GardenBanter.co.uk

GardenBanter.co.uk (https://www.gardenbanter.co.uk/)
-   Edible Gardening (https://www.gardenbanter.co.uk/edible-gardening/)
-   -   Low carb, high fat cute garden plants? (https://www.gardenbanter.co.uk/edible-gardening/83513-re-low-carb-high-fat-cute-garden-plants.html)

Teeb 13-09-2004 03:09 PM

Low carb, high fat cute garden plants?
 
Veggies and such that you can grow like that usually aren't high fat..
spinach is great if you like it and is usually easy to grow..

Teeb

"Ignoramus2437" wrote in message
...
I am on a low carb high fat "paleo diet". In the front yard, we have a
concrete retaining wall that is a boundary of our land. Beyond the
retaining wall, 3 feet lower, is a public sidewalk. I rented a monster
tiller recently, and tilled a 24" strip of land immediately adjacent
to the retaining wall. (did a lot of other tilling to plant a lawn
elsewhere).

My desire is to plant some pretty, high fat, low carb, edible plants
that are not grains.

I live in Zone 5 (N Illinois).

One plant that I can think of is sunflowers. Maybe I will throw some
corn into it, for looks and for other members of my family, but I am
looking for other suggestions.

Thanks!

i




Jennifer 13-09-2004 05:04 PM

Besides avocado or nut trees... very few plants bear high fat edibles.

Since it's already Fall... you have all winter to peruse the garden
catalogs (a fun thing) and decide what to plant come spring.

Jennifer


Ignoramus2437 wrote:

I am on a low carb high fat "paleo diet". In the front yard, we have a
concrete retaining wall that is a boundary of our land. Beyond the
retaining wall, 3 feet lower, is a public sidewalk. I rented a monster
tiller recently, and tilled a 24" strip of land immediately adjacent
to the retaining wall. (did a lot of other tilling to plant a lawn
elsewhere).

My desire is to plant some pretty, high fat, low carb, edible plants
that are not grains.

I live in Zone 5 (N Illinois).

One plant that I can think of is sunflowers. Maybe I will throw some
corn into it, for looks and for other members of my family, but I am
looking for other suggestions.

Thanks!

i



Teeb 13-09-2004 05:23 PM

I live smack in the middle of the desert in the southwest US.. I had spinach
in my garden very early this past spring.. it's a great cool weather plant.
I didn't water it any more than my other veggies, which is about every other
day when I walk around with the hose.. I currently still have tomatoes,
several kinds of chiles, cucumbers and planted my fall crop of spinach just
last weekend. Also have tons of various herbs. Cooler weather can usually
help deal somewhat with watering issues.

Teeb

"Ignoramus2437" wrote in message
...
In article , Teeb wrote:
Veggies and such that you can grow like that usually aren't high fat..
spinach is great if you like it and is usually easy to grow..


Spinach requires a lot of watering, I think, but you made a good
point.

Maybe I will also plant some peppers there also.

i

Teeb

"Ignoramus2437" wrote in message
...
I am on a low carb high fat "paleo diet". In the front yard, we have a
concrete retaining wall that is a boundary of our land. Beyond the
retaining wall, 3 feet lower, is a public sidewalk. I rented a monster
tiller recently, and tilled a 24" strip of land immediately adjacent
to the retaining wall. (did a lot of other tilling to plant a lawn
elsewhere).

My desire is to plant some pretty, high fat, low carb, edible plants
that are not grains.

I live in Zone 5 (N Illinois).

One plant that I can think of is sunflowers. Maybe I will throw some
corn into it, for looks and for other members of my family, but I am
looking for other suggestions.

Thanks!

i






Bill 13-09-2004 07:50 PM


"Ignoramus2437" wrote in message
...
I am on a low carb high fat "paleo diet". In the front yard, we have a
concrete retaining wall that is a boundary of our land. Beyond the
retaining wall, 3 feet lower, is a public sidewalk. I rented a monster
tiller recently, and tilled a 24" strip of land immediately adjacent
to the retaining wall. (did a lot of other tilling to plant a lawn
elsewhere).

My desire is to plant some pretty, high fat, low carb, edible plants
that are not grains.


That's a foolish diet, you may lose weight for a while, but you may also die
from clogged arteries, cancer, stroke, heart attack, etc., before the next
year is up.

Low carb diet is nothing but a scam.

Bill



Bill 13-09-2004 07:50 PM


"Ignoramus2437" wrote in message
...
I am on a low carb high fat "paleo diet". In the front yard, we have a
concrete retaining wall that is a boundary of our land. Beyond the
retaining wall, 3 feet lower, is a public sidewalk. I rented a monster
tiller recently, and tilled a 24" strip of land immediately adjacent
to the retaining wall. (did a lot of other tilling to plant a lawn
elsewhere).

My desire is to plant some pretty, high fat, low carb, edible plants
that are not grains.


That's a foolish diet, you may lose weight for a while, but you may also die
from clogged arteries, cancer, stroke, heart attack, etc., before the next
year is up.

Low carb diet is nothing but a scam.

Bill



Jennifer 13-09-2004 09:23 PM

Ignoramus2437 wrote:


That's a foolish diet, you may lose weight for a while, but you may also die
from clogged arteries, cancer, stroke, heart attack, etc., before the next
year is up.



Bill, I am not looking to lose weight. I lost weight last year and
kept it off, by eating a moderate carb diet, plenty of meat, eggs etc,
about 25% of calories from carbs, calorie controlled.


This is why it's not good net-iquette to cross post.

People in the garden group will have opinions about your food choices.

Better to post it twice individually.

Jennifer


Jennifer 13-09-2004 09:23 PM

Ignoramus2437 wrote:


That's a foolish diet, you may lose weight for a while, but you may also die
from clogged arteries, cancer, stroke, heart attack, etc., before the next
year is up.



Bill, I am not looking to lose weight. I lost weight last year and
kept it off, by eating a moderate carb diet, plenty of meat, eggs etc,
about 25% of calories from carbs, calorie controlled.


This is why it's not good net-iquette to cross post.

People in the garden group will have opinions about your food choices.

Better to post it twice individually.

Jennifer


The Queen of Cans and Jars 13-09-2004 09:32 PM

Jennifer wrote:

Ignoramus2437 wrote:


That's a foolish diet, you may lose weight for a while, but you may also die
from clogged arteries, cancer, stroke, heart attack, etc., before the next
year is up.



