GardenBanter.co.uk

GardenBanter.co.uk (https://www.gardenbanter.co.uk/)
-   United Kingdom (https://www.gardenbanter.co.uk/united-kingdom/)
-   -   stop snails climbing shrubs (https://www.gardenbanter.co.uk/united-kingdom/173694-stop-snails-climbing-shrubs.html)

Lol[_2_] 30-04-2008 08:20 AM

stop snails climbing shrubs
 
We have a 2yr old weeping Caragana Arborescens in a large pot in front
garden, and snails are determined to killl kill kill.

It's a case of picking off 20+ every night, and last year they succeeded in
destroying all new shoots, and bypassing a cardboard collar I fitted to stop
them climbing up.

What other ideas to stop them do you have?

thanks,
lol



Charlie Pridham[_2_] 30-04-2008 08:24 AM

stop snails climbing shrubs
 
In article ,
says...
We have a 2yr old weeping Caragana Arborescens in a large pot in front
garden, and snails are determined to killl kill kill.

It's a case of picking off 20+ every night, and last year they succeeded in
destroying all new shoots, and bypassing a cardboard collar I fitted to stop
them climbing up.

What other ideas to stop them do you have?

thanks,
lol



Get a large pan and fill with water, create an island in the middle and
stand pot on it, the water gap will stop them as long as its over 2".
make sure the pot is not in the water.
Spray plant on dry evenings with a liquid slug & snail killer
--
Charlie Pridham, Gardening in Cornwall
www.roselandhouse.co.uk
Holders of national collections of Clematis viticella cultivars and
Lapageria rosea

'Mike' 30-04-2008 08:54 AM

stop snails climbing shrubs
 



"Charlie Pridham" wrote in message
T...
In article ,
says...
We have a 2yr old weeping Caragana Arborescens in a large pot in front
garden, and snails are determined to killl kill kill.

It's a case of picking off 20+ every night, and last year they succeeded
in
destroying all new shoots, and bypassing a cardboard collar I fitted to
stop
them climbing up.

What other ideas to stop them do you have?

thanks,
lol



Get a large pan and fill with water, create an island in the middle and
stand pot on it, the water gap will stop them as long as its over 2".
make sure the pot is not in the water.
Spray plant on dry evenings with a liquid slug & snail killer
--
Charlie Pridham, Gardening in Cornwall
www.roselandhouse.co.uk
Holders of national collections of Clematis viticella cultivars and
Lapageria rosea


Charlie, is that 2" deep or 2" from the side to the pot? ie they have to
swim or stretch 2"?

Mike


--
www.rneba.org.uk. The Royal Naval Electrical Branch Association.
'THE' Association to find your ex-Greenie mess mates.





Lol[_2_] 30-04-2008 09:07 AM

stop snails climbing shrubs
 

"Charlie Pridham" wrote in message
T...
In article ,
says...
We have a 2yr old weeping Caragana Arborescens in a large pot in front
garden, and snails are determined to killl kill kill.

It's a case of picking off 20+ every night, and last year they succeeded
in
destroying all new shoots, and bypassing a cardboard collar I fitted to
stop
them climbing up.

What other ideas to stop them do you have?

thanks,
lol



Get a large pan and fill with water, create an island in the middle and
stand pot on it, the water gap will stop them as long as its over 2".
make sure the pot is not in the water.
Spray plant on dry evenings with a liquid slug & snail killer
--
Charlie Pridham, Gardening in Cornwall


Good idea thanks, theory is sound but not practical - this is about an 18"
tub, I'd need to be into landscaping a pond to put it in.

Just found reference to copper strips as a barrier, does that really work,
or simply a cash crop at garden centre tills?

lol



Sandy 30-04-2008 09:32 AM

stop snails climbing shrubs
 
Lol wrote:
"Charlie Pridham" wrote in message
T...
In article ,
says...
We have a 2yr old weeping Caragana Arborescens in a large pot in front
garden, and snails are determined to killl kill kill.

It's a case of picking off 20+ every night, and last year they succeeded
in
destroying all new shoots, and bypassing a cardboard collar I fitted to
stop
them climbing up.

