GardenBanter.co.uk

GardenBanter.co.uk (https://www.gardenbanter.co.uk/)
-   United Kingdom (https://www.gardenbanter.co.uk/united-kingdom/)
-   -   Tree stump killer (https://www.gardenbanter.co.uk/united-kingdom/190658-tree-stump-killer.html)

Tim Watts 06-04-2010 12:30 PM

Tree stump killer
 
I have a 6" stump left from a tree I just chopped down (threatening to break
the drain chamber in my garden that's all of a foot away from the trunk).

No idea what the tree was, but I need to ensure its complete and permanent
demise.

Apart from the old drill-holes-in-stump and pour in diesel/old-sump-oil
trick (don't have any mouldy sump oil to hand anyway) what would be a good
product to use?

Are any of these any good?


http://www.selections.com/GF1911/dee...-stump-killer/

http://www.garden4less.co.uk/bayer-g...ump-killer.asp

http://www.wilkinsonplus.com/Weedkil.../Roundup-Tree-
Stump+Root-Killer-250ml/invt/0263127

Some of those seem to be glyphospate based, which I *thought* acted on
foliage. I need something that can be applied to the cut trunk end that will
travel through the tree's system.

Ta

Tim

--
Tim Watts

Managers, politicians and environmentalists: Nature's carbon buffer.


DAVEJ 06-04-2010 03:16 PM

Tree stump killer
 

"Tim Watts" wrote in message
...
I have a 6" stump left from a tree I just chopped down (threatening to
break
the drain chamber in my garden that's all of a foot away from the trunk).

No idea what the tree was, but I need to ensure its complete and permanent
demise.

SBK comes to mind for what you want.



duncspur 06-04-2010 04:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tim Watts (Post 882599)
I have a 6" stump left from a tree I just chopped down (threatening to break
the drain chamber in my garden that's all of a foot away from the trunk).

No idea what the tree was, but I need to ensure its complete and permanent
demise.

Apart from the old drill-holes-in-stump and pour in diesel/old-sump-oil
trick (don't have any mouldy sump oil to hand anyway) what would be a good
product to use?

Are any of these any good?


http://www.selections.com/GF1911/dee...-stump-killer/

http://www.garden4less.co.uk/bayer-g...ump-killer.asp

http://www.wilkinsonplus.com/Weedkil.../Roundup-Tree-
Stump+Root-Killer-250ml/invt/0263127

Some of those seem to be glyphospate based, which I *thought* acted on
foliage. I need something that can be applied to the cut trunk end that will
travel through the tree's system.

Ta

Tim

--
Tim Watts

Managers, politicians and environmentalists: Nature's carbon buffer.

I've used the Roundup Stump Killer. Drilled a hole in the top of the stump and poured the liquid in using the plastic pipette that comes with it (during a dry period), then topped it up every few days as it soaked into the stump. I can now declare the stump is well and truly dead.

Tim Watts 06-04-2010 04:52 PM

Tree stump killer
 
davej
wibbled on Tuesday 06 April 2010 15:16

SBK


Found it - cool, thanks.

--
Tim Watts

Managers, politicians and environmentalists: Nature's carbon buffer.


Rusty Hinge[_2_] 06-04-2010 05:44 PM

Tree stump killer
 
Tim Watts wrote:
I have a 6" stump left from a tree I just chopped down (threatening to break
the drain chamber in my garden that's all of a foot away from the trunk).

No idea what the tree was, but I need to ensure its complete and permanent
demise.

Apart from the old drill-holes-in-stump and pour in diesel/old-sump-oil
trick (don't have any mouldy sump oil to hand anyway) what would be a good
product to use?


Sulphuric acid. (Battery acid.)

--
Rusty

Tim Watts 06-04-2010 05:47 PM

Tree stump killer
 
Rusty Hinge
wibbled on Tuesday 06 April 2010 17:44

Tim Watts wrote:
I have a 6" stump left from a tree I just chopped down (threatening to
break the drain chamber in my garden that's all of a foot away from the
trunk).

No idea what the tree was, but I need to ensure its complete and
permanent demise.

Apart from the old drill-holes-in-stump and pour in diesel/old-sump-oil
trick (don't have any mouldy sump oil to hand anyway) what would be a
good product to use?


Sulphuric acid. (Battery acid.)


I've got 20% HCl - would that be any good?

--
Tim Watts

Managers, politicians and environmentalists: Nature's carbon buffer.


Jeff Layman[_2_] 06-04-2010 07:11 PM

Tree stump killer
 
"Chris Hogg" wrote in message
...


The first one. Either that or anything containing ammonium sulphamate
(not to be confused with ammonium sulphate!). Drill two or three
decent sized deep holes into the top of the stump, pour in crystals of
stump killer, cover with a tile or whatever to keep the rain out.

--

Chris

Gardening in West Cornwall overlooking the sea.
Mild, but very exposed to salt gales

E-mail: christopher[dot]hog[at]virgin[dot]net


Ammonium sulphamate was withdrawn from sale over 2 years ago and is not
approved for use in the EU.

--

Jeff



Martin Brown 06-04-2010 08:07 PM

Tree stump killer
 
Jeff Layman wrote:
"Chris Hogg" wrote in message
...


The first one. Either that or anything containing ammonium sulphamate
(not to be confused with ammonium sulphate!). Drill two or three
decent sized deep holes into the top of the stump, pour in crystals of
stump killer, cover with a tile or whatever to keep the rain out.


