"Mushy Potatoes" - anyone know why?
 

Hi Folks,

Quick question: one of my clients (I'm a professional gardener, but don't hold that against me) asked me why his entire potato crop, of various types, turned to mush as soon as they were put into boiling water.

I have no idea!!

Desperate to preserve my reputation, I turn to you (picture me with hands out, pleading) for suggestion...

Rachel Aitch

"Mushy Potatoes" - anyone know why?
 

On Thu, 9 Nov 2006 20:54:55 +0000, Rachel Aitch wrote:

Hi Folks,

Quick question: one of my clients (I'm a professional gardener, but
don't hold that against me) asked me why his entire potato crop, of
various types, turned to mush as soon as they were put into boiling
water.

I have no idea!!

Desperate to preserve my reputation, I turn to you (picture me with
hands out, pleading) for suggestion...

Rachel Aitch

It's probably to do with the water content - if, say, the pots got heavily
frosted in the ground, or even frozen, they will cook up really soft and
mushy....

"Mushy Potatoes" - anyone know why?
 

In message , Rachel Aitch
writes

Hi Folks,

Quick question: one of my clients (I'm a professional gardener, but
don't hold that against me) asked me why his entire potato crop, of
various types, turned to mush as soon as they were put into boiling
water.

I have no idea!!

Desperate to preserve my reputation, I turn to you (picture me with
hands out, pleading) for suggestion...

Perhaps they had been frozen?
--
June Hughes

"Mushy Potatoes" - anyone know why?
 

"June Hughes" wrote in message
...
In message , Rachel Aitch
writes

Hi Folks,

Quick question: one of my clients (I'm a professional gardener, but
don't hold that against me) asked me why his entire potato crop, of
various types, turned to mush as soon as they were put into boiling
water.

I have no idea!!

Desperate to preserve my reputation, I turn to you (picture me with
hands out, pleading) for suggestion...

Perhaps they had been frozen?

I've had potatoes which turned mushy after a few minutes of boiling, I
reagard that as good (saves energy). But I've never had a potato which
turned to mush as soon as they were put into boiling water. Perhaps it was
an exaggeration?

There again, I start potatoes in cold water, as I was taught.

Has the questioner tried steaming?

Mary
--
June Hughes

"Mushy Potatoes" - anyone know why?
 

On Fri, 10 Nov 2006 11:43:14 -0000, "Mary Fisher"
wrote and included this (or some of this):

Quick question: one of my clients (I'm a professional gardener, but
don't hold that against me) asked me why his entire potato crop, of
various types, turned to mush as soon as they were put into boiling
water.

I have no idea!!

Desperate to preserve my reputation, I turn to you (picture me with
hands out, pleading) for suggestion...

Perhaps they had been frozen?

I've had potatoes which turned mushy after a few minutes of boiling, I
reagard that as good (saves energy). But I've never had a potato which
turned to mush as soon as they were put into boiling water. Perhaps it was
an exaggeration?

Perhaps someone has developed a new "Smash" potato cultivar.


--
®óñ© © ² * ¹°°³

"Mushy Potatoes" - anyone know why?
 

On Fri, 10 Nov 2006 12:47:44 +0000, jane wrote:

On Fri, 10 Nov 2006 03:07:42 GMT, bigjon
wrote:

~On Thu, 9 Nov 2006 20:54:55 +0000, Rachel Aitch wrote:
~
~ Hi Folks,
~
~ Quick question: one of my clients (I'm a professional gardener, but
~ don't hold that against me) asked me why his entire potato crop, of
~ various types, turned to mush as soon as they were put into boiling
~ water.
~
~ I have no idea!!
~
~ Desperate to preserve my reputation, I turn to you (picture me with
~ hands out, pleading) for suggestion...
~
~ Rachel Aitch
~
~It's probably to do with the water content - if, say, the pots got heavily
~frosted in the ground, or even frozen, they will cook up really soft and
~mushy....

Yes, it is water content.
In years when we don't get much rain, the potatoes have a higher
percentage of dry matter, which makes even well-known 'waxy' potatoes
go 'floury'. And the flourys are even drier. This means nearly all
spuds will fall on boiling. Did your client have a very dry veg plot
this year?

I suggest steaming - it does help a bit. Or chips. Or roast potatoes.
(Both do best with floury potatoes).

Or resolve yourself to having gloopy mash. :-)


jane

Chiltern Hills, 140m above sea level.

Please remove onmaps from replies, thanks!

i don't have a problem - my pots are from tescos....
--
(\__/)
(='.'=) This is Bunny. Copy and paste bunny into your
(")_(") signature to help him gain world domination.

"Mushy Potatoes" - anyone know why?
 

On Fri, 10 Nov 2006 12:11:09 +0000, ®óñ© © ² * ¹°°³ wrote:

On Fri, 10 Nov 2006 11:43:14 -0000, "Mary Fisher"
wrote and included this (or some of this):

Quick question: one of my clients (I'm a professional gardener, but
don't hold that against me) asked me why his entire potato crop, of
various types, turned to mush as soon as they were put into boiling
water.

I have no idea!!

Desperate to preserve my reputation, I turn to you (picture me with
hands out, pleading) for suggestion...

Perhaps they had been frozen?

