GardenBanter.co.uk

GardenBanter.co.uk (https://www.gardenbanter.co.uk/)
-   Ponds (https://www.gardenbanter.co.uk/ponds/)
-   -   What kind of salt to get (https://www.gardenbanter.co.uk/ponds/58716-what-kind-salt-get.html)

KRF 12-04-2004 02:03 PM

What kind of salt to get
 
Just need to know what kind of salt to buy, my local pond store sells
jars for 20.00 each. There has to be a cheaper alternative, I just
don't know what. Can I use un iodized table salt? Water softener salt?
Thanks


[email protected] 12-04-2004 06:06 PM

What kind of salt to get
 
water softening salt, no additives, crystals and in a plastic bag, not paper. it is
often called solar salt. usually at the food store. Ingrid

(KRF) wrote:

Just need to know what kind of salt to buy, my local pond store sells
jars for 20.00 each. There has to be a cheaper alternative, I just
don't know what. Can I use un iodized table salt? Water softener salt?
Thanks




~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
List Manager: Puregold Goldfish List
http://puregold.aquaria.net/
www.drsolo.com
Solve the problem, dont waste energy finding who's to blame
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Unfortunately, I receive no money, gifts, discounts or other
compensation for all the damn work I do, nor for any of the
endorsements or recommendations I make.

Hal 12-04-2004 07:08 PM

What kind of salt to get
 
On Mon, 12 Apr 2004 08:41:37 -0400, (KRF) wrote:

Just need to know what kind of salt to buy, my local pond store sells
jars for 20.00 each. There has to be a cheaper alternative, I just
don't know what. Can I use un iodized table salt? Water softener salt?
Thanks


Solar salt for water softeners is almost 100% pure salt.

Regards,

Hal

volts500 13-04-2004 10:35 PM

What kind of salt to get
 

"KRF" wrote in message
...
Just need to know what kind of salt to buy, my local pond store sells
jars for 20.00 each. There has to be a cheaper alternative, I just
don't know what. Can I use un iodized table salt? Water softener salt?
Thanks


Don't use iodized salt. Rock salt is best because it contains not only
Sodium salt, but Calcium and Magnesium salts as well, which yields better
results when trying to improve the fishes osmoregulation as compared to
using pure NaCl (water softener salt). 99.9 % pure NaCl water softener salt
does work and is inexpensive, however if you can find bulk rock salt, IMHO,
that would be preferred. "Aquarium Salt" and "Pond Salt" _is_ rock salt,
just with an expensive price tag.



Hal 14-04-2004 03:05 AM

What kind of salt to get
 
On Tue, 13 Apr 2004 21:07:35 GMT, "volts500"
wrote:


"KRF" wrote in message
...
Just need to know what kind of salt to buy, my local pond store sells
jars for 20.00 each. There has to be a cheaper alternative, I just
don't know what. Can I use un iodized table salt? Water softener salt?
Thanks


Don't use iodized salt. Rock salt is best because it contains not only
Sodium salt, but Calcium and Magnesium salts as well, which yields better
results when trying to improve the fishes osmoregulation as compared to
using pure NaCl (water softener salt). 99.9 % pure NaCl water softener salt
does work and is inexpensive, however if you can find bulk rock salt, IMHO,
that would be preferred. "Aquarium Salt" and "Pond Salt" _is_ rock salt,
just with an expensive price tag.

Wouldn't it be better to check hardness (GH) before adding calcium or
magnesium?

Regards,

Hal

Mike Patterson 14-04-2004 03:05 AM

What kind of salt to get
 


On Tue, 13 Apr 2004 21:07:35 GMT, "volts500"
wrote:


"KRF" wrote in message
...
Just need to know what kind of salt to buy, my local pond store sells
jars for 20.00 each. There has to be a cheaper alternative, I just
don't know what. Can I use un iodized table salt? Water softener salt?
Thanks


Don't use iodized salt. Rock salt is best because it contains not only
Sodium salt, but Calcium and Magnesium salts as well, which yields better
results when trying to improve the fishes osmoregulation as compared to
using pure NaCl (water softener salt). 99.9 % pure NaCl water softener salt
does work and is inexpensive, however if you can find bulk rock salt, IMHO,
that would be preferred. "Aquarium Salt" and "Pond Salt" _is_ rock salt,
just with an expensive price tag.

how about "kosher" salt?

