Diana Kulaga 22-08-2004 09:16 PM

Oh, we have little toads, Gene! I find them in the orchids all the time.
And Casper would "play" with them, for sure. Happily, he hasn't caught any.
We've got tons of geckos out there, too. Those, he does catch, although he
doesn't try to kill them. He wants to play.

Diana



Diana Kulaga 22-08-2004 09:23 PM

Thanks, Sue and Shell. I think we'll take an all-out-war approach and do
the bait trap, copper, and beer, along with more bait in the pots, until I
feel rid of them.

Dirty rotten scoundrels!

Diana



Susan Erickson 22-08-2004 10:17 PM

On Sun, 22 Aug 2004 20:23:26 GMT, "Diana Kulaga"
wrote:

Thanks, Sue and Shell. I think we'll take an all-out-war approach and do
the bait trap, copper, and beer, along with more bait in the pots, until I
feel rid of them.

Dirty rotten scoundrels!

Diana

Don't forget - If you pick any up toss them out hole. If you
squash them they self fertilize the eggs and you are now the
carrier planting snail eggs on every plant you touch. Big snails
or little.

My question is how do the little bush snails get into vandas
hanging over head? I found 3 of the little guys today.
SuE
http://orchids.legolas.org/gallery/albums.php

profpam 23-08-2004 12:38 AM

Diana,

Try a product such as THAT'S IT, which doesn't leave a soggy mess and crown rot
in some orchids.

.. . . Pam
Everything Orchid Management System http://www.pe.net/~profpam/page3.html

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Diana Kulaga wrote:

All,

'Tis the summer of the escargots! Big, fat snails hiding in the pots, on
the benches, etc, and doing their evil night work.

I've been using Garden Safe Slug and Snail Bait by Schultz, and it does work
(I've been throwing out dead snails). I chose this product because Casper
the cat goes out in the lanai and it's safe for him. But the pellets
degrade in water, and end up a soggy, moldy mess. This eventually
disappears, but it's still mold, and going into the pots.

It seems to me that I remember copper being an effective snail/slug
deterent. So, if I wrap copper wire around the edges and legs of the
benches, and around the hanging bars, will that help?

TIA

Diana



mg 23-08-2004 02:18 AM

I tried the copper wire thing for slugs. Basically took a wire around
the perimeter boards of a raised garden bed. Didn't do a thing to deter
the slugs. I went back to the Bait.


Diana Kulaga wrote:
All,

'Tis the summer of the escargots! Big, fat snails hiding in the pots, on
the benches, etc, and doing their evil night work.

I've been using Garden Safe Slug and Snail Bait by Schultz, and it does work
(I've been throwing out dead snails). I chose this product because Casper
the cat goes out in the lanai and it's safe for him. But the pellets
degrade in water, and end up a soggy, moldy mess. This eventually
disappears, but it's still mold, and going into the pots.

It seems to me that I remember copper being an effective snail/slug
deterent. So, if I wrap copper wire around the edges and legs of the
benches, and around the hanging bars, will that help?

TIA

Diana




Ray 23-08-2004 10:42 AM

If I'm not mistaken, a wire won't do the trick. It needs to be a strip wide
enough that the entire body must pass over it at once to be effective.

I'd rather just kill them, though...

--

Ray Barkalow - First Rays Orchids - www.firstrays.com
Plants, Supplies, Books, Artwork, and Lots of Free Info!
..
"mg" wrote in message ...
I tried the copper wire thing for slugs. Basically took a wire around
the perimeter boards of a raised garden bed. Didn't do a thing to deter
the slugs. I went back to the Bait.


Diana Kulaga wrote:
All,

'Tis the summer of the escargots! Big, fat snails hiding in the pots,

on
the benches, etc, and doing their evil night work.

I've been using Garden Safe Slug and Snail Bait by Schultz, and it does

work
(I've been throwing out dead snails). I chose this product because

Casper
the cat goes out in the lanai and it's safe for him. But the pellets
degrade in water, and end up a soggy, moldy mess. This eventually
disappears, but it's still mold, and going into the pots.

It seems to me that I remember copper being an effective snail/slug
deterent. So, if I wrap copper wire around the edges and legs of the
benches, and around the hanging bars, will that help?

TIA

Diana






Diana Kulaga 23-08-2004 08:52 PM

My question is how do the little bush snails get into vandas
hanging over head? I found 3 of the little guys today.
SuE


I guess they climb, since I find them in overhead stuff as well.

Diana



Diana Kulaga 23-08-2004 08:53 PM

Try a product such as THAT'S IT, which doesn't leave a soggy mess and
crown rot
in some orchids.


Haven't heard of that, but I'll check it out. Thanks, Pam.

Diana



Diana Kulaga 23-08-2004 08:58 PM

If I'm not mistaken, a wire won't do the trick. It needs to be a strip
wide
enough that the entire body must pass over it at once to be effective.

I'd rather just kill them, though...


We bought copper flashing at HD today. I'd rather kill them, too, but I
don't want to find out I have them by waking up to shredded leaves or
partially eaten flowers! So we're going the two pronged way: bait and
copper.

