GardenBanter.co.uk

GardenBanter.co.uk (https://www.gardenbanter.co.uk/)
-   United Kingdom (https://www.gardenbanter.co.uk/united-kingdom/)
-   -   Composting (https://www.gardenbanter.co.uk/united-kingdom/12257-composting.html)

Pete The Gardener 30-03-2003 02:33 AM

Composting
 
Has anyone tried the products from: http://www.livingsoil.co.uk/# One
of the people on the estate was talking about them the other day, but
hadn't had a chance to give it a proper try. If it works then I might
give it a go, but I don't want to waste the cash and time if it's a
load of rubbish.


--
Pete The Gardener
A room without books is like a body without a soul.


bnd777 30-03-2003 02:33 AM

Composting
 
I suggest you stick to good old fashioned Compost with liberall dashings of
Sulphate of ammonia and urine thrown in plus a shoveful of worms later
"Pete The Gardener" wrote in message
...
Has anyone tried the products from: http://www.livingsoil.co.uk/# One
of the people on the estate was talking about them the other day, but
hadn't had a chance to give it a proper try. If it works then I might
give it a go, but I don't want to waste the cash and time if it's a
load of rubbish.


--
Pete The Gardener
A room without books is like a body without a soul.




Pete The Gardener 30-03-2003 02:33 AM

Composting
 
On Sat, 29 Mar 2003 19:34:33 +0000 (UTC), "bnd777"
wrote:


"Pete The Gardener" wrote in message
...
Has anyone tried the products from: http://www.livingsoil.co.uk/# One
of the people on the estate was talking about them the other day, but
hadn't had a chance to give it a proper try. If it works then I might
give it a go, but I don't want to waste the cash and time if it's a
load of rubbish.

I suggest you stick to good old fashioned Compost with liberall dashings of
Sulphate of ammonia and urine thrown in plus a shoveful of worms later


Top Posting re-arranged for ease of reading.

I'm not at all sure I fancy a standard compost heap (particularly
using urine) in my kitchen;-) This thing is for composting kitchen
waste, even bones apparently.
--
Pete The Gardener
A room without books is like a body without a soul.


Victor West 30-03-2003 02:33 AM

Composting
 

"Pete The Gardener" wrote in message
...
On Sat, 29 Mar 2003 19:34:33 +0000 (UTC), "bnd777"
wrote:


snip
Top Posting re-arranged for ease of reading.


Illogical moan on.........
Now I know that bottom posting is more correct and usually easier to follow
but one thing that annoys me slightly is when I find someone rearranging
someone else's post. Top posting may be technically incorrect but we
wouldn't all go and amend the grammar or spelling of other posts, would we?
......Illogical moan off

Victor



bnd777 30-03-2003 02:33 AM

Composting
 
Actually I find bottom posting blasted annoying
If you bother to follow a thread you simply read the follow up instead of
rereading all the garbage

If Pete had said he wanted a composter in his kitchen the answer might be
different however beats me what "bug" would also decompose bones


"Victor West" wrote in message
...

"Pete The Gardener" wrote in message
...
On Sat, 29 Mar 2003 19:34:33 +0000 (UTC), "bnd777"
wrote:


snip
Top Posting re-arranged for ease of reading.


Illogical moan on.........
Now I know that bottom posting is more correct and usually easier to

follow
but one thing that annoys me slightly is when I find someone rearranging
someone else's post. Top posting may be technically incorrect but we
wouldn't all go and amend the grammar or spelling of other posts, would

we?
.....Illogical moan off

Victor





Nick Maclaren 30-03-2003 02:33 AM

Composting
 
In article ,
Victor West wrote:

"Pete The Gardener" wrote in message
...
On Sat, 29 Mar 2003 19:34:33 +0000 (UTC), "bnd777"
wrote:


Top Posting re-arranged for ease of reading.


Illogical moan on.........
Now I know that bottom posting is more correct and usually easier to follow
but one thing that annoys me slightly is when I find someone rearranging
someone else's post. Top posting may be technically incorrect but we
wouldn't all go and amend the grammar or spelling of other posts, would we?
.....Illogical moan off


Have you ever tried to read a posting with a history of 10-20 long,
with a mixture of top and bottom posting? I can assure you that the
only practical solution is to rearrange it!

Regards,
Nick Maclaren.