What other ideas to stop them do you have?

thanks,
lol



Get a large pan and fill with water, create an island in the middle and
stand pot on it, the water gap will stop them as long as its over 2".
make sure the pot is not in the water.
Spray plant on dry evenings with a liquid slug & snail killer
--
Charlie Pridham, Gardening in Cornwall


Good idea thanks, theory is sound but not practical - this is about an 18"
tub, I'd need to be into landscaping a pond to put it in.

Just found reference to copper strips as a barrier, does that really work,
or simply a cash crop at garden centre tills?

lol


Place a ring of 2p coins around the pot.

Sacha[_3_] 30-04-2008 09:40 AM

stop snails climbing shrubs
 
On 30/4/08 09:07, in article
, "Lol"
wrote:


"Charlie Pridham" wrote in message
T...
In article ,
says...
We have a 2yr old weeping Caragana Arborescens in a large pot in front
garden, and snails are determined to killl kill kill.

It's a case of picking off 20+ every night, and last year they succeeded
in
destroying all new shoots, and bypassing a cardboard collar I fitted to
stop
them climbing up.

What other ideas to stop them do you have?

thanks,
lol



Get a large pan and fill with water, create an island in the middle and
stand pot on it, the water gap will stop them as long as its over 2".
make sure the pot is not in the water.
Spray plant on dry evenings with a liquid slug & snail killer
--
Charlie Pridham, Gardening in Cornwall


Good idea thanks, theory is sound but not practical - this is about an 18"
tub, I'd need to be into landscaping a pond to put it in.

Just found reference to copper strips as a barrier, does that really work,
or simply a cash crop at garden centre tills?

lol


You could get one of those large green or black plastic tubs they sell at
e.g. feed merchants, fill that with water, put another inside but upside
down to make the island and stand your 18" pot on that. Or you could indeed
make a pond and put your Caragana on a plastic pot island in the middle of
it. Then you could have fish and marginal plants.......... ;-)


--
Sacha
http://www.hillhousenursery.co.uk
South Devon
'We do not inherit the earth from our ancestors, we borrow it from our
children.'



Jeff Layman 30-04-2008 09:58 AM

stop snails climbing shrubs
 
Lol wrote:
"Charlie Pridham" wrote in message
T...
In article ,
says...
We have a 2yr old weeping Caragana Arborescens in a large pot in
front garden, and snails are determined to killl kill kill.

It's a case of picking off 20+ every night, and last year they
succeeded in
destroying all new shoots, and bypassing a cardboard collar I
fitted to stop
them climbing up.

What other ideas to stop them do you have?

thanks,
lol



Get a large pan and fill with water, create an island in the middle
and stand pot on it, the water gap will stop them as long as its
over 2". make sure the pot is not in the water.
Spray plant on dry evenings with a liquid slug & snail killer
--
Charlie Pridham, Gardening in Cornwall


Good idea thanks, theory is sound but not practical - this is about
an 18" tub, I'd need to be into landscaping a pond to put it in.

Just found reference to copper strips as a barrier, does that really
work, or simply a cash crop at garden centre tills?

lol


It is supposed to work. it might be interesting to try a band of copper
separated by a few mm from a band of aluminium foil (or a strip cut from a
tin) round the trunk. A snail crawling across should cause a voltage to
appear across the different metals, and that should be enough to dissuade
it. If you do try it, please let us know if it does or does not work.

--
Jeff
(cut "thetape" to reply)



George.com 30-04-2008 09:58 AM

stop snails climbing shrubs
 

"Lol" wrote in message
m...
We have a 2yr old weeping Caragana Arborescens in a large pot in front
garden, and snails are determined to killl kill kill.

It's a case of picking off 20+ every night, and last year they succeeded
in destroying all new shoots, and bypassing a cardboard collar I fitted to
stop them climbing up.

What other ideas to stop them do you have?

thanks,
lol


a ring off dried coffee grounds around the plant should keep them away, at
least according to experiments I have tried. The ring may need to be quite
wide & the coffee grounds replaced over time as they get wet. My observation
is that the dried grounds seem to deter the snails crawling over them,
probably due to moisture loss. Within reason the grounds also make a decent
fertiliser for the plant.

rob


Mary Fisher 30-04-2008 11:15 AM

stop snails climbing shrubs
 

"Lol" wrote in message
m...
We have a 2yr old weeping Caragana Arborescens in a large pot in front
garden, and snails are determined to killl kill kill.