Ammonium sulphamate was withdrawn from sale over 2 years ago and is not
approved for use in the EU.


Do you have any idea why?

I checked an it is apparently due to the insane requirement that the
halfwitted Irish Rapporteur that insisted on additional gratuitous
animal testing on dogs. This is nothing to do with safety when used by
amateurs. It is entirely to do with insane EEC red tape on chemicals.

http://www.pesticides.gov.uk/garden.asp?id=1997

Even the Henry Doublespeak organisation considers Ammonium Sulphamate as
a borderline acceptable weedkiller although not strictly Organic(TM).

This is an example of the H&SE at its dumbest. You can bet your bottom
dollar it is still widely available to amateurs elsewhere in Europe
despite a notional EU wide ban. Only the UK blindly enforces this junk.

Regards,
Martin Brown

Martin Brown 06-04-2010 10:23 PM

Tree stump killer
 
Tim Watts wrote:
davej
wibbled on Tuesday 06 April 2010 15:16

SBK


Found it - cool, thanks.


And as strange as it sounds adding a small amount of copper sulphate to
it after a month or so will speed up the decay of the wood - assuming
that is what you want to happen. I levered mine out after it had been
weakened sufficiently but close to drains that isn't a good idea.

A trace of copper salt inhibits the natural fungicides in the wood.

Regards,
Martin Brown

Tim Watts 06-04-2010 11:29 PM

Tree stump killer
 
Martin Brown
wibbled on Tuesday 06 April 2010 20:07

Jeff Layman wrote:
"Chris Hogg" wrote in message
...


The first one. Either that or anything containing ammonium sulphamate
(not to be confused with ammonium sulphate!). Drill two or three
decent sized deep holes into the top of the stump, pour in crystals of
stump killer, cover with a tile or whatever to keep the rain out.


Ammonium sulphamate was withdrawn from sale over 2 years ago and is not
approved for use in the EU.


Do you have any idea why?

I checked an it is apparently due to the insane requirement that the
halfwitted Irish Rapporteur that insisted on additional gratuitous
animal testing on dogs. This is nothing to do with safety when used by
amateurs. It is entirely to do with insane EEC red tape on chemicals.

http://www.pesticides.gov.uk/garden.asp?id=1997

Even the Henry Doublespeak organisation considers Ammonium Sulphamate as
a borderline acceptable weedkiller although not strictly Organic(TM).

This is an example of the H&SE at its dumbest. You can bet your bottom
dollar it is still widely available to amateurs elsewhere in Europe
despite a notional EU wide ban. Only the UK blindly enforces this junk.

Regards,
Martin Brown


You can still buy it as a compost accelerator.

--
Tim Watts

Managers, politicians and environmentalists: Nature's carbon buffer.


Tim Watts 06-04-2010 11:29 PM

Tree stump killer
 
Martin Brown
wibbled on Tuesday 06 April 2010 22:23

Tim Watts wrote:
davej
wibbled on Tuesday 06 April 2010 15:16

SBK


Found it - cool, thanks.


And as strange as it sounds adding a small amount of copper sulphate to
it after a month or so will speed up the decay of the wood - assuming
that is what you want to happen. I levered mine out after it had been
weakened sufficiently but close to drains that isn't a good idea.

A trace of copper salt inhibits the natural fungicides in the wood.

Regards,
Martin Brown


Thanks for that!

--
Tim Watts

Managers, politicians and environmentalists: Nature's carbon buffer.


chris French 07-04-2010 03:07 AM

Tree stump killer
 
In message , Tim Watts
writes
I have a 6" stump left from a tree I just chopped down (threatening to break
the drain chamber in my garden that's all of a foot away from the trunk).

No idea what the tree was, but I need to ensure its complete and permanent
demise.

Apart from the old drill-holes-in-stump and pour in diesel/old-sump-oil
trick (don't have any mouldy sump oil to hand anyway) what would be a good
product to use?

Are any of these any good?


http://www.selections.com/GF1911/dee...-stump-killer/

http://www.garden4less.co.uk/bayer-g...ump-killer.asp

http://www.wilkinsonplus.com/Weedkil.../Roundup-Tree-
Stump+Root-Killer-250ml/invt/0263127

Some of those seem to be glyphospate based, which I *thought* acted on
foliage. I need something that can be applied to the cut trunk end that will
travel through the tree's system.


Glyphosphate is normally applied to foliage, but apparently it can be
used to kill stumps and tree - hence them selling a version for that
purpose. Which seems to be just strongish glyphosphate applied neat
--
Chris French


Rusty Hinge[_2_] 07-04-2010 03:41 PM

Tree stump killer
 
Tim Watts wrote:
Rusty Hinge
wibbled on Tuesday 06 April 2010 17:44

Tim Watts wrote:
I have a 6" stump left from a tree I just chopped down (threatening to
break the drain chamber in my garden that's all of a foot away from the
trunk).

No idea what the tree was, but I need to ensure its complete and
permanent demise.

Apart from the old drill-holes-in-stump and pour in diesel/old-sump-oil
trick (don't have any mouldy sump oil to hand anyway) what would be a
good product to use?

Sulphuric acid. (Battery acid.)


I've got 20% HCl - would that be any good?


Not as far as I know.

Sulphuric acid naturally absorbs any moisture it an find, and such that
it does, evaporates to some extent.

