What about salt?
Of course, if you do salt treat, you will probably not be able to plant
anything else their either. ;-)


In article ,
escape wrote:

Okay, so now you sucked me into this reading. This is the only time I see
motor
oil mentioned, and it's accompanied with "Insert appropriate expression of
horror here."

I am also certain that Roundup will indeed not kill a stump of any sort. It
is
absorbed systemically through the foliage. If you read the label like you
are
supposed to do before using toxic poisons, you would have known that.

Other than this post, I see no other person telling you to pour motor oil
in,
on or near the tree stump.

Case is now closed and you do what you want. A piece of advice: If it comes
from this newsgroup or others does not mean you are getting "good advice."
That
includes my advice. But I do advise you to try reading a label now and then.




************************************************** ****************************
********
When they cut down a big hackberry under our power lines, th?!=ey put some
colored stuff on the stump that is supposed to keep it from ?!=growing back,
but I am doubtful. In my front yard, we had another hackber?!=ry removed and
the stump ground out. But a few of the old roots continue t?!=o send up
shoots
which I carefully coat with Roundup. We'll see how that goe?!=s.


On the other hand, an even larger hackberry that was split b?!=y the wind, cut
down and the stump ground out never shot up a single shoot.


An old method of dealing with stumps was to drill many deep ?!=holes in it and
fill them with motor oil. (Insert appropriate expression of ?!=horror here.)
************************************************** ****************************
******





On Thu, 03 Feb 2005 03:37:53 GMT, "Tex John" opined:

http://tinyurl.com/5k4db here's one in this group not by me.

And like I said last year when we had this conversation, I will repeat these
comments because I was given them on good advice from this group, from
rec.gardens and from the 'experts' at Home Depot...and none of them
worked -- including the Round Up concentrate applied straight as suggested
by the plant girl at Home Depot.

Not so much the Privet/Ligustrums, but at that time a neighbor's cigar tree
had infested half my back yard so my kids couldn't play barefoot for the
pencil-thick sticks after you mowed and no grass would grow because you
couldn't water it enough and we were already under water rationing. I tried
everything, but started with buttermilk which is supposed to help make the
trunk rot. Well, on these things, you cut them down but they aren't actually
dead...so they don't rot.

If I can pass on my rather bad experiences and get ONE person to NOT try the
things that were suggested to me and either just rent a grinder or burn the
stumps out with charcoal, I'll keep it up. But you really don't need to
remind me I was wrong year after year in multiple news groups :/

And don't expect a grinder to work on a Ligustrum either. If it has live
suckers, it'll just pop back up next week a few feet over.

I've been working in a wetland on Clear Creek in Houston and a smaller
leafed Ligustrum (looks like Yaupon but isn't) has actually weeded the
Yaupon out on an old homesite. The native oak and elm seedlings and saplings
get weeded out by a bush! No different than allowing Chinese Tallows to take
over an old field pouring millions of seeds into the watershed to wash up
between a yard in Austin and an old rice patty in Houston. Of course all
noxious-list plants should be cut down, but all too often, that just ain't
enough.

John


"escape" wrote in message
.. .
On Wed, 02 Feb 2005 17:49:25 GMT, "Tex John" opined:


"escape" wrote in message
.. .

You doused the soil with motor oil, glysophate and burning charcoal.
In
your
case, the ligustrums may have been better to keep.



Yup...tho was less than a quart of oil all total.

All suggestions were from either this list or the plant people at Home
Depot
:)

Don't forget the buttermilk...

John


I doubt anyone here told you to use motor oil on soil.





Need a good, cheap, knowledge expanding present for yourself or a friend?
http://www.animaux.net/stern/present.html







Need a good, cheap, knowledge expanding present for yourself or a friend?
http://www.animaux.net/stern/present.html
--
K.

Sprout the MungBean to reply

"I don't like to commit myself about heaven and hell--you
see, I have friends in both places." --Mark Twain