GardenBanter.co.uk - View Single Post - choice of glyphospate or amonium sulphamate?

Uncle Marvo · 31-08-2007, 09:51 AM posted to uk.rec.gardening

In reply to John McMillan ) who wrote
this in , I, Marvo, say
:

In article ,
"Uncle Marvo" wrote:

In reply to Uncle Marvo ) who
wrote this in , I, Marvo, say :

In reply to johngood_____ ) who wrote this in
, I, Marvo, say :

which would be the most effective chemical to terminate a rampant
bamboo plant please; glyphospate or ammonium sulphamate.?

Are there any particular properties (secondary to which is the most
affective killing agent) which might be brought into consideration
in choosing between them? Thanks

Neither will do a lot of good. They won't get the rhysomes (sp?) and
it will be back. If that's what you want, then glyphosate will work
(slowly).
SBK and a lot of patience, or hire a microdigger for the weekend, or
get digging. Expect to dig long and wide.

My mate's bamboo took us two weekends to get rid of, and made quite
a nice fence when we'd finished. However, it was recently, and I
won't be surprised if and when it makes its reappearance :-)

R H I Z O M E S

Is what I meant. I think. Biology, never could get the hang of it.

I'd use Glyphosate since it will translocate in the plant from the
leaves to the rhizomes - and I'm not sure that ammonium sulfamate
does.

I'm not sure that it will, certainly not in much of a hurry. We tried that
for several months and it comes back. Also it doesn't take to the glyphosate
anywhere near as well as broadleafed plants.

Anyway the bamboo has to be active. Best would have been
earlier in the year when it was growing. Maybe cut it to the
ground and treat the foliage when it reappears in spring. Or lots of
digging.

I agree with the digging :-)