Pete The Gardener 30-03-2003 04:20 AM

Composting
 
On Sat, 29 Mar 2003 21:20:56 -0000, "Victor West"
wrote:


Illogical moan on.........
Now I know that bottom posting is more correct and usually easier to follow
but one thing that annoys me slightly is when I find someone rearranging
someone else's post. Top posting may be technically incorrect but we
wouldn't all go and amend the grammar or spelling of other posts, would we?
.....Illogical moan off


Since I was quoting my own post as well as the one I was responding to
it would have been rather dificult to follow without the
re-arrangement.
I don't do spelling and grammar since I'm dyslexic and have enough
problems with my own without trying to sort out anyone else's.

--
Pete The Gardener
A room without books is like a body without a soul.


Anne Jackson 30-03-2003 05:44 AM

Composting
 
The message
from "Victor West" contains these words:

"Pete The Gardener" wrote in message
...
On Sat, 29 Mar 2003 19:34:33 +0000 (UTC), "bnd777"
wrote:


snip
Top Posting re-arranged for ease of reading.


Illogical moan on.........
Now I know that bottom posting is more correct and usually easier
to follow but one thing that annoys me slightly is when I find
someone rearranging someone else's post. Top posting may be
technically incorrect but we wouldn't all go and amend the grammar
or spelling of other posts, would we?
.....Illogical moan off


I would. I even sort out line wraps.

--
AnneJ
ICQ #:- 119531282





Sarah Dale 30-03-2003 09:20 PM

Composting
 
Hi Pete,

I can't find this web site at all! However, if you have some further info
I would be interested. It always annoys me to have to put waste meat
scraps and bones in the bin when they are highly bidegradable. (Although
not suitable for a home garden compost heap).

Sarah

On Sat, 29 Mar 2003 18:50:58 +0000, Pete The Gardener wrote:

Has anyone tried the products from: http://www.livingsoil.co.uk/# One
of the people on the estate was talking about them the other day, but
hadn't had a chance to give it a proper try. If it works then I might
give it a go, but I don't want to waste the cash and time if it's a
load of rubbish.



Rog 30-03-2003 09:44 PM

Composting
 
A layer of vegetation etc, a layer of soil, a sprinkling of lime, then
repeat the process.
No smell, excellent compost.
No top post, no bottom post , just plain post :0)
--
Rog
http://www.geocities.com/rogerscyberhome



bnd777 30-03-2003 10:56 PM

Composting
 
Bones and scaps etc are fine in a worm bin though ......although the bones
dont disintegrate they are just picked clean


"Sarah Dale" wrote in message
o.uk...
Hi Pete,

I can't find this web site at all! However, if you have some further info
I would be interested. It always annoys me to have to put waste meat
scraps and bones in the bin when they are highly bidegradable. (Although
not suitable for a home garden compost heap).

Sarah

On Sat, 29 Mar 2003 18:50:58 +0000, Pete The Gardener wrote:

Has anyone tried the products from: http://www.livingsoil.co.uk/# One
of the people on the estate was talking about them the other day, but
hadn't had a chance to give it a proper try. If it works then I might
give it a go, but I don't want to waste the cash and time if it's a
load of rubbish.





Nick Maclaren 31-03-2003 08:32 AM

Composting
 

In article ,
"Sarah Dale" writes:
|
| I can't find this web site at all! However, if you have some further info
| I would be interested. It always annoys me to have to put waste meat
| scraps and bones in the bin when they are highly bidegradable. (Although
| not suitable for a home garden compost heap).

Why not? I have composted them for 25 years with no problems.
Others have done so for longer.


Regards,
Nick Maclaren.

Paul Kelly 31-03-2003 09:08 AM

Composting
 

"Nick Maclaren" wrote in message
...

In article ,
"Sarah Dale" writes:
|
| I can't find this web site at all! However, if you have some further

info
| I would be interested. It always annoys me to have to put waste meat
| scraps and bones in the bin when they are highly bidegradable.

(Although
| not suitable for a home garden compost heap).

Why not? I have composted them for 25 years with no problems.
Others have done so for longer.



Do you live in town or country?

In town putting meat on the compost bin is an open invitation to foxes and
rats.

pk



Nick Maclaren 31-03-2003 09:56 AM

Composting
 

In article ,
"Paul Kelly" writes:
|
| Do you live in town or country?
|
| In town putting meat on the compost bin is an open invitation
| to foxes and rats.

Suburbs. There are both in the vicinity, and I believe that both
visit the garden regularly. It is an old wife's tale that putting
meat scraps or bones on the compost heap attracts rats (or even
foxes) any more than anything else does. I don't know whether
putting whole joints on would, as it is not something that we do!