I keep it around for margarita glasses, I guess I could share it with
my little pisce friends.

Mike Patterson
Please remove the spamtrap to email me.

Lee B. 14-04-2004 04:34 PM

What kind of salt to get
 
The lasts time I looked, kosher salt has/d YSP, which is something that's
used to keep the salt from clumping. It's not good for gills . . . but if
you're only using a small amount of it, it won't kill them (the *first*
time, at least s). Keep it for the margueritas (or other cooking!).

Lee

"Mike Patterson" wrote in message
...


On Tue, 13 Apr 2004 21:07:35 GMT, "volts500"
wrote:


"KRF" wrote in message
...
Just need to know what kind of salt to buy, my local pond store sells
jars for 20.00 each. There has to be a cheaper alternative, I just
don't know what. Can I use un iodized table salt? Water softener

salt?
Thanks


Don't use iodized salt. Rock salt is best because it contains not only
Sodium salt, but Calcium and Magnesium salts as well, which yields better
results when trying to improve the fishes osmoregulation as compared to
using pure NaCl (water softener salt). 99.9 % pure NaCl water softener

salt
does work and is inexpensive, however if you can find bulk rock salt,

IMHO,
that would be preferred. "Aquarium Salt" and "Pond Salt" _is_ rock salt,
just with an expensive price tag.

how about "kosher" salt?

I keep it around for margarita glasses, I guess I could share it with
my little pisce friends.

Mike Patterson
Please remove the spamtrap to email me.




Lee B. 14-04-2004 04:34 PM

What kind of salt to get
 
Volts, go to Home Depot, Lowe's, whatever and get the Morton Salt in the
blue bag. You'll get 20 lbs. of it for about $3.00 or so. It's fine for
fish.

Lee


"volts500" wrote in message
...

"KRF" wrote in message
...
Just need to know what kind of salt to buy, my local pond store sells
jars for 20.00 each. There has to be a cheaper alternative, I just
don't know what. Can I use un iodized table salt? Water softener salt?
Thanks


Don't use iodized salt. Rock salt is best because it contains not only
Sodium salt, but Calcium and Magnesium salts as well, which yields better
results when trying to improve the fishes osmoregulation as compared to
using pure NaCl (water softener salt). 99.9 % pure NaCl water softener

salt
does work and is inexpensive, however if you can find bulk rock salt,

IMHO,
that would be preferred. "Aquarium Salt" and "Pond Salt" _is_ rock salt,
just with an expensive price tag.





volts500 15-04-2004 02:03 AM

What kind of salt to get
 

"Lee B." wrote in message
...
Volts, go to Home Depot, Lowe's, whatever and get the Morton Salt in the
blue bag. You'll get 20 lbs. of it for about $3.00 or so. It's fine for
fish.

Lee


OK, thanks. Is that Morton in the blue bag rock salt or water softener
salt?


"volts500" wrote in message
...

"KRF" wrote in message
...
Just need to know what kind of salt to buy, my local pond store sells
jars for 20.00 each. There has to be a cheaper alternative, I just
don't know what. Can I use un iodized table salt? Water softener

salt?
Thanks


Don't use iodized salt. Rock salt is best because it contains not only
Sodium salt, but Calcium and Magnesium salts as well, which yields

better
results when trying to improve the fishes osmoregulation as compared to
using pure NaCl (water softener salt). 99.9 % pure NaCl water softener

salt
does work and is inexpensive, however if you can find bulk rock salt,

IMHO,
that would be preferred. "Aquarium Salt" and "Pond Salt" _is_ rock

salt,
just with an expensive price tag.