It also removes (chemically) the elements of water from many organic
substances, so hydrogen and oxygen are taken from the wood's cellulose
and dilute the acid. The cycle continues until all the acid is
neutralised by contact with bases and some mildly alkaline salts (in the
surrounsing soil and potassium carbonate amongst other salts in the wood.)

The wood is first rendered into a friable condition much like naturally
rotten wood, and if there's still enough acid left, the roots are
reduced mainly to carbon.

This does not happen with HCl.

--
Rusty

Rusty Hinge[_2_] 07-04-2010 03:46 PM

Tree stump killer
 
Jeff Layman wrote:
"Chris Hogg" wrote in message
...


The first one. Either that or anything containing ammonium sulphamate
(not to be confused with ammonium sulphate!). Drill two or three
decent sized deep holes into the top of the stump, pour in crystals of
stump killer, cover with a tile or whatever to keep the rain out.

--

Chris

Gardening in West Cornwall overlooking the sea.
Mild, but very exposed to salt gales

E-mail: christopher[dot]hog[at]virgin[dot]net


Ammonium sulphamate was withdrawn from sale over 2 years ago and is not
approved for use in the EU.


Must get some and use it!

Applies for Nigel Farage Medal

--
Rusty

Rusty Hinge[_2_] 07-04-2010 03:50 PM

Tree stump killer
 
Martin Brown wrote:
Jeff Layman wrote:
"Chris Hogg" wrote in message
...


The first one. Either that or anything containing ammonium sulphamate
(not to be confused with ammonium sulphate!). Drill two or three
decent sized deep holes into the top of the stump, pour in crystals of
stump killer, cover with a tile or whatever to keep the rain out.


Ammonium sulphamate was withdrawn from sale over 2 years ago and is
not approved for use in the EU.


Do you have any idea why?

I checked an it is apparently due to the insane requirement that the
halfwitted Irish Rapporteur that insisted on additional gratuitous
animal testing on dogs. This is nothing to do with safety when used by
amateurs. It is entirely to do with insane EEC red tape on chemicals.

http://www.pesticides.gov.uk/garden.asp?id=1997

Even the Henry Doublespeak organisation considers Ammonium Sulphamate as
a borderline acceptable weedkiller although not strictly Organic(TM).

This is an example of the H&SE at its dumbest. You can bet your bottom
dollar it is still widely available to amateurs elsewhere in Europe
despite a notional EU wide ban. Only the UK blindly enforces this junk.


Quite agree with those sentiments.

If you want a relatively harmles chemical banned for garden use, you can
usually get it from a chemical distributor, who won't ask you what you
want it for, unless it's something which you could blow-up politicians with.

Mind you, you'd have to buy several years' supply...

--
Rusty

Rusty Hinge[_2_] 07-04-2010 03:51 PM

Tree stump killer
 
Tim Watts wrote:

You can still buy it as a compost accelerator.


Hmmm. I make my own compost accelerator, especially after a night out.

--
Rusty

Tim Watts 07-04-2010 04:03 PM

Tree stump killer
 
Rusty Hinge
wibbled on Wednesday 07 April 2010 15:41

Tim Watts wrote:
Rusty Hinge
wibbled on Tuesday 06 April 2010 17:44

Tim Watts wrote:
I have a 6" stump left from a tree I just chopped down (threatening to
break the drain chamber in my garden that's all of a foot away from the
trunk).

No idea what the tree was, but I need to ensure its complete and
permanent demise.

Apart from the old drill-holes-in-stump and pour in diesel/old-sump-oil
trick (don't have any mouldy sump oil to hand anyway) what would be a
good product to use?
Sulphuric acid. (Battery acid.)


I've got 20% HCl - would that be any good?


Not as far as I know.

Sulphuric acid naturally absorbs any moisture it an find, and such that
it does, evaporates to some extent.

It also removes (chemically) the elements of water from many organic
substances, so hydrogen and oxygen are taken from the wood's cellulose
and dilute the acid. The cycle continues until all the acid is
neutralised by contact with bases and some mildly alkaline salts (in the
surrounsing soil and potassium carbonate amongst other salts in the wood.)

The wood is first rendered into a friable condition much like naturally
rotten wood, and if there's still enough acid left, the roots are
reduced mainly to carbon.

This does not happen with HCl.


Oh - so not so much that it is an acid, more that it rips the H2O out of
anything it touches - remember the chem lesson experiment with conc H2SO4 +
sugar?

--
Tim Watts

Managers, politicians and environmentalists: Nature's carbon buffer.


Tim Watts 07-04-2010 04:06 PM

Tree stump killer
 
Rusty Hinge
wibbled on Wednesday 07 April 2010 15:46

Jeff Layman wrote:
"Chris Hogg" wrote in message
...


The first one. Either that or anything containing ammonium sulphamate
(not to be confused with ammonium sulphate!). Drill two or three
decent sized deep holes into the top of the stump, pour in crystals of
stump killer, cover with a tile or whatever to keep the rain out.

--

Chris

Gardening in West Cornwall overlooking the sea.
Mild, but very exposed to salt gales

E-mail: christopher[dot]hog[at]virgin[dot]net


Ammonium sulphamate was withdrawn from sale over 2 years ago and is not
approved for use in the EU.


Must get some and use it!