Bill, I am not looking to lose weight. I lost weight last year and
kept it off, by eating a moderate carb diet, plenty of meat, eggs etc,
about 25% of calories from carbs, calorie controlled.


This is why it's not good net-iquette to cross post.


it is, in fact, proper netiquette to crosspost if the original post is
relevant to more than one group.

People in the garden group will have opinions about your food choices.

Better to post it twice individually.


like they aren't going to have an opinion on it if he posts it
individually?


The Queen of Cans and Jars 13-09-2004 09:32 PM

Jennifer wrote:

Ignoramus2437 wrote:


That's a foolish diet, you may lose weight for a while, but you may also die
from clogged arteries, cancer, stroke, heart attack, etc., before the next
year is up.



Bill, I am not looking to lose weight. I lost weight last year and
kept it off, by eating a moderate carb diet, plenty of meat, eggs etc,
about 25% of calories from carbs, calorie controlled.


This is why it's not good net-iquette to cross post.


it is, in fact, proper netiquette to crosspost if the original post is
relevant to more than one group.

People in the garden group will have opinions about your food choices.

Better to post it twice individually.


like they aren't going to have an opinion on it if he posts it
individually?


Bill 13-09-2004 10:01 PM


"Ignoramus2437" wrote in message
...
In article , Bill wrote:

"Ignoramus2437" wrote in message
...


Alright, anyhow, if we set this issue aside, do you have any garden
suggestions in response to my question that Iposted oroginally?


Peanuts? :)

Bill



marengo 13-09-2004 10:35 PM

Bill wrote:

| That's a foolish diet, you may lose weight for a while, but you may
| also die from clogged arteries, cancer, stroke, heart attack, etc.,
| before the next year is up.
|
| Low carb diet is nothing but a scam.
|
| Bill


Please cite the research to back up your claims.

Oh that;s right, you can't -- because it's purely fiction!

LMAO!
--
Peter
Before/Current Pix:
http://users.thelink.net/marengo/wei...htlosspix.html



marengo 13-09-2004 10:35 PM

Bill wrote:

| That's a foolish diet, you may lose weight for a while, but you may
| also die from clogged arteries, cancer, stroke, heart attack, etc.,
| before the next year is up.
|
| Low carb diet is nothing but a scam.
|
| Bill


Please cite the research to back up your claims.

Oh that;s right, you can't -- because it's purely fiction!

LMAO!
--
Peter
Before/Current Pix:
http://users.thelink.net/marengo/wei...htlosspix.html



Roger Zoul 13-09-2004 11:02 PM

Ig -

Check out this site for some ideas: http://www.ediblelandscaping.com/

I was thinking olive, but that might not work in zone 5.


Ignoramus2437 wrote:
|| I am on a low carb high fat "paleo diet". In the front yard, we have
|| a concrete retaining wall that is a boundary of our land. Beyond the
|| retaining wall, 3 feet lower, is a public sidewalk. I rented a
|| monster tiller recently, and tilled a 24" strip of land immediately
|| adjacent to the retaining wall. (did a lot of other tilling to plant
|| a lawn elsewhere).
||
|| My desire is to plant some pretty, high fat, low carb, edible plants
|| that are not grains.
||
|| I live in Zone 5 (N Illinois).
||
|| One plant that I can think of is sunflowers. Maybe I will throw some
|| corn into it, for looks and for other members of my family, but I am
|| looking for other suggestions.
||
|| Thanks!
||
|| i



Roger Zoul 13-09-2004 11:02 PM

Ig -

Check out this site for some ideas: http://www.ediblelandscaping.com/

I was thinking olive, but that might not work in zone 5.


Ignoramus2437 wrote:
|| I am on a low carb high fat "paleo diet". In the front yard, we have
|| a concrete retaining wall that is a boundary of our land. Beyond the
|| retaining wall, 3 feet lower, is a public sidewalk. I rented a
|| monster tiller recently, and tilled a 24" strip of land immediately
|| adjacent to the retaining wall. (did a lot of other tilling to plant
|| a lawn elsewhere).
||
|| My desire is to plant some pretty, high fat, low carb, edible plants
|| that are not grains.
||
|| I live in Zone 5 (N Illinois).
||
|| One plant that I can think of is sunflowers. Maybe I will throw some
|| corn into it, for looks and for other members of my family, but I am
|| looking for other suggestions.
||
|| Thanks!
||
|| i



Ada Ma 14-09-2004 01:17 AM

I saw your earlier post talking about growing chilies - you might have to
treat your chilies plants the way you treat your olive tree if you're
planning to grow them. Otherwise you'll have to seed a new batch every
year.

Do you have a glass house? They perform particularly well in a glass house
from what I heard.


"Ignoramus2437" wrote in message
...
In article , Roger Zoul wrote:
Ig -

Check out this site for some ideas: http://www.ediblelandscaping.com/

I was thinking olive, but that might not work in zone 5.


Thanks. We actually do own an olive tree, but it grows in a huge
pot. We take it out for the summer and will take it inside for the
winter.

i


Ignoramus2437 wrote:
|| I am on a low carb high fat "paleo diet". In the front yard, we have
|| a concrete retaining wall that is a boundary of our land. Beyond the
|| retaining wall, 3 feet lower, is a public sidewalk. I rented a
|| monster tiller recently, and tilled a 24" strip of land immediately
|| adjacent to the retaining wall. (did a lot of other tilling to plant
|| a lawn elsewhere).
||
|| My desire is to plant some pretty, high fat, low carb, edible plants
|| that are not grains.
||
|| I live in Zone 5 (N Illinois).
||
|| One plant that I can think of is sunflowers. Maybe I will throw some
|| corn into it, for looks and for other members of my family, but I am
|| looking for other suggestions.
||
|| Thanks!
||
|| i





Penelope Periwinkle 14-09-2004 03:34 AM

On Tue, 14 Sep 2004 01:17:39 +0100, "Ada Ma"
wrote:

I saw your earlier post talking about growing chilies - you might have to
treat your chilies plants the way you treat your olive tree if you're
planning to grow them. Otherwise you'll have to seed a new batch every
year.


You say that like it's a bad thing.

Do you have a glass house?


No, then I couldn't throw stones.