Diana



Rob Halgren 23-08-2004 09:22 PM

Diana Kulaga wrote:


We bought copper flashing at HD today. I'd rather kill them, too, but I
don't want to find out I have them by waking up to shredded leaves or
partially eaten flowers! So we're going the two pronged way: bait and
copper.


Take it one step beyond. Plug the copper into the wall socket.
Then you can have bait _and_ switch... *grin*

I've heard of (but haven't seen) people putting the legs of their
benches in buckets filled with water. Slugs can't swim... Seems like
this would be detrimental to the longevity of the benches, but I suppose
you could figure something out.

Rob

--
Rob's Rules: http://www.msu.edu/~halgren
1) There is always room for one more orchid
2) There is always room for two more orchids
2a. See rule 1
3) When one has insufficient credit to purchase
more orchids, obtain more credit
LittlefrogFarm is open - e-mail me for a list )

Diana Kulaga 23-08-2004 10:30 PM

Take it one step beyond. Plug the copper into the wall socket. Then you
can have bait _and_ switch... *grin*

Aaaarrrrggh! Groan! LOL!

Diana



Diana Kulaga 23-08-2004 11:07 PM

I have one more question. I like to know why I'm doing what I do. So,
relative to what you said, Ray, does the copper kill the snail or otherwise
disable it? I thought it was used as a deterrent, something the creeps
wouldn't cross. Is that right, or is it something more?

Also, about laying the copper flashing: Frank was going to put down a 2"
border around the edges of the benches, and wrap the legs. Is that the
right way to go about it?

Thanks so much for all the info.

Diana



Pat Brennan 24-08-2004 01:38 PM

The best weapon against slugs I know of is liquid metaldehyde. Same active
ingredient as most of the baits, but nothing left for the pets or to mold in
the pot. I also find it works much better at getting the slugs that are
living at the bottom of the pot then bait will. It is hard to find and a
google search will find 50 UK sources every source in the US. When
comparing prices it seems that UK products are 20% metaldehyde while the US
products are 25%. It used to be cheaper to order from the UK, but the weak
dollar has changed that. Many growers use it in combination with sevin.


Pat


"Diana Kulaga" wrote in message
ink.net...
If I'm not mistaken, a wire won't do the trick. It needs to be a strip

wide
enough that the entire body must pass over it at once to be effective.

I'd rather just kill them, though...


We bought copper flashing at HD today. I'd rather kill them, too, but I
don't want to find out I have them by waking up to shredded leaves or
partially eaten flowers! So we're going the two pronged way: bait and
copper.

Diana





Pat Brennan 24-08-2004 01:38 PM

The best weapon against slugs I know of is liquid metaldehyde. Same active
ingredient as most of the baits, but nothing left for the pets or to mold in
the pot. I also find it works much better at getting the slugs that are
living at the bottom of the pot then bait will. It is hard to find and a
google search will find 50 UK sources every source in the US. When
comparing prices it seems that UK products are 20% metaldehyde while the US
products are 25%. It used to be cheaper to order from the UK, but the weak
dollar has changed that. Many growers use it in combination with sevin.


Pat


"Diana Kulaga" wrote in message
ink.net...
If I'm not mistaken, a wire won't do the trick. It needs to be a strip

wide
enough that the entire body must pass over it at once to be effective.

I'd rather just kill them, though...


We bought copper flashing at HD today. I'd rather kill them, too, but I
don't want to find out I have them by waking up to shredded leaves or
partially eaten flowers! So we're going the two pronged way: bait and
copper.

Diana





Diana Kulaga 24-08-2004 10:12 PM

Thanks, Pat.

Diana



Diana Kulaga 24-08-2004 10:12 PM

Thanks, Pat.

Diana



orchids3 25-08-2004 10:21 PM

"Diana Kulaga" wrote in message hlink.net...
Thanks, Pat.

Diana


Hi
My first post on this Forum - Hello everyone.
I dont use mataldahyde because it gives me a serious itch
that lasts for months. I have used SLUGGO. Sluggo uses
Iron phosphate to kill the slugs and snails and that component
actually turns to a beneficial fertilizer when the stuff decays
but what is the slimy stuff that forms around the pellets?Is
it the Iron phosphate or something else they are useing to attract
snails to eat it. I dont like the appearance of the stuff but it
sure seems to work. Have found Brown Millipedes on top of my
potting medium (about 3 inches long - round brown bodies)which
also seem to be dead but I pull them out and put 250 pounds
thru my shoeon them to be sure - has anyone else found these
things in their pots? By the way WAL-MART has an Iron Phosphate
type bait at a much lower cost than Sluggo - neither of the baits
will harm pets or birds.

orchids3 25-08-2004 10:21 PM

"Diana Kulaga" wrote in message hlink.net...
Thanks, Pat.