It's a case of picking off 20+ every night, and last year they succeeded
in destroying all new shoots, and bypassing a cardboard collar I fitted to
stop them climbing up.

What other ideas to stop them do you have?

thanks,
lol


Why cardboard?

Solid copper collars work very well - not 100% because they travel under as
well as overground.

Mary



Mary Fisher 30-04-2008 11:18 AM

stop snails climbing shrubs
 

"Lol" wrote in message
om...


Just found reference to copper strips as a barrier, does that really work,
or simply a cash crop at garden centre tills?


In my experience the strips aren't very effective.

We make our own copper collars, the garden supplier ones are exorbitant.

You can either go to your local scrap metal merchant and buy a copper
cylinder then cut it to the size you want or even buy sheets of new copper.
That's what we do these days because we use the copper for other purposes,
it's easier to work than scrap metal and it's easier to store. It's also
usually thinner, it doesn't need to be thick.

Mary



Peter James[_2_] 30-04-2008 12:36 PM

stop snails climbing shrubs
 
On Wed, 30 Apr 2008 08:20:05 +0100, Lol wrote
(in article ):

We have a 2yr old weeping Caragana Arborescens in a large pot in front
garden, and snails are determined to killl kill kill.

It's a case of picking off 20+ every night, and last year they succeeded in
destroying all new shoots, and bypassing a cardboard collar I fitted to stop
them climbing up.

What other ideas to stop them do you have?

thanks,
lol



The way my wife and I keep snails and slugs away from our Hostas also in
large pots, is to smear a good 2" or 3" strip or Vaseline all way around the
pot. That stops the little buggers. But you do need to renew it at least
once during the growing season. The other precaution is to make sure that
the foliage of the plant is not touching any other plant or wall or object.
They will go up one plant in order to get to another.

Peter

--
It was my Uncle George who discovered that alcohol was a food well in
advance of medical thought.
P G *Wodehouse 1881 -1975



mogga 30-04-2008 12:44 PM

stop snails climbing shrubs
 
On Wed, 30 Apr 2008 20:58:37 +1200, "George.com"
wrote:


"Lol" wrote in message
om...
We have a 2yr old weeping Caragana Arborescens in a large pot in front
garden, and snails are determined to killl kill kill.

It's a case of picking off 20+ every night, and last year they succeeded
in destroying all new shoots, and bypassing a cardboard collar I fitted to
stop them climbing up.

What other ideas to stop them do you have?

thanks,
lol


a ring off dried coffee grounds around the plant should keep them away, at
least according to experiments I have tried. The ring may need to be quite
wide & the coffee grounds replaced over time as they get wet. My observation
is that the dried grounds seem to deter the snails crawling over them,
probably due to moisture loss. Within reason the grounds also make a decent
fertiliser for the plant.

rob



Starbucks in the US apparently leave their grounds outside for people
to take
http://www.epa.gov/epaoswer/osw/cons...ws/04-star.htm


They say:
http://www.starbucks.com/aboutus/compost.asp
--
http://www.freedeliveryuk.co.uk
http://www.holidayunder100.co.uk

Charlie Pridham[_2_] 30-04-2008 01:00 PM

stop snails climbing shrubs
 
In article ,
says...



"Charlie Pridham" wrote in message
T...
In article ,
says...
We have a 2yr old weeping Caragana Arborescens in a large pot in front
garden, and snails are determined to killl kill kill.

It's a case of picking off 20+ every night, and last year they succeeded
in
destroying all new shoots, and bypassing a cardboard collar I fitted to
stop
them climbing up.

What other ideas to stop them do you have?

thanks,
lol



Get a large pan and fill with water, create an island in the middle and
stand pot on it, the water gap will stop them as long as its over 2".
make sure the pot is not in the water.
Spray plant on dry evenings with a liquid slug & snail killer
--
Charlie Pridham, Gardening in Cornwall
www.roselandhouse.co.uk
Holders of national collections of Clematis viticella cultivars and
Lapageria rosea


Charlie, is that 2" deep or 2" from the side to the pot? ie they have to
swim or stretch 2"?