Penelope



--
"Maybe you'd like to ask the Wizard for a heart."
"ElissaAnn"

J. David Anderson 14-09-2004 04:08 AM

Bill wrote:

"Ignoramus2437" wrote in message
...

I am on a low carb high fat "paleo diet". In the front yard, we have a
concrete retaining wall that is a boundary of our land. Beyond the
retaining wall, 3 feet lower, is a public sidewalk. I rented a monster
tiller recently, and tilled a 24" strip of land immediately adjacent
to the retaining wall. (did a lot of other tilling to plant a lawn
elsewhere).

My desire is to plant some pretty, high fat, low carb, edible plants
that are not grains.



That's a foolish diet, you may lose weight for a while, but you may also die
from clogged arteries, cancer, stroke, heart attack, etc., before the next
year is up.

Low carb diet is nothing but a scam.

Bill



That explains it Bill! Thanks for the info.

I ate a low carb peanut butter sandwich last year and I immediately died
from clogged arteries, cancer, stroke, heart attack etc., just as you
said. Luckily I had my reincarnation insurance paid up, wasn't it?

You are a very useful guy to have around Bill. Your in-depth knowledge
and incredible insight into scams and human nutrition is something that
can only be admired.

I guess that avocados are poison eh Bill? What with the high fat, low
carbs. Maybe they are Saddam's secret weapons of mass destruction? They
are a sort of drab military green after all. Do you think that someone
should whisper into Bush's ear?

What do you suggest as a good diet Bill?

It is obvious that you personally are thriving amazingly well on BS, but
for those of us with a little more taste and discernment, coupled with
a lack of access to fresh bovine created food sources, what would be a
good thing?

Regards

David




--

To reply, please include the letters DNF anywhere in the subject line.

All other mail is automatically deleted.

J. David Anderson 14-09-2004 04:08 AM

Bill wrote:

"Ignoramus2437" wrote in message
...

I am on a low carb high fat "paleo diet". In the front yard, we have a
concrete retaining wall that is a boundary of our land. Beyond the
retaining wall, 3 feet lower, is a public sidewalk. I rented a monster
tiller recently, and tilled a 24" strip of land immediately adjacent
to the retaining wall. (did a lot of other tilling to plant a lawn
elsewhere).

My desire is to plant some pretty, high fat, low carb, edible plants
that are not grains.



That's a foolish diet, you may lose weight for a while, but you may also die
from clogged arteries, cancer, stroke, heart attack, etc., before the next
year is up.

Low carb diet is nothing but a scam.

Bill



That explains it Bill! Thanks for the info.

I ate a low carb peanut butter sandwich last year and I immediately died
from clogged arteries, cancer, stroke, heart attack etc., just as you
said. Luckily I had my reincarnation insurance paid up, wasn't it?

You are a very useful guy to have around Bill. Your in-depth knowledge
and incredible insight into scams and human nutrition is something that
can only be admired.

I guess that avocados are poison eh Bill? What with the high fat, low
carbs. Maybe they are Saddam's secret weapons of mass destruction? They
are a sort of drab military green after all. Do you think that someone
should whisper into Bush's ear?

What do you suggest as a good diet Bill?

It is obvious that you personally are thriving amazingly well on BS, but
for those of us with a little more taste and discernment, coupled with
a lack of access to fresh bovine created food sources, what would be a
good thing?

Regards

David




--

To reply, please include the letters DNF anywhere in the subject line.

All other mail is automatically deleted.

Bill 14-09-2004 05:33 AM

Hi Dave:

A fool you are! LOL

I have no problem with you believing in a high fat, low carb diet, I find
the planet overpopulated with fatso's anyway.
The nutrition committee of the American Heart Association has issued a
science advisory warning that high-protein diets have not been proven
effective and pose health risks. The report covered the Atkins, Zone,
Protein Power, Sugar Busters, and Stillman diets. The committee stated:

a.. Such diets may produce short-term weight loss through dehydration.
b.. Weight loss may also occur through caloric restriction resulting from
the fact that the diets are relatively unpalatable.
c.. The high fat content may be harmful to the cardiovascular system in
the long run.
d.. Any improvement in blood cholesterol levels and insulin management
would be due to weight loss, not the change in composition.
e.. A very high-protein diet is especially risky for patients with
diabetes because it can speed the progression of diabetic kidney disease
[8].
http://www.quackwatch.org/01Quackery...opics/lcd.html

Bill

I ate a low carb peanut butter sandwich last year and I immediately died
from clogged arteries, cancer, stroke, heart attack etc., just as you
said. Luckily I had my reincarnation insurance paid up, wasn't it?

You are a very useful guy to have around Bill. Your in-depth knowledge and
incredible insight into scams and human nutrition is something that can
only be admired.

I guess that avocados are poison eh Bill? What with the high fat, low
carbs. Maybe they are Saddam's secret weapons of mass destruction? They
are a sort of drab military green after all. Do you think that someone
should whisper into Bush's ear?

What do you suggest as a good diet Bill?

It is obvious that you personally are thriving amazingly well on BS, but
for those of us with a little more taste and discernment, coupled with a
lack of access to fresh bovine created food sources, what would be a good
thing?

Regards

David




Bill 14-09-2004 05:48 AM


"marengo" wrote in message
...
Bill wrote:

| That's a foolish diet, you may lose weight for a while, but you may
| also die from clogged arteries, cancer, stroke, heart attack, etc.,
| before the next year is up.
|
| Low carb diet is nothing but a scam.
|
| Bill


Please cite the research to back up your claims.


http://www.quackwatch.org/01Quackery...opics/lcd.html

There is plenty of research to back up my claim, problem is that fat people
won't believe it. Being fat is being lazy and being lazy means that you are
looking for a panacea.

You can lose weight with any diet, but to lose weight with high fat, low
carbs permanently, you have to die, and die you will, as Dr. Atkins did at
258 lbs with conditions arising from his cardiomyopathy, a lack of blood
flow.