Applies for Nigel Farage Medal

http://www.stantonhope.com/Tools_26_...r_ 872kg_.asp

smaller quantities regularly on ebay (around 10 quid/kilo)
--
Tim Watts

Managers, politicians and environmentalists: Nature's carbon buffer.


Jeff Layman[_2_] 07-04-2010 05:21 PM

Tree stump killer
 
"Tim Watts" wrote in message
...
Martin Brown
wibbled on Tuesday 06 April 2010 20:07

Jeff Layman wrote:
"Chris Hogg" wrote in message
...


The first one. Either that or anything containing ammonium sulphamate
(not to be confused with ammonium sulphate!). Drill two or three
decent sized deep holes into the top of the stump, pour in crystals of
stump killer, cover with a tile or whatever to keep the rain out.

Ammonium sulphamate was withdrawn from sale over 2 years ago and is not
approved for use in the EU.


Do you have any idea why?

I checked an it is apparently due to the insane requirement that the
halfwitted Irish Rapporteur that insisted on additional gratuitous
animal testing on dogs. This is nothing to do with safety when used by
amateurs. It is entirely to do with insane EEC red tape on chemicals.

http://www.pesticides.gov.uk/garden.asp?id=1997

Even the Henry Doublespeak organisation considers Ammonium Sulphamate as
a borderline acceptable weedkiller although not strictly Organic(TM).

This is an example of the H&SE at its dumbest. You can bet your bottom
dollar it is still widely available to amateurs elsewhere in Europe
despite a notional EU wide ban. Only the UK blindly enforces this junk.

Regards,
Martin Brown


You can still buy it as a compost accelerator.


But if you use the ammonium sulphamate from that pack as a stump killer, you
will be doing something illegal, as daft as it may sound. In fact, AFAIAA,
you are only allowed to use approved products for designated "pesticide"
uses. If you use anything else (eg coffee grounds to deal with slugs), then
you risk prosecution. It's a funny old world, innit?

--

Jeff



Martin Brown 07-04-2010 05:46 PM

Tree stump killer
 
Jeff Layman wrote:
"Tim Watts" wrote in message
...
Martin Brown
wibbled on Tuesday 06 April 2010 20:07

Jeff Layman wrote:
"Chris Hogg" wrote in message
...


The first one. Either that or anything containing ammonium sulphamate
(not to be confused with ammonium sulphate!). Drill two or three
decent sized deep holes into the top of the stump, pour in crystals of
stump killer, cover with a tile or whatever to keep the rain out.

Ammonium sulphamate was withdrawn from sale over 2 years ago and is not
approved for use in the EU.

Do you have any idea why?

I checked an it is apparently due to the insane requirement that the
halfwitted Irish Rapporteur that insisted on additional gratuitous
animal testing on dogs. This is nothing to do with safety when used by
amateurs. It is entirely to do with insane EEC red tape on chemicals.

http://www.pesticides.gov.uk/garden.asp?id=1997

Even the Henry Doublespeak organisation considers Ammonium Sulphamate as
a borderline acceptable weedkiller although not strictly Organic(TM).

This is an example of the H&SE at its dumbest. You can bet your bottom
dollar it is still widely available to amateurs elsewhere in Europe
despite a notional EU wide ban. Only the UK blindly enforces this junk.

Regards,
Martin Brown


You can still buy it as a compost accelerator.


But if you use the ammonium sulphamate from that pack as a stump killer,
you will be doing something illegal, as daft as it may sound. In fact,
AFAIAA, you are only allowed to use approved products for designated
"pesticide" uses. If you use anything else (eg coffee grounds to deal
with slugs), then you risk prosecution. It's a funny old world, innit?


It would be unlicensed use. But they would have to catch you doing it.
Who knows you might decide to start a compost heap on the stump and then
change your mind. The rules on ammonium sulphamate are a complete joke
and someone deserves a good knee capping for this particular mess.

An effective and relatively benign weedkiller banned for amateur use in
the EEC because of red tape and unbridled bureaucratic stupidity.

A fitting punishment would be application of the unapproved product to
sensitive parts of the Irish Rapporteurs anatomy. It is an irritant.

Regards,
Martin Brown

Rusty Hinge[_2_] 07-04-2010 05:51 PM

Tree stump killer
 
Tim Watts wrote:

Oh - so not so much that it is an acid, more that it rips the H2O out of
anything it touches - remember the chem lesson experiment with conc H2SO4 +
sugar?


Ding!

Not one we did, but I'd expect it to reduce sugar (sucrose - C12H22O11)
to carbon.

C12H22O11 + H2SO4 - 12.C + H2SO4/11H2O

--
Rusty

Tim Watts 07-04-2010 06:20 PM

Tree stump killer
 
Jeff Layman
wibbled on Wednesday 07 April 2010 17:21


But if you use the ammonium sulphamate from that pack as a stump killer,
you
will be doing something illegal, as daft as it may sound. In fact,
AFAIAA, you are only allowed to use approved products for designated
"pesticide"


Sod that, already ordered :)

uses. If you use anything else (eg coffee grounds to deal with slugs),
then
you risk prosecution.


What you have to realise is that there are now so many statues on the book
that criminalise perfectly innocuous activities that the only way to remain
sane is forget the law and use common sense - this has become and will
remain my approach to life in this country until such a time that sanity is
restored (if ever).

Do you feel happy that it is a non indictable criminal offence for you to
replace one of your windows or an external door without informing local
building control, to quote one example?

--
Tim Watts

Managers, politicians and environmentalists: Nature's carbon buffer.


