Hi Steve,

Reckon they should all be the same clone.
The variation comes about from label writing.
Should be the long one

Paph. rothschildianum 'Charles E. Edwards' FCC/AOS

There is an old pic of one in flower that we
flowered back in the early 1970's
There are much better pics around, I admit.

http://tinyurl.com/2ppzy

Regards
Alan L Winthrop.





"Steve" wrote in message
...


TRAINMAN9 wrote:
..........We used p.rothchildianum 'Charles E'
in a number of crosses and most
of them were very unreliable
bloomers.........................

Oh foo, I have 2 or 3 Paph seedlings that have
'Charles E' as one of
the parents.
Perhaps you (or anyone else here) can answer a
question I have been
wondering about. I have Wildcatt (almost 2 years
out of date at this
point) and looking at awards in there didn't
answer the question for me.
There is a Paph. rothschildianum 'Charles E.
Edwards' FCC/AOS. I
also see listed Paph. rothschildianum 'Charles
E' FCC/AOS. I also
sometimes see 'Charles Edwards'.
Are all 3 versions really the same clone? Are
there really 3
different clones with interrelated names? Maybe
2 are the same?

When I search google, I just find one of the
names with no reference
to the others. I could keep looking but I'm sure
people here know
the answer and can clear this up for me. :-)

Steve