The Bottom Line
Although short-range studies have found that low-carbohydrate diets can
produce weight loss, no study has demonstrated that such diets are safe or
effective for long-term use [11-14,22,23]. Atkins advocated his diet for
more than 30 years and stated that more than 60,000 patients treated at his
center had used his diet as their primary protocol. However, he never
published any study in which people who used his program were monitored over
a period of several years. The recent popularity of low-carbohydrate diets
has encouraged food companies to market low-carbohydrate foods for people
who want to "watch their carbs." Most of these foods are much higher in fat
than the foods they are designed to replace. I believe that "low-carb"
advertising is encouraging both dieters and nondieters to eat high-fat
foods, which is exactly the opposite of what medical and nutrition
authorities have been urging for decades. Following a low-carbohydrate diet
under medical supervision may make sense for some people, but a
population-wide increase in fat consumption is a recipe for disaster.

For Additional Information
a.. American Heart Association Statement on High Protein Diets
b.. atkinsfacts.org: Archive of documents about the Atkins diet

Oh that;s right, you can't -- because it's purely fiction!

LMAO!


The joke is on you fat boy! LOL

Bill
--
Peter
Before/Current Pix:
http://users.thelink.net/marengo/wei...htlosspix.html





Bill 14-09-2004 05:48 AM


"marengo" wrote in message
...
Bill wrote:

| That's a foolish diet, you may lose weight for a while, but you may
| also die from clogged arteries, cancer, stroke, heart attack, etc.,
| before the next year is up.
|
| Low carb diet is nothing but a scam.
|
| Bill


Please cite the research to back up your claims.


http://www.quackwatch.org/01Quackery...opics/lcd.html

There is plenty of research to back up my claim, problem is that fat people
won't believe it. Being fat is being lazy and being lazy means that you are
looking for a panacea.

You can lose weight with any diet, but to lose weight with high fat, low
carbs permanently, you have to die, and die you will, as Dr. Atkins did at
258 lbs with conditions arising from his cardiomyopathy, a lack of blood
flow.

The Bottom Line
Although short-range studies have found that low-carbohydrate diets can
produce weight loss, no study has demonstrated that such diets are safe or
effective for long-term use [11-14,22,23]. Atkins advocated his diet for
more than 30 years and stated that more than 60,000 patients treated at his
center had used his diet as their primary protocol. However, he never
published any study in which people who used his program were monitored over
a period of several years. The recent popularity of low-carbohydrate diets
has encouraged food companies to market low-carbohydrate foods for people
who want to "watch their carbs." Most of these foods are much higher in fat
than the foods they are designed to replace. I believe that "low-carb"
advertising is encouraging both dieters and nondieters to eat high-fat
foods, which is exactly the opposite of what medical and nutrition
authorities have been urging for decades. Following a low-carbohydrate diet
under medical supervision may make sense for some people, but a
population-wide increase in fat consumption is a recipe for disaster.

For Additional Information
a.. American Heart Association Statement on High Protein Diets
b.. atkinsfacts.org: Archive of documents about the Atkins diet

Oh that;s right, you can't -- because it's purely fiction!

LMAO!


The joke is on you fat boy! LOL

Bill
--
Peter
Before/Current Pix:
http://users.thelink.net/marengo/wei...htlosspix.html





Pat Kiewicz 14-09-2004 12:32 PM

Bill said:

"Ignoramus2437" wrote in message
...
I am on a low carb high fat "paleo diet". In the front yard, we have a
concrete retaining wall that is a boundary of our land. Beyond the
retaining wall, 3 feet lower, is a public sidewalk. I rented a monster
tiller recently, and tilled a 24" strip of land immediately adjacent
to the retaining wall. (did a lot of other tilling to plant a lawn
elsewhere).

My desire is to plant some pretty, high fat, low carb, edible plants
that are not grains.


Nuts are things you could grow that contain good fats with omega-3s.
Purslane, a green, is also a source of omega-3s.
Sunflower oil has a pretty good fat profile (still more omega-6 than olive
oil, but less than corn and soybean oil).

Nuts might be the hardest thing to grow at home as you would need space
and would have to fight off the squirrels. Pick a type that suits your climate
(examples, hazelnuts in Oregon, pecans in Georgia, hickory nuts in Indiana).

That's a foolish diet, you may lose weight for a while, but you may also die
from clogged arteries, cancer, stroke, heart attack, etc., before the next
year is up.

The problem is the fat profile of modern domestic animals vs. the wild animals
our ancestors ate. Fat from domestic animals is high in saturated acids. Fat from
wild animals has plenty monosaturated fats and is high in omega-3 fatty acids.
The closest we could come these days to a real 'paleo diet' would be very lean
meats with plenty of olive oil and nuts plus plenty of fatty fish like salmon and
sardines. (Polyunsaturated vegetable fats are high in omega-6 fatty acids, no
real help.) The October issue of Discover touches on this in a feature article titled
'The Inuit Paradox.'

Side comment #1:
Quite alarmingly, this morning's newspaper front page warned of dioxin
contamination if wild game. So even wild game isn't what it used to be.

Side comment #2:
I have kind of a problem with the whole low-carb thing. Limiting high-glycemic
foods is sensible. Avoiding highly processed foods is sensible. Eating a lot
of meat from grain-fed, confined animals and the wrong sorts of fats isn't.
Someone close to me went on the original Atkins diet. He developed kidney
stones and ended up not so much later with inoperable cancer. Soured me
on the concept.

--
Pat in Plymouth MI ('someplace.net' is comcast)

Any technology distinguishable from magic is insufficiently advanced.
(attributed to Don Marti)


Pat Kiewicz 14-09-2004 12:32 PM

Bill said:

"Ignoramus2437" wrote in message
...
I am on a low carb high fat "paleo diet". In the front yard, we have a
concrete retaining wall that is a boundary of our land. Beyond the
retaining wall, 3 feet lower, is a public sidewalk. I rented a monster
tiller recently, and tilled a 24" strip of land immediately adjacent
to the retaining wall. (did a lot of other tilling to plant a lawn
elsewhere).

My desire is to plant some pretty, high fat, low carb, edible plants
that are not grains.


Nuts are things you could grow that contain good fats with omega-3s.
Purslane, a green, is also a source of omega-3s.
Sunflower oil has a pretty good fat profile (still more omega-6 than olive
oil, but less than corn and soybean oil).

Nuts might be the hardest thing to grow at home as you would need space
and would have to fight off the squirrels. Pick a type that suits your climate
(examples, hazelnuts in Oregon, pecans in Georgia, hickory nuts in Indiana).

That's a foolish diet, you may lose weight for a while, but you may also die
from clogged arteries, cancer, stroke, heart attack, etc., before the next
year is up.