Tim Watts 07-04-2010 06:22 PM

Tree stump killer
 
Rusty Hinge
wibbled on Wednesday 07 April 2010 17:51

Tim Watts wrote:

Oh - so not so much that it is an acid, more that it rips the H2O out of
anything it touches - remember the chem lesson experiment with conc H2SO4
+ sugar?


Ding!

Not one we did, but I'd expect it to reduce sugar (sucrose - C12H22O11)
to carbon.

C12H22O11 + H2SO4 - 12.C + H2SO4/11H2O


That's it! Lots of steam and a pile of foamy graphite left which curously
extrudes from the glass beaker like an oversized indoor firework...

--
Tim Watts

Managers, politicians and environmentalists: Nature's carbon buffer.


Jeff Layman[_2_] 08-04-2010 10:36 AM

Tree stump killer
 
"Tim Watts" wrote in message
...
Jeff Layman
wibbled on Wednesday 07 April 2010 17:21


But if you use the ammonium sulphamate from that pack as a stump killer,
you
will be doing something illegal, as daft as it may sound. In fact,
AFAIAA, you are only allowed to use approved products for designated
"pesticide"


Sod that, already ordered :)

uses. If you use anything else (eg coffee grounds to deal with slugs),
then
you risk prosecution.


What you have to realise is that there are now so many statues on the book
that criminalise perfectly innocuous activities that the only way to
remain
sane is forget the law and use common sense - this has become and will
remain my approach to life in this country until such a time that sanity
is
restored (if ever).


Trouble is they go for the easiest target to keep numbers up. How else do
you explain the recent prosecution of the pet shop owner for selling a
goldfish to a 14-year-old?

Do you feel happy that it is a non indictable criminal offence for you to
replace one of your windows or an external door without informing local
building control, to quote one example?


What else is there for Jobsworths to do?! This country has become a mass of
idiotic laws which were brought in (mainly) for "good" reason. As the
saying goes: "The road to hell is paved with good intentions".

--

Jeff



Tim Watts 08-04-2010 11:50 AM

Tree stump killer
 
Jeff Layman
wibbled on Thursday 08 April 2010 10:36

"Tim Watts" wrote in message
...
Jeff Layman
wibbled on Wednesday 07 April 2010 17:21


But if you use the ammonium sulphamate from that pack as a stump killer,
you
will be doing something illegal, as daft as it may sound. In fact,
AFAIAA, you are only allowed to use approved products for designated
"pesticide"


Sod that, already ordered :)

uses. If you use anything else (eg coffee grounds to deal with slugs),
then
you risk prosecution.


What you have to realise is that there are now so many statues on the
book that criminalise perfectly innocuous activities that the only way to
remain
sane is forget the law and use common sense - this has become and will
remain my approach to life in this country until such a time that sanity
is
restored (if ever).


Trouble is they go for the easiest target to keep numbers up.


They'll have to catch me, on private land (= warrant to gain access). Sure
I've expressed hypothetical intent here, but as yet no crime has been
committed...

I've already banned anyone from TV Licensing from coming on my land in
writing removing their implied right of access.

How else do
you explain the recent prosecution of the pet shop owner for selling a
goldfish to a 14-year-old?


Link? I haven't seen that.


Do you feel happy that it is a non indictable criminal offence for you to
replace one of your windows or an external door without informing local
building control, to quote one example?


What else is there for Jobsworths to do?! This country has become a mass
of
idiotic laws which were brought in (mainly) for "good" reason. As the
saying goes: "The road to hell is paved with good intentions".


Which is why the sooner people start saying "enough" and stop acting like
brainless sheep, the better. We either need to get sensible, or become more
like Italians, ie have lots of crap but everyone to a man ignores it and has
a glass of wine in the sun instead :)

--
Tim Watts

Managers, politicians and environmentalists: Nature's carbon buffer.


Martin Brown 08-04-2010 12:41 PM

Tree stump killer
 
Tim Watts wrote:
Jeff Layman
wibbled on Thursday 08 April 2010 10:36

"Tim Watts" wrote in message
...
Jeff Layman
wibbled on Wednesday 07 April 2010 17:21


But if you use the ammonium sulphamate from that pack as a stump killer,
you
will be doing something illegal, as daft as it may sound. In fact,
AFAIAA, you are only allowed to use approved products for designated
"pesticide"
Sod that, already ordered :)

uses. If you use anything else (eg coffee grounds to deal with slugs),
then
you risk prosecution.
What you have to realise is that there are now so many statues on the
book that criminalise perfectly innocuous activities that the only way to
remain
sane is forget the law and use common sense - this has become and will
remain my approach to life in this country until such a time that sanity
is
restored (if ever).

Trouble is they go for the easiest target to keep numbers up.


They'll have to catch me, on private land (= warrant to gain access). Sure
I've expressed hypothetical intent here, but as yet no crime has been
committed...

I've already banned anyone from TV Licensing from coming on my land in
writing removing their implied right of access.

How else do
you explain the recent prosecution of the pet shop owner for selling a
goldfish to a 14-year-old?


Link? I haven't seen that.


Real enough although if you only read the Hate Mail or Sun biassed
accounts you will get the impression that is all they were had up for.

A more balanced view is on the local BBC site. I suspect the cockatiel
with the broken leg and eye infection and the gerbil dunked in coffee
had something to do with their decision to prosecute.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/england/m...er/8597762.stm

Even so it does seem a bit OTT to me.

