DD potted vs. bare root
Susan H. Simko wrote:
The Lowes rose was also twice the size of the bare root when I put the Lowes in the ground. However, the bare root now makes the Lowes look like a shrimp. Near identical conditions for the two roses so it's just "interesting" right now. Daniel Hanna wrote: Interesting. Susan, what kind of soil did you plant the bare root in? Both of the beds were prepared at the same time - a good rich potting soil with some fertilizer(s) mixed in. I'm of the "dig a big hole in the clay, throw away the clay, and fill the hole with good soil" camp. I can't remember exactly what soil I used at the time as I have switched off brands when putting in different beds but the interesting part is that both beds were prepared at the same time and the soil mix came out of the same wheelbarrow. Only difference that I can think of is that the J&P bare root got a several week soak in a bucket with nutrients before it was planted where as I don't know what was done to the Lowes potted J&P to prepare it. Susan shsimko at duke dot edu |
DD potted vs. bare root
In Susan H. Simko wrote:
I'm of the "dig a big hole in the clay, throw away the clay, and fill the hole with good soil" camp. I'm in the tent right next to yours :-) When I shovel pruned a couple of roses last season, I dug up one where I used the native soil and one that had the soil replaced with a high quality rose mix. The difference in root systems was remarkable - over 50%. The rose with replaced soil had grown and bloomed far better too. It was hard for me to believe that I'd planted both as bare roots, at the same time. |
DD potted vs. bare root
In Susan H. Simko wrote:
I'm of the "dig a big hole in the clay, throw away the clay, and fill the hole with good soil" camp. I'm in the tent right next to yours :-) When I shovel pruned a couple of roses last season, I dug up one where I used the native soil and one that had the soil replaced with a high quality rose mix. The difference in root systems was remarkable - over 50%. The rose with replaced soil had grown and bloomed far better too. It was hard for me to believe that I'd planted both as bare roots, at the same time. |
DD potted vs. bare root
Why did it get shovel pruned???? Theo When I shovel pruned a couple of roses last season, I dug up one where I used the native soil and one that had the soil replaced with a high quality rose mix. The difference in root systems was remarkable - over 50%. The rose with replaced soil had grown and bloomed far better too. It was hard for me to believe that I'd planted both as bare roots, at the same time. |
DD potted vs. bare root
In m Theo Asir wrote:
Why did it get shovel pruned???? Theo, my garden has limited size but I want to keep exploring. So... each year I remove 3 roses, and get 3 new ones. I often pot the rejects or give them away. Killing a rose just seems like bad karma. The ones I remove are my least favourite, but even they are getting pretty good now. This winter I removed White Lightnin', Black Velvet and Hot Chocolate. Hot Chocolate is the only one of those I won't miss. Ironically it was also the one I used soil replacement on...and the root system was so strong I nearly did my back in removing it! |
DD potted vs. bare root
Ahh! That explains it. I have a rejects bed where I crowd the roses shamelessly. Toughest ones will survive. Theo "Daniel Hanna" wrote in message home.com.au... In m Theo Asir wrote: Why did it get shovel pruned???? Theo, my garden has limited size but I want to keep exploring. So... each year I remove 3 roses, and get 3 new ones. I often pot the rejects or give them away. Killing a rose just seems like bad karma. The ones I remove are my least favourite, but even they are getting pretty good now. This winter I removed White Lightnin', Black Velvet and Hot Chocolate. Hot Chocolate is the only one of those I won't miss. Ironically it was also the one I used soil replacement on...and the root system was so strong I nearly did my back in removing it! |
All times are GMT +1. The time now is 02:31 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
GardenBanter