Diana


Hi
My first post on this Forum - Hello everyone.
I dont use mataldahyde because it gives me a serious itch
that lasts for months. I have used SLUGGO. Sluggo uses
Iron phosphate to kill the slugs and snails and that component
actually turns to a beneficial fertilizer when the stuff decays
but what is the slimy stuff that forms around the pellets?Is
it the Iron phosphate or something else they are useing to attract
snails to eat it. I dont like the appearance of the stuff but it
sure seems to work. Have found Brown Millipedes on top of my
potting medium (about 3 inches long - round brown bodies)which
also seem to be dead but I pull them out and put 250 pounds
thru my shoeon them to be sure - has anyone else found these
things in their pots? By the way WAL-MART has an Iron Phosphate
type bait at a much lower cost than Sluggo - neither of the baits
will harm pets or birds.

Diana Kulaga 26-08-2004 10:14 PM

Welcome! Glad you are posting. I will wait for someone else to address the
iron phosphate question, since I really don't know.

Thanks for the response.

Diana



Diana Kulaga 26-08-2004 10:14 PM

Welcome! Glad you are posting. I will wait for someone else to address the
iron phosphate question, since I really don't know.

Thanks for the response.

Diana



Orchidguy 30-08-2004 12:41 PM

Uggg....this is the absolute worst year here in Fl for snail ...millions of
them everywhere, I think I'm somwhat getting them under control...
Good luck
Todd
"Diana Kulaga" wrote in message
hlink.net...
All,

'Tis the summer of the escargots! Big, fat snails hiding in the pots, on
the benches, etc, and doing their evil night work.

I've been using Garden Safe Slug and Snail Bait by Schultz, and it does

work
(I've been throwing out dead snails). I chose this product because Casper
the cat goes out in the lanai and it's safe for him. But the pellets
degrade in water, and end up a soggy, moldy mess. This eventually
disappears, but it's still mold, and going into the pots.

It seems to me that I remember copper being an effective snail/slug
deterent. So, if I wrap copper wire around the edges and legs of the
benches, and around the hanging bars, will that help?

TIA

Diana






Orchidguy 30-08-2004 12:41 PM

Uggg....this is the absolute worst year here in Fl for snail ...millions of
them everywhere, I think I'm somwhat getting them under control...
Good luck
Todd
"Diana Kulaga" wrote in message
hlink.net...
All,

'Tis the summer of the escargots! Big, fat snails hiding in the pots, on
the benches, etc, and doing their evil night work.

I've been using Garden Safe Slug and Snail Bait by Schultz, and it does

work
(I've been throwing out dead snails). I chose this product because Casper
the cat goes out in the lanai and it's safe for him. But the pellets
degrade in water, and end up a soggy, moldy mess. This eventually
disappears, but it's still mold, and going into the pots.

It seems to me that I remember copper being an effective snail/slug
deterent. So, if I wrap copper wire around the edges and legs of the
benches, and around the hanging bars, will that help?

TIA

Diana






Clanorchid 30-08-2004 09:06 PM

Hi,

this is the absolute worst year here in Fl for snail ...millions of
them everywhere, I think I'm somwhat getting them under control...


Been in RGO, since 1995. Posted maybe five times, now 7 posts in two days.

Coffee mixture in your water.

Never could figure out the 2% concentration.(remember, I'm a graduate of Fl
schools-have to take my shoes off to count above 12 +GRIN+). We just dump the
remainder of morning coffee (probably 2-3 cups) in the 55 gallon barrel from
which we run our watering/fertilizing/fungicide. Haven't seen a snail in a
year. Plants seem more wide awake, too. LOL.

Caffeine can repel or kill snails that might otherwise eat and ruin plants,

Agricultural Research Service scientists report in the June 27, 2002 issue of
the scientific journal Nature.

In preliminary experiments at his research greenhouse in Hilo, Hollingsworth

applied a 2 percent solution of caffeine in water as a spray to the coconut
husk-chips material in which orchids are grown. This growth medium, called
coir, was infested with the tiny snails. The scientists found that the caffeine
spray killed up to 95 percent of the snails.

In another experiment, the researchers showed that growth medium treated

with the 2 percent caffeine solution had only 5 snails, when checked 30 days
after the spray was applied. That's in contrast to the 35 snails that they
found in growth medium that had been treated with a standard dose of
metaldehyde, a common molluscicide.


Hope This May Help Someone,

Karen and Jerry

Camp Lot A Noise Tropicals (C. L. A. N.) http://www.clanorchids.com
Orchid Species, Hybrids, Supplies, Photos and Books
Chat (941) 352-2483 Fax: (941) 351-2483 X 123 Order Only 1-800-351-CITE

Diana Kulaga 30-08-2004 10:20 PM

Uggg....this is the absolute worst year here in Fl for snail ...millions
of them everywhere, I think I'm somwhat getting them under control...

You're right. I have never had a snail problem to speak of before. This
year is brutal. This is war!!

Diana



Diana Kulaga 30-08-2004 10:22 PM

Karen and Jerry,

Thanks much for that tip! Easy to try, and the worst that can happen is
that Casper the Wonder Cat drinks some and has a really wild gym session!

Diana




All times are GMT +1. The time now is 12:32 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
GardenBanter