Mike



They wont swim but a big one can stretch a surprisingly long way, so I
reckon 2" horizontal as a minimum
--
Charlie Pridham, Gardening in Cornwall
www.roselandhouse.co.uk
Holders of national collections of Clematis viticella cultivars and
Lapageria rosea

'Mike' 30-04-2008 01:18 PM

stop snails climbing shrubs
 


"Charlie Pridham" wrote in message
T...
In article ,
says...



"Charlie Pridham" wrote in message
T...
In article ,
says...
We have a 2yr old weeping Caragana Arborescens in a large pot in front
garden, and snails are determined to killl kill kill.

It's a case of picking off 20+ every night, and last year they
succeeded
in
destroying all new shoots, and bypassing a cardboard collar I fitted
to
stop
them climbing up.

What other ideas to stop them do you have?

thanks,
lol



Get a large pan and fill with water, create an island in the middle and
stand pot on it, the water gap will stop them as long as its over 2".
make sure the pot is not in the water.
Spray plant on dry evenings with a liquid slug & snail killer
--
Charlie Pridham, Gardening in Cornwall
www.roselandhouse.co.uk
Holders of national collections of Clematis viticella cultivars and
Lapageria rosea


Charlie, is that 2" deep or 2" from the side to the pot? ie they have to
swim or stretch 2"?

Mike



They wont swim but a big one can stretch a surprisingly long way, so I
reckon 2" horizontal as a minimum
--
Charlie Pridham, Gardening in Cornwall
www.roselandhouse.co.uk
Holders of national collections of Clematis viticella cultivars and
Lapageria rosea


Many thanks. That is what I suspected

Mike


--
www.rneba.org.uk. The Royal Naval Electrical Branch Association.
'THE' Association to find your ex-Greenie mess mates.






Mary Fisher 30-04-2008 04:01 PM

stop snails climbing shrubs
 

"Peter James" wrote in message
.uk...
... The other precaution is to make sure that
the foliage of the plant is not touching any other plant or wall or
object.
They will go up one plant in order to get to another.

They will indeed.

I once protected tomato seedlings by standing the pots on a high device. I
saw a slug climbing to the tip of a small broom and weighting down the top
branch so that the seedlings could be reached.

Intelligent slugs!

How did it know the seedlings were there? How did it know which way to bend
the branch??

I can't forget the sight, you really must admire such a feat - although I
still don't warm to slugs.

Mary



Judith in France 30-04-2008 04:27 PM

stop snails climbing shrubs
 
On Apr 30, 11:15 am, "Mary Fisher" wrote:
"Lol" wrote in message

m...

We have a 2yr old weeping Caragana Arborescens in a large pot in front
garden, and snails are determined to killl kill kill.


It's a case of picking off 20+ every night, and last year they succeeded
in destroying all new shoots, and bypassing a cardboard collar I fitted to
stop them climbing up.


What other ideas to stop them do you have?


thanks,
lol


Why cardboard?

Solid copper collars work very well - not 100% because they travel under as
well as overground.

Mary


There is someone who contributes to this group who has a copper
business, it may be that she might be interested in this, I certainly
would be interested in using copper collers.

Judith

Judith in France 30-04-2008 04:28 PM

stop snails climbing shrubs
 
On Apr 30, 4:01 pm, "Mary Fisher" wrote:
"Peter James" wrote in message

.uk... ... The other precaution is to make sure that
the foliage of the plant is not touching any other plant or wall or
object.
They will go up one plant in order to get to another.


They will indeed.

I once protected tomato seedlings by standing the pots on a high device. I
saw a slug climbing to the tip of a small broom and weighting down the top
branch so that the seedlings could be reached.

Intelligent slugs!

How did it know the seedlings were there? How did it know which way to bend
the branch??

I can't forget the sight, you really must admire such a feat - although I
still don't warm to slugs.

Mary


But you have chickens don't you Mary, don't they peck them and keep
the numbers down?

Judith

Sacha[_3_] 30-04-2008 05:15 PM

stop snails climbing shrubs
 
On 30/4/08 16:27, in article
, "Judith
in France" wrote:

On Apr 30, 11:15 am, "Mary Fisher" wrote:
"Lol" wrote in message

m...