The problem is the fat profile of modern domestic animals vs. the wild animals
our ancestors ate. Fat from domestic animals is high in saturated acids. Fat from
wild animals has plenty monosaturated fats and is high in omega-3 fatty acids.
The closest we could come these days to a real 'paleo diet' would be very lean
meats with plenty of olive oil and nuts plus plenty of fatty fish like salmon and
sardines. (Polyunsaturated vegetable fats are high in omega-6 fatty acids, no
real help.) The October issue of Discover touches on this in a feature article titled
'The Inuit Paradox.'

Side comment #1:
Quite alarmingly, this morning's newspaper front page warned of dioxin
contamination if wild game. So even wild game isn't what it used to be.

Side comment #2:
I have kind of a problem with the whole low-carb thing. Limiting high-glycemic
foods is sensible. Avoiding highly processed foods is sensible. Eating a lot
of meat from grain-fed, confined animals and the wrong sorts of fats isn't.
Someone close to me went on the original Atkins diet. He developed kidney
stones and ended up not so much later with inoperable cancer. Soured me
on the concept.

--
Pat in Plymouth MI ('someplace.net' is comcast)

Any technology distinguishable from magic is insufficiently advanced.
(attributed to Don Marti)


marengo 14-09-2004 12:56 PM

Bill, do you realize how hysterically funny your post is?!

Bill wrote:
|
| a.. Such diets may produce short-term weight loss through
| dehydration.

Geez, I've lost 55 pounds of water so far! LMAO!

b.. Weight loss may also occur through caloric
| restriction resulting from the fact that the diets are relatively
| unpalatable.

Yup, bacon,eggs, cheese, steaks, and vegetables are so much more unpalatable
that dry toast and rice cakes!
*wiping eyes* Stop! My sides hurt too much from laughing!

c.. The high fat content may be harmful to the
| cardiovascular system in the long run.

Heeheeheeheheehee. My total cholesterol dropped from 232 to 187, blood
pressure to 120/70, and tricglycerides from 635 to 217 on Atkins. Which is
supposed to hurt my CV systemmo the lower blood pressure, the low
ercholesterol or the lower triglycerides?? ROFLMAO!

| d.. Any improvement in blood cholesterol levels and insulin
| management would be due to weight loss, not the change in composition.

Um, isn't that the point?

| e.. A very high-protein diet is especially risky for patients with
| diabetes because it can speed the progression of diabetic kidney
| disease [8].

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA! Good one!
Let's see, I have to take no medication for my T2 diabetes because its';s
controlled completely with my low-carb diet. My blood glucose is
consistently normal. High blood sugars cause kidney disease. Guess you
lose this one too!

| http://www.quackwatch.org/01Quackery...opics/lcd.html

You're the quack. Get educated.

Oh wait. My guess is that you're either PETA or PCRM, both with a vested
interest in not wanting people to eat meat. Bet that doesn't slant your
point of view, does it?

In a way I feel sorry for you, because you are so misinformed and stupid
enough to promote the tired old Lies that no one listens to any more. Maybe
you could switch careers and find some nice snake oil to sell?

|--
Peter
Before/Current Pix:
http://users.thelink.net/marengo/wei...htlosspix.html



Roger Zoul 14-09-2004 01:18 PM

Pat Kiewicz wrote:

|| Side comment #2:
|| I have kind of a problem with the whole low-carb thing. Limiting
|| high-glycemic
|| foods is sensible. Avoiding highly processed foods is sensible.
|| Eating a lot
|| of meat from grain-fed, confined animals and the wrong sorts of fats
|| isn't.
|| Someone close to me went on the original Atkins diet. He developed
|| kidney
|| stones and ended up not so much later with inoperable cancer.
|| Soured me
|| on the concept.

Side comment #1: Why do you assume that low-carbers eat a lot of meat?

Side comment #2: what makes you think that your friend got kidney stones and
ended up not o much later with inoperable cancer as a result of low carb?

Side comment #3: if you're soured on the concept, it because you're a
simpleton.



Roger Zoul 14-09-2004 01:18 PM

Pat Kiewicz wrote:

|| Side comment #2:
|| I have kind of a problem with the whole low-carb thing. Limiting
|| high-glycemic
|| foods is sensible. Avoiding highly processed foods is sensible.
|| Eating a lot
|| of meat from grain-fed, confined animals and the wrong sorts of fats
|| isn't.
|| Someone close to me went on the original Atkins diet. He developed
|| kidney
|| stones and ended up not so much later with inoperable cancer.
|| Soured me
|| on the concept.

Side comment #1: Why do you assume that low-carbers eat a lot of meat?

Side comment #2: what makes you think that your friend got kidney stones and
ended up not o much later with inoperable cancer as a result of low carb?

Side comment #3: if you're soured on the concept, it because you're a
simpleton.



FDR 14-09-2004 04:50 PM


"marengo" wrote in message
...
Bill, do you realize how hysterically funny your post is?!

Bill wrote:
|
| a.. Such diets may produce short-term weight loss through
| dehydration.

Geez, I've lost 55 pounds of water so far! LMAO!

b.. Weight loss may also occur through caloric
| restriction resulting from the fact that the diets are relatively
| unpalatable.

Yup, bacon,eggs, cheese, steaks, and vegetables are so much more

unpalatable

Yeah, but geez, how much bacon and eggs and steak can you eat? At least
throw some fish and chicken in there. I have red meat once a week and
that's plenty fine.

that dry toast and rice cakes!
*wiping eyes* Stop! My sides hurt too much from laughing!


Funny, but there are plenty of people from around the world that eat diets
high in carbohydrates that are not fat and have high life expectancies.
It's not the carbs killing you, it's the amount of calories you eat. Eat
less and you lose weight. Simple equation.



FDR 14-09-2004 04:53 PM


"Roger Zoul" wrote in message
...
Pat Kiewicz wrote:

|| Side comment #2:
|| I have kind of a problem with the whole low-carb thing. Limiting
|| high-glycemic
|| foods is sensible. Avoiding highly processed foods is sensible.
|| Eating a lot
|| of meat from grain-fed, confined animals and the wrong sorts of fats
|| isn't.
|| Someone close to me went on the original Atkins diet. He developed
|| kidney
|| stones and ended up not so much later with inoperable cancer.
|| Soured me
|| on the concept.