Note that there is a similar old wife's tale that is more common
in the USA but still appears here, where it is putting cooked food
on the heap that attracts rats. I have even heard the variant that
it is putting uncooked vegetables that does, so now we have covered
all bases :-)

Unless you run a VERY wasteful kitchen, then just heaving all
kitchen waste on the heap is usually fine. I can believe that
the occasional rat or fox will be attracted by certain foods, and
obviously meat scraps are one of the more likely, but it is rare.
This is not just my experience, either, but has been told to me
by several rat-catchers (sorry, pest control operatives).


Regards,
Nick Maclaren.

Victoria Clare 31-03-2003 10:44 AM

Composting
 
(Nick Maclaren) wrote in news:b68v6p$qh4$1
@pegasus.csx.cam.ac.uk:


In article ,
"Paul Kelly" writes:
|
| Do you live in town or country?
|
| In town putting meat on the compost bin is an open invitation
| to foxes and rats.

Suburbs. There are both in the vicinity, and I believe that both
visit the garden regularly. It is an old wife's tale that putting
meat scraps or bones on the compost heap attracts rats (or even
foxes) any more than anything else does. I don't know whether
putting whole joints on would, as it is not something that we do!


To support this, one of my cats caught a rabbit (not one of mine!) the
week before last.

I slung it on the compost heap. I had a prod through this week and it's
still there, quite untouched (even by flies yet: must be too early in
the year).

Another example: there was a time when we used to buy big bones for our
dogs. Dogs aren't very organised, so they tended to leave the chewed
remnants in distant beds and under hedges. Never caused a rat problem
(I don't think the rats were scared for the dogs: the dogs were
wusses!).

The one thing I have found attracts rats is fresh grains in rabbit or
guinea-pig food. They really like that, and will hang around to get it.

I keep food for my bunnies inside the house in a sealed box, and if the
bunnies don't clean out their bowl I feed 'em less till they do: this
seems to help and is also better for the bunnies (they don't believe
this though!).

Victoria

(Yes, I know I could have made a pie. It was a busy week and I find
preparing rabbit from scratch very tedious. Skinning takes forever and
all those little bones!)

Ophelia 31-03-2003 01:56 PM

Composting
 

"Victoria Clare" wrote in message


(Yes, I know I could have made a pie. It was a busy week and I find
preparing rabbit from scratch very tedious. Skinning takes forever and
all those little bones!)


I am very lucky:)) My SO shoots and always cleans the kill in the field:))
He says it is food for the other wild things there and no mess at home

O





William Tasso 31-03-2003 04:32 PM

Composting
 
Nick Maclaren wrote:
In article ,
"Sarah Dale" writes:

I can't find this web site at all! However, if you have some
further info I would be interested. It always annoys me to have to
put waste meat scraps and bones in the bin when they are highly
bidegradable. (Although not suitable for a home garden compost
heap).


Why not? I have composted them for 25 years with no problems.
Others have done so for longer.


Seems an excessively long time to wait for compost ;o)

--
William Tasso




Nick Maclaren 31-03-2003 04:44 PM

Composting
 

In article ,
"William Tasso" writes:
| Nick Maclaren wrote:
| In article ,
| "Sarah Dale" writes:
|
| I can't find this web site at all! However, if you have some
| further info I would be interested. It always annoys me to have to
| put waste meat scraps and bones in the bin when they are highly
| bidegradable. (Although not suitable for a home garden compost
| heap).
|
| Why not? I have composted them for 25 years with no problems.
| Others have done so for longer.
|
| Seems an excessively long time to wait for compost ;o)

Nice one! Admittedly, beef leg bones to take getting on for that
long to break down :-)


Regards,
Nick Maclaren.

Sarah Dale 31-03-2003 09:20 PM

Composting
 
On Mon, 31 Mar 2003 07:17:59 +0000, Nick Maclaren wrote:

| I can't find this web site at all! However, if you have some further info
| I would be interested. It always annoys me to have to put waste meat
| scraps and bones in the bin when they are highly bidegradable. (Although


Why not? I have composted them for 25 years with no problems.
Others have done so for longer.


Well, I can't put in chicken or other light bones in case the cats get at
it. But you raise an interesting point in one of your other responses to
this thread. So many people on URG have said don't put meat or bones on
the heap because it attracts rats - you're saying that it doesn't make any
difference.

