Recommendations please - replacement tree
 

We just took down a Silver Birch, much to my annoyance. I really miss it.

I am looking for something to replace it, around 5 metres from the house and 4 metres from another surviving silver birch that is around 45 years old and around 5 metres high. Soil is heavyish clay, south Lincolnshire,just off the fens.

Ideally I would like something with an edible crop, be that fruit or nuts, but am having trouble identifying something suitable. I am 65 years old, and want to plant a tree for me, not for some unknown successor. I am quite prepared to pay for summat already 4 metres tall, at least.

1. can anyone suggest something interesting for the spot?

2. Can anyone suggest a tree nursery in the Lincolnshire/Leicestershire/Rutland/Cambridgeshire area who might be prpared to supply and plant a semi-mature specimen of whatever it is that we come up with?

Recommendations please - replacement tree
 

On Sunday, 20 September 2015 11:37:49 UTC+1, wrote:

1. can anyone suggest something interesting for the spot?

2. Can anyone suggest a tree nursery in the Lincolnshire/Leicestershire/Rutland/Cambridgeshire area who might be prpared to supply and plant a semi-mature specimen of whatever it is that we come up with?


Well, I have decided, reluctantly, agains Walnut because it would probably spread too quickly. Wondering about the Wild Service Tree.

Hazels will probably need a partner to pollinate it. Still thinking about that

Recommendations please - replacement tree
 

On 20/09/2015 22:45, wrote:
On Sunday, 20 September 2015 11:37:49 UTC+1, wrote:

1. can anyone suggest something interesting for the spot?

2. Can anyone suggest a tree nursery in the Lincolnshire/Leicestershire/Rutland/Cambridgeshire area who might be prpared to supply and plant a semi-mature specimen of whatever it is that we come up with?


Well, I have decided, reluctantly, agains Walnut because it would probably spread too quickly. Wondering about the Wild Service Tree.

Hazels will probably need a partner to pollinate it. Still thinking about that



You might consider Crataegus persimilis 'Prunifolia'. This is a
splendid 'cherry-leaved' hawthorn with a handsome spreading crown;
blossom in May/June, magnificent leaf colour in autumn and
larger-than-usual red haws in autumn/winter, depending on the local birds!

It copes with pollution and (in my garden) heavy clay.
--
Spider
On high ground in SE London
Gardening on heavy clay

Recommendations please - replacement tree
 

On 20/09/15 11:37, wrote:
We just took down a Silver Birch, much to my annoyance. I really
miss it.

I am looking for something to replace it, around 5 metres from the
house and 4 metres from another surviving silver birch that is around
45 years old and around 5 metres high. Soil is heavyish clay, south
Lincolnshire,just off the fens.

Ideally I would like something with an edible crop, be that fruit or
nuts, but am having trouble identifying something suitable. I am 65
years old, and want to plant a tree for me, not for some unknown
successor. I am quite prepared to pay for summat already 4 metres
tall, at least.

1. can anyone suggest something interesting for the spot?

2. Can anyone suggest a tree nursery in the
Lincolnshire/Leicestershire/Rutland/Cambridgeshire area who might be
prpared to supply and plant a semi-mature specimen of whatever it is
that we come up with?

Depends somewhat on the position, but would a cherry of some sort fill
the bill? You might get some good blossom, maybe fruit, perhaps autumn
colour, and, with something like Prunus serrula, the bark would shine
throughout winter.

--

Jeff

Recommendations please - replacement tree
 

On Monday, 21 September 2015 07:06:38 UTC+1, Jeff Layman wrote:

Depends somewhat on the position, but would a cherry of some sort fill
the bill? You might get some good blossom, maybe fruit, perhaps autumn
colour, and, with something like Prunus serrula, the bark would shine
throughout winter.

interesting. Are they self-fertile, or would they need a pollinator somewhere?

Recommendations please - replacement tree
 

On 20/09/2015 11:37, wrote:
We just took down a Silver Birch, much to my annoyance. I really miss it.