I've had potatoes which turned mushy after a few minutes of boiling, I
reagard that as good (saves energy). But I've never had a potato which
turned to mush as soon as they were put into boiling water. Perhaps it was
an exaggeration?

Perhaps someone has developed a new "Smash" potato cultivar.

those aliens might have returned to take our potatoes over...

"Mushy Potatoes" - anyone know why?
 

"®óñ© © ² * ¹°°³" wrote in message
...


Perhaps someone has developed a new "Smash" potato cultivar.

I wish I'd thought of that!

Mary

"Mushy Potatoes" - anyone know why?
 

Mary Fisher wrote:


"®óñ© © ² * ¹°°³" wrote in message
...


Perhaps someone has developed a new "Smash" potato cultivar.

I wish I'd thought of that!

Mary

You will! :-)

Neil Jones

"Mushy Potatoes" - anyone know why?
 

"Neil Jones" wrote in message
...
Mary Fisher wrote:


"®óñ© © ² * ¹°°³" wrote in message
...


Perhaps someone has developed a new "Smash" potato cultivar.

I wish I'd thought of that!

Mary

You will! :-)

Sadly, I shan't. It will be forgotten :-(

Mary

"Mushy Potatoes" - anyone know why?
 

Rachel Aitch wrote:
Hi Folks,

Quick question: one of my clients (I'm a professional gardener, but
don't hold that against me) asked me why his entire potato crop, of
various types, turned to mush as soon as they were put into boiling
water.

I have no idea!!

Desperate to preserve my reputation, I turn to you (picture me with
hands out, pleading) for suggestion...

Rachel Aitch




If this a genuine 'Quick' question and not a 'Trick' question
the answer is obvious. Your client cannot cook !
You do not put potatoes into boiling water ,you put them
into cold water and bring up to the boil.
I'm a bloke and even I know that.
I suggest you ask him to bring a few round then peel and boil
them yourself.

"Mushy Potatoes" - anyone know why?
 

"sam" wrote in message
...

If this a genuine 'Quick' question and not a 'Trick' question
the answer is obvious. Your client cannot cook !
You do not put potatoes into boiling water ,you put them
into cold water and bring up to the boil.
I'm a bloke and even I know that.
I suggest you ask him to bring a few round then peel and boil
them yourself.

Or don't peel - I don't.

Mary

"Mushy Potatoes" - anyone know why?
 

"Rachel Aitch" wrote via GB, not direct...
Quick question: one of my clients (I'm a professional gardener, but
don't hold that against me) asked me why his entire potato crop, of
various types, turned to mush as soon as they were put into boiling
water.

I have no idea!!

Desperate to preserve my reputation, I turn to you (picture me with
hands out, pleading) for suggestion...

Grown in too dry conditions.
And/or Wrong variety. You don't say which variety but floury ones will do as
you say especially if they have been subject to drought conditions. Try some
waxy ones and/or drought tolerant ones next year.

Kestral (SE), Spey (MC) and Romano (MC) seem Ok for us.
--
Regards
Bob H
17mls W. of London.UK

"Mushy Potatoes" - anyone know why?
 

"Bob Hobden" wrote in message
...

"Rachel Aitch" wrote : one of my clients asked me why his entire
potato crop, turned to mush as soon as they were put into boiling
water.

Grown in too dry conditions.
And/or Wrong variety. You don't say which variety but floury ones
will do as you say especially if they have been subject to drought
conditions. Try some waxy ones and/or drought tolerant ones next
year.

Kestral (SE), Spey (MC) and Romano (MC) seem Ok for us.

For once I judged the weather right this year and started watering the
spuds regularly as soon as the weather turned dry. Most of what we
have at home this year is Desiree (I've grown some Desiree every year
for over 30 years now), and these are some of the best I've had so I'm
convinced it's down to growing conditions. I judge by how they turn
out at home with my wife's cooking because we've had some cooks in the
'big house' over the years who seem to be capable of destroying any
spud you give them.

--
Rod

My real address is rodthegardeneratmyisp

"Mushy Potatoes" - anyone know why?
 

"Rod" wrote after
"Bob Hobden" replied to
"Rachel Aitch" wrote : one of my clients asked me why his entire potato
crop, turned to mush as soon as they were put into boiling
water.

Grown in too dry conditions.
And/or Wrong variety. You don't say which variety but floury ones will do
as you say especially if they have been subject to drought conditions.
Try some waxy ones and/or drought tolerant ones next year.

Kestral (SE), Spey (MC) and Romano (MC) seem Ok for us.

For once I judged the weather right this year and started watering the
spuds regularly as soon as the weather turned dry. Most of what we have at
home this year is Desiree (I've grown some Desiree every year for over 30
years now), and these are some of the best I've had so I'm convinced it's
down to growing conditions. I judge by how they turn out at home with my
wife's cooking because we've had some cooks in the 'big house' over the
years who seem to be capable of destroying any spud you give them.

Hello Rod.

Our problem was that this year we had a hosepipe ban from early on (it's
still in place!!!) so all watering was by hand with watering cans. (our
Council also say hosepipes are banned permanently anyway) Rather difficult
to consistently water the spuds that way as well as everything else so
mainly they had to take their chance.

We tried Desiree a couple of times years ago but found them rather prone to
slug damage, obviously not a problem with you.

Regards
Bob.