In my household, all vegetable based scraps - cooked and uncooked go on my
(cold heap, sarah-rigged wooden containers, open topped) compost heap, as do all
prunings and garden waste. All meat bones and inedible bits (skin, gristle
etc.) are binned. All the meat is eaten.

I'm willing to have a go by putting in big bones, gristle and skin - what
sort of decomposition rate should I expect based on the fact I run a cold
heap? And possibly I would need to look at putting some sort of lid on the
heap perhaps... Mind you given that the compost bins are starting to need
rebuilding (PLEASE wait to Autumn!) that could be interesting!

Sarah

Nick Maclaren 31-03-2003 09:44 PM

Composting
 
In article ,
Sarah Dale wrote:

Well, I can't put in chicken or other light bones in case the cats get at
it. But you raise an interesting point in one of your other responses to
this thread. So many people on URG have said don't put meat or bones on
the heap because it attracts rats - you're saying that it doesn't make any
difference.


In general, it doesn't. That doesn't mean it never will. I don't
keep cats, but I agree that they raid the heap - the only solution
there is to cover the bones, because cats won't dig far.

In my household, all vegetable based scraps - cooked and uncooked go on my
(cold heap, sarah-rigged wooden containers, open topped) compost heap, as do all
prunings and garden waste. All meat bones and inedible bits (skin, gristle
etc.) are binned. All the meat is eaten.

I'm willing to have a go by putting in big bones, gristle and skin - what
sort of decomposition rate should I expect based on the fact I run a cold
heap? And possibly I would need to look at putting some sort of lid on the
heap perhaps... Mind you given that the compost bins are starting to need
rebuilding (PLEASE wait to Autumn!) that could be interesting!


I run a cold heap, too. I find that most chicken bones go by the time
I use the compost (12-18 months), but leg bones that dry out need to go
round again. Large mammal bones are a bit more durable, and beef leg
bones can take a decade!

But there isn't a problem, as all the decomposable matter has gone
within a month or so, inside the bone and out, and the stray bones
are 'clean'. My wife isn't een on them in the flowerbeds, but that is
really the only issue :-)

There is no long-term accumulation, even of the heaviest bones.


Regards,
Nick Maclaren.

Janet Baraclough 31-03-2003 11:56 PM

Composting
 
The message
from "Sarah Dale" contains these words:

In my household, all vegetable based scraps - cooked and uncooked go on my
(cold heap, sarah-rigged wooden containers, open topped) compost heap,
as do all
prunings and garden waste. All meat bones and inedible bits (skin, gristle
etc.) are binned. All the meat is eaten.


Same here... what is it with these households that throw out uneaten
meat? :-) When I've finished with a chicken, there is a cupful of bare
clean bones left; absolutely nothing else.

I'm willing to have a go by putting in big bones, gristle and skin - what
sort of decomposition rate should I expect based on the fact I run a cold
heap? And possibly I would need to look at putting some sort of lid on the
heap perhaps... Mind you given that the compost bins are starting to need
rebuilding (PLEASE wait to Autumn!) that could be interesting!


I think it's more beneficial to plants, to bury bones beneath them
when making a planting hole. Think of it as longterm bonemeal.

Janet.

swroot 01-04-2003 08:08 AM

Composting
 
Victoria Clare wrote:
[-]

The one thing I have found attracts rats is fresh grains in rabbit or
guinea-pig food. They really like that, and will hang around to get it.


Birdfood. My very large feeder was (very briefly) sited where the wind
caught it, knocking it against a branch. This spilt a feeder-full
(several litres) of seed on the ground while we were away for a
fortnight. When I returned I found a rat's castle beneath the paving
slabs under the feeder.

regards
sarah


--
"Great is truth, but still greater, from a practical point of view,
is silence about truth." Aldous Huxley

Pete The Gardener 01-04-2003 08:08 AM

Composting
 
On Sun, 30 Mar 2003 20:07:30 +0100, "Sarah Dale"
wrote:

Hi Pete,

I can't find this web site at all!


Nor can I now! It could be that their server is down, though it seems
to be quite a long time, or perhaps they've had to withdraw it due to
it being rubbish.

However, if you have some further info
I would be interested. It always annoys me to have to put waste meat
scraps and bones in the bin when they are highly bidegradable. (Although
not suitable for a home garden compost heap).


The leaflet I've got gives 2 phone numbers if you want to try them,
either 01556 650116 or mobile 07754 401381. There's no snailmail addy.

--
Pete The Gardener
A room without books is like a body without a soul.


