Thread: Tree problem
View Single Post
  #7   Report Post  
Old 30-06-2005, 03:18 PM
Janet Baraclough
 
Posts: n/a
Default

The message
from Jaques d'Alltrades contains
these words:

The message
from "Mike Lyle" contains these words:


Brendy wrote:
kate7 Wrote:
it's a spruce tree Kate


In that case, knock it off as soon as you like, please: it doesn't
fit our ecosystem or our aesthetic very well.. And no, it won't
regrow from the base. Or if it does, you've probably got an
interesting cultivar which may or may not be worth propagating.


However, the roots may get in the way.


If you cut the tree down and *THEN* try to remove them, you're making a
lot of extra work for yourself.


If it's a big tree, my advice would be to cut off the lower branches so
you can work under it, attach a rope to a solid bit of trunk as high as
you can, then dig round and cut as many roots as you can find. A sharp
spade usually suffices, but a big tree might need a mattock to do the
job.


Then just pull the tree over and the roots will come out on the end of it...


Poor advice imho. As the roots are cut, they would no longer anchor
the weight of the (heavy) trunk branches and foliage, and the whole tree
might fall suddenly, in an unintended direction. You certainly don't
have enough oomph from a rope held from the ground, to influence that
direction. Trees weigh more than people.

Better to fell it leaving a stump 2 or 3 ft high. Then excavate round
the roots, severing them, and use the stump as a lever to get them out.

Janet.