We have a 2yr old weeping Caragana Arborescens in a large pot in front
garden, and snails are determined to killl kill kill.


It's a case of picking off 20+ every night, and last year they succeeded
in destroying all new shoots, and bypassing a cardboard collar I fitted to
stop them climbing up.


What other ideas to stop them do you have?


thanks,
lol


Why cardboard?

Solid copper collars work very well - not 100% because they travel under as
well as overground.

Mary


There is someone who contributes to this group who has a copper
business, it may be that she might be interested in this, I certainly
would be interested in using copper collers.

Judith


We have a Camphill Community not far from us and we sell their pots.
Sometimes they also make copper rings and they're extremely popular with our
customers, so it seems as if they work.
--
Sacha
http://www.hillhousenursery.co.uk
South Devon
'We do not inherit the earth from our ancestors, we borrow it from our
children.'



Bob Hobden 30-04-2008 06:24 PM

stop snails climbing shrubs
 

"Lol" wrote ...
We have a 2yr old weeping Caragana Arborescens in a large pot in front
garden, and snails are determined to killl kill kill.

It's a case of picking off 20+ every night, and last year they succeeded
in destroying all new shoots, and bypassing a cardboard collar I fitted to
stop them climbing up.

What other ideas to stop them do you have?

We stood out large hosta pot on a copper impregnated mat and that worked a
treat, got them free with our Rootrainers as a trial so they should be
available.
I've also found that coffee grounds (strong roast) work well, always had a
real snail problem in our front garden such that at one point I used to pay
a local child 1p each for them he collected but since I've been putting the
coffee grounds around the plants I've not seen one. Seems from what I've
read that neither snails nor slugs like caffeine.

--
Regards
Bob Hobden





Mary Fisher 30-04-2008 10:50 PM

stop snails climbing shrubs
 

"Judith in France" wrote in message
...


There is someone who contributes to this group who has a copper
business,


Who's that then?

Mary



Mary Fisher 30-04-2008 10:52 PM

stop snails climbing shrubs
 

"Judith in France" wrote in message
...
On Apr 30, 4:01 pm, "Mary Fisher" wrote:
"Peter James" wrote in message

.uk... ... The other
precaution is to make sure that
the foliage of the plant is not touching any other plant or wall or
object.
They will go up one plant in order to get to another.


They will indeed.

I once protected tomato seedlings by standing the pots on a high device.
I
saw a slug climbing to the tip of a small broom and weighting down the
top
branch so that the seedlings could be reached.

Intelligent slugs!

How did it know the seedlings were there? How did it know which way to
bend
the branch??

I can't forget the sight, you really must admire such a feat - although I
still don't warm to slugs.

Mary


But you have chickens don't you Mary, don't they peck them and keep
the numbers down?


No. We once had a chjicken who would kill for a certain type of slug, some
of our present ones will, if hungry (which is rare) eat a certain type, but
mostly they sniff then ignore them.

Snails are a different matter, the three bantams fight over them, it's like
watching a football match (I imagine).

Mary

Judith




Judith in France 30-04-2008 11:28 PM

stop snails climbing shrubs
 
On Apr 30, 10:50 pm, "Mary Fisher" wrote:
"Judith in France" wrote in ...



There is someone who contributes to this group who has a copper
business,


Who's that then?

Mary


Anne Jackson owns a reputable copper company.

Judith

Mary Fisher 01-05-2008 09:08 AM

stop snails climbing shrubs
 

"Judith in France" wrote in message
...
On Apr 30, 10:50 pm, "Mary Fisher" wrote:
"Judith in France" wrote in
...



There is someone who contributes to this group who has a copper
business,


Who's that then?

Mary


Anne Jackson owns a reputable copper company.


I'd no idea!

But I think she's not near me ... :-(

Mary



Mary Fisher 01-05-2008 09:10 AM

stop snails climbing shrubs
 

"Anne Jackson" wrote in message
...
The message from "Mary Fisher" contains these
words:
"Judith in France" wrote:

There is someone who contributes to this group who has a copper
business,


Who's that then?


Me! Didn't you know?


How would I?

If I had I'd definitely have called when we went to Kirkmichael last year
:-)

But you're not on the way to Traquair and that will be our only Scottish
expedition this year.

