Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Horticultural Myths, Dr. L. Chalker-Scott
"Billy" wrote in message ... In article ss, "gunner" wrote: "Billy" wrote in message ... .. Gunner wrote: BTW, 100lbs of 10-10-10 will yield 10 lbs of N, ~4.4 lbs of P and ~8.3 lbs of K. P and K are not elemental in fert labeling, you need to use the atomic weights. Billy tapdanced with: "Considering the atmosphere is about 78% N2, and elemental phosphorus and potassium can be exciting stuff, I wasn't trying to be analytical here. As I'm sure you are aware that agricultural nitrogen comes in the salt forms of NH3 and NO3 but the percentage on the container is only for the elemental nitrogen, not that of the compound, but strangely enough the next two numbers are for the compounds and not the elements. To follow along you must know that the atomic weight (at.wt.) of phosphorus is approximately 31, and oxygen is 16. Phosphorus comes as P2O5 ([31 X 2]+[16 X 5]= at. wt. 142 for the compound, but the percentage of phosphorus is P/P2O5 = 62/142 =.44) and the actual percentage of elemental phosphorus is 44% of the percentage listed. Potassium comes as K2O and the percentage of elemental potassium is 83% of the percentage listed, or K = 39 (atomic weight) and O = 16, so K2O = 94, and %K = K/K2O = 78/94 = .83 --- 83%. Bottom line is that in a 100 lb. bag of 10 - 10 - 10, 10 lbs will be N (as NH3 or NO3), 10 lb. of P2O5 = 4.4 lb. P, and 10 lb. of K2O = 8.3 lb. of K. Anybody still awake? And that's why I said it the way I did. See: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fertilizer for further confusion. Are you confused as to what you actually said? Here is your cut and pasteed comment to Florabloom: "If you buy a HUNDRED POUND BAG of 10 - 10 - 10 chemical fertilizer, it will contain 10 lbs of nitrogen (ammonia or nitrate), 10 lbs of phosphorous, and 10 lbs of potassium. A similar bag of 1-1-1, would yield a pound of each/bag." Changing stories again? Not quite accurate is it nor what you now say. the same for your comment on "chemferts kill micro organisms the inferences causing nitrates in water harming babies. You BS ........alot and as we saw with Florabloom you attack when you lose. |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Worth discussing Gunner's PDF from Linda Chalker-Scott | Edible Gardening | |||
100 Tree Myths by SHIGO online | Texas | |||
100 Tree Myths by SHIGO online | Australia | |||
Saffron Crocus Myths & Cultic Associations | Gardening | |||
Saffron Crocus Myths && Cultic Associations | Gardening |