Regards,
Martin Brown

Tim Watts 08-04-2010 02:51 PM

Tree stump killer
 
Martin Brown
wibbled on Thursday 08 April 2010 12:41

Tim Watts wrote:
Jeff Layman
wibbled on Thursday 08 April 2010 10:36


How else do
you explain the recent prosecution of the pet shop owner for selling a
goldfish to a 14-year-old?


Link? I haven't seen that.


Real enough although if you only read the Hate Mail or Sun biassed
accounts you will get the impression that is all they were had up for.

A more balanced view is on the local BBC site. I suspect the cockatiel
with the broken leg and eye infection and the gerbil dunked in coffee
had something to do with their decision to prosecute.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/england/m...er/8597762.stm

Even so it does seem a bit OTT to me.


Yes it is, a fine would have been more in order. Taken in balance with feral
oiks roaming the streets in many towns, then it is definately picking on a
soft target...



--
Tim Watts

Managers, politicians and environmentalists: Nature's carbon buffer.


hugh 08-04-2010 07:13 PM

Tree stump killer
 
In message , Tim Watts
writes
Pretty much anyone has implied right of access to your property to conduct
their legal business, eg anyone wishing to post something through your
letterbox, milkman etc as well as certain bodies with additional statutory
rights such as the gas company in an emergency, Customs Officers under some
conditions, coppers with a warrant etc.

And very shortly council official to come and inspect your house as
part of the council tax revaluation which will go ahead if Labour is
returned to power next month.
--
hugh
"Believe nothing. No matter where you read it, Or who said it, Even if
I have said it, Unless it agrees with your own reason And your own
common sense." Buddha

hugh 08-04-2010 07:19 PM

Tree stump killer
 
In message , Rusty Hinge
writes
Martin Brown wrote:
Jeff Layman wrote:
"Chris Hogg" wrote in message
...


The first one. Either that or anything containing ammonium sulphamate
(not to be confused with ammonium sulphate!). Drill two or three
decent sized deep holes into the top of the stump, pour in crystals of
stump killer, cover with a tile or whatever to keep the rain out.

Ammonium sulphamate was withdrawn from sale over 2 years ago and is
not approved for use in the EU.

Do you have any idea why?
I checked an it is apparently due to the insane requirement that the
halfwitted Irish Rapporteur that insisted on additional gratuitous
animal testing on dogs. This is nothing to do with safety when used by
amateurs. It is entirely to do with insane EEC red tape on chemicals.
http://www.pesticides.gov.uk/garden.asp?id=1997
Even the Henry Doublespeak organisation considers Ammonium
Sulphamate as a borderline acceptable weedkiller although not
strictly Organic(TM).
This is an example of the H&SE at its dumbest. You can bet your
bottom dollar it is still widely available to amateurs elsewhere in
Europe despite a notional EU wide ban. Only the UK blindly enforces
this junk.


Quite agree with those sentiments.

If you want a relatively harmles chemical banned for garden use, you
can usually get it from a chemical distributor, who won't ask you what
you want it for, unless it's something which you could blow-up
politicians with.

Mind you, you'd have to buy several years' supply...

Very shortly harmless food supplements will also be severely restricted.
This is at the behest of the big pharmas who want us to pop pills which
remove one symptom and replace it with another requiring more pills
rather than taking beneficial supplements and vitamins.
--
hugh
"Believe nothing. No matter where you read it, Or who said it, Even if
I have said it, Unless it agrees with your own reason And your own
common sense." Buddha

Tim Watts 08-04-2010 08:19 PM

Tree stump killer
 
hugh
wibbled on Thursday 08 April 2010 19:13

In message , Tim Watts
writes
Pretty much anyone has implied right of access to your property to conduct
their legal business, eg anyone wishing to post something through your
letterbox, milkman etc as well as certain bodies with additional statutory
rights such as the gas company in an emergency, Customs Officers under
some conditions, coppers with a warrant etc.

And very shortly council official to come and inspect your house as
part of the council tax revaluation which will go ahead if Labour is
returned to power next month.


Ah that old chestnut...

Well, they can try to get in my house...

Hopefully, there's not much danger of another Labour term - the general
hatred of Labour probably outweighs the lack of belief in the
alternatives... Personally we might be better off if they just scrap teh
general election and alternate one term of Labour with one term of the
Tories. They seem to do less damage in 5 years rather than 15.

While we're diverted to politics, I would strongly urge you all to go and
look at:

http://www.theyworkforyou.com/

You can see what your MPs voting record is, whether they can be arsed to
take part in debates or have the balls to vote as a rebel from time to time.
Not to mention how much of a thieving weasel they've been WRT expense
claims. Could provide material for embarrasing questions when the
campaigners turn up on yer doorstep...



--
Tim Watts

Managers, politicians and environmentalists: Nature's carbon buffer.


[email protected] 08-04-2010 09:37 PM

Tree stump killer
 
In article ,
Tim Watts wrote:

While we're diverted to politics, I would strongly urge you all to go and
look at:

http://www.theyworkforyou.com/

You can see what your MPs voting record is, whether they can be arsed to
take part in debates or have the balls to vote as a rebel from time to time.
Not to mention how much of a thieving weasel they've been WRT expense
claims. Could provide material for embarrasing questions when the
campaigners turn up on yer doorstep...