Mary



Mary Fisher 01-05-2008 09:14 AM

stop snails climbing shrubs
 

"Anne Jackson" wrote in message
...

There is someone who contributes to this group who has a copper
business, it may be that she might be interested in this, I certainly
would be interested in using copper collars.


I've been following this thread, and thinking exactly the same thing! ;-)

Problem would be in the variety of sizes that we would need to produce...


No, you don't need more than three sizes, I'd have thought two would be
enough.

we couldn't have an overlap of velcro at the ends, either, or the slugs
would soon find it - and the 1/2" braided copper has many sharp ends.


You don't need Velcro either.

We don't use braided copper, just solid sheet, might be swg18, I could ask
him.

Mary



Mary Fisher 01-05-2008 11:08 AM

stop snails climbing shrubs
 

"Anne Jackson" wrote in message
...
The message from "Mary Fisher" contains these
words:
"Anne Jackson" wrote:
The message from "Mary Fisher" contains
these
words:
"Judith in France" wrote:

There is someone who contributes to this group who has a copper
business,

Who's that then?

Me! Didn't you know?


How would I?


We have spoken of it in D-i-Y, several times. Maybe you missed the
threads?
There have been a few - mostly about removing moss from roofs...


That's of no interest to me :-)

If I had I'd definitely have called when we went to Kirkmichael last year
:-)


I bought the company last May, and started trading in June. It was a
'sentimental' thing, allied to my former ownership of a scrapyard...


Ah. Scrapyards are fun! We went to Kirkmichael in February 2007, hunting
with hawks.

But you're not on the way to Traquair and that will be our only Scottish
expedition this year.


We pass Traquair on our way 'home' to the Borders, but we won't be doing
a lot of travelling this summer, until Bill recovers fully from his
by-pass
surgery...


I wish him well.

Mary



Judith in France 01-05-2008 01:16 PM

stop snails climbing shrubs
 
On May 1, 1:29 am, Anne Jackson wrote:
The message from Judith in France contains
these words:



On Apr 30, 11:15 am, "Mary Fisher" wrote:
"Lol" wrote:


We have a 2yr old weeping Caragana Arborescens in a large pot
in front garden, and snails are determined to killl kill kill.


It's a case of picking off 20+ every night, and last year they
succeeded in destroying all new shoots, and bypassing a cardboard
collar I fitted to stop them climbing up.


What other ideas to stop them do you have?


thanks,
lol


Why cardboard?
Solid copper collars work very well - not 100% because they travel
under as well as overground.


There is someone who contributes to this group who has a copper
business, it may be that she might be interested in this, I certainly
would be interested in using copper collars.


I've been following this thread, and thinking exactly the same thing! ;-)

Problem would be in the variety of sizes that we would need to produce...
we couldn't have an overlap of velcro at the ends, either, or the slugs
would soon find it - and the 1/2" braided copper has many sharp ends.

--
AnneJ

www.copperridge.co.ukwww.freedomcollars.co.uk


What you need is a flexible copper tape, wafer thin, it could come on
a roll, rather like sellotape. I have seen such a thing on my
friend's large garden pots, half way up the pot, it stops slugs
climbing into the pot and it works 100%. Now that could well be a
lucrative sideline for your business.

Judith

'Mike' 01-05-2008 01:23 PM

stop snails climbing shrubs
 

What you need is a flexible copper tape, wafer thin, it could come on
a roll, rather like sellotape. I have seen such a thing on my
friend's large garden pots, half way up the pot, it stops slugs
climbing into the pot and it works 100%. Now that could well be a
lucrative sideline for your business.

Judith




Electrical Wholesalers such as Newey & Eyre, City Electrics and the like
Used by Electricians for Electrical earth Bonding.

Also used in Shipbuilding in the Radio and Radar Rooms, again for Earth
Electrical 'Grounding'

The price of Copper has soared lately so try your Industrial Estates for the
Electrical Wholesalers instead of Garden Centres

Comes in 'about' 20 metre rolls 'about' 15mm wide and you can cut it with a
SHARP pair of Kitchen Scissors. Put the strip right up near the pivot when
you cut it.