volts500 15-04-2004 02:34 AM

What kind of salt to get
 

"Hal" wrote in message
...
On Tue, 13 Apr 2004 21:07:35 GMT, "volts500"
wrote:


"KRF" wrote in message
...
Just need to know what kind of salt to buy, my local pond store sells
jars for 20.00 each. There has to be a cheaper alternative, I just
don't know what. Can I use un iodized table salt? Water softener

salt?
Thanks


Don't use iodized salt. Rock salt is best because it contains not only
Sodium salt, but Calcium and Magnesium salts as well, which yields better
results when trying to improve the fishes osmoregulation as compared to
using pure NaCl (water softener salt). 99.9 % pure NaCl water softener

salt
does work and is inexpensive, however if you can find bulk rock salt,

IMHO,
that would be preferred. "Aquarium Salt" and "Pond Salt" _is_ rock salt,
just with an expensive price tag.

Wouldn't it be better to check hardness (GH) before adding calcium or
magnesium?

Regards,

Hal


I'd think that if the GH were changed significantly by adding salt that the
salt level would be way over what the fish could take anyway.



Sue Walsh 15-04-2004 12:33 PM

What kind of salt to get
 
"Lee B." wrote in message ...
The lasts time I looked, kosher salt has/d YSP, which is something that's
used to keep the salt from clumping. It's not good for gills . . .


Lee,
My box of Kosher Salt says ingredients: Salt

Nothing else listed, does that mean it's OK to use for the fish?

Sue W

Lee B. 15-04-2004 03:03 PM

What kind of salt to get
 
It's just rock salt used for water softeners. Or icy sidewalks, but we don't
live there G. Just don't get the pellets (yellow bag). You want plain ol'
rock salt. (I have a water softener that I use the yellow bag for, and then
I have the blue bag that I use for the pond. Every once in awhile, when my
husband gets in a "helpful" mood, he'll dump my fish salt in the water
softener to top it off. Oh well - it's cheap!)

Lee



"volts500" wrote in message
m...

"Lee B." wrote in message
...
Volts, go to Home Depot, Lowe's, whatever and get the Morton Salt in the
blue bag. You'll get 20 lbs. of it for about $3.00 or so. It's fine for
fish.

Lee


OK, thanks. Is that Morton in the blue bag rock salt or water softener
salt?


"volts500" wrote in message
...

"KRF" wrote in message
...
Just need to know what kind of salt to buy, my local pond store

sells
jars for 20.00 each. There has to be a cheaper alternative, I just
don't know what. Can I use un iodized table salt? Water softener

salt?
Thanks

Don't use iodized salt. Rock salt is best because it contains not

only
Sodium salt, but Calcium and Magnesium salts as well, which yields

better
results when trying to improve the fishes osmoregulation as compared

to
using pure NaCl (water softener salt). 99.9 % pure NaCl water

softener
salt
does work and is inexpensive, however if you can find bulk rock salt,

IMHO,
that would be preferred. "Aquarium Salt" and "Pond Salt" _is_ rock

salt,
just with an expensive price tag.










Lee B. 15-04-2004 03:04 PM

What kind of salt to get
 
Hey Sue! Yeh - if there's nothing else in it but salt - but trust me: a 3
lb. box of kosher salt won't do jack-diddly for a pond's salt level. And
it's expensive compared to a 20 lb. bag of rock salt. Shoot - you can buy
the rock salt at the grocery store (I know Publix and Winn-Dixie carries
it) - it's more expensive than at Home Depot, but you won't have to make the
extra stop.

Lee


"Sue Walsh" wrote in message
om...
"Lee B." wrote in message

...
The lasts time I looked, kosher salt has/d YSP, which is something

that's
used to keep the salt from clumping. It's not good for gills . . .


Lee,
My box of Kosher Salt says ingredients: Salt

Nothing else listed, does that mean it's OK to use for the fish?

Sue W





All times are GMT +1. The time now is 09:48 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
GardenBanter