Side comment #1: Why do you assume that low-carbers eat a lot of meat?

Side comment #2: what makes you think that your friend got kidney stones

and
ended up not o much later with inoperable cancer as a result of low carb?

Side comment #3: if you're soured on the concept, it because you're a
simpleton.


Side comment to #3. Name calling won't help you change someone's view.



FDR 14-09-2004 04:53 PM


"Roger Zoul" wrote in message
...
Pat Kiewicz wrote:

|| Side comment #2:
|| I have kind of a problem with the whole low-carb thing. Limiting
|| high-glycemic
|| foods is sensible. Avoiding highly processed foods is sensible.
|| Eating a lot
|| of meat from grain-fed, confined animals and the wrong sorts of fats
|| isn't.
|| Someone close to me went on the original Atkins diet. He developed
|| kidney
|| stones and ended up not so much later with inoperable cancer.
|| Soured me
|| on the concept.

Side comment #1: Why do you assume that low-carbers eat a lot of meat?

Side comment #2: what makes you think that your friend got kidney stones

and
ended up not o much later with inoperable cancer as a result of low carb?

Side comment #3: if you're soured on the concept, it because you're a
simpleton.


Side comment to #3. Name calling won't help you change someone's view.



Roger Zoul 14-09-2004 05:06 PM

FDR wrote:
|| "Roger Zoul" wrote in message
|| ...
||| Pat Kiewicz wrote:
|||
||||| Side comment #2:
||||| I have kind of a problem with the whole low-carb thing. Limiting
||||| high-glycemic
||||| foods is sensible. Avoiding highly processed foods is sensible.
||||| Eating a lot
||||| of meat from grain-fed, confined animals and the wrong sorts of
||||| fats isn't.
||||| Someone close to me went on the original Atkins diet. He
||||| developed kidney
||||| stones and ended up not so much later with inoperable cancer.
||||| Soured me
||||| on the concept.
|||
||| Side comment #1: Why do you assume that low-carbers eat a lot of
||| meat?
|||
||| Side comment #2: what makes you think that your friend got kidney
||| stones and ended up not o much later with inoperable cancer as a
||| result of low carb?
|||
||| Side comment #3: if you're soured on the concept, it because you're
||| a simpleton.
||
|| Side comment to #3. Name calling won't help you change someone's
|| view.

Side comment to side comment to #3. I'm not interested in changing someone
view. That almost never happens on usenet.



Roger Zoul 14-09-2004 05:12 PM

FDR wrote:
|| "marengo" wrote in message
|| ...
||| Bill, do you realize how hysterically funny your post is?!
|||
||| Bill wrote:
||||
|||| a.. Such diets may produce short-term weight loss through
|||| dehydration.
|||
||| Geez, I've lost 55 pounds of water so far! LMAO!
|||
||| b.. Weight loss may also occur through caloric
|||| restriction resulting from the fact that the diets are relatively
|||| unpalatable.
|||
||| Yup, bacon,eggs, cheese, steaks, and vegetables are so much more
||| unpalatable
||
|| Yeah, but geez, how much bacon and eggs and steak can you eat? At
|| least throw some fish and chicken in there. I have red meat once a
|| week and that's plenty fine.

I rarely eat bacon and steak and certainly eat less red meat than you and
I've been LCing for 3 years.

||
||| that dry toast and rice cakes!
||| *wiping eyes* Stop! My sides hurt too much from laughing!
||
|| Funny, but there are plenty of people from around the world that eat
|| diets high in carbohydrates that are not fat and have high life
|| expectancies. It's not the carbs killing you, it's the amount of
|| calories you eat. Eat less and you lose weight. Simple equation.

That is exactly what LC allows most people to do, eat less and lose weight.
Many people who eat diets high in carbs have BG swings that stimulate
appetite. Many of those people are very overweight and will stay that way
if the continue on a high carb diet.

Simple equations are all that folks with simple minds can handle. The real
world is often not so simple.



Jennifer S. 14-09-2004 06:01 PM

Blah,Blah,Blah,
You don't get it at all. It is the release of insulin that makes us fat. If
the insulin release is not there or controlled by a low carb diet then you
will not store the fat you take in.
Simple as that..
Jennifer S.
206/159/135



Glenna Rose 14-09-2004 06:07 PM

Sidebar: My niece started a low carb diet early this year and coupled it
with stopping smoking . . . no one can tell me that decision can be a bad
one!

writes:

There is plenty of research to back up my claim, problem is that fat
people
won't believe it. Being fat is being lazy and being lazy means that you
are
looking for a panacea.


While that might be true with a few people, it is certainly not true of
everyone. I know of many "fat" people who are anything but lazy.
Unfortunately, our society often equates heavy with fat and the two are
not the same thing at all.

I need to only look at my own grandmother who for years hovered around 160
pounds, at 5'4" . . . anyone who would say she was lazy is a fool. She
worked in the fields along side my grandfather, maintained a huge garden,
keep beautiful flowers, sewed, crocheted, was a sports advocate, etc.,
hardly a person who even the most critical person would call lazy or
looking for a panacea. Yet, she was not able to lose weight though her
diet was not excessive in any area . . . it was simply her makeup. Pure
and simple, that weight was where her body wanted to be, regardless of
what she did. It happens.

For the record, her doctor was not the least bit concerned about her
weight for she was healthy. Now before the critical among us jump on the
bandwagon and discuss health problems related to being overweight . . .
she celebrated her 95th birthday in August and is still as healthy as one
can expect someone who has lived 95 years to be and, until two years ago,
fully maintained a household!

The issue with health is not the amount of weight but rather whether it is
healthy weight. A "normal" weight person can be very unhealthy while
looking good to others.