Mike


--
www.rneba.org.uk. The Royal Naval Electrical Branch Association.
'THE' Association to find your ex-Greenie mess mates.





Judith in France 01-05-2008 02:09 PM

stop snails climbing shrubs
 
On May 1, 1:29 pm, Martin wrote:
On Thu, 1 May 2008 05:16:59 -0700 (PDT), Judith in France



wrote:
On May 1, 1:29 am, Anne Jackson wrote:
The message from Judith in France contains
these words:


On Apr 30, 11:15 am, "Mary Fisher" wrote:
"Lol" wrote:


We have a 2yr old weeping Caragana Arborescens in a large pot
in front garden, and snails are determined to killl kill kill.


It's a case of picking off 20+ every night, and last year they
succeeded in destroying all new shoots, and bypassing a cardboard
collar I fitted to stop them climbing up.


What other ideas to stop them do you have?


thanks,
lol


Why cardboard?
Solid copper collars work very well - not 100% because they travel
under as well as overground.


There is someone who contributes to this group who has a copper
business, it may be that she might be interested in this, I certainly
would be interested in using copper collars.


I've been following this thread, and thinking exactly the same thing! ;-)


Problem would be in the variety of sizes that we would need to produce...
we couldn't have an overlap of velcro at the ends, either, or the slugs
would soon find it - and the 1/2" braided copper has many sharp ends.


--
AnneJ


www.copperridge.co.ukwww.freedomcollars.co.uk


What you need is a flexible copper tape, wafer thin, it could come on
a roll, rather like sellotape. I have seen such a thing on my
friend's large garden pots, half way up the pot, it stops slugs
climbing into the pot and it works 100%. Now that could well be a
lucrative sideline for your business.


Wait to see if the EU limits copper for agricultural use first.
It's already banned for use in antifouling on boats in some EU countries.
--

Martin


Really? But we can still buy copper water pipes!!!!!

Judith

Mary Fisher 01-05-2008 04:42 PM

stop snails climbing shrubs
 

"Judith in France" wrote in message
...

What you need is a flexible copper tape, wafer thin, it could come on
a roll, rather like sellotape. I have seen such a thing on my
friend's large garden pots, half way up the pot, it stops slugs
climbing into the pot and it works 100%. Now that could well be a
lucrative sideline for your business.


Yes but it doesn't last, the copper rings last for ever - well, they'll see
us out :-)

Mary



Judith in France 01-05-2008 05:01 PM

stop snails climbing shrubs
 
On May 1, 4:42 pm, "Mary Fisher" wrote:
"Judith in France" wrote in ...



What you need is a flexible copper tape, wafer thin, it could come on
a roll, rather like sellotape. I have seen such a thing on my
friend's large garden pots, half way up the pot, it stops slugs
climbing into the pot and it works 100%. Now that could well be a
lucrative sideline for your business.


Yes but it doesn't last, the copper rings last for ever - well, they'll see
us out :-)

Mary


I'm sure copper rings are the best but I was thinking of the initial
outlay, it could well be expensive and for those on a limited budget,
I thought copper tape would be an acceptable solution.

Judith

Mary Fisher 02-05-2008 09:02 AM

stop snails climbing shrubs
 

"Judith in France" wrote in message
...
On May 1, 4:42 pm, "Mary Fisher" wrote:
"Judith in France" wrote in
...



What you need is a flexible copper tape, wafer thin, it could come on
a roll, rather like sellotape. I have seen such a thing on my
friend's large garden pots, half way up the pot, it stops slugs
climbing into the pot and it works 100%. Now that could well be a
lucrative sideline for your business.


Yes but it doesn't last, the copper rings last for ever - well, they'll
see
us out :-)

Mary


I'm sure copper rings are the best but I was thinking of the initial
outlay, it could well be expensive and for those on a limited budget,
I thought copper tape would be an acceptable solution.


Fair point - although if it's a short-lived outlay it seems a waste. I've
done it :-(

Mary



Rick... (The other Rick) 02-05-2008 10:48 AM

stop snails climbing shrubs
 
On Thu, 1 May 2008 13:23:59 +0100, "'Mike'" wrote:


What you need is a flexible copper tape, wafer thin, it could come on
a roll, rather like sellotape. I have seen such a thing on my
friend's large garden pots, half way up the pot, it stops slugs
climbing into the pot and it works 100%. Now that could well be a
lucrative sideline for your business.