Nah. I live in South Cambridgeshire, where the Electoral Reform
Society correctly states that the election is over as soon as the
Conservatives nominate a candidate. A stuffed monkey with a blue
rosette would get in - indeed, some people felt that actually was
the case at one time.

The solution is to compost the canvassers. Just like Jehovah's
Witnesses and Encyclopaedia salesmen.


Regards,
Nick Maclaren.

Tim Watts 08-04-2010 10:09 PM

Tree stump killer
 

wibbled on Thursday 08 April 2010 21:37

In article ,
Tim Watts wrote:

While we're diverted to politics, I would strongly urge you all to go and
look at:

http://www.theyworkforyou.com/

You can see what your MPs voting record is, whether they can be arsed to
take part in debates or have the balls to vote as a rebel from time to
time. Not to mention how much of a thieving weasel they've been WRT
expense claims. Could provide material for embarrasing questions when the
campaigners turn up on yer doorstep...


Nah. I live in South Cambridgeshire, where the Electoral Reform
Society correctly states that the election is over as soon as the
Conservatives nominate a candidate. A stuffed monkey with a blue
rosette would get in - indeed, some people felt that actually was
the case at one time.

The solution is to compost the canvassers. Just like Jehovah's
Witnesses and Encyclopaedia salesmen.


I do wonder why some constituencies have this unfailing allegence to a
party.

Ours (Battle & Bexhill) has a exceedingly rich tory incumbent (ex banker)
who was also notable for his expenses claims of late. However, the last X
elections have always had at least twice as many votes for the tory as the
next runner up. Perhaps there'll be enough old fashioned oldies round here
to get upset by him leaving his wife and running off with the painter - can
but hope.


--
Tim Watts

Managers, politicians and environmentalists: Nature's carbon buffer.


Will Wilkinson 09-04-2010 01:00 AM

[OT] TV Licensing (Was: Tree stump killer)
 
In message , Tim Watts
writes

I had no TV for a period of time so I rang the number and they made a note.

Then a couple of months later, the annoying reminders started coming again.
I threw them away at first, then later, marked them "Return to sender" and
stuck them in the post box. The tone of the reminders left much to be
desired. However, the biscuit taker was this:

http://www.dionic.net/tv/OfficialWarning.jpeg

So I sent them this:

http://www.dionic.net/tv/Reply.jpeg
(Not for the faint hearted)

The bit in question is in the last paragraph.

Pretty much anyone has implied right of access to your property to conduct
their legal business, eg anyone wishing to post something through your
letterbox, milkman etc as well as certain bodies with additional statutory
rights such as the gas company in an emergency, Customs Officers under some
conditions, coppers with a warrant etc.

However, if the former right of implied access is explicitly denied in
writing to a single body as here, or by putting a sign on the gate saying
"No Hawkers" then any such person is guilty of trespass if they do set foot
on your property and may be removed using reasonable force.

Anyway, it was mostly spleen venting and it did elicit a response - a
grovelling apology in this case.


Love your response, just what these neo-nazi quangos need IMO. The UK is
getting worryingly (sp?) close to the police state that Germany became
in the mid 30s. If I was 10 years younger I'd probably be away to NZ or
Canada.

Will
--
Once you open a can of worms, the only way to recan them is to use a larger
can.
e-mail news dot will at lancre dot net
'98 300Tdi Defender 110 CSW, 1/12th NB Sometimes
PGP Fingerprint E089 1736 A023 9E5C AFA3 0B40 E5DC D80A 9E1F D521
Public key can be obtained from ldap://certserver.pgp.com

chris French 09-04-2010 10:03 AM

Tree stump killer
 
In message ,
writes
In article ,
Tim Watts wrote:

While we're diverted to politics, I would strongly urge you all to go and
look at:

http://www.theyworkforyou.com/

You can see what your MPs voting record is, whether they can be arsed to
take part in debates or have the balls to vote as a rebel from time to time.
Not to mention how much of a thieving weasel they've been WRT expense
claims. Could provide material for embarrasing questions when the
campaigners turn up on yer doorstep...


Nah. I live in South Cambridgeshire, where the Electoral Reform
Society correctly states that the election is over as soon as the
Conservatives nominate a candidate. A stuffed monkey with a blue
rosette would get in - indeed, some people felt that actually was
the case at one time.


Yeah.

At least we don't need to bother worrying about who to vote for :-)
--
Chris French


hugh 09-04-2010 01:13 PM

Tree stump killer
 
In message , Tim Watts
writes
Hopefully, there's not much danger of another Labour term - the general
hatred of Labour probably outweighs the lack of belief in the
alternatives...

Unfortunately that is a pretty accurate if somewhat cynical analysis of
what faces the voters at this election.
--
hugh
"Believe nothing. No matter where you read it, Or who said it, Even if
I have said it, Unless it agrees with your own reason And your own
common sense." Buddha

hugh 09-04-2010 01:15 PM

Tree stump killer
 
In message ,
writes
In article ,
Tim Watts wrote:

While we're diverted to politics, I would strongly urge you all to go and
look at:

http://www.theyworkforyou.com/

You can see what your MPs voting record is, whether they can be arsed to
take part in debates or have the balls to vote as a rebel from time to time.
Not to mention how much of a thieving weasel they've been WRT expense
claims. Could provide material for embarrasing questions when the
campaigners turn up on yer doorstep...