If a person is physically active and has good muscle tone, which means
exercises either by design or by life style regularly, he/she usually
don't need special diets regardless of his/her weight. Apart from those
folks who have organic issues (thyroid, genetic, etc.), the truth of the
entire weight issue is how motivated the person is to lose weight. A
person can lose weight and become healthier keeping exactly the same diet.
Yes, he/she can. The first thing is to have the proper mind set. The
next thing is to drink plenty of just plain water . . . you notice that
diets mention water intake, there's a reason for that. Our bodies need
that minimum of two quarts of water every day to metabolize properly. The
next thing is exercise, not just once a day but throughout the day, the
point being of getting the metabolism up early in the day and keeping it
up throughout the day. Going to a gym and working out at 7 a.m. does only
minimal good if the person goes home and takes a nap and is physically
quiet the remainder of the day. Drinking water so the body can operate at
proper metabolism, keeping physically active throughout the day to keep
the metabolism up, and then following it with sensible eating will do the
job for any person who wants to lose (and does not have organic issues as
mentioned above). The third thing is, of course, the sensible eating.
Keep away from the things that we know are not good for our bodies such as
excessive sugars, fatty foods (and I mean *fatty* not just the type of
food, chicken can have as much fat as a piece of marbled beef!).

It is a fact that *if* a person eats exactly the same thing in the same
amounts and adds the water intake and exercise, that person *will* lose
weight/tone and be healthier. It happens, naturally.

While I'm not a L.C. advocate, the premise behind it has good points.
Staying away from excessive refined flour products (donuts, cookies,
rolls, etc.) is not a bad thing . . . there are a lot of calories in that
stuff and little food value. The important thing is that it has people
thinking about what is going into their bodies.

If you really are concerned about your health and your weight, make
everything you put in your mouth beneficial to your body; don't put it
there only because it tastes good. If those who want to lose weight think
of food like money and there is only a limited amount to intake like
spending, they will begin to be more health conscious and are more likely
to make life-style changes that will improve their health. It is the
*mind-set* more than the *diet* that does the trick.

Whether I agree with the current low-carb fad (and it is a fad and will
fade as many others have), it is encouraging people to think about what
they eat. Any time a person thinks about what they eat is one step closer
to better health. Thinking, after all, is the first step to doing.

As for those who say it is alone what you put in your mouth that
determines your weight, I say they are full of it. After my son died, I
averaged less than 500 calories a day for nearly a year and lost not a
single ounce! On the other side, when my children were young and I was
very, very active with three healthy little boys to keep up with, I gained
not an ounce, staying within 3 pounds of 105 for years, even though I ate
more than most men working outdoors! (I'm 5'6") There are many factors
that enter into weight and whether an individual will gain or lose, or
just maintain.

My point is that regardless of what you eat, make it all good substantial
(meaning with health benefits) food, drink a minimum of two quarts of
water every day, keep physically active (take the stairs, not the
elevator, walk not drive to the corner market, etc.) by looking at your
life and seeing where you can add more physical movement.

Insulting the ideas of others as to what type of diet to utilize to lose
weight is pointless and only demonstrates ignorance as well as a lack of
common consideration. Personally, I would prefer to hear all arguments
(meaning *debate* not attacking) about the diets because somewhere there
is something of benefit to me.

Glenna


DigitalVinyl 14-09-2004 06:24 PM

Ignoramus2437 wrote:

I am on a low carb high fat "paleo diet". In the front yard, we have a
concrete retaining wall that is a boundary of our land. Beyond the
retaining wall, 3 feet lower, is a public sidewalk. I rented a monster
tiller recently, and tilled a 24" strip of land immediately adjacent
to the retaining wall. (did a lot of other tilling to plant a lawn
elsewhere).

My desire is to plant some pretty, high fat, low carb, edible plants
that are not grains.

I live in Zone 5 (N Illinois).

One plant that I can think of is sunflowers. Maybe I will throw some
corn into it, for looks and for other members of my family, but I am
looking for other suggestions.

Thanks!


Green beans, peppers, lettuces, zucchini (big plants), spaghetti
squash (train it and trim it back it can send out 12 foot vines
without stopping) or other squash, eggplant(not sure if you get enough
heat in zone 5). Broccoli and to a lesser extent cauliflower(only
develops one head then stops). I did kerby cucumbers and made my own
pickle varieties. COrn takes a lot of space and my second batch of the
season was eaten by bugs and a near total failure.

I can't imagine not growing tomatoes! I went on maintenance for the
summer/fall harvest so I could enjoy anything I wanted from the
garden. After all it may be carbs but a lot healthier than say...
sugar cookies. Has worked well since I don't hesitate to eat
grape-sized tomatoes from the vine in the garden or slice-&-salt
tomatoes in the kitchen as an afternoon snack. I tried canteloupe and
watermelon this year but I messed them up with spacing and I got two
3" canteloupes. :-( Next year I will do better.

DiGiTAL ViNYL (no email)
Zone 6b/7, Westchester Co, NY, 1 mile off L.I.Sound
2nd year gardener
http://photos.yahoo.com/ph/royalfrazier/

DigitalVinyl 14-09-2004 06:24 PM

Ignoramus2437 wrote:

I am on a low carb high fat "paleo diet". In the front yard, we have a
concrete retaining wall that is a boundary of our land. Beyond the
retaining wall, 3 feet lower, is a public sidewalk. I rented a monster
tiller recently, and tilled a 24" strip of land immediately adjacent
to the retaining wall. (did a lot of other tilling to plant a lawn
elsewhere).

My desire is to plant some pretty, high fat, low carb, edible plants
that are not grains.

I live in Zone 5 (N Illinois).

One plant that I can think of is sunflowers. Maybe I will throw some
corn into it, for looks and for other members of my family, but I am
looking for other suggestions.

Thanks!


Green beans, peppers, lettuces, zucchini (big plants), spaghetti
squash (train it and trim it back it can send out 12 foot vines
without stopping) or other squash, eggplant(not sure if you get enough
heat in zone 5). Broccoli and to a lesser extent cauliflower(only
develops one head then stops). I did kerby cucumbers and made my own
pickle varieties. COrn takes a lot of space and my second batch of the
season was eaten by bugs and a near total failure.

I can't imagine not growing tomatoes! I went on maintenance for the
summer/fall harvest so I could enjoy anything I wanted from the
garden. After all it may be carbs but a lot healthier than say...
sugar cookies. Has worked well since I don't hesitate to eat
grape-sized tomatoes from the vine in the garden or slice-&-salt
tomatoes in the kitchen as an afternoon snack. I tried canteloupe and
watermelon this year but I messed them up with spacing and I got two
3" canteloupes. :-( Next year I will do better.