Judith




Electrical Wholesalers such as Newey & Eyre, City Electrics and the like
Used by Electricians for Electrical earth Bonding.

Also used in Shipbuilding in the Radio and Radar Rooms, again for Earth
Electrical 'Grounding'

The price of Copper has soared lately so try your Industrial Estates for the
Electrical Wholesalers instead of Garden Centres

Comes in 'about' 20 metre rolls 'about' 15mm wide and you can cut it with a
SHARP pair of Kitchen Scissors. Put the strip right up near the pivot when
you cut it.

Mike


Also available for use in stained glass work.

look towards the bottom of the page here....
http://www.tempsfordstainedglass.co...._BEST__27.html

Also....
http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/COPPER-FOIL-TA...QQcmdZViewItem

Rick... (The other Rick)

Lol[_2_] 02-05-2008 12:26 PM

stop snails climbing shrubs
 

"Sandy" wrote in message
...
Lol wrote:
"Charlie Pridham" wrote in message
T...
In article ,
says...
We have a 2yr old weeping Caragana Arborescens in a large pot in front
garden, and snails are determined to killl kill kill.

It's a case of picking off 20+ every night, and last year they
succeeded in
destroying all new shoots, and bypassing a cardboard collar I fitted to
stop
them climbing up.

What other ideas to stop them do you have?

thanks,
lol



Get a large pan and fill with water, create an island in the middle and
stand pot on it, the water gap will stop them as long as its over 2".
make sure the pot is not in the water.
Spray plant on dry evenings with a liquid slug & snail killer
--
Charlie Pridham, Gardening in Cornwall


Good idea thanks, theory is sound but not practical - this is about an
18" tub, I'd need to be into landscaping a pond to put it in.

Just found reference to copper strips as a barrier, does that really
work, or simply a cash crop at garden centre tills?

lol


Place a ring of 2p coins around the pot.


I remember sixpences being real silver, but don't think any coins have been
since..

lol.



Lol[_2_] 02-05-2008 12:29 PM

stop snails climbing shrubs
 

"Mary Fisher" wrote in message
t...

"Lol" wrote in message
m...
We have a 2yr old weeping Caragana Arborescens in a large pot in front
garden, and snails are determined to killl kill kill.

It's a case of picking off 20+ every night, and last year they succeeded
in destroying all new shoots, and bypassing a cardboard collar I fitted
to stop them climbing up.

What other ideas to stop them do you have?

thanks,
lol


Why cardboard?

Mary


Because it was handy, and easy to cut to the shape I wanted - a downward
facing collar - and tape onto the stem. No idea how to do that in copper.

Didn't work at all, of course

Lol



Mary Fisher 02-05-2008 12:31 PM

stop snails climbing shrubs
 

"Lol" wrote in message
om...

"Mary Fisher" wrote in message
t...

"Lol" wrote in message
m...
We have a 2yr old weeping Caragana Arborescens in a large pot in front
garden, and snails are determined to killl kill kill.

It's a case of picking off 20+ every night, and last year they succeeded
in destroying all new shoots, and bypassing a cardboard collar I fitted
to stop them climbing up.

What other ideas to stop them do you have?

thanks,
lol


Why cardboard?

Mary


Because it was handy, and easy to cut to the shape I wanted - a downward
facing collar - and tape onto the stem. No idea how to do that in copper.

Didn't work at all, of course


:-)

M

Lol




robert 06-05-2008 08:27 PM

stop snails climbing shrubs
 
In message , Mary Fisher
writes
Mary


I'm sure copper rings are the best but I was thinking of the initial
outlay, it could well be expensive and for those on a limited budget,
I thought copper tape would be an acceptable solution.


Fair point - although if it's a short-lived outlay it seems a waste. I've
done it :-(

Our first adhesive copper tape is now in its third year and it still
appears to be totally excluding slugs.

It is not 100% effective against snails, but it does not claim to be. I
understand that there is another copper tape with a serrated edge which
is designed to cope with snails but as we do have much of a snail
problem (the thrushes see to that) we have not tried it out.
--
Robert


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 04:53 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
GardenBanter