Nah. I live in South Cambridgeshire, where the Electoral Reform
Society correctly states that the election is over as soon as the
Conservatives nominate a candidate. A stuffed monkey with a blue
rosette would get in - indeed, some people felt that actually was
the case at one time.

The solution is to compost the canvassers. Just like Jehovah's
Witnesses and Encyclopaedia salesmen.


Regards,
Nick Maclaren.

Haven't seen a canvasser in 40 years around here - Crewe & Nantwich
We don't have Japanese knot weed either - just to keep it vaguely on
topic.
--
hugh
"Believe nothing. No matter where you read it, Or who said it, Even if
I have said it, Unless it agrees with your own reason And your own
common sense." Buddha

Rusty Hinge[_2_] 14-04-2010 09:38 PM

Tree stump killer
 
Tim Watts wrote:
Jeff Layman
wibbled on Wednesday 07 April 2010 17:21


But if you use the ammonium sulphamate from that pack as a stump killer,
you
will be doing something illegal, as daft as it may sound. In fact,
AFAIAA, you are only allowed to use approved products for designated
"pesticide"


Sod that, already ordered :)

uses. If you use anything else (eg coffee grounds to deal with slugs),
then
you risk prosecution.


What you have to realise is that there are now so many statues on the book
that criminalise perfectly innocuous activities that the only way to remain
sane is forget the law and use common sense - this has become and will
remain my approach to life in this country until such a time that sanity is
restored (if ever).

Do you feel happy that it is a non indictable criminal offence for you to
replace one of your windows or an external door without informing local
building control, to quote one example?


Oh dear! Oh dear oh dear! And I've replaced my back door *AND* my front
door,,,

And I've a box full of old mains cable waiting for something-or-other,
and a gas cooker to put in the kitchen.

Who's got the duty handcuffs this week?

--
Rusty

Rusty Hinge[_2_] 14-04-2010 09:51 PM

Tree stump killer
 
Tim Watts wrote:

/snip/

I had no TV for a period of time so I rang the number and they made a note.

Then a couple of months later, the annoying reminders started coming again.
I threw them away at first, then later, marked them "Return to sender" and
stuck them in the post box. The tone of the reminders left much to be
desired. However, the biscuit taker was this:

http://www.dionic.net/tv/OfficialWarning.jpeg

So I sent them this:

http://www.dionic.net/tv/Reply.jpeg
(Not for the faint hearted)

The bit in question is in the last paragraph.

Pretty much anyone has implied right of access to your property to conduct
their legal business, eg anyone wishing to post something through your
letterbox, milkman etc as well as certain bodies with additional statutory
rights such as the gas company in an emergency, Customs Officers under some
conditions, coppers with a warrant etc.

However, if the former right of implied access is explicitly denied in
writing to a single body as here, or by putting a sign on the gate saying
"No Hawkers" then any such person is guilty of trespass if they do set foot
on your property and may be removed using reasonable force.

Anyway, it was mostly spleen venting and it did elicit a response - a
grovelling apology in this case.


/snip/

http://www.marmalade.net/lime

http://www.girolle.co.uk/tv/

--
Rusty

Rusty Hinge[_2_] 14-04-2010 09:57 PM

Tree stump killer
 
hugh wrote:
In message , writes


Nah. I live in South Cambridgeshire, where the Electoral Reform
Society correctly states that the election is over as soon as the
Conservatives nominate a candidate. A stuffed monkey with a blue
rosette would get in - indeed, some people felt that actually was
the case at one time.

The solution is to compost the canvassers. Just like Jehovah's
Witnesses and Encyclopaedia salesmen.


Haven't seen a canvasser in 40 years around here - Crewe & Nantwich
We don't have Japanese knot weed either - just to keep it vaguely on topic.


I wonder how they'll vote in Wilmslow?

--
Rusty

Mike Lyle 14-04-2010 10:11 PM

Tree stump killer
 
Rusty Hinge wrote:
Tim Watts wrote:
Jeff Layman
wibbled on Wednesday 07 April 2010 17:21


But if you use the ammonium sulphamate from that pack as a stump
killer, you
will be doing something illegal, as daft as it may sound. In fact,
AFAIAA, you are only allowed to use approved products for designated
"pesticide"


Sod that, already ordered :)

uses. If you use anything else (eg coffee grounds to deal with
slugs), then
you risk prosecution.


What you have to realise is that there are now so many statues on
the book that criminalise perfectly innocuous activities that the
only way to remain sane is forget the law and use common sense -
this has become and will remain my approach to life in this country
until such a time that sanity is restored (if ever).

Do you feel happy that it is a non indictable criminal offence for
you to replace one of your windows or an external door without
informing local building control, to quote one example?


Oh dear! Oh dear oh dear! And I've replaced my back door *AND* my
front door,,,

And I've a box full of old mains cable waiting for something-or-other,
and a gas cooker to put in the kitchen.

Who's got the duty handcuffs this week?


People don't 'alf panic about this kind of thing...or perhaps there's a
hidden political agenda. I need chapter and verse before believing most
of these Daily-Mail-type tales: you may not (perhaps for good reasons of
public safety or consumer protection) be allowed to _sell_ certain
things for certain purposes, but that doesn't necessarily mean you
aren't free to _use_ said things for said purposes.

The claim that prosecution could follow tipping coffee grounds on the
garden is almost too silly to reply to.

--
Mike.





All times are GMT +1. The time now is 02:17 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
GardenBanter