Can somebody please identify the fruit contained in the bottle
illustrated at

http://www.box.net/public/static/490zvq1gf6.jpg

It tastes almost exactly like the European gooseberry Ribes
uva-crispa, but clearly is not.

The fruit is the size of an olive and, as the photo shows, seems to
have had a stone removed.

It is a product of China.

To me, they look like little pomes. If they were North American, I'd
say hawthorn fruits.

M. Reed


Richard Wright wrote:
Can somebody please identify the fruit contained in the bottle
illustrated at

http://www.box.net/public/static/490zvq1gf6.jpg

It tastes almost exactly like the European gooseberry Ribes
uva-crispa, but clearly is not.

The fruit is the size of an olive and, as the photo shows, seems to
have had a stone removed.

It is a product of China.

In message , monique
writes
To me, they look like little pomes. If they were North American, I'd
say hawthorn fruits.

M. Reed


Pome. China. Free associates. Loquat (Eriobotyra japonica). Images
online don't look too bad a match, but tend more to the yellow or orange
than to the red. Taste (per Google) is said to vary.

Richard Wright wrote:
Can somebody please identify the fruit contained in the bottle
illustrated at
http://www.box.net/public/static/490zvq1gf6.jpg
It tastes almost exactly like the European gooseberry Ribes
uva-crispa, but clearly is not.
The fruit is the size of an olive and, as the photo shows, seems to
have had a stone removed.
It is a product of China.

--
Stewart Robert Hinsley

I agree about the possibility of it being a pome. But any hawthorn I
have seen in Europe and Australia has fruits the size of a pea - not
an olive.

On Fri, 31 Mar 2006 17:23:18 -0600, monique
wrote:

To me, they look like little pomes. If they were North American, I'd
say hawthorn fruits.

M. Reed


Richard Wright wrote:
Can somebody please identify the fruit contained in the bottle
illustrated at

http://www.box.net/public/static/490zvq1gf6.jpg

It tastes almost exactly like the European gooseberry Ribes
uva-crispa, but clearly is not.

The fruit is the size of an olive and, as the photo shows, seems to
have had a stone removed.

It is a product of China.

In article ,
Richard Wright wrote:
Can somebody please identify the fruit contained in the bottle
illustrated at

http://www.box.net/public/static/490zvq1gf6.jpg

It tastes almost exactly like the European gooseberry Ribes
uva-crispa, but clearly is not.

The fruit is the size of an olive and, as the photo shows, seems to
have had a stone removed.

It is a product of China.

I agree that it looks like a pome fruit. The leaves in the picture
are lobed, like many Crataegus spp (hawthorns). I don't think it was
a stone removed -- more like the whole core punched out, as is often
done with pickled crabapples.

Note that there are literally hundreds of species and hybrids in
Malus (apples), Pyrus (pears), Crataegus (hawthorns) and other
pome genera, and some may have been selected for larger fruit in
some area of China. Note also that olives vary a lot in size... ;-)

Cripes, it could be an unusually meaty rosehip or a little known
type of loquat or a Chaenomeles quince.

Perhaps you can find someone to translate the Chinese for you, but
common names are no more scientifically accurate in Chinese than in
European languages. My first thought, before I looked at the picture,
was jujubes (Zizyphus sp), which are called red dates or thorn dates
in Chinese although they are completely unrelated to dates or AFAIK,
pome fruits.

Let us know if you find out.

http://images.google.cn/images?hl=zh...TW&sa=N&tab=wi

On 1 Apr 2006 03:19:03 GMT, wrote:

In article ,
Richard Wright wrote:
Can somebody please identify the fruit contained in the bottle
illustrated at

http://www.box.net/public/static/490zvq1gf6.jpg

It tastes almost exactly like the European gooseberry Ribes
uva-crispa, but clearly is not.

The fruit is the size of an olive and, as the photo shows, seems to
have had a stone removed.

It is a product of China.

I agree that it looks like a pome fruit. The leaves in the picture
are lobed, like many Crataegus spp (hawthorns). I don't think it was
a stone removed -- more like the whole core punched out, as is often
done with pickled crabapples.

Note that there are literally hundreds of species and hybrids in
Malus (apples), Pyrus (pears), Crataegus (hawthorns) and other
pome genera, and some may have been selected for larger fruit in
some area of China. Note also that olives vary a lot in size... ;-)

Cripes, it could be an unusually meaty rosehip or a little known
type of loquat or a Chaenomeles quince.

Perhaps you can find someone to translate the Chinese for you, but
common names are no more scientifically accurate in Chinese than in
European languages. My first thought, before I looked at the picture,
was jujubes (Zizyphus sp), which are called red dates or thorn dates
in Chinese although they are completely unrelated to dates or AFAIK,
pome fruits.

Let us know if you find out.

Well, it turns out it is hawthorn. I had not considered that there
might be large cultivated varieties.

Somebody on rec.gardens.edible translated the Chinese: "The four
Chinese characters on the label says "ben tong san ja"
translate into "rock sugar san ja". As I said before, "san ja" is
hawthorn berry. The can contains peeled hawthorn berries on rock
sugar syrup."

See also

http://www.pfaf.org/database/plants....natifida+major