DiGiTAL ViNYL (no email)
Zone 6b/7, Westchester Co, NY, 1 mile off L.I.Sound
2nd year gardener
http://photos.yahoo.com/ph/royalfrazier/

DigitalVinyl 14-09-2004 06:27 PM

Bill you're clueless. You know nothing about Low-carb diets. You just
said theat every doctor in the united states advises every diabetic to
use a scam of a diet. Diabetics are low-carbers. Low carbing is the
control of insulin.


"Bill" wrote:

"Ignoramus2437" wrote in message
...
I am on a low carb high fat "paleo diet". In the front yard, we have a
concrete retaining wall that is a boundary of our land. Beyond the
retaining wall, 3 feet lower, is a public sidewalk. I rented a monster
tiller recently, and tilled a 24" strip of land immediately adjacent
to the retaining wall. (did a lot of other tilling to plant a lawn
elsewhere).

My desire is to plant some pretty, high fat, low carb, edible plants
that are not grains.


That's a foolish diet, you may lose weight for a while, but you may also die
from clogged arteries, cancer, stroke, heart attack, etc., before the next
year is up.

Low carb diet is nothing but a scam.

Bill



DiGiTAL ViNYL (no email)
Zone 6b/7, Westchester Co, NY, 1 mile off L.I.Sound
2nd year gardener
http://photos.yahoo.com/ph/royalfrazier/

FDR 14-09-2004 07:23 PM


"Roger Zoul" wrote in message
...
FDR wrote:
|| "Roger Zoul" wrote in message
|| ...
||| Pat Kiewicz wrote:
|||
||||| Side comment #2:
||||| I have kind of a problem with the whole low-carb thing. Limiting
||||| high-glycemic
||||| foods is sensible. Avoiding highly processed foods is sensible.
||||| Eating a lot
||||| of meat from grain-fed, confined animals and the wrong sorts of
||||| fats isn't.
||||| Someone close to me went on the original Atkins diet. He
||||| developed kidney
||||| stones and ended up not so much later with inoperable cancer.
||||| Soured me
||||| on the concept.
|||
||| Side comment #1: Why do you assume that low-carbers eat a lot of
||| meat?
|||
||| Side comment #2: what makes you think that your friend got kidney
||| stones and ended up not o much later with inoperable cancer as a
||| result of low carb?
|||
||| Side comment #3: if you're soured on the concept, it because you're
||| a simpleton.
||
|| Side comment to #3. Name calling won't help you change someone's
|| view.

Side comment to side comment to #3. I'm not interested in changing

someone
view. That almost never happens on usenet.


Then why even bother?



FDR 14-09-2004 07:23 PM


"Roger Zoul" wrote in message
...
FDR wrote:
|| "Roger Zoul" wrote in message
|| ...
||| Pat Kiewicz wrote:
|||
||||| Side comment #2:
||||| I have kind of a problem with the whole low-carb thing. Limiting
||||| high-glycemic
||||| foods is sensible. Avoiding highly processed foods is sensible.
||||| Eating a lot
||||| of meat from grain-fed, confined animals and the wrong sorts of
||||| fats isn't.
||||| Someone close to me went on the original Atkins diet. He
||||| developed kidney
||||| stones and ended up not so much later with inoperable cancer.
||||| Soured me
||||| on the concept.
|||
||| Side comment #1: Why do you assume that low-carbers eat a lot of
||| meat?
|||
||| Side comment #2: what makes you think that your friend got kidney
||| stones and ended up not o much later with inoperable cancer as a
||| result of low carb?
|||
||| Side comment #3: if you're soured on the concept, it because you're
||| a simpleton.
||
|| Side comment to #3. Name calling won't help you change someone's
|| view.

Side comment to side comment to #3. I'm not interested in changing

someone
view. That almost never happens on usenet.


Then why even bother?



Roger Zoul 14-09-2004 07:40 PM

FDR wrote:
|| "Roger Zoul" wrote in message
|| ...
||| FDR wrote:
||||| "Roger Zoul" wrote in message
||||| ...
|||||| Pat Kiewicz wrote:
||||||
|||||||| Side comment #2:
|||||||| I have kind of a problem with the whole low-carb thing.
|||||||| Limiting high-glycemic
|||||||| foods is sensible. Avoiding highly processed foods is
|||||||| sensible. Eating a lot
|||||||| of meat from grain-fed, confined animals and the wrong sorts of
|||||||| fats isn't.
|||||||| Someone close to me went on the original Atkins diet. He
|||||||| developed kidney
|||||||| stones and ended up not so much later with inoperable cancer.
|||||||| Soured me
|||||||| on the concept.
||||||
|||||| Side comment #1: Why do you assume that low-carbers eat a lot of
|||||| meat?
||||||
|||||| Side comment #2: what makes you think that your friend got kidney
|||||| stones and ended up not o much later with inoperable cancer as a
|||||| result of low carb?
||||||
|||||| Side comment #3: if you're soured on the concept, it because
|||||| you're a simpleton.
|||||
||||| Side comment to #3. Name calling won't help you change someone's
||||| view.
|||
||| Side comment to side comment to #3. I'm not interested in changing
||| someone view. That almost never happens on usenet.
||
|| Then why even bother?

It's about stamping out misinformation for others how may benefit from
accurate knowledge about low-carb diets. Many many people here have
benefited greatly from LC diets....



simy1 14-09-2004 09:25 PM

"Roger Zoul" wrote in message ...
Ig -

Check out this site for some ideas: http://www.ediblelandscaping.com/

I was thinking olive, but that might not work in zone 5.


so you are calling Pat a simpleton, and then you suggest olives for
Zone 5? with this kind of advice, the guy will go on a starvation diet
for sure.


Ignoramus2437 wrote:
|| I am on a low carb high fat "paleo diet". In the front yard, we have
|| a concrete retaining wall that is a boundary of our land. Beyond the
|| retaining wall, 3 feet lower, is a public sidewalk. I rented a
|| monster tiller recently, and tilled a 24" strip of land immediately
|| adjacent to the retaining wall. (did a lot of other tilling to plant
|| a lawn elsewhere).
||
|| My desire is to plant some pretty, high fat, low carb, edible plants
|| that are not grains.
||
|| I live in Zone 5 (N Illinois).
||
|| One plant that I can think of is sunflowers. Maybe I will throw some
|| corn into it, for looks and for other members of my family, but I am
|| looking for other suggestions.
||
|| Thanks!
||
|| i



All times are GMT +1. The time now is 06:52 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
GardenBanter