I am looking for something to replace it, around 5 metres from the house and 4 metres from another surviving silver birch that is around 45 years old and around 5 metres high. Soil is heavyish clay, south Lincolnshire,just off the fens.

Ideally I would like something with an edible crop, be that fruit or nuts, but am having trouble identifying something suitable. I am 65 years old, and want to plant a tree for me, not for some unknown successor. I am quite prepared to pay for summat already 4 metres tall, at least.

1. can anyone suggest something interesting for the spot?

2. Can anyone suggest a tree nursery in the Lincolnshire/Leicestershire/Rutland/Cambridgeshire area who might be prpared to supply and plant a semi-mature specimen of whatever it is that we come up with?

Just keep in mind that the other birch is nearing the end of its life,
they are not long lived trees.

Recommendations please - replacement tree
 

On Monday, September 21, 2015 at 12:18:54 PM UTC+1, Dave Hill wrote:

Just keep in mind that the other birch is nearing the end of its life,
they are not long lived trees.

Which is another good reason to get something now!

Recommendations please - replacement tree
 

On 21/09/15 10:25, wrote:
On Monday, 21 September 2015 07:06:38 UTC+1, Jeff Layman wrote:

Depends somewhat on the position, but would a cherry of some sort fill
the bill? You might get some good blossom, maybe fruit, perhaps autumn
colour, and, with something like Prunus serrula, the bark would shine
throughout winter.

interesting. Are they self-fertile, or would they need a pollinator somewhere?

It's easiest, but not very helpful, for me to repeat the RHS page on
cherries "Some sweet cherries need pollination partners, others are self
fertile, producing fruit on a single tree. Acid cherries are self-fertile."

Of course, if you aren't interested in fruit, but purely want ornamental
effects, it won't matter if they are self-fertile or not."

--

Jeff

Recommendations please - replacement tree
 

On Sunday, 20 September 2015 22:45:10 UTC+1, wrote:

Well, I have decided, reluctantly, agains Walnut because it would probably spread too quickly. Wondering about the Wild Service Tree.

Hazels will probably need a partner to pollinate it. Still thinking about that

Given up on the wild service tree. We have summat similar in the back (smaller, redder berries, otherwise the same) so I want a bit of variety.

Ok. What can I get that is
* Native
* relatively fast growing
* Upright in habit
And, if possible as a bonus
* produces edible things.

Recommendations please - replacement tree
 

In article ,
says...

On Sunday, 20 September 2015 22:45:10 UTC+1, wrote:

Well, I have decided, reluctantly, agains Walnut because it would probably spread too quickly. Wondering about the Wild Service Tree.

Hazels will probably need a partner to pollinate it. Still thinking about that

Given up on the wild service tree. We have summat similar in the back (smaller, redder berries, otherwise the same) so I want a bit of variety.

Ok. What can I get that is
* Native
* relatively fast growing
* Upright in habit
And, if possible as a bonus
* produces edible things.

Crab apple

Janet

Recommendations please - replacement tree
 

On 27/09/2015 16:12, wrote:
On Sunday, 20 September 2015 22:45:10 UTC+1, wrote:

Well, I have decided, reluctantly, agains Walnut because it would probably spread too quickly. Wondering about the Wild Service Tree.

Hazels will probably need a partner to pollinate it. Still thinking about that

Given up on the wild service tree. We have summat similar in the back (smaller, redder berries, otherwise the same) so I want a bit of variety.

Ok. What can I get that is
* Native
* relatively fast growing
* Upright in habit
And, if possible as a bonus
* produces edible things.

Hazels Don't need a pollinator as they all have Male (Catkins) and
female flowers https://www.flickr.com/photos/76126065@N06/6958465241/
I would look at an ornamental Crab apple, possibly one of the dark
leafed varieties

Recommendations please - replacement tree
 

David Hill wrote:

I would look at an ornamental Crab apple, possibly one of the dark
leafed varieties

That's a several of nominations for crab apple. Thanks all. Will
investigate

Dark leaved, eh?


My other, possibly mad, idea was to create an artwork: 4 identical trees
of matching height. Plant in square of 1.5m sides. Call it Quadrilateral.