Sarah Dale 02-04-2003 12:32 AM

Composting
 
On Mon, 31 Mar 2003 22:12:52 +0100, Janet Baraclough wrote:

I think it's more beneficial to plants, to bury bones beneath them
when making a planting hole. Think of it as longterm bonemeal.


Very true Janet - but given that I think I've finished moving shrubs in
this garden I may end up with a surfiet of bones waiting for a hole....

Sarah


bnd777 02-04-2003 08:44 PM

Composting
 
Its even worse in the Rural areas ......Rats will climb into any compost
bins even when they only contain grass and shreddings


"Paul Kelly" wrote in message
...

"Nick Maclaren" wrote in message
...

In article ,
"Sarah Dale" writes:
|
| I can't find this web site at all! However, if you have some further

info
| I would be interested. It always annoys me to have to put waste meat
| scraps and bones in the bin when they are highly bidegradable.

(Although
| not suitable for a home garden compost heap).

Why not? I have composted them for 25 years with no problems.
Others have done so for longer.



Do you live in town or country?

In town putting meat on the compost bin is an open invitation to foxes and
rats.

pk





bnd777 02-04-2003 08:44 PM

Composting
 
sarah .........just start a worm bin and put the bones and scraps in that
.........no rats have ever got into my converted dustbins /wormeries
"Sarah Dale" wrote in message
o.uk...
On Mon, 31 Mar 2003 07:17:59 +0000, Nick Maclaren wrote:

| I can't find this web site at all! However, if you have some further

info
| I would be interested. It always annoys me to have to put waste meat
| scraps and bones in the bin when they are highly bidegradable.

(Although

Why not? I have composted them for 25 years with no problems.
Others have done so for longer.


Well, I can't put in chicken or other light bones in case the cats get at
it. But you raise an interesting point in one of your other responses to
this thread. So many people on URG have said don't put meat or bones on
the heap because it attracts rats - you're saying that it doesn't make any
difference.

In my household, all vegetable based scraps - cooked and uncooked go on my
(cold heap, sarah-rigged wooden containers, open topped) compost heap, as

do all
prunings and garden waste. All meat bones and inedible bits (skin, gristle
etc.) are binned. All the meat is eaten.

I'm willing to have a go by putting in big bones, gristle and skin - what
sort of decomposition rate should I expect based on the fact I run a cold
heap? And possibly I would need to look at putting some sort of lid on the
heap perhaps... Mind you given that the compost bins are starting to need
rebuilding (PLEASE wait to Autumn!) that could be interesting!

Sarah




Natalie 03-04-2003 08:20 AM

Composting
 

"
I can't find this web site at all!


Nor can I now! It could be that their server is down, though it seems
to be quite a long time, or perhaps they've had to withdraw it due to
it being rubbish.


Their site is up and running again. I think it was down whilst it was
getting a makeover!

Natalie



Pete The Gardener 03-04-2003 08:08 PM

Composting
 
On Thu, 3 Apr 2003 08:04:21 +0100, "Natalie"
wrote:


Their site is up and running again. I think it was down whilst it was
getting a makeover!


Or putting the price up:-( It was 34.99 the other day.
So what do you think, I'm still in 2 minds about trying it because I
can't see how it would work so quickly.

--
Pete The Gardener
A room without books is like a body without a soul.


Natalie 03-04-2003 11:32 PM

Composting
 

"Pete The Gardener" wrote in message
...
On Thu, 3 Apr 2003 08:04:21 +0100, "Natalie"
wrote:


Their site is up and running again. I think it was down whilst it was
getting a makeover!


Or putting the price up:-( It was 34.99 the other day.
So what do you think, I'm still in 2 minds about trying it because I
can't see how it would work so quickly.

--
Pete The Gardener
A room without books is like a body without a soul.


I find it very hard to believe that it will make useable compost in just 2
weeks. In fact instructions say you have to bury the fermented waste!

I think I'll stick to the compost heap and wormery for now.

I'm going to make two compost towers, out of plastic bottles, tomorrow with
my Environment Club at school. One with and without worms....

Natalie



Alan Holmes 27-04-2003 11:44 PM

Composting
 

"bnd777" wrote in message
...
Its even worse in the Rural areas ......Rats will climb into any compost
bins even when they only contain grass and shreddings


What is worse in rural areas?

Alan
--
Reply to alan(at)windsor-berks(dot)freeserve(dot)co(dot)uk





All times are GMT +1. The time now is 